Warning! Spoilers!
OK, let's get going. When the first trailer for Avatar came up at a movie theater, I immediately assumed it was this:
"Avatar" is also an anime cartoon and I think it's being made into a movie as well. That movie is being done by M. Night Shyamalan. The Cosmic Daughter is a big fan of the Avatar cartoon so I thought "cool, we get to see a preview of Avatar!"
But it clearly wasn't the cartoon. At the end of the preview the Cosmic Wife and I looked at each other and I said "Well, we humans get to be the evil bad guys again." And she said "It looks like Fern Gully meets Terminator" or something like that.
But the graphics looked awesome. I'm something of a fan of dragons. I've got dragon sculptures and figurines, books on dragons, I've sculpted my own dragons and one year I had a dragon calendar. So anything with dragons in it gets my attention. And if people are flying the dragons? That's even better. People flying dragons is a favorite theme of mine. I used to love Anne McCaffrey's "Pern" books (yes, I've told you all before that I am firmly in touch with my feminine side and always have been).
So, in spite of the obvious Hollywood self-loathing, military-as-evil-buffon schtick, I knew I'd have to watch the movie.
So to get the easy stuff out of the way...
The story is inane. The plot is a sort of hodge-podge of "Dances With Wolves", "Pocahontas", "Fern Gully" and "Terminator". In the opening shots as you fly over the verdant world of "Pandora" you end up at a huge strip mine where the humans lived. I swear if they had been playing "Diggety Dig" from Pocahontas I would not have been remotely surprised. That's how cartoonish the whole plot felt. With the exception of a disabled veteran and a black female hovercopter pilot, everyone else in the military was no more intelligent or human than a robot. And of course the two most evil creatures in the movie were both white males. One a rapacious corporate stooge, the other a mindless military warmonger. Oh Hollywood, you are so original and clever.
So let's just dispense with the pathetic, moronic and insulting parts of the movie (the plot, the acting, and the writing) and stick instead to the only good part of the movie.
The graphics. Besides being awesome, they were in 3D! Woohoo! OK, so there are still some limits to computer animation and if you wanted to you could clearly see how the live action and animation still had significant gaps, but they are getting better. (Although I still think Gollum was more "realistic" than the CGI in "Avatar").
I went to the movie with the explicit intent to turn off my critical brain and just enjoy the thrill ride. And it was a great ride. The graphics were immersive and spectacular. Had this been a Heavy Metal movie with nothing but heavy metal music in the background as you went from scene to scene, I would probably have enjoyed it more. If I were a druggie, I would certainly have wanted to view this while under the influence of my favorite psychedelic. Man I loved those dragons! And there were some nice touches apart from the dragons. The writers were at least smart enough to have an entire branch of six-legged vertebrates, which is one of the things that makes dragons more believable. ("Dragons" with two hind legs, two wings and no forelegs are technically called "wyverns". "Dragons" have four legs and two wings. And yes I know that Chinese dragons don't have wings....) So we are given lovingly crafted shots of six-legged predators of various sizes, and dragons as well as drakes ("Drakes" are small dragons) with six limbs.
The Pocahontas love interest was attractive enough, although the general relative physiology of the natives was somewhat runway super-modelish. There were no fat and lazy "Na'vi" (the natives). The Na'vi were so obviously based on Hollywood fantasies of native American culture that it was downright funny sometimes. Complete with skull totems, feathered headdresses and coming of age rituals. But the crowning moment came when you realized that the "mother tree" from Pocahontas had been reproduced on Pandora.
OK, so the graphics were amazing, and the view from the back of a flying dragon was beatifully accomplished. So if you enjoy that sort of thing (and who doesn't?) go see the movie. You can listen to your iPod if you want, you won't miss anything worthwhile.
But just to snark on the most laughable things in the movie because I can't help myself...
I can't imagine writing that could possibly be worse than naming the planet "Pandora" and naming the mineral being strip mined "unobtainium." I almost laughed out loud when they got to that part. "Unobtainium!" That's the sort of made-up name a 9 year old would come up with. What does it do? Your guess is as good as mine. All you know is that it sells for a ginormous sum on earth the "dead planet" where humans have "killed their mother." No wonder the humans are so soulless. What unobtainium is, or what it does is never remotely explained, although the "richest deposit on the planet" just happens to be directly under the main native village's Home Tree. Wow, what a coincidence, eh?
Two or three things really have to be mentioned because they are so insane. The first is the "legendary floating mountains of Pandora." Yes, floating mountains. Floating in the air! Way up in the air, connected by implausible knotted vines. Why do they float? Who knows? Are the humans on the planet remotely interested in exploring the physics of how you make entire mountains float? Apparently not. They are too busy with raping the planet for the unobtanium, or doing "critical" research on the local flora and fuana to look into a physical effect that would totally revolutionize transportation as well as dozens of other fields. Anti-gravity would seem to be somewhat interesting to even soulless humans, but instead the humans on Pandora avoid the floating mountains like the plague.
Why? Because the floating mountains happen to be within a "flux field" which makes all their fancy technology go all wobbly. Well, except for the technology that keeps motors running and hovercraft flying anyway. Again, what is the source of this "flux field?" Who knows? What IS a "flux field?" Who CARES? It's just there, coincidentally co-located with the flying mountains. Does anyone even speculate that the flux field might be RESPONSIBLE for the floating mountains? Nope. Does anyone want to RESEARCH the flux field? Not really. Bigger fish to fry. Gotta get to the genocide, science can wait.
And finally, when the human protagonist's avatar connects with the mother tree, he can hear the voices of his ancestors speaking to him. They are all there! Just like the natives! But how can they be there? First of all the avatar is created by combining genetic material from the Na'Vi with human DNA. So shouldn't the human be hearing Na'Vi voices too? And why was my initial reaction to this revelation an internal shudder? Was I channeling Baron Harkonnen from Dune? ABOMINATION!!!
Anyway... I don't have a problem with the concept of a living interconnected world where the "dominant" intelligent species have nobly decided to live in the stone age forever. There are lots of sci-fi books with this sort of premise. It makes for a good counterpoint to a technological star-faring civilization and provides some opportunities for delivering life lessons about remembering our roots and appreciating the value of organic life. I just don't care for the absolute demonization of humans that is considered to be required among the Leftist intelligentsia.
The reality is that while the Left claims to love and appreciate the lifestyle of stone age cultures, they would be eaten alive if they ever found themselves in one. Romanticizing and glorifying stone age life is one of the great tragedies of modern times. The average life span of an indigineous native American, or indigineous native Australian, or pretty much ANY stone age culture, was about 30. Elderly individuals were revered because they were so freaking rare. Living to the age of 40 was quite an accomplishment, and very few did so without serious debilitating effects of the harshness of their lives.
This demonization of technology is made more ridiculous when you realize that the entire lifestyle and livelihood of the Hollywood mental midgets who ladle admiration upon the "noble savages" is dependent on the very technology they are attacking. People can't make movies without technology. In fact making movies is among the worst offenders when it comes to environmental damage. Film processing alone relies heavily on poisonous chemicals. Computer technology also relies heavily on poisonous chemicals. But even more than that, the entire profession relies on people having the leisure time to sit down for hours to be lectured by these idiots. How is that leisure time arrived at? Through the very technology that the filmmakers attack.
I suppose it's not new to point out the monumental hypocrisy and abject ignorance of the Left. But I still can't help myself. Go watch the movie so James Cameron can rake in more millions (billions?) of dollars so James Cameron can continue to travel the world in his private jets and private yachts to lecture us on the evils of technology and the greed of capitalism. I did. And it was worth it. Love those dragons!
OK, I've had the droid phone for a bit more than two weeks now. I took it with me on our Thanksgiving trip to Louisiana just a day or so after purchasing it. Here's my thoughts on it as of this moment:
The good:
The screen is unbelievable. It's got twice the resolution of an iPhone screen. It's sharp as a tack. I can use my bifocals to read tiny text and the tiny text is sharp and clear. This is probably the droid's best feature.
The ability to browse from just about anywhere is really cool. While on the highway in middle-of-freaking-nowhere, New Mexico, I was getting updates to the exploding Tiger Woods mistresses scandal.
The ability to do email from the droid is a huge benefit to me since I'm not allowed to access my email from my work computer. At least now if I get an email about changes to lunch or dinner plans, I see it before getting home at night.
The built-in keyboard. This is real nice for doing longer emails compared to having a keyboard pop up on the screen. That way the whole screen is still usable for reading.
The GPS navigation system. It's like having a Tom-Tom in your pocket. Although I wish the navigation was a bit more clever about avoiding obvious traffic jam areas in big cities.
The sound from both the headphone jack and the droid itself is surprisingly good. Plugged into my car stereo to play my iTunes songs, it sounds as good as my iPod.
Oh, yeah, the music... I got a 16GB card with my droid, and that's more than enough to hold my fairly tiny collection of songs. I used up about 2G loading the iTunes songs that loaded.
The user interface. I find it to be quite intuitive and fun to use.
The recharger is a simple USB connection. I can charge it from a wall socket with a tiny converter or I can plug it into any USB 2.0 port and it will charge the phone. That's really nice.
The connectivity to a computer is also pretty simple, although you have to learn the right technique to make the connection, which takes about a second. Once you do that you can plug into a computer and it is treated just like any USB external storage device. This is really good for transferring files like photos back and forth. You do need a special USB cable for that. (I did see a post on a droid forum that you can do the same with a wireless connection. I haven't figured that out yet though.)
Oh yeah, speaking of wireless, if you are in a wireless network location, you can do your email and internet surfing over the LAN instead of over the slower 3G network. That not only improves the speed of your activities, it also saves your battery. It will remember wireless networks and automatically reconnect as you move about.
The bad:
The camera isn't nearly as good as one would expect. It is really bad in low light situations, which includes just about any indoor shot.
The built in keyboard. Yeah, I know I put this in the "good" because just having one is really nice, but I'm just not very good at using it. My fingers are too big I guess.
The battery life. It's OK just using it as a phone, but anything else just kills the battery. The screen itself is the biggest battery drain, and the screen seems to brighten and dim without any pattern I can find so it is brighter than it needs to be frequently.
The browser and email programs tend to crash a lot more than I would expect. They restart within a few seconds, but it's annoying.
The ugly:
My lack of aeshtetic credibility is legendary, but even I acknowledge that the iPhone is much sleeker looking than the droid. The droid looks all business. It's heavy (although I like that, it feels solid to me compared to iPhones)
Lack of iTunes support is a big problem. I had to go find a utility to attempt to load my iTunes songs and it worked for about 2/3 of the songs. The manual says the droid does not support .mp4 files, but after syncing up with iTunes, many .mp4 files are working fine.
No bluetooth keyboard support. This is a real shame, although it is said to be on the list of firmware upgrade items.
No music controls unless you are running the music app. This means you have to run the battery down if you tend to skip, pause, replay or search for specific songs. The only controls that work while the screen is off is the volume control. They should have at least allowed you to pause and skip to a new song.
But overall, I am enjoying this phone more than any new gadget I've owned since my iPod. I probably would have got an iPhone if they worked with Verizon, but the droid is working fine for me.
Years ago I predicted the convergence of cell phone, GPS, music player, video player, portable game system, portable email/browser, radio and TV receiver into one device. I also predicted that device would replace computers, becoming the primary computing device for individuals. The natural evolution of this is to a hand-held device that does all of those things and plugs into a dock at your desk to provide a comfortable screen, keyboard, mouse or other input devices. These smart phones are about halfway there. If I could plug this into a keyboard, mouse and large screen, it would do 80% of what I do on a computer already.
Give it five more years.
Anyone who knows me knows that I am culturally challenged. I drove a Gremlin for over six years for goodness sake. And I loved it.
I graduated high school in 1977, but somehow managed to escape the "Saturday Night Fever" virus. I probably went to a disco less than ten times in my life. I always found the environment at bars and discos to be nearly unendurable. I've got a bit of the Grinch in me, I suspect, and somehow spending hours in an environment of flashing lights, loud music and people stumbling over each other struck me as about as much fun as a root canal. As far as dating was concerned, I tended to prefer the girls I met at school or at work or even at church (no, Cosmic has not always been godless...)
But as out of step with my generation as I was in the 70s, today it's an entirely different scale of unhipness. I find television today to be virtually impossible to watch. The shows are laughably simplistic, the characters are insulting caricatures and the performers are plasticized clones as interchangable as lego blocks.
I watched a movie the other night called "Wild Hogs." It was a story of four middle aged guys (back in my youth I would have called them "geezers" but now that I'm one myself, I'll stick with "middle aged guys") who rode around on motorcycles as a way to inject some "excitement" into their humdrum lives. It starred Tim Allen, John Travolta, William Macy and Martin Lawrence.
It wasn't a bad movie, I suppose. But when I watch a movie like that all the glaring stereotypes, formulaic plot devices and adolescent humor just hits me like a jarring out of tune piano chord. I found myself wondering if the movie had been released directly to DVD because it was so poorly written, constructed and acted, especially considering the star power of the cast, which inclued Oscar winner Marisa Tomei. To call the movie a lazy collection of stereotypes and movie formula is to be very kind. I figured that most people involved in the movie would be glad to just forget about it and move on, but then a commercial came on for a "Wild Hogs 2". What? This movie deserves a sequel? Is that how lame our culture has become? A movie as lame, predictable, clumsy and insulting as Wild Hogs gets a sequel? Wow.
So the reason for this post is that I ran across a section of the local paper, which just happened to include the "style" section. That section had photos of models, including one ex-model who had quit modeling, she said, because she decided she couldn't live on a diet of lettuce and celery. This seemingly common-sensical woman had her hair split into a curtain which opened up over the top of her left eye, completley covering her right eye and running along the bridge of her nose and part of her mouth. This is a model? She looked like a lopsided Cyclops. Plus anytime I see a woman (or man) with an eye completely covered by hair, my immediate reaction isn't "how cool" my reaction is "what an IDIOT. I hope you don't freaking DRIVE on the same highways I do!" This is an example of beauty in America in 2009? It's certainly not an example of common sense.
However, her comment about models being unhealthy due to pressure to be thin appears to be true. Again I am so completely out of step with the culture that looking at the "models" in the photos on that page, my immediate reaction was "ug." Not only were the clothes ridiculously ugly and completely non-functional (most of them could not possibly be worn in public without exposing the wearer's naughty bits since most people don't glue their clothes to their bodies to keep them from moving around a bit), but the poses the models were in were quite literally hilarious. Since when is it sexy for a woman to stand with one leg cocked straight out to her side, her hands awkwardly placed on her waist, her head strained to look over one shoulder and sucking in her cheeks while attempting to scowl sensously? As if that wasn't enough, the makeup on these models would make the average clown green with envy.
I don't like skinny women. I really don't. I don't understand what is sexy about a woman with no hips, boobs that look like ballons stuck on a popsicle stick, and bones sticking out of her shoulders, knees and back.
So my question is, WHO DOES LIKE these women? Most of them don't even have a butt, it's wasted away to nothing. Their hip bones stick out like an old starving nag in a stall at a dude ranch. They look like stick figures with poofy lips and boobs with the consistency of foam rubber. They aren't women, they are stretched and contorted arrested development pre-pubescent girls with stick on boobies.
I have similar opinions of most situation comedies these days. What people in this country seem to find funny falls totally flat with me. I don't get the total obsession with fart and poop jokes. I stopped laughing at bodily functions when I was in junior high school. Didn't everyone?
And what is it in Hollywood where we are expected to believe that a 30-something hot-bodied vixen (Marisa Tomei) would actually fall for a 60-something paunchy dude with a bad rug (William Macy)? I get really tired of ancient male actors getting the hot chick.
Thank god for sports....
OK, so I've admitted here before that among my geeky activities is that I engage in tabletop role playing games. I've played Dungeons and Dragons off and on since the early 80s when my brother ("Drax" here) re-introduced me to it when he returned from doing a stint in the US Navy. (I had played a bit in the early days pre-second edition, but not much).
I love the game, pretty much unreservedly and unabashedly. It's a great game, and I'm a game aficionado of the first order. I love all kinds of games from card games to table top games to computer games. Of all the games I've played though, table-top role-playing games are the most challenging, complex and rewarding, when done well. It is unfortunately true though that they can be done badly.
My initial experiences in D&D were with the first "mainstream" release of the game, now called the "black box" version, if I recall. In those days the game was fairly limited and constrained, but still it was a new "thing" for me and the opportunity to create entire worlds and roam around in them was just too much fun. Soon after that came the "Advanced D&D" version, also known as "Second Edition" which was the first really comprehensive version of the game, and was published primarily as a set of books calld the "Dungeon Master's Guide" the "Player's Handbook" and the "Monster Manual." Every version since has been built around these three "core" books, usually referred to as the "DMG" the "PHB" and the "MM".
Up through the various modifications and add-ons to second edition, the game was fully human-centric, with only human characters being allowed to advance to the upper tiers of the game. This was by design, but it frustrated a lot of players who felt that it was a bit of species bigoting and there was no reason in a fantasy setting that an elf shouldn't be every bit as powerful as a human. Also the various rules around combat, dialog and traps had developed sort of organically and as such had completely different rules mechanics around them. This made the game somewhat challenging to master since in some cases you needed to roll a high result to do well, while in other, similar, situations, you need to roll a low result.
All of that led to the first really major rewrite of the rules when the "Third edition" for D&D came out. Gone were the "racial" limitations (the game uses "race" to mean "species" of intelligent beings. "Elf" is a "race" for example) which limited non-humans to second-class status. In fact the various racial options were embraced and blended into the overall game experience so that choosing a race became part of the overall "flavor" of the character you wanted to play. This was accomplished by having "racial attributes" defined for each race which provided benefits and deficits to make each race different, but still (mostly) balanced. (In my opinion dwarves are overpowered in third edition). Third edition also introduced several new character building concepts such as "feats" and "skills." This provided a means to custom build your character according to guidelines that were intended to allow for powerful, interesting characters, without arbitrary game-changing decisions being necessary. (In second edition there were no fundamental rules to deal with a player who decided his character could fight ambidextrously, which effectively made that character over-powered compared to traditional fighters).
Still, third edition was a bit clunky and had some major flaws, but those were mostly overcome with what is now regarded as the first fully fleshed out, flexible and comprehensive version of the game, the 3.5 version. The 3.5 version was incredibly diverse and allowed for the creation of wildly different characters, even allowing a player to play completely new and unique races and classes. It also introduced the concept of "epic" characters to deal with the game-changing aspect of higher level characters by providing new challenges and opportunities for characters which had essentially become superheroes or demigods.
I really enjoyed the 3.5 version of the game. That's the version I've mostly been playing for the past five years or so. Unfortunately I don't play enough to have any "epic" characters, but playing up to level 10 or so has been quite challenging and fun on its own. In fact I felt the game was pretty well complete and had no desire whatsoever for any new major changes in the rules. I invested in books and add-ons to the tune of a hundred bucks or so and expected to play that version pretty much from then on.
However, there was trouble in paradise. At levels nearing level 20 or above, characters became insanely overpowered by exploiting unintended synergies between different abilities of certain characters. There were ways to combine certain powers to effectively become omnipotent in game terms. Once people started figuring out how to create super-powerful characters, running high level dungeons became a frustrating exercise where individual game masters had to house rule spells and effects to keep higher level spell casters from simply overpowering everything in the game. In effect the game's greatest strength became it's greatest weakness. At the same time the role-playing genre exploded, with new games built around gamers playing vampires, or werewolves, or jedi knights or just about anything you can imagine started heavily intruding on the fundamental market that D&D had always owned. Add to that the explosion of online role playing games like World of Warcraft and Wizards of the Coast (which had purchased D&D to go along with their other fantasy games portfolio) decided that D&D was dying.
So they decided to completely revamp the game system, addressing the biggest concerns with the 3.5 version of the game.
The primary complaints in the 3.5 version of the game were around the spell-casters spell casting rules, and the unbalanced nature of the classes. The problem as it was perceived was that a wizard at low levels had very limited spell casting abiltities, and once his daily spells were cast, he became nothing but a very poor crossbow shooter wearing no armor. A fighter, on the other hand, could keep pounding away using his sword or bow with unlimited capacity to do damage. This situation reversed at higher levels where a fighter's melee combat became nearly irrelevent when compared to a wizard's ability to cast dozens of powerful spells, some of which could kill the most powerful monsters with nothing but a word. So at low levels the spell casters felt useless and bored while at high level the non spell casters felt like nothing but cannon fodder for the spell casters.
To "fix" that problem, in the 4e version of the game, all characters have roughly the same amount of combat potential in the form of at will, encounter and daily powers. Wizards no longer have a set of spells they gain each day and have to hoard to get through the day, they now had powers that were always usable, and other powers that would recharge after a fight (an "encounter" in D&D terms). Fighters gained special abilities that could be used in an encounter or daily which while not being "spells" were similar in effect. For example, a wizard might have a daily ability to cast "fireball" but the fighter would have some combat abilty to swing his weapon around in a circle hitting every enemy adjacent to him.
My first reaction to 4e was that it was too simplified when compared to 3.5e. The game mechanic was totally changed and it felt like there was no reason to play a spellcaster. In previous versions of the game, the dynamic forced a player to "suffer" with a spell-caster's low-level limitations to "earn" the high level benefits of being a spell-caster. It "felt" right to me that spell casters should dominate the upper levels of the game. The new fourth edition rules seemed to mimic the play of an online game like Everquest or WoW, which had gone to great lengths to keep different classes and races balanced from start to finish. In effect I pretty much decided that 4th edition was not my cup of tea.
But time goes on, and it turns out that it is hard to find a group that still plays 3.5 regularly. As with most things, people move on and adopt the new rules while older players stick with the old rules. (In D&D terminology, a player who adamantly refuses to play the new versions of the game is called a "grognard." There are grognards around who still insist on playing the first edition rules of the game, arguing that all subsequent editions have reduced the role-playing aspect of the game in favor of tactical battle simulations.) So a few weeks ago, I signed up for a 4e campaign just to see if I liked it. (OK, to be accurate, I had been running a 4e campaign for my regular group, but running a game is not the same thing as playing a character in the game. I wanted to experience the player side of things too).
Well, this past Sunday we had our first session. My biggest fear was that the game would feel too constrained and contrived, and that the role-playing would be subjugated entirely to the tactical battle simulations. I also thought the at-will, encounter and daily power thing would be confusing and also feel arbitrary.
I am pleased to say that I didn't feel that way at all during the game play. It was different, for sure, and there were things I missed from 3.5, but I was surprised to realize that there were some things I liked better in 4e. The main thing was the character balance was vastly improved compared to 3.5 games I've played. Every player is engaged in every round in every battle. In 3.5e my druid mostly hoards her spell-casting until there is a major battle because she has so few spells she can cast and they are so desperately needed in the major fights. In 4e you have your encounter and at will powers that you recharge anyway, so you may as well use them. This gives each battle more tactical options than in 3.5 where most of the real complex and interesting battles happen when you reach some final "boss" where everyone lets loose with all the spells and powers they've been saving all day. In 4e you get to use those even in minor random encounter battles. So there is much less of a "war of attrition" where the DM can coax a player into using up their major powers before the final encounter, or the players have a fight half an hour after waking up, and then decide that they can't go on before sleeping again.
I have to say I enjoyed it, but I was playing a melee ranger, a class that in 3.5e would have basically had just a few melee abilities that he would use over and over, while in 4e he has some interesting options to choose from. I'm still not sure how it would feel to play a spell-caster in 4e. But the ranger was a lot of fun. I can't say I'm "sold" on 4e, but I will say that most of my major concerns about the game have turned out to be overblown and in some cases, completely incorrect. I enjoyed it thoroughly and am looking forward to my next session in a few weeks.
SATURDAY AM UPDATE: With a big pricetag of $175 million, and bad buzz preceding it, G.I. Joe: The Rise Of Cobra seemed certain to tank. For months, Paramount's claims that the movie worked fell on deaf ears. Not until the Stephen Sommers' directed pic came on tracking with incredibly high awareness among males (with scores in the 90s). Now, despite all the sniping and snarking, it's the biggest opener ever in August for a non-sequel, and the 3rd biggest August opener ever.
OK, so we saw GI Joe last night.
You always hear the pseudo intelligentsia and wanna-be critics whine about how a popular movie is "stupid" and "has no plot" and "makes no sense" and "is just eye candy" etc...
Well, for once all that is true.
This movie is great eye candy, both in the sense of great special effects, and in the sense of some very sexy ladies dressed in very sexy clothes.
But it's stupid. It makes no sense. It is really just eye candy.
I suppose I could go on and on about the gaping plot holes and the obvious lack of any sense whatsoever in the movie, but instead I'll just use one example from the epic climactic scene of the movie.
In the GI Joe universe, ice sinks, and it sinks so fast and hard, that it crushes underwater military installations like boulders falling from a mountain.
I think that's really all you need to know about how much the makers of this movie attempted to have it make any sense whatsoever.
But it is great eye candy. Especially the red-haired eye candy.
(I was gonna say that I felt sorta bad for Dennis Quaid, but then I thought about what he got to look at for a few months making this movie and decided he did OK.)
We saw the latest Harry Potter installment yesterday. It's been getting rave reviews from critics and regular movie-goers alike. Here's my take:
For a Harry Potter movie, this one seemed painfully slow and halting. Long moments of inane teen angst dialogue filled several scenes. The interplay of the nascent love lives of the characters was interesting and entertaining on occasion, but I don't go to see a Harry Potter movie to agonize over who's going to end up in whose arms. Most of the interaction seemed clumsy and unrealistic anyway, including the bumbling towards intimacy of Harry Potter and his new love interest, Ron's little sister Ginny Weasley.
Interspersed with this ongoing middle-school soap opera were moments of darkness that had the classic Harry Potter lack of believability. The special effects were excellent, as usual, but some of the filming was, to me, downright irritating. One of the key scenes in the movie, of Harry confronting Bellatrix and her Deatheater cronies in a corn field, was filmed at waist level to minimize the visibility of the scene. I couldn't help but have a "Blair Witch Project" flashback. I find that technique of filming to be perhaps the most annoying thing to have been "added" to a director's toolkit in the past decade or so. It is supposed to add immediacy and bring the observer in, but it has the exact opposite effect on me, I mostly just turn it off and wait until the scene returns to something halfway understandable.
The "half-blood prince" is the unknown author of a ratty old textbook on potions that Harry ends up with after taking the potions class given by new Hogwarts teacher Horace Slughorn. Essentially the book is presented as a sort of classroom cheat sheet which has all the right answers for how to make potions penciled in because the actual published recipes in the book are all wrong. Since Hogwarts has been teaching potion making for hundreds of years, you would think that a potions textbook which had a dozen errors in one recipe might have been replaced in the time between the half-blood prince taking the classes and Harry's turn. Especially since the eventual revelation of who the half-blood prince was makes it far more unlikely that the class textbooks would have remained riddled (heh... I made a pun) with errors. But this is the essence of Harry Potter, to make the story interesting Rowlings routinely throws logic, common sense and any sort of believability to the winds... and I guess that's OK, people love her for it.
I could go on with other similar things, and the use of magic in Harry Potter, especially in the battle scenes, still just makes me shake my head, but my main problem with this movie is that it is just so painfully slow and boring in places. It's LONG, and you feel every minute of it. When Harry and Ginny finally do manage to steal their first kiss it's in the process of one of the least comprehensible acts in the movie, but again, who cares? It's Harry Potter! One thing that did surprise me was how plain the movie made Ginny Weasley appear. In scene after scene she appears frumpy, dumpy or just plain .... plain. Camera angles are poor, makeup is lackluster, her clothes are frumpy... In the book, as I recall (it's been years) Ginny essentially blossomed from a tomboyish little sister into a stunning young woman. In the movie she just gets taller. Hermione, in comparison, has moments of stunning beauty. I've always liked Hermione and I think Emma Watson portrays her nearly flawlessly. Bonnie Wright, as Ginny Weasley, always seems to have just bitten into something unpleasant.
It's not all bad though, the pursuit of Voldemort seems to have gone into stealth mode, with Dumbledore disappearing mysteriously on occasion, and with him dragging Harry on life-and-death missions on other occasions.
Overall I enjoyed about half of it, and felt more than a bit bored and confused during the other half. But you can't really miss this movie if you've been watching the franchise, so if you have, then get there and watch it.
Saw the Transformers Movie "Revenge of the Fallen" last night. I was not expecting much (other than Megan Fox in short shorts and low-cut blouses).
But in reality I enjoyed it thoroughly. The only things I didn't like about the movie were some pathetically gratuitous visual "humping" jokes with dogs and robots (yes, robots).
When I saw the movie "Holes" I sat up and took notice of Shia LaBeouf. I remember telling the Cosmic family at the time that I thought he was the real deal. I haven't seen anything to change that opinion since, although I think he was annoying in the Indiana Jones movie. LaBeouf can do comedy, drama, action and romance. And yet he isn't remotely the typical leading man type. I think he's just going to get better with age. I don't know of any other young actor with his range and his potential.
What do you say about Megan Fox? She is our version of Marilyn Monroe. She is pure, raw sex appeal. I haven't seen any actress with such primal sensuality in a long, long time. Maybe Raquel Welch. My only problem with Megan Fox is that she looks like a hot sexy girl, not quite a hot, sexy mature woman. I wonder what she will be in five years. I can't say she impresses me much as an actress, but she wasn't hired to emote, she was hired to run across a field of explosions in super slow-motion with her breasts bouncing so much that she must have glued them to her clothes to keep them from popping out. ( Darnit ;-) ) She does just fine in that role.
Sam Witwicky's parents in the movie are pretty good comedy relief, just as they were in the first movie. The role of his mother had the most over-the-top scenes in the movie, and some of them were quite funny.
But the main thing in this movie is the action. And this is probably the most action packed movie I've ever seen. There were few scenes that did not have explosions, falling, racing, chasing, fighting or even rocketing around. The special effects were un-freaking-believable. In fact my only complaint about the robots themselves were the two new Autobots they introduced, apparently to appeal to the kids. Although based on the squeals I heard in the theater, the kids themselves loved them.
Here's a slight segue into the whole rating system today. We went to an afternoon showing of the movie, and it was full of kids. In fact we were one of the few couples in the movie without several kids along. And when I say "kids" I don't mean 13 year olds. I mean six and seven year olds. Not only was the movie theater full of them, but regardless of the rating this movie had, parts of the movie clearly were aimed at young children. What's the point of calling a movie "PG-13" if everyone brings their six year old kid to it anyway?
OK, back to the movie. One of the complaints I saw in some reviews was that it was impossible to tell the Autobots and Decepticons apart. And it wasn't easy, but for some reason I found it much easier to do in this movie than in the first movie. For the most part in this movie I was able to keep track of who to root for and who to root against.
I found a couple scenes in the movie to be easily interpreted as digs at President Obama. The President (and he is referred to as "President Obama" in the movie) sends a lackey to take over the Autobot/US Military partnership, and that lackey exhibited many of the classic caricatures that are aimed at Obama by the right. He was arrogant, ignorant, bureaucratic, naive and ultimately an appeasing ideologue willing to jeopardize the entire future of the human race to pursue his narrow anti-military ideology. I was somewhat surprised by this, but actually also somewhat pleased.
In this movie the military actions against the Decepticons proved to be much more effective, and in fact had a significant impact in the major battles. I was glad to see this. In the first movie it seemed the Decepticons simply swatted our most powerful weapons around like bugs. In this movie the US Military did some serious damage to the Decepticons.
Without revealing too much of the movie I'll just say that there was a surprising amount of comedy, romance and drama in the movie. I found myself getting drawn in and sympathizing with Sam and even with some of the other characters. There is a nice subplot involving the redemption of one character, and that was actually nice to see.
I left the theater in a good mood, and that's a lot to say about a movie these days.
I give it four and a half Allspark splinters out of five. Cosmic says, check it out.
I post a lot of reviews. In general my reviews tend to be somewhat clinical. I don't "rave" about books or movies, nor do I create snarky, blistering attacks on them. Mostly I try to describe what I thought were the strengths and weaknesses and then give my own recommendation for what it is worth.
But I'm going to rave about this movie. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I loved the actors. I loved the writing. I loved the plot (but I can't reveal why). I loved the special effects. In fact I have rarely enjoyed a movie more. And this is after some fairly high expectations were set by some of the trailers and reviews I did read.
Before going into the details though, I do feel a need to provide some background so the reader of this review has some context for my own perspective on Star Trek itself.
I am not a big Star Trek fan. I never really have been, although I liked the original series much more than any of the spinoffs. I found even the original series to mostly be melodramatic and most of the episodes poorly written, some of them downright silly. However, there were some episodes that were absolutely brilliant. But what was great about the first series were the characters. Kirk, Spock, Bones and Scottie, and even sometimes including Uhuru, Chekhov and Sulu. The characters themselves were strong and within the confines of the show, unique. They played off of each other well, and the sense of commaradarie was palpable in some episodes.
Of the original cast, I was and am to this day a Kirk fan. James Tiberius Kirk is one of the great characters of fiction, right up there with Captain Ahab or Gandalf the Gray. Gene Roddenberry intentionally created his main characters as archetypes. Kirk represented the brash intuitive leader. Spock represented the analytical thinker. Bones represented the emotional conscience. The interplay of these archetypes provides powerful opportunities for drama and comedy, and the original series milked both fairly well.
Now back to this movie. Many people will probably want to know if they managed to capture the essence of those relationships. And I think that is actually one of the great strengths of this movie. They managed to do so surprisingly well. But more than that. They did so with a tongue firmly planted in their cheeks and a twinkle in their eye. They hit the classic lines and stereotypes in a way that provided both a sincere nod of appreciation towards the original series, but delivered them with a freshness and tone that provided an appreciative chuckle instead of boredom. Very well played indeed.
And then there were the actors. One of the most difficult things to do in film or on stage is to reprise a beloved character, especially one associated entirely to one actor and that actor's personality. I had expected to see at least a few of the actors in this film provide a caricature of the original character, caught up in the portrayal people are expecting to see, instead of infusing the character with a life and a personality of their own, while still providing a believable sense that this young version could plausibly grow into the older version. But the five main characters, Kirk, Spock, Uhuru, McCoy and Scottie, were played to near perfection by their respective actors.
As I said, of the original series characters, I liked Kirk best, because of what he represented. In this movie, the same holds true. Kirk is decisive, impulsive, daring and insouciant, no matter if he is facing the ire of his fellow cadets or the fury of a genocidal psychotic maniac.
I had also expected the movie to succumb to modern ideas of political correctness, particularly around Kirk's well-known womanizing. But this movie reveled in his debauchery. This Kirk is no namby-pamby Picard-ized version of the original Kirk. This may sound odd coming from such a firm heterosexual man, but this Kirk is downright sexy.
The dialog is snappy and with a few exceptions, delivered in believable ways. All Hollywood movies suffer from a fatal case of scientific illiteracy, and this movie has it's eye-rolling moments when the actors try to discuss physics or math, but it is obvious to me that expecting even moderate levels of scientific awareness is simply expecting too much out of Hollywood. So those moments were quickly forgotten.
And if you like action, you should love this movie. The action is non-stop, and many of the action scenes are obvious deliberate nods to famous action scenes in other movies, again demonstrating the director's edgy but successful effort to merge the actions on the screen with the viewers own cinematic expectations. This is a delicate line to walk, and I thought it was navigated nearly perfectly. In that sense the movie is a surprisingly LITERATE experience. The writers and director clearly appreciated the audience and provided different levels of experience for the viewers.
Finally, without giving the movie away too much, this movie has attempted one of the boldest and riskiest means of reconciling an appreciation of its own history with a need to revitalize the franchise that I've ever seen. No doubt this is what many people will love to hate or hate to love. But I thought it was bold, decisive, daring and even insouciant, so I loved to love it. Such a risk pulled off so well should be rewarded. This movie ended in a way that provides not only a new beginning for more Star Trek movies, but will no doubt spawn dozens of new Star Trek novels as well. And it will be forever debated by the faithful as either a brilliant stroke of genius, or the worst sort of hackneyed butchery since Bobby Ewing ambled out of the shower on Dallas.
I give this movie five blobs of red matter out of five. I am greatly impressed by the risks the producer, writer, director, actors and studio took with this movie. They deserve great rewards for their boldness.
I am looking forward to more Star Trek movies in the future.
Yeah, I know the movie's actual title is "X-Men Beginnings: Wolverine" or something like that, but you know what I mean...
This is the movie the ardent X-Men and Wolverine fans have been clamoring for. Wolverine is by far the most popular of the X-Men, and may by now have even passed the likes of Spidey himself in the Marvel pantheon of superheroes.Certainly the Wolverine fans are more vocal than the Spidey fans.
Perhaps the biggest reason for that is that Wolverine is a much darker anti-hero than Spidey is. Wolverine is a superhero with sharp edges, and not just on his adamantium claws.
No doubt many critics will sneer at yet another comic book movie. And I must admit that I too am surprised and potentially even concerned by the complete dominance of the "blockbuster" genre by comic book film adaptations in the past decade or so. But perhaps I shouldn't be. Comic books are almost identical in format to story boards which are commonly used to lay out movie scenes.
So how does this comic book come across on the big screen?
Pretty darn good I'd say. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I can only imagine how hard it is to act in the role of a superhero doing physically impossible things. Hugh Jackman pulls it off well, although some of the other "mutants" in the film could have used a few more takes in their closeups.
The basic storyline is pretty standard. Mutant boy mistakenly kills his own father using his mutant powers, runs off with his equally mutant older brother and the two of them become mercenaries in a succession of wars for decades as neither ages beyond 30 or so. Mutant man becomes evil military experiment subject where his powers are amplified before he is hunted down by that same military. Mutant man turns the tables on the military before the military unleashes their new and improved version of HIM to destroy him, whereupon an earthshaking climactic battle proves that even mutants can defeat vastly superior foes if they just listen to their hearts before decapitating the enemy.
Pretty standard story line, I think Frank Capra did about a dozen of these heartwarming stories back in the fifties...
Still it mostly works. The flaws, and there are many, are easily forgiven in part due to surprisingly strong performances by Jackman and by Lynn Collins who plays his lover who also happened to be a spy in the employ of the evil military mastermind dude. Again pretty standard stuff, I think originally employed in "Hamlet." Many of the supporting roles have forgettable performances, and the performance of Danny Huston as William Stryker was particularly lame.
Great special effects. Surprisingly good acting in the main leading roles. Great fight choreography. A reasonably interesting story with some twists and turns that might catch a few viewers off guard.
Cosmic says check it out. I give it four out of five erupting adamantium fist claws.
So maybe you've seen the trailer for the recent movie "City of Ember" starring Bill Murray as the Mayor of the city. Or maybe you saw the movie itself. I just finished reading the book at the request of the Cosmic Daughter who read it some time ago. I haven't seen the movie.
It's an interesting book, with a rather odd premise and a fairly implausible plot, but I liked it enough to read the whole thing, even though any surprises in the reading were more or less unveiled by about page 20.
The basic story is that during some crisis in world history a group of people determined to save the human race (the "Builders") decided they needed to build a city deep underground, and populate it with a group of people kept deliberately ignorant of their origins and their history. After 200 years or so, a special locked box kept in the possession of the Mayor of the city would open, revealing the way back out from the city and to a presumably post-apocalyptic world. The premise apparently being that the city's inhabitants would become the seed of a new human renaissance.
But the seventh Mayor in the line went nutzo and died after trying to force the box open. The eighth Mayor never heard of the box and so it remained in the seventh Mayor's closet from that time on. That Mayor's great-great-grandaughter, Lina, still lived in the same house, but the closet had long since become packed so full that the box was forgotten until Lina's own grandmother went similarly nutzo and tore the house apart looking for some mysterious "lost" thing. In the frenzy the now-unlocked box was recovered by Lina's toddler sister, who ripped and chewed the instructions apart. The rest of the book covers Lina and her best friend Doon's attempts to decipher the mysterious contents of the tattered remains of the note, leading them to eventually attempt to escape from the city themselves. Their story has added urgency due to the dilapidated condition of everything in the city, including the great generator which supplies the city with power, and which is in the process of failing.
I wasn't terribly impressed with the book. I felt the story was weak, the characters were one-dimensional, including Lina and Doon, the main characters in the book, and the plot was, as I have already said, completely implausible. The central theme of the book probably was SUPPOSED to be about the indominatable human spirit, as represented by Doon and Lina. But the overwhelming darkness and depression of the rest of the city suffocates that message and instead the real theme, intentional or not, becomes instead about the crushing power of conformity and fear.
But what really struck me in reading the book is not so much anything IN the book, except in a literal, as opposed to a literary way. See, the book I have was published after the movie was in production, and as such it has a central section that contains still photographs from the movie. Not wanting to "spoil" the story (as if I hadn't already figured the whole thing out by page 20) I deliberately ignored those glossy photos until I finished the book. When I did look at the photos I had to ask what book the movie was made from, because over half of the photos in the insert depicted events that NEVER HAPPENED in the book. Then I went and looked at the trailor, and again the movie seems to have been made about a completely different book.
This isn't the first time I've written a review of a book or movie and complained that the movie was so radically different from the book that it was hard to even see the resemblance between the two. I guess Hollywood directors buy book ideas based on how they sell as books, but then decide that the book really isn't much of a movie and so completely restructure the story so that it makes a better movie.
Whatever, I don't like it. And I didn't really care THAT much for this book, but as I said, it was just interesting enough for me to finish the whole thing. If you have a child in the 12 - 15 age group, they might enjoy it.