Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

GI Schmoe

By CosmicConservative

SATURDAY AM UPDATE: With a big pricetag of $175 million, and bad buzz preceding it, G.I. Joe: The Rise Of Cobra seemed certain to tank. For months, Paramount's claims that the movie worked fell on deaf ears. Not until the Stephen Sommers' directed pic came on tracking with incredibly high awareness among males (with scores in the 90s). Now, despite all the sniping and snarking, it's the biggest opener ever in August for a non-sequel, and the 3rd biggest August opener ever.

Nikki Finke's Deadline Hollywood Daily » FINALLY, A FILM FOR FLYOVER COUNTRY: ‘G.I. Joe’ Breaks August Record For $22.3M Friday/$60.3M Weekend; ‘Julie & Julia’ Cheaply Counter-Programs For $20M Wkd.
OK, so we saw GI Joe last night. You always hear the pseudo intelligentsia and wanna-be critics whine about how a popular movie is "stupid" and "has no plot" and "makes no sense" and "is just eye candy" etc... Well, for once all that is true. This movie is great eye candy, both in the sense of great special effects, and in the sense of some very sexy ladies dressed in very sexy clothes. But it's stupid. It makes no sense. It is really just eye candy. I suppose I could go on and on about the gaping plot holes and the obvious lack of any sense whatsoever in the movie, but instead I'll just use one example from the epic climactic scene of the movie. In the GI Joe universe, ice sinks, and it sinks so fast and hard, that it crushes underwater military installations like boulders falling from a mountain. I think that's really all you need to know about how much the makers of this movie attempted to have it make any sense whatsoever. But it is great eye candy. Especially the red-haired eye candy. (I was gonna say that I felt sorta bad for Dennis Quaid, but then I thought about what he got to look at for a few months making this movie and decided he did OK.)

Comments (9)

Dadman
And yet you liked 'Transformers'... I'll likely see this just for the eye candy. ;)
CosmicConservative
Well, in my humble opinion, Transformers had more going for it than GI Joe. I liked several of the subplots and human interest aspects of Transformers, and particularly liked the "bad guy" from movie #1 having an opportunity for redemption in movie #2. Redemption is almost never pursued in movies these days, and I thought it was heartwarming. I did like Transformers #2, I had a great time watching it.
Dadman
'Transformers 2' was an incoherent, two-plus hour, headache-inducing explosion. Michael Bay needs Ritalin or a sedative or to just stop making movies altogether. I'm glad you enjoyed 'Transformers'. It just surprises me. It seems to me that 'Transformers' can be easily criticized for precisely the same things you've criticized 'G.I. Joe' for. I HATED 'Transformers 2' in spite of a solid performance by Shia LeBeouf and the exquisite eye candy of Megan Fox. Oh well. Too each his own. If I see G.I. Joe I'll let you know what I think. I'll probably agree with your assessment.
CosmicConservative
Here are the differences I see in "Transformers" and "GI Joe". I actually cared something about the characters in Transformers. I thought the relationship between Sam Witwicki and his parents was clever and thought his mother, in particular, did a nice comedic turn, while his father did a pretty good job as bemused straight man converted to proud, if reluctant to let go, father. The characters in GI Joe were so one-dimensional that they were nearly zero dimensional. I really didn't care for any of them, although I will give the writers some credit for some funny moments. As far as Transformers is concerned, I've already mentioned the redemption of the government agent who was trying to ruin Sam and Mikaela's lives. Yes, it was noisy, yes it was cartoonish. Those reviewers who think they are being critical of the movie by calling it "cartoonish" somehow seem to not understand that IT IS A CARTOON! I never held Transformers up as some sort of modern movie masterpiece, I simply said I enjoyed it, and enjoyed some of the subplots, while greatly appreciating some of the best special effects ever done. I will point out that in spite of the movie having alien technology that is effectively "magic," I can't think of anything remotely as ridiculous in either Transformers movie as ice falling through the water like boulders through air. I didn't snicker my way through Transformers. I snickered and nearly guffawed my way through GI Joe.
Dadman
Most critics are morons, but their consensus with respect to 'Transformers' hit the mark, I think. It really doesn't matter. My favortie movie this year is 'Gran Torino' which gives you some idea of the kind of movie I prefer. Watching too many Michael Bay movies will induce ADD I'm convinced. By the way, I moaned my way through 'Transformers' it was so painful to watch. ;)
CosmicConservative
Haven't seen "Gran Torino". In fact I don't know much, if anything, about the movie.
Dadman
It's a Clint Eastwood flick that makes a strong statement against the absurdity of political correctness among other things. Most Eastwood films are praiseworthy and GT is no exception. Dadman says check it out!
mtnlurker
I saw Gran Torino and loved it. Though it is not for those who have sensitive ears.
Dadman
Well, I saw G.I. Joe over the weekend and agree with your assessment. Dumb from beginning to end. They should have called this movie G.I.C. Cleavage... Just a couple comments: The Star War franchise seems to have inspired many of G.I. Joe's action scenes. I'd call it blatant cinematic plagarism. Also, casting the kid from 'Third Rock from the Sun' as the arch villian in the film was a serious miscalculation (among many). He just didn't have the gravitas a good villian should have. The studio spent a gigazillion dollars producing this film and it looked good as a result - great sets, costumes, effects, etc. It just had no substance. It was like a gorgeous woman without a brain or personality. And speaking of gorgeous women...Sienna Miller is quite lovely as a brunette.