Book Review: City of Ember
By CosmicConservativeSo maybe you've seen the trailer for the recent movie "City of Ember" starring Bill Murray as the Mayor of the city. Or maybe you saw the movie itself. I just finished reading the book at the request of the Cosmic Daughter who read it some time ago. I haven't seen the movie.
It's an interesting book, with a rather odd premise and a fairly implausible plot, but I liked it enough to read the whole thing, even though any surprises in the reading were more or less unveiled by about page 20.
The basic story is that during some crisis in world history a group of people determined to save the human race (the "Builders") decided they needed to build a city deep underground, and populate it with a group of people kept deliberately ignorant of their origins and their history. After 200 years or so, a special locked box kept in the possession of the Mayor of the city would open, revealing the way back out from the city and to a presumably post-apocalyptic world. The premise apparently being that the city's inhabitants would become the seed of a new human renaissance.
But the seventh Mayor in the line went nutzo and died after trying to force the box open. The eighth Mayor never heard of the box and so it remained in the seventh Mayor's closet from that time on. That Mayor's great-great-grandaughter, Lina, still lived in the same house, but the closet had long since become packed so full that the box was forgotten until Lina's own grandmother went similarly nutzo and tore the house apart looking for some mysterious "lost" thing. In the frenzy the now-unlocked box was recovered by Lina's toddler sister, who ripped and chewed the instructions apart. The rest of the book covers Lina and her best friend Doon's attempts to decipher the mysterious contents of the tattered remains of the note, leading them to eventually attempt to escape from the city themselves. Their story has added urgency due to the dilapidated condition of everything in the city, including the great generator which supplies the city with power, and which is in the process of failing.
I wasn't terribly impressed with the book. I felt the story was weak, the characters were one-dimensional, including Lina and Doon, the main characters in the book, and the plot was, as I have already said, completely implausible. The central theme of the book probably was SUPPOSED to be about the indominatable human spirit, as represented by Doon and Lina. But the overwhelming darkness and depression of the rest of the city suffocates that message and instead the real theme, intentional or not, becomes instead about the crushing power of conformity and fear.
But what really struck me in reading the book is not so much anything IN the book, except in a literal, as opposed to a literary way. See, the book I have was published after the movie was in production, and as such it has a central section that contains still photographs from the movie. Not wanting to "spoil" the story (as if I hadn't already figured the whole thing out by page 20) I deliberately ignored those glossy photos until I finished the book. When I did look at the photos I had to ask what book the movie was made from, because over half of the photos in the insert depicted events that NEVER HAPPENED in the book. Then I went and looked at the trailor, and again the movie seems to have been made about a completely different book.
This isn't the first time I've written a review of a book or movie and complained that the movie was so radically different from the book that it was hard to even see the resemblance between the two. I guess Hollywood directors buy book ideas based on how they sell as books, but then decide that the book really isn't much of a movie and so completely restructure the story so that it makes a better movie.
Whatever, I don't like it. And I didn't really care THAT much for this book, but as I said, it was just interesting enough for me to finish the whole thing. If you have a child in the 12 - 15 age group, they might enjoy it.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.