Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Avatar

By CosmicConservative
Warning! Spoilers! OK, let's get going. When the first trailer for Avatar came up at a movie theater, I immediately assumed it was this: the-avatar-cartoon-character "Avatar" is also an anime cartoon and I think it's being made into a movie as well. That movie is being done by M. Night Shyamalan. The Cosmic Daughter is a big fan of the Avatar cartoon so I thought "cool, we get to see a preview of Avatar!" But it clearly wasn't the cartoon. At the end of the preview the Cosmic Wife and I looked at each other and I said "Well, we humans get to be the evil bad guys again." And she said "It looks like Fern Gully meets Terminator" or something like that. But the graphics looked awesome. I'm something of a fan of dragons. I've got dragon sculptures and figurines, books on dragons, I've sculpted my own dragons and one year I had a dragon calendar. So anything with dragons in it gets my attention. And if people are flying the dragons? That's even better. People flying dragons is a favorite theme of mine. I used to love Anne McCaffrey's "Pern" books (yes, I've told you all before that I am firmly in touch with my feminine side and always have been). So, in spite of the obvious Hollywood self-loathing, military-as-evil-buffon schtick, I knew I'd have to watch the movie. So to get the easy stuff out of the way... The story is inane. The plot is a sort of hodge-podge of "Dances With Wolves", "Pocahontas", "Fern Gully" and "Terminator". In the opening shots as you fly over the verdant world of "Pandora" you end up at a huge strip mine where the humans lived. I swear if they had been playing "Diggety Dig" from Pocahontas I would not have been remotely surprised. That's how cartoonish the whole plot felt. With the exception of a disabled veteran and a black female hovercopter pilot, everyone else in the military was no more intelligent or human than a robot. And of course the two most evil creatures in the movie were both white males. One a rapacious corporate stooge, the other a mindless military warmonger. Oh Hollywood, you are so original and clever. So let's just dispense with the pathetic, moronic and insulting parts of the movie (the plot, the acting, and the writing) and stick instead to the only good part of the movie. The graphics. Besides being awesome, they were in 3D! Woohoo! OK, so there are still some limits to computer animation and if you wanted to you could clearly see how the live action and animation still had significant gaps, but they are getting better. (Although I still think Gollum was more "realistic" than the CGI in "Avatar"). I went to the movie with the explicit intent to turn off my critical brain and just enjoy the thrill ride. And it was a great ride. The graphics were immersive and spectacular. Had this been a Heavy Metal movie with nothing but heavy metal music in the background as you went from scene to scene, I would probably have enjoyed it more. If I were a druggie, I would certainly have wanted to view this while under the influence of my favorite psychedelic. Man I loved those dragons! And there were some nice touches apart from the dragons. The writers were at least smart enough to have an entire branch of six-legged vertebrates, which is one of the things that makes dragons more believable. ("Dragons" with two hind legs, two wings and no forelegs are technically called "wyverns". "Dragons" have four legs and two wings. And yes I know that Chinese dragons don't have wings....) So we are given lovingly crafted shots of six-legged predators of various sizes, and dragons as well as drakes ("Drakes" are small dragons) with six limbs. The Pocahontas love interest was attractive enough, although the general relative physiology of the natives was somewhat runway super-modelish. There were no fat and lazy "Na'vi" (the natives). The Na'vi were so obviously based on Hollywood fantasies of native American culture that it was downright funny sometimes. Complete with skull totems, feathered headdresses and coming of age rituals. But the crowning moment came when you realized that the "mother tree" from Pocahontas had been reproduced on Pandora. OK, so the graphics were amazing, and the view from the back of a flying dragon was beatifully accomplished. So if you enjoy that sort of thing (and who doesn't?) go see the movie. You can listen to your iPod if you want, you won't miss anything worthwhile. But just to snark on the most laughable things in the movie because I can't help myself... I can't imagine writing that could possibly be worse than naming the planet "Pandora" and naming the mineral being strip mined "unobtainium." I almost laughed out loud when they got to that part. "Unobtainium!" That's the sort of made-up name a 9 year old would come up with. What does it do? Your guess is as good as mine. All you know is that it sells for a ginormous sum on earth the "dead planet" where humans have "killed their mother." No wonder the humans are so soulless. What unobtainium is, or what it does is never remotely explained, although the "richest deposit on the planet" just happens to be directly under the main native village's Home Tree. Wow, what a coincidence, eh? Two or three things really have to be mentioned because they are so insane. The first is the "legendary floating mountains of Pandora." Yes, floating mountains. Floating in the air! Way up in the air, connected by implausible knotted vines. Why do they float? Who knows? Are the humans on the planet remotely interested in exploring the physics of how you make entire mountains float? Apparently not. They are too busy with raping the planet for the unobtanium, or doing "critical" research on the local flora and fuana to look into a physical effect that would totally revolutionize transportation as well as dozens of other fields. Anti-gravity would seem to be somewhat interesting to even soulless humans, but instead the humans on Pandora avoid the floating mountains like the plague. Why? Because the floating mountains happen to be within a "flux field" which makes all their fancy technology go all wobbly. Well, except for the technology that keeps motors running and hovercraft flying anyway. Again, what is the source of this "flux field?" Who knows? What IS a "flux field?" Who CARES? It's just there, coincidentally co-located with the flying mountains. Does anyone even speculate that the flux field might be RESPONSIBLE for the floating mountains? Nope. Does anyone want to RESEARCH the flux field? Not really. Bigger fish to fry. Gotta get to the genocide, science can wait. And finally, when the human protagonist's avatar connects with the mother tree, he can hear the voices of his ancestors speaking to him. They are all there! Just like the natives! But how can they be there? First of all the avatar is created by combining genetic material from the Na'Vi with human DNA. So shouldn't the human be hearing Na'Vi voices too? And why was my initial reaction to this revelation an internal shudder? Was I channeling Baron Harkonnen from Dune? ABOMINATION!!! Anyway... I don't have a problem with the concept of a living interconnected world where the "dominant" intelligent species have nobly decided to live in the stone age forever. There are lots of sci-fi books with this sort of premise. It makes for a good counterpoint to a technological star-faring civilization and provides some opportunities for delivering life lessons about remembering our roots and appreciating the value of organic life. I just don't care for the absolute demonization of humans that is considered to be required among the Leftist intelligentsia. The reality is that while the Left claims to love and appreciate the lifestyle of stone age cultures, they would be eaten alive if they ever found themselves in one. Romanticizing and glorifying stone age life is one of the great tragedies of modern times. The average life span of an indigineous native American, or indigineous native Australian, or pretty much ANY stone age culture, was about 30. Elderly individuals were revered because they were so freaking rare. Living to the age of 40 was quite an accomplishment, and very few did so without serious debilitating effects of the harshness of their lives. This demonization of technology is made more ridiculous when you realize that the entire lifestyle and livelihood of the Hollywood mental midgets who ladle admiration upon the "noble savages" is dependent on the very technology they are attacking. People can't make movies without technology. In fact making movies is among the worst offenders when it comes to environmental damage. Film processing alone relies heavily on poisonous chemicals. Computer technology also relies heavily on poisonous chemicals. But even more than that, the entire profession relies on people having the leisure time to sit down for hours to be lectured by these idiots. How is that leisure time arrived at? Through the very technology that the filmmakers attack. I suppose it's not new to point out the monumental hypocrisy and abject ignorance of the Left. But I still can't help myself. Go watch the movie so James Cameron can rake in more millions (billions?) of dollars so James Cameron can continue to travel the world in his private jets and private yachts to lecture us on the evils of technology and the greed of capitalism. I did. And it was worth it. Love those dragons!

Comments (18)

CosmicConservative
Yeah, I did love the dragons. Here's why. 1. They created a plausible branch of six-legged vertebrates on the planet. That provides an explanation of how such a large six-limbed beast could have evolved in the first place. 2. They did not stick to standard dragon imagery. They created unique dragon physiology with plausible airfoils and musculature. 3. The dragons flew realistically. Whoever was in charge of the dragon animation obviously worked not only with a flying animal expert, but also with aviation experts who could intuitively understand how the unique airfoils would act and react to air flow. I loved how the back "wings" were being used to stabilize the flight. If they put as much thought and analysis into the plot as they did the dragon wings and flight, it would have been a much better movie. 4. Dragon riding. 'Nuff said. 5. When the protagonist described riding his drake and shooting his arrows as "raining destruction from the sky" my D&D 3.5 edition ranger (who flies a hippogriff) has said virtually the same thing about riding his hippogriff and shooting his arrows at targets on the ground. About the only thing I didn't like about the dragons (and drakes) was the same thing I didn't like about the mother tree and the six-legged horses. That's the whole "jacked in" concept where somehow these lifeforms on Pandora have evolved this organ which appears to be exposed nerve ends that can be connected like a USB port to another living thing. That was perhaps the least plausible thing in a very implausible movie.
CosmicConservative
reggie, you have a 3D compatible video system at home?
reggie
no, I imagine the 3D stuff will be gone for the DVD release. I can't imagine them missing out on the DVD money. If not, no great loss. I hate going to the movie theater.The last theater movie was the latest Star Trek. Between the loud talking, crying babies and the dolts texting and talking on their phones.........you get the picture.
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... I don't go see a lot of movies, but I probably see about eight per year. I can't honestly say I've noticed the behavior in movie theaters being any worse than it has been for years. Yeah, when we went to see "The Princess and the Frog" we had some kids crying and stuff, but you gotta expect that. But I don't recall any significant interruptions or rudeness at "Avatar" or the other movies we've seen this year. Maybe you just need to find a different theater to watch movies at. :)
reggie
With a 50 inch 1080p plasma tv and a VERY nice sound system to go with it, I don't miss the theater at all.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I hear ya... We've got a big 1080p TV ourselves (but not any special sound system) and it's definitely very nice. I've also got a big HDTV projector so I can put a six foot HDTV image on the wall if I want (I've done it a couple of times). And we've watched lots of movies and TV shows that way. But going to the movies is still something "different" than watching a movie at home for us. It's an opportunity to make an evening out, away from the house, the dishes, the laundry, the dog... There's still a lot to be said for watching a show at a cinema... In fact, the only reason we didn't do the Imax showing is 'cause it was sold out.
reggie
not my cuppa tea, I used to love going, in fact I ran movies as a high school kid in the small town I grew up in, what memories, 2 Simplex carbon arc projectors,Cinemascope curtains to open and real 35mm film . I suppose I'm spoiled. Going to the movie theater used to be something special, now after 20 minutes of commercials, and the lack of civility of some of the other patrons, why bother. I'm not a "gotta see/do/have" it now sort of person. Now for the best part, nice comfy chair, my choice of food or beverage, and best of all the PAUSE button. So I only go to the movies when my lovely wife makes me.
TDale
Reggie: The IMAX 3D is incredible. Drag yourself out for it. You will not be disappointed. Unless of course you have a 3D ready system. I bet this movie on DVD or BlueRay will be used to promote RealID 3D technology on home systems. CosmicConservative, do you really think it is only the left that 'love and appreciate the lifestyle of stone age cultures?' Do you think all those involved in Civil War re-enactments are liberals? There are a lot of libertarians into the middle ages re-enactments too. There got to be an aspect of future shock in this over sentimentalization of the past for which conservative vs liberal is irrelevant. Our society has and continues to be undergoing an enormous amount of structural change where the accelerated rate of technological and social change which is leaving both liberals, progressives, libertarians and conservatives disconnected and suffering from "shattering stress and disorientation." It's been hard to watch the Tea Party movement without seeing a strong aspect along this line. It's been evident as a fringe part of the green party for a long time. By and large, the people who invest in movies, while admittedly disconnected from reality, mostly are factoring in this emotion in the audience they depend on for a profit. I thought your critique of the movie's plot was dead on and was surprised and disappointed when you brought out the simplistic left vs right demagoguery. That is so last century. I would have thought that last fall when the 'Masters of the Universe' switched parties you would have snapped to the realization that they are playing the left and right like puppets on a string. I'm also seeing aspects of the Joe Haldeman's Forever War and Larry Niven's The Integral Trees in this movie. Larry at least as I remember explained the floating trees. I just wish I could stop repeating: 'Massed Armour ALWAYS wins" to myself as I relive the final battle scene:) By and large a great commentary on the movie.
CosmicConservative
TDale: I said that the people on the left romanticize and fantasize about stone age cultures. I play D&D and could see myself in re-enactments, but I don't romanticize the lifestyle of stone age barbarians. Unlike James Cameron I understand that for a native American in 1750 a tooth cavity could be a death sentence. People on the right tend not to romanticize those cultures. They can "appreciate" and even "admire" them, but they know that if you went into a typical stone age village you'd find several of them sick and dying, many of them children. That's just the way it was. They weren't all hyper fit paragons of health and virtue and praying to Gaia might feel good, but it doesn't cure an abscess. And just for the record, you'll find "simplistic right vs. left demagoguery" here from time to time. It's part of the program. :)
TDale
CosmicSonservative: I was really impressed with your review. It showed insight and thoughtfulness such that the sudden attack on left ended wing nuts was surprising (ignoring the subtle hint in your username:) But I'm more than a little skeptical of your assumptions. With your use of the words 'romanticize', 'fantasize', 'appreciate' and 'admire' I see little more than an attempt to subtly differentiate and divide the world to your liking. Your writing indicates an intellectual depth that this belies. Remember, both Left and Right ended wing nuts verbalize a reality disconnect displayed in a lot of ways, including their romanticizing, fantasizing, appreciation and admiration of the past. It's really more fun to sit in the middle and throw rocks at both ends. P.S. I've recently read a reference to Dwight Eisenhower's favorite book, The True Believer, by Eric Hoffer. Have you read it? I'm still trying to get a hold of a copy. P.P.S. Merry Christmas to you and yours on this Chrismas Eve.
CosmicConservative
TDale: OK, you have a point. The right also romanticizes the past, but in a different way. But to be honest I don't like the way the right does it any more than the way the Left does. What I should have tried to be more clear about is that the Left tends towards a very paganistic view of the world. Terms like "gaia" and "earth-mother" trip off their tongues very easily. My evaluation of the Left's view of spirituality is that it is very animistic. When they romanticize the past they tend to create a simplistic and laughable "man in touch with nature" fantasy. On the right there are other fantasies, that is true. I guess in this case I was picking on the way the Left does it. Lord of the Rings might be an example of the right's means of romanticizing the past as a time when man was more in touch with God and culture had not descended to the depths of depravity of the modern world. Both are simplistic notions, neither is accurate. But in this case I was focusing on a movie with a hard-left message.
TDale
CosmicConservative: Yeah, the more I reflect, the more this movie reminds me of Dances with Wolves. And interestingly, I just read that JRR Tolkien was a Christian writer. Who knew? (well lots evidently - just not me) Anyway, the graphics were great, and I will be going back. I wonder if an enterprising soul somewhere will set this movie to music? A space opera, perhaps? Cheers.
Dadman
For the record, Tolkien was best friends with one of Christianity's most outspoken apologists, C.S. Lewis. The Lord of the Rings is rife with Christian allegory as is The Chronicles of Narnia, Lewis' masterwork... And on that note, Merry Christmas everyone...
Ridge Runner
When used copies of the DVD are available on Amazon, I may spring for one, or use Netflix the next time I get a gift subscription for a few months. The various reviews have provided enough details of the content until then, and I generally try to minimize the revenue stream accruing to the purveyors of pernicious messages, however attractive the packaging. Our culture is not exceptionally perverse,yet, although it is approaching the historical envelope with state-subsidized assembly line slaughterhouses for the "product of conception" of designated untermenschen classes (as can be verified by any of the readily available ethnic profiles of abortion statistics). However, note that there is still plenty of organized resistance to the proliferation of and tax-support for these charnel houses. Its popular sports produce a certain level of gruesome casualties (e.g., quadraplegic victims of US style football), but far from the systematic slaughter typical of the sports arenas of Rome or the Mayans or the Aztecs. Its pornography and commercial sexual services are more elaborate than earlier eras, and more readily available to immature members of the community, but mainly as a byproduct of the increasing functionality and decreasing cost of use of communications technology rather than some general amplification of the sexual perversity of the users of such product. The demand for products designed to inflame the erotic drive would be unsurpising to any of the authors of the Biblical texts, who found that demand as pervasive millenia ago as we experience now. Our technology has uncovered a variety of subject-to-abuse recreational substances that were not previously available, but the resulting self-immolation of abusers would not be a novelty to those writer of testimonies in the past either. This is neither the "best of times" nor "the worst of times". It has it's own charms and stresses, and abounds in opportunities to enjoy life or despair of it. I hope you who read this grab the opportunities to enjoy it, and sidestep the temptations to despair of it. Happy New Decade!
JonB
Would you also compare this movie to Dune, Princess Mononoke, Nausicaa, Heavy Metal, Castle in The Sky etc.?