Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: "Star Trek"

By CosmicConservative
I post a lot of reviews. In general my reviews tend to be somewhat clinical. I don't "rave" about books or movies, nor do I create snarky, blistering attacks on them. Mostly I try to describe what I thought were the strengths and weaknesses and then give my own recommendation for what it is worth. But I'm going to rave about this movie. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I loved the actors. I loved the writing. I loved the plot (but I can't reveal why). I loved the special effects. In fact I have rarely enjoyed a movie more. And this is after some fairly high expectations were set by some of the trailers and reviews I did read. Before going into the details though, I do feel a need to provide some background so the reader of this review has some context for my own perspective on Star Trek itself. I am not a big Star Trek fan. I never really have been, although I liked the original series much more than any of the spinoffs. I found even the original series to mostly be melodramatic and most of the episodes poorly written, some of them downright silly. However, there were some episodes that were absolutely brilliant. But what was great about the first series were the characters. Kirk, Spock, Bones and Scottie, and even sometimes including Uhuru, Chekhov and Sulu. The characters themselves were strong and within the confines of the show, unique. They played off of each other well, and the sense of commaradarie was palpable in some episodes. Of the original cast, I was and am to this day a Kirk fan. James Tiberius Kirk is one of the great characters of fiction, right up there with Captain Ahab or Gandalf the Gray. Gene Roddenberry intentionally created his main characters as archetypes. Kirk represented the brash intuitive leader. Spock represented the analytical thinker. Bones represented the emotional conscience. The interplay of these archetypes provides powerful opportunities for drama and comedy, and the original series milked both fairly well. Now back to this movie. Many people will probably want to know if they managed to capture the essence of those relationships. And I think that is actually one of the great strengths of this movie. They managed to do so surprisingly well. But more than that. They did so with a tongue firmly planted in their cheeks and a twinkle in their eye. They hit the classic lines and stereotypes in a way that provided both a sincere nod of appreciation towards the original series, but delivered them with a freshness and tone that provided an appreciative chuckle instead of boredom. Very well played indeed. And then there were the actors. One of the most difficult things to do in film or on stage is to reprise a beloved character, especially one associated entirely to one actor and that actor's personality. I had expected to see at least a few of the actors in this film provide a caricature of the original character, caught up in the portrayal people are expecting to see, instead of infusing the character with a life and a personality of their own, while still providing a believable sense that this young version could plausibly grow into the older version. But the five main characters, Kirk, Spock, Uhuru, McCoy and Scottie, were played to near perfection by their respective actors. As I said, of the original series characters, I liked Kirk best, because of what he represented. In this movie, the same holds true. Kirk is decisive, impulsive, daring and insouciant, no matter if he is facing the ire of his fellow cadets or the fury of a genocidal psychotic maniac. I had also expected the movie to succumb to modern ideas of political correctness, particularly around Kirk's well-known womanizing. But this movie reveled in his debauchery. This Kirk is no namby-pamby Picard-ized version of the original Kirk. This may sound odd coming from such a firm heterosexual man, but this Kirk is downright sexy. The dialog is snappy and with a few exceptions, delivered in believable ways. All Hollywood movies suffer from a fatal case of scientific illiteracy, and this movie has it's eye-rolling moments when the actors try to discuss physics or math, but it is obvious to me that expecting even moderate levels of scientific awareness is simply expecting too much out of Hollywood. So those moments were quickly forgotten. And if you like action, you should love this movie. The action is non-stop, and many of the action scenes are obvious deliberate nods to famous action scenes in other movies, again demonstrating the director's edgy but successful effort to merge the actions on the screen with the viewers own cinematic expectations. This is a delicate line to walk, and I thought it was navigated nearly perfectly. In that sense the movie is a surprisingly LITERATE experience. The writers and director clearly appreciated the audience and provided different levels of experience for the viewers. Finally, without giving the movie away too much, this movie has attempted one of the boldest and riskiest means of reconciling an appreciation of its own history with a need to revitalize the franchise that I've ever seen. No doubt this is what many people will love to hate or hate to love. But I thought it was bold, decisive, daring and even insouciant, so I loved to love it. Such a risk pulled off so well should be rewarded. This movie ended in a way that provides not only a new beginning for more Star Trek movies, but will no doubt spawn dozens of new Star Trek novels as well. And it will be forever debated by the faithful as either a brilliant stroke of genius, or the worst sort of hackneyed butchery since Bobby Ewing ambled out of the shower on Dallas. I give this movie five blobs of red matter out of five. I am greatly impressed by the risks the producer, writer, director, actors and studio took with this movie. They deserve great rewards for their boldness. I am looking forward to more Star Trek movies in the future.

Comments (7)

Boyd
And it will be forever debated by the faithful as either a brilliant stroke of genius, or the worst sort of hackneyed butchery since Bobby Ewing ambled out of the shower on Dallas. I think you missed it on this one. While there will undoubtedly be a few who take the latter position, they're going to be drowned out and ignored by folks heaping praise on this movie for years to come. That being said, the first thing I noticed when I watched the movie was the audience. I went to the first showing on Friday at a small, underutilized cinema. I walked in about 15 minutes before show time, and the highly favored back third of the seats was fairly filled by geeks discussing 1s and 0s and reading stuff on their iPhones. They all spread out, including the groups who were their together, leaving an empty seat between them all. I had a chuckle at what looked to me like a stereotypical Trek audience. There were also a few...umm...socially challenged attendees who stood out like sore thumbs once they were out in the brighter lights.
CosmicConservative
I like that word. It's a great word.
Cullen
J-Mom and I went and saw it Friday night and were both floored. I think she liked it even more than me. I was very fond of Simon Pegg as Scotty. Probably my favorite casting.
Dean Esmay
The character of James T. Kirk was originally (according to Roddenberry and contemporary sources) modeled quite directly after Horatio Hornblower. Just FYI.
CosmicConservative
From Wikipedia on Horatio Hornblower: "Described as "unhappy and lonely", Hornblower's chief characteristics are not so much his courage and skilled seamanship as his intense reserve, introspection and self-doubt. Despite numerous personal feats of extraordinary skill and cunning, he belittles his achievements by numerous rationalizations, remembering only his fears. He consistently ignores or is unaware of the admiration with which he is held by his fellow sailors. He regards himself as cowardly, dishonest, and, at times, disloyal—never crediting his ability to persevere, think rapidly, organize, or cut to the nub of a matter. His sense of duty, hard work, and drive to succeed make these imagined negative characteristics undetectable by everyone but him, and being introspective, he obsesses over petty failures to reinforce his poor self image. " If Roddenberry was attempting to channel Horatio Hornblower, he got it badly wrong. I would have to do more research to be sure Dean, and I most likely won't, but my guess is that Roddenberry modeled the whole Enterprise mission on the Hornblower "mission" in Central America, but his Kirk is, in my estimation, a vastly different character than Horatio Hornblower in virtually every detail.
reggie
Margot and I viewed the Star Trek movie yesterday. We loved it. We are both big fans of the Star Trek franchise. I think that this is going to be big. Can't wait for the next one, or to add this one to the DVD collection.