Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Reviews

Movie Review - The Great Debaters

By Dadman
When I told my 12 year old son that I want him to compete for his high school debate team (rumored to be one of the best debate teams in the country) he looked at me like I had just endorsed Britney Spears for President. Luckily, he is only in the 7th grade so there is ample time for me to wear him down. My interest in debate and the fact that this film was shot in and around the Shreveport/Bossier area of Louisiana put The Great Debaters high on my must-see movie list. I really didn't know much beyond that as the lights dimmed and the movie began to roll. It turns out The Great Debaters is based on a true story (like so many Hollywood productions are) about Melvin B. Tolson, a professor at all-black Wiley College in Marshall, Texas who in 1935 inspired students to form the school's first debate team, which went on to challenge Harvard in the national championship (in truth it was USC, but some creative license was taken by the writers). I won't tell you if they win or lose, but will say the film's denouement is very moving and inspirational. Denzel Washington, one of Hollywood's shining stars, both directs and acts in this film, playing the role of Professor Tolson. He does both with great aplomb and competence in the tradition of Clint Eastwood in both Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby. Members of the Wiley debate team are played solidly by largely unknown actors led by Nate Paker as Henry Lowe who delivers and Oscar worthy performance. Another noteworthy performance is delivered by the consistently effective Forest Whitaker who plays the part of Dr. James Farmer, Sr., father of Wiley's youngest debate team member. There is clearly an agenda attached to this film (a film produced by Oprah Winfrey, by the way), but it is an agenda I can support. Black people are the stars of this film, as they should be. They are universally portrayed as intellligent, hard-working, articulate, principled, good people. In a world filled with so many negative stereotypes of African-Americans, past and present (some propagated by black people themselves), it's heartening to see such uplifting, positive African-American characters. Oprah's fingerprints are all over this aspect of the film. That's the part of the agenda I can support. Regrettably, virtually every white person in this film is portrayed as a hate-filled, dim-witted, bloodthirsty, racist. Given that Washington and Winfrey are both good liberals, I doubt they see the irony in challenging vile stereotypes of black Americans by perpetuating equally vile stereotypes of southern white people. This polarized view of white vs. black characters is the film's greatest weakness and it's so blatant I have to think it was done intentionally. But, I'm inclined to forgive them in this case. The Jim Crow south has a lot to be ashamed of and the film makes some powerful statements. I very much liked the protagonists in this film and found myself actively rooting for their success. There is little debate The Great Debaters is a good, thought provoking film worth the price of admission. Go check it out...

Movie Review - I Am Legend

By Dadman
I saw this film with my family (wife, one son, one daughter) on opening day a week ago. My expectations were soaring. The premise of the film - a post-apocalyptic world inhabited by mysterious, dark-seeking creatures and protagonist humans struggling to survive - is like celluloid crack to me. I've loved the post-apocalyptic genre since the day I saw The Planet of the Apes. Probably before, I just don't remember. I became an all-things-Planet-of-the-Apes junkie. Roddy McDowell was my favorite actor. I had a crush on the ape-version of Kim Hunter. Now, I own all the Planet of the Apes movies on DVD. As I said, as a genre enthusiast, I had high hopes for I Am Legend. In this story, based on the classic novel by Richard Matheson, the world's population has been decimated by a designer virus created for the purpose of curing cancer. And cure cancer it did. Unfortunately, it also transformed those infected with it into raging, hyped-up, extremely athletic monsters seemingly incapable of higher-order thinking and sensitive to light (darkseekers is what they are called in the film). The good news, I suppose, is they are cancer-free monsters. Humans immune to the virus were eventually hunted down by the darkseekers and, well, consumed. Except for Robert Neville played well by Will Smith. He seems to be the last man on earth. And, fortuitously, in addition to being immune to the virus and successfully eluding the darkseekers voracious appetites, he is also one of the scientists that was involved in the creation of the virus that destroyed civilization. As you might imagine he is racked with guilt and spends a good bit of time in his basement laboratory trying to conjure up a cure. With much regret, I have to say I was disappointed in I Am Legend. The film is like an exquisite cake made of the best ingredients money can buy - star power, fine acting, high production values, an intriguing premise, excellent cinematography, etc. - but unfortunately it was served up half-baked. While there are some excellent, intense scares in the film, there are just not enough of them. Neville's first on-screen encounter with the creatures is very well done, perhaps the best sequence in the film, but very little follows that matches it, and what does follow is unconvincing. The peril of living in a world of insane, meat-eating darkseekers that seem to be getting smarter is underdeveloped. Too much suspense, horror and intensity were simply left on the table by director Francis Lawrence (Constantine, 2005). I would ultimately rather see a good 'zombie' flick like 28 Days Later based on the same source novel that does not shy away from being truly intense and scary. A huge reason I left the theater unconvinced is due to the fact they animated, and rather poorly I might add, all the darkseekers rather than use live actors. It was a flat-out stupid creative decision. They looked like cartoons. They moved like cartoons. They flung themselves about like Chinese gymnasts, or Spiderman (the cartoon). Hollywood's unhealthy obsession with CGI has got to stop. It ruined I Am Legend for me and I bet there are a lot of other movie fanboys out there that feel the same way. Dr. Neville does encounter another survivor and her son during the course of the film. She's a fine looking Brazlian woman who reminds me of a Brazilian gal I dated in college that was a tonsil-hockey pro. And she wasn't a cartoon...

Movie Review - The Mist

By Dadman
There is something in the mist, but it really doesn't matter because this film is more about the people trapped by the mysterious mist in a small town grocery store. The Mist is pure social commentary masquerading as a half-way decent horror flick. When I learned Frank Darabont, director of The Shawshank Redemption and The Green Mile, was adapting Stephen King's story and directing this film, I knew I had to see it. Shawshank is one of my favorite films. A near perfect picture that never ceases to move me with its profound message of hope and redemption. The Mist is not nearly as hopeful. In fact, it's nihilistic. It's a social commentary that beats you about the head until you are left bloody and whimpering for mercy. I'm not a huge fan of nihilism and was put off by this aspect of the film. But the movie is interesting; you might say it's a thinking man's horror flick. The premise is bare-bones simple: a strange mist rolls into a small coastal village after a night of raging storms. It doesn't take long to discover that something malevolent is lurking in the mist and it's not averse to snacking on humans for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. A couple dozen villagers manage to barricade themselves into the local grocery store with the mist just on the other side of the glass doors. I knew going into this film that it was a social commentary of sorts so I spent a great deal of time playing spot-the-metaphor. That game soon deteriorated into a game of spot-the-stereotype. Darabont is anything but subtle in this film. The film's tagline - fear changes everything - essentially tells us The Mist is a comment on how fear changes us. This mist is fear - ambiguous, amorphous, menacing, mysterious and ubiquitous. Thus, the most compelling quality of this film is witnessing how the characters react to the menace and realizing that their reactions are a microcosm of the human condition. Hat tip to Darabont for making the effort. But, he's guilty of employing offensive stereotypes to make the point. Fear of the mist begins to drive some of the villagers to faith, and, of course, these otherwise reasonable people decide to adopt of brand of faith being advocated by an insane woman (Marcia Gay Harden) that quickly descends into bloodlust and human sacrifice. Of course, she's an insane Christian. This annoys me, but I do understand the point Darabont is making - fear of the unknown drives people to religion (some would argue fear led humans to invent religion) and all too often religion has been a catalyst for violence. In our present world, it is Muslims who are using faith to justify horrific acts of violence. So, why did the character in this film have to be a knife-wielding, wild-eyed Christian? Just wondering. The crazy religious woman provided some of the more dramatic moments in this film, but she did not upstage in any way the strange creatures that inhabit the mist. While the creature CGI may have been somewhat below my expectations, they proved to be sufficiently creepy and provided some excellent classic horror moments. The were squirm-inducing to say the least. In spite of its nihilistic theme, I was for the most part entertained by this movie. The script is intelligent, the acting is engaging, and the social commentary is legitimately thought provoking. Who would have thought blood-sucking spiders from another dimension could be part of a compelling lesson on human nature?

Movie Review - Beowulf

By Dadman
I've been hawking this film for some time now here on the blog. My wife and I went to see it today. There's no question that Beowulf is the most ambitious computer-generated film I've ever seen. I imagine it's the most ambitious ever produced. However, more than once I found myself asking the question: why did Zemeckis go to such great lengths to produce realistic 'cartoons' of real life actors like Anthony Hopkins, Angelina Jolie, John Malkovich, and Robin Wright Penn when the real thing might have been more convincing and less distracting? I say distracting because that is precisely what it was. Instead of being drawn into the story and action I found myself constantly assessing how well Zemeckis was able to pull off the illusion of reality. At times (as in the case of Jolie's jaw-dropping physique) he was stunningly successful. At other times, I felt like I was watching a Saturday morning cartoon. For example, the ambulatory movements of most of the characters, whether walking, running, or swimming always seemed a little off. These movement irregularities combined with incredibly realistic faces, textures, lighting, hair, etc. created a level of visual dissonance I could not get past. I found myself unable to accept the characters as anything more than computer generated imagery. And the eyes...the eyes of the characters seemed dead all too often. The eyes just creeped me out. On the other hand, at times 'reality' and the CGI in this film are virtually indistinguishable and in those moments I found myself feeling utter amazement at how far digital animation technology has come since the release of Toy Story just a little over 10 years ago. It's just a matter of time before we have Star Trek-like Holidecks to play with... Regrettably, there were also other aspects of this film I found distracting. There is more nudity and sexual innuendo in this film than many movie-goers will expect. I suspect if the film were not computer-generated it might have earned a 'R' rating. Now, I personally like a little bit of the unexpected in the movies I see, but the directorial decision to have Beowulf fight Grendel to the death - in the nude - is an odd one to say the least. As a result, a critical scene that should have been all about Beowulf proving his worth becomes more about hiding his naughty bits in coy and clever ways. There also seems to be a distinct, albeit subtle, anti-Christian aspect to the film that frankly surprised me. Hollywood just can't seem to resist taking cheap shots at Christians these days. All that aside, the scene in which Beowulf confronts Grendel's mother (Angelina Jolie) in her lair proved to be spellbinding and hugely effective. If Jolie in any way resembles her CGI character in real life Brad Pitt is one lucky dude. I think I may have uttered an audible 'wow' as she arose from the water and began her seduction of Beowulf. She is exquisitely rendered in this film and, in spite of all the film's flaws, may be worth the price of admission alone. Its digitial wizardry also makes Beowulf worth seeing, but unfortunately it is not a greatly entertaining film. It may have been a better film without the distractions I've mentioned, and I may have enjoyed it more had I spent more money and seen it in 3-D at the local IMAX. Hmmmm....Angelina Jolie, half naked, in 3-D on a giant IMAX screen. I may have to see this movie again. ;)

Lions for Lambs being panned by critics...

By Dadman
I'll admit it; I didn't expect this film to be received so poorly. Here's a sample of what some of the critics are saying:
Lions for Lambs simply isn't fresh or courageous enough to make an impact let alone a difference.
A lame exercise in proscenium dialectics.
Pure fence-sitting liberal agony is all that's on offer here, in a muddled and pompous film about America's war on terror.
But then there is this:
Not surprisingly, the Redford segment is the best. His character, who hopes to save America one slacker at a time, rings true; and his real-life conviction and his fears for democracy come through.
I still expect it to win the Best Picture Oscar. ;)

Movie Review: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix

By CosmicConservative
Watched it tonight with the Cosmic Wife and Cosmic Son. First I have to say that Order of the Phoenix was one of my least favorite of the Harry Potter books. Especially the ending which quite frankly was nearly incoherent. But most of the book seemed forced and contrived to me, especially the Ron / Hermione relationship. So I wasn't expecting this to be my favorite of the Harry Potter movies. A few thoughts: The cinematography was surprisingly poor in comparison to the previous two Harry Potter movies, which I thought were stunningly filmed. This one struck me as having poor quality control, bad lighting in several segments, and generally poor makeup, poor framing and poor editing. I was quite frankly pretty stunned by how poorly those basic movie crafting things were done. I also felt that the pacing of the movie was inconsistent. It sometimes seemed to lurch forward when it should have paused, and paused when it should have moved forward. The acting has improved a bit, I thought Daniel Radcliffe was better in this movie than in any previous movie. This is the first time that he showed any steel in his backbone. Ron was, again, good. I thought he had slacked off in the last movie, but this time he was back on form and pulled off the hulking/sulking teenager bit fairly well. I was not as thrilled with Hermione this time. She was alternately geeky and goofy instead of her previously steady, studious self. The standout acting in this movie though was by the actress who played Luna Lovegood. She was dead on. She displayed a serious level of stage presence, I found even her quiet, brooding moments to be pulling the eye toward her. In fact I would say that she made the character more compelling than the book's version. There was a sense of earnest wisdom in her that was well beyond the skills of most young actresses. The story was typical Harry Potter stuff. If you haven't read the books, please do. If you have then you know the story. Harry battles his own inner demons in this book, even more than he battles Voldemort. I know a lot of people are going to say that Professor Umbridge was great. The audience certainly seemed to enjoy her pink-clothed, small-statured, giggly sort of evil. And it got a chuckle out of me from time to time. But, as in the book, I simply could not buy that this sycophantic functionary could have outmaneuvered Dumbledore. She's just too vapid. And the acting was simply too melodramatic, I would have found her far more sinister if she had not flounced around with that silly grin on her face all the time. I know that was done purposefully, I just didn't like it. I wonder if the director didn't deliberately save up all the budget for the final climactic battle scene in the Ministry of Mysteries, or whatever that hall of glass globes was. Once we got there the CGI improved dramatically. I did feel, just as I did in the book, that it was not credible that the children could have battled the adult death-eaters even as effectively as they did. But once the Order of the Phoenix arrived, the CGI and the acting was quite good. That was by far the best part of the movie. Now I have to be fair and say that I judge a Harry Potter movie differently than most movies. Mostly that's because of the expectations I have that money is really no object, and so there is no monetary reason that the film makers would skimp on the fundamentals. So I am probably harsher than I would be in reviewing a movie like "Transformers" for instance (I plan on seeing this soon). But that's the price they pay for being such a successful franchise. I have the same approach to Spiderman, Pirates of the Caribbean, Shrek and other franchise blockbusters. I expect a lot when I go to see one of them. All in all though, I liked it. I particularly liked that they did not put a single Quidditch match in the movie. I really, really hate that game. Overall though, still a good movie to go see. I definitely recommend it, if just for the final battle alone.

Chicken Little review

By CosmicConservative
Disney and Pixar animation teamed up for some really excellent movies, including Toy Story and The Incredibles. (Toy Story II was not nearly as good). The Pixar/Disney combination was presumably a combination of the latest in technological animation (Pixar) and the grandest tradition of animated movies (Disney). Recently Disney and Pixar have parted ways and there has been great anticipation about the results. It will be a while before we see the results from Pixar (their next movie, "Cars" is still a Disney partnership). But Chicken Little is in theaters already. The first question most people probably have is "does the animation equal Pixar's animation? My answer is "no", but it is close. The animation in Chicken Little feels "flatter" than in Pixar. I can't put my finger on it, but I think it may be due to fewer "camera pans" in the movie which show off the 3-D computer capability. But this is being really picky, the animation "worked" just fine, I never felt like the movie was being hindered by animation limitations, and that's all that really matters. So for all intents and purposes I would say that Disney is a serious player in CG animation and will likely only improve. So with animation out of the way, we should focus on the story. I don't like doing spoilers in reviews so I won't reveal anything that isn't revealed in the trailers (or I'll try not to). The story line is pretty simple, and starts one year after an embarrassing incident where Chicken Little panicked the entire town because he was hit on the head with something under the village oak tree that he thought was part of the sky. The town, once calmed down, decided it was merely an acorn, which being the primary agricultural product of "Oakey Oaks" seemed reasonable enough that Chicken Little's own father doubted his son. Since Buck Cluck (Chicken Little's dad) was a single parent, this lack of faith in his son caused no end of trauma for Chicken Little. The first half of the movie revolves around Chicken Little's attempt to win back his father's respect, and to do that he decides to join the high school baseball team, a team that has been down on its luck since the days when Buck was the high school hero who led the team to the top of the high school heap. This part of the movie tries very hard to be engaging and endearing, with a generous helping of "revenge of the nerds" where Chicken Little's equally socially inept friends (Ugly Duckling, Runt of the Litter and Fish out of Water) provide him with the emotional support he lacks from his own father. Ugly Duckling, in particular, is the focus of emotional tension as she quotes from a series of pop psychology articles found in her stacks of too-cleverly named magazines. Chicken and his friends are frequently at odds with the more popular kids led by an athletic over-achiever named "Foxey-Loxey". In this story Foxey-Loxey is a girl, but she is still the star of the baseball team and the top dodgeball thrower. She and Chicken Little cross swords more than once. This part of the movie ends with Chicken Little and Buck rediscovering their relationship, but not quite resolving their deeper issues. The second half of the movie revolves around the fact that Chicken Little was not imagining things when he thought a piece of the sky had fallen. Without revealing too much, Chicken's headache was caused by a falling piece of spaceship disguised to look like the sky. Chicken and his friends are now called upon to save the world, but Chicken Little is still traumatized by the town's reaction to his first call for help, and this is where the dramatic tension of the movie tries to focus, with repeated confrontations between Chicken Little, townspeople and his own father, with the final climax combining alien invasion and father-son reconciliation. The second half of the movie is significantly more violent and frightening than the first. In the theater we were in I heard at least two small children crying. The images of tentacle-weilding aliens tramping through Oakey Oaks are pretty intense. However it does give the actions of Chicken and his pals more urgency. Unfortunately the story never really connects. There are moments, and my wife enjoyed it more than I did. Both of my kids seemed to enjoy it, but they are older (12 and 17). I would think that kids below about 9 might find the alien invasion scenes pretty scary. Of course everything works out in the end, but for 30 minutes or so even I was wondering about the intensity level. There are a few sub-plots to wrap up, mostly romantic twists between the lead characters. When comparing this to Toy Story or The Incredibles, the main difference to me is not the computer graphics, but the story telling. In both TS and TI I found myself caring about the characters. In CL I really didn't. The vocal renditions were okay but not nearly as strong as in the previous movies. The interactions of the characters were too, well, cartoonish. In Toy Story, when Buzz Lightyear leaps from the railing to try to fly out the window of the stairwell, the moment builds beautifully from his initial realization that he is a toy, the denial and determination and then the, quite literal, fall. And the music was perfect for the moment. In Chicken Little the story sort of hops along from one thing to the next. I don't really even recall the score much, and the emotional flow seems to rise and fall in a completely leisurely fashion. As I said, my wife and kids liked it, and I found it likeable too, but Chicken Little pales in comparison to previous Pixar/Disney efforts. For that matter it also pales in comparison to other Disney efforts such as Aladdin or The Little Mermaid, which were traditionally animated.

Movie Review: The Were-Rabbit

By CosmicConservative
Just got back from watching the Wallace and Gromit movie, "Curse of the Were-Rabbit." It was worth watching, my daughter liked it a lot. There were some adult humor bits for the parents but it was mostly a movie for the kids. Perhaps the thing that stood out the most for me was the thumb prints in the claymation figures. I guess I've really been spoiled by modern computer animation. But the interesting thing is that, and other low-tech glimpses, really added to the charm of the movie. The story was predictable, but that's really what you want for kids. Wallace and Gromit demonstrate their devotion to each other, Wallace falls for the girl, and the last 20 minutes are actually quite a ride, with some clever nods to old movies that are probably over the heads of most kids, and quite a few parents, I guess. The voice talent was excellent. The sound editing was also excellent. Overall the movie felt well crafted and well paced. I recommend it as a good family outing. The movie also had a short starring the penguins from "Madagascar". I wasn't impressed, it seemed sort of thrown together, although the animation quality was excellent and it had its moments. If you get there a bit late and miss the short, you haven't missed that much.