When I told my 12 year old son that I want him to compete for his high school debate team (rumored to be one of the best debate teams in the country) he looked at me like I had just endorsed Britney Spears for President. Luckily, he is only in the 7th grade so there is ample time for me to wear him down.
My interest in debate and the fact that this film was shot in and around the Shreveport/Bossier area of Louisiana put The Great Debaters high on my must-see movie list. I really didn't know much beyond that as the lights dimmed and the movie began to roll.
It turns out The Great Debaters is based on a true story (like so many Hollywood productions are) about Melvin B. Tolson, a professor at all-black Wiley College in Marshall, Texas who in 1935 inspired students to form the school's first debate team, which went on to challenge Harvard in the national championship (in truth it was USC, but some creative license was taken by the writers).
I won't tell you if they win or lose, but will say the film's denouement is very moving and inspirational.
Denzel Washington, one of Hollywood's shining stars, both directs and acts in this film, playing the role of Professor Tolson. He does both with great aplomb and competence in the tradition of Clint Eastwood in both Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby. Members of the Wiley debate team are played solidly by largely unknown actors led by Nate Paker as Henry Lowe who delivers and Oscar worthy performance. Another noteworthy performance is delivered by the consistently effective Forest Whitaker who plays the part of Dr. James Farmer, Sr., father of Wiley's youngest debate team member.
There is clearly an agenda attached to this film (a film produced by Oprah Winfrey, by the way), but it is an agenda I can support. Black people are the stars of this film, as they should be. They are universally portrayed as intellligent, hard-working, articulate, principled, good people. In a world filled with so many negative stereotypes of African-Americans, past and present (some propagated by black people themselves), it's heartening to see such uplifting, positive African-American characters. Oprah's fingerprints are all over this aspect of the film. That's the part of the agenda I can support.
Regrettably, virtually every white person in this film is portrayed as a hate-filled, dim-witted, bloodthirsty, racist. Given that Washington and Winfrey are both good liberals, I doubt they see the irony in challenging vile stereotypes of black Americans by perpetuating equally vile stereotypes of southern white people. This polarized view of white vs. black characters is the film's greatest weakness and it's so blatant I have to think it was done intentionally.
But, I'm inclined to forgive them in this case. The Jim Crow south has a lot to be ashamed of and the film makes some powerful statements. I very much liked the protagonists in this film and found myself actively rooting for their success.
There is little debate The Great Debaters is a good, thought provoking film worth the price of admission. Go check it out...
Movie Review - The Great Debaters
By Dadman
When I told my 12 year old son that I want him to compete for his high school debate team (rumored to be one of the best debate teams in the country) he looked at me like I had just endorsed Britney Spears for President. Luckily, he is only in the 7th grade so there is ample time for me to wear him down.
My interest in debate and the fact that this film was shot in and around the Shreveport/Bossier area of Louisiana put The Great Debaters high on my must-see movie list. I really didn't know much beyond that as the lights dimmed and the movie began to roll.
It turns out The Great Debaters is based on a true story (like so many Hollywood productions are) about Melvin B. Tolson, a professor at all-black Wiley College in Marshall, Texas who in 1935 inspired students to form the school's first debate team, which went on to challenge Harvard in the national championship (in truth it was USC, but some creative license was taken by the writers).
I won't tell you if they win or lose, but will say the film's denouement is very moving and inspirational.
Denzel Washington, one of Hollywood's shining stars, both directs and acts in this film, playing the role of Professor Tolson. He does both with great aplomb and competence in the tradition of Clint Eastwood in both Unforgiven and Million Dollar Baby. Members of the Wiley debate team are played solidly by largely unknown actors led by Nate Paker as Henry Lowe who delivers and Oscar worthy performance. Another noteworthy performance is delivered by the consistently effective Forest Whitaker who plays the part of Dr. James Farmer, Sr., father of Wiley's youngest debate team member.
There is clearly an agenda attached to this film (a film produced by Oprah Winfrey, by the way), but it is an agenda I can support. Black people are the stars of this film, as they should be. They are universally portrayed as intellligent, hard-working, articulate, principled, good people. In a world filled with so many negative stereotypes of African-Americans, past and present (some propagated by black people themselves), it's heartening to see such uplifting, positive African-American characters. Oprah's fingerprints are all over this aspect of the film. That's the part of the agenda I can support.
Regrettably, virtually every white person in this film is portrayed as a hate-filled, dim-witted, bloodthirsty, racist. Given that Washington and Winfrey are both good liberals, I doubt they see the irony in challenging vile stereotypes of black Americans by perpetuating equally vile stereotypes of southern white people. This polarized view of white vs. black characters is the film's greatest weakness and it's so blatant I have to think it was done intentionally.
But, I'm inclined to forgive them in this case. The Jim Crow south has a lot to be ashamed of and the film makes some powerful statements. I very much liked the protagonists in this film and found myself actively rooting for their success.
There is little debate The Great Debaters is a good, thought provoking film worth the price of admission. Go check it out...
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.