Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review - I Am Legend

By Dadman
I saw this film with my family (wife, one son, one daughter) on opening day a week ago. My expectations were soaring. The premise of the film - a post-apocalyptic world inhabited by mysterious, dark-seeking creatures and protagonist humans struggling to survive - is like celluloid crack to me. I've loved the post-apocalyptic genre since the day I saw The Planet of the Apes. Probably before, I just don't remember. I became an all-things-Planet-of-the-Apes junkie. Roddy McDowell was my favorite actor. I had a crush on the ape-version of Kim Hunter. Now, I own all the Planet of the Apes movies on DVD. As I said, as a genre enthusiast, I had high hopes for I Am Legend. In this story, based on the classic novel by Richard Matheson, the world's population has been decimated by a designer virus created for the purpose of curing cancer. And cure cancer it did. Unfortunately, it also transformed those infected with it into raging, hyped-up, extremely athletic monsters seemingly incapable of higher-order thinking and sensitive to light (darkseekers is what they are called in the film). The good news, I suppose, is they are cancer-free monsters. Humans immune to the virus were eventually hunted down by the darkseekers and, well, consumed. Except for Robert Neville played well by Will Smith. He seems to be the last man on earth. And, fortuitously, in addition to being immune to the virus and successfully eluding the darkseekers voracious appetites, he is also one of the scientists that was involved in the creation of the virus that destroyed civilization. As you might imagine he is racked with guilt and spends a good bit of time in his basement laboratory trying to conjure up a cure. With much regret, I have to say I was disappointed in I Am Legend. The film is like an exquisite cake made of the best ingredients money can buy - star power, fine acting, high production values, an intriguing premise, excellent cinematography, etc. - but unfortunately it was served up half-baked. While there are some excellent, intense scares in the film, there are just not enough of them. Neville's first on-screen encounter with the creatures is very well done, perhaps the best sequence in the film, but very little follows that matches it, and what does follow is unconvincing. The peril of living in a world of insane, meat-eating darkseekers that seem to be getting smarter is underdeveloped. Too much suspense, horror and intensity were simply left on the table by director Francis Lawrence (Constantine, 2005). I would ultimately rather see a good 'zombie' flick like 28 Days Later based on the same source novel that does not shy away from being truly intense and scary. A huge reason I left the theater unconvinced is due to the fact they animated, and rather poorly I might add, all the darkseekers rather than use live actors. It was a flat-out stupid creative decision. They looked like cartoons. They moved like cartoons. They flung themselves about like Chinese gymnasts, or Spiderman (the cartoon). Hollywood's unhealthy obsession with CGI has got to stop. It ruined I Am Legend for me and I bet there are a lot of other movie fanboys out there that feel the same way. Dr. Neville does encounter another survivor and her son during the course of the film. She's a fine looking Brazlian woman who reminds me of a Brazilian gal I dated in college that was a tonsil-hockey pro. And she wasn't a cartoon...

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
I don't know if I will see this movie. It has gotten lukewarm reviews and I don't typically care for horror movies. And I am sorry to say that having had my (perfectly healthy) tonsils removed at age 11, I have never been able to play tonsil-hockey.
Andy
Dadman: You are the movie guy, so I ask you...Has Will Smith ever made a good movie? Not being a part of the movie-going public I am truly ignorant. But it seems like every time I hear about Will Smith, the report involves a "dud" of a film.
Dadman
I think it's fair to say that Will Smith has made several good movies and several blockbusters (high money makers) which are frequently NOT the same thing. Blockbusters that Will Smith has starred in include: Independence Day, Men in Black (1 and 2), and I, Robot. All of these films made a significant amount of moola at the boxoffice and established Will as an 'A-list' actor. I think I Am Legend is well on the way to blockbuster status, in spite of its faults. Will has also made several smaller films that were well received critically and, in some cases, were a hit with audiences. These films also established Will as a serious actor: Six Degrees of Separation, The Legend of Bagger Vance, Hitch, The Pursuit of Happyness, and Ali. Mr. Smith was nominated for Best Actor for his performances in both Ali and Pursuit. I actually like Will Smith a lot. He oozes talent and is quite effective in both dramatic and comedic roles. He also has a incredible work ethic from what I hear. He was quite good in I Am Legend acting against cartoon monsters.
Andy
Dadman: Cool...not being a movie fan, I guess I only hear what the press puts out about movies. I should assume that the media loves to trash good talent...so thanks for the info. I don't know much about the guy, but when I see him on television he always seems like a decent, genuine, hard-working dude...glad to know that he has made some good ones.
CosmicConservative
I like Will Smith. I've seen him in several movies and I've always found him to be likable and talented. He's been in some really good movies (like Ali, for which he won an Academy Award, I think) and in some pure fun movies like "Independence Day" and I loved him in that role.
Brian
I liked Legend a great deal - but I agree with you about the CGI critters. Not because they acted like Spiderman. Critters that hyper are going to need a great deal of protein. They've already hunted down most of the ready food (us!) so they should be thinning out. According to Steve Barnes, Will Smith and his agent sat down a few years ago and decided to concentrate on SF films. This is probably a smart career move - he gets a lot of face time on the screen, earns him a great deal of cash. He can use this as leverage to do 'serious' films like 'Happyness' and 'Ali'.