I've been hawking this film for some time now here on the blog. My wife and I went to see it today.
There's no question that Beowulf is the most ambitious computer-generated film I've ever seen. I imagine it's the most ambitious ever produced. However, more than once I found myself asking the question: why did Zemeckis go to such great lengths to produce realistic 'cartoons' of real life actors like Anthony Hopkins, Angelina Jolie, John Malkovich, and Robin Wright Penn when the real thing might have been more convincing and less distracting?
I say distracting because that is precisely what it was. Instead of being drawn into the story and action I found myself constantly assessing how well Zemeckis was able to pull off the illusion of reality. At times (as in the case of Jolie's jaw-dropping physique) he was stunningly successful. At other times, I felt like I was watching a Saturday morning cartoon. For example, the ambulatory movements of most of the characters, whether walking, running, or swimming always seemed a little off. These movement irregularities combined with incredibly realistic faces, textures, lighting, hair, etc. created a level of visual dissonance I could not get past. I found myself unable to accept the characters as anything more than computer generated imagery.
And the eyes...the eyes of the characters seemed dead all too often. The eyes just creeped me out.
On the other hand, at times 'reality' and the CGI in this film are virtually indistinguishable and in those moments I found myself feeling utter amazement at how far digital animation technology has come since the release of Toy Story just a little over 10 years ago. It's just a matter of time before we have Star Trek-like Holidecks to play with...
Regrettably, there were also other aspects of this film I found distracting. There is more nudity and sexual innuendo in this film than many movie-goers will expect. I suspect if the film were not computer-generated it might have earned a 'R' rating. Now, I personally like a little bit of the unexpected in the movies I see, but the directorial decision to have Beowulf fight Grendel to the death - in the nude - is an odd one to say the least. As a result, a critical scene that should have been all about Beowulf proving his worth becomes more about hiding his naughty bits in coy and clever ways. There also seems to be a distinct, albeit subtle, anti-Christian aspect to the film that frankly surprised me. Hollywood just can't seem to resist taking cheap shots at Christians these days.
All that aside, the scene in which Beowulf confronts Grendel's mother (Angelina Jolie) in her lair proved to be spellbinding and hugely effective. If Jolie in any way resembles her CGI character in real life Brad Pitt is one lucky dude. I think I may have uttered an audible 'wow' as she arose from the water and began her seduction of Beowulf. She is exquisitely rendered in this film and, in spite of all the film's flaws, may be worth the price of admission alone.
Its digitial wizardry also makes Beowulf worth seeing, but unfortunately it is not a greatly entertaining film. It may have been a better film without the distractions I've mentioned, and I may have enjoyed it more had I spent more money and seen it in 3-D at the local IMAX.
Hmmmm....Angelina Jolie, half naked, in 3-D on a giant IMAX screen. I may have to see this movie again. ;)
Movie Review - Beowulf
By Dadman
I've been hawking this film for some time now here on the blog. My wife and I went to see it today.
There's no question that Beowulf is the most ambitious computer-generated film I've ever seen. I imagine it's the most ambitious ever produced. However, more than once I found myself asking the question: why did Zemeckis go to such great lengths to produce realistic 'cartoons' of real life actors like Anthony Hopkins, Angelina Jolie, John Malkovich, and Robin Wright Penn when the real thing might have been more convincing and less distracting?
I say distracting because that is precisely what it was. Instead of being drawn into the story and action I found myself constantly assessing how well Zemeckis was able to pull off the illusion of reality. At times (as in the case of Jolie's jaw-dropping physique) he was stunningly successful. At other times, I felt like I was watching a Saturday morning cartoon. For example, the ambulatory movements of most of the characters, whether walking, running, or swimming always seemed a little off. These movement irregularities combined with incredibly realistic faces, textures, lighting, hair, etc. created a level of visual dissonance I could not get past. I found myself unable to accept the characters as anything more than computer generated imagery.
And the eyes...the eyes of the characters seemed dead all too often. The eyes just creeped me out.
On the other hand, at times 'reality' and the CGI in this film are virtually indistinguishable and in those moments I found myself feeling utter amazement at how far digital animation technology has come since the release of Toy Story just a little over 10 years ago. It's just a matter of time before we have Star Trek-like Holidecks to play with...
Regrettably, there were also other aspects of this film I found distracting. There is more nudity and sexual innuendo in this film than many movie-goers will expect. I suspect if the film were not computer-generated it might have earned a 'R' rating. Now, I personally like a little bit of the unexpected in the movies I see, but the directorial decision to have Beowulf fight Grendel to the death - in the nude - is an odd one to say the least. As a result, a critical scene that should have been all about Beowulf proving his worth becomes more about hiding his naughty bits in coy and clever ways. There also seems to be a distinct, albeit subtle, anti-Christian aspect to the film that frankly surprised me. Hollywood just can't seem to resist taking cheap shots at Christians these days.
All that aside, the scene in which Beowulf confronts Grendel's mother (Angelina Jolie) in her lair proved to be spellbinding and hugely effective. If Jolie in any way resembles her CGI character in real life Brad Pitt is one lucky dude. I think I may have uttered an audible 'wow' as she arose from the water and began her seduction of Beowulf. She is exquisitely rendered in this film and, in spite of all the film's flaws, may be worth the price of admission alone.
Its digitial wizardry also makes Beowulf worth seeing, but unfortunately it is not a greatly entertaining film. It may have been a better film without the distractions I've mentioned, and I may have enjoyed it more had I spent more money and seen it in 3-D at the local IMAX.
Hmmmm....Angelina Jolie, half naked, in 3-D on a giant IMAX screen. I may have to see this movie again. ;)
Comments (11)