Heh... According to reports from Dove Valley, the ongoing soap opera of the relationship between Denver Broncos new head coach Josh McDaniels and Denver Broncos "All Pro" quarterback, Jay Cutler, continues to degenerate. The "official" word from Dove Valley is that Jay and the Broncos brain trust held a long-anticipated conference call yesterday and the parties resolved their differences. However, "unofficial" reports from people who were supposedly on the call directly contradict that version of events and instead say that Cutler is more angry than ever because the Broncos refused to promise him that he would not be traded, leaving the door open to a trade at least before draft day. According to THAT version of events, Cutler asked to be traded as soon as possible.
Regular readers of this blog know that I have been unconvinced of Jay Cutler's brilliance since he was drafted. What I HAVE been convinced of since Cutler was drafted is that he has been pampered and hyped more than any similar quarterback I can think of, and has performed well below the top level "young quarterbacks" that he is frequently considered to be the "best of". In particular his performance has been well below that of Phil Rivers, Ben Roethlesberger, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub and others. Which is not to even compare him to perennial QB superstars like Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees or (cough) Eli Manning.
In fact if you look at statistics over the past three years Cutler has been mediocre at best. Other than yards per game, he is decidedly in the middle of the pack for yards per attempt, % complete, touchdowns per attempt etc. In fact the only starting QB in the past three years who has thrown more interceptions than Jay Cutler has been Brett Favre. Which I find very interesting because while many (if not most) of the sports pundits like to compare Cutler to ex-Broncos Hall of Fame QB John Elway, I find his statistics and style are much more comparable to Brett Favre, particularly his tendency to throw the ball up for grabs and give up game-breaking interceptions.
It is probably fair to say that if Cutler is traded, I won't miss him. Denver's revolving door at quarterback the last twelve years has been entertaining in some ways, but frankly you could compare all of those quarterbacks (Brian Griese, Gus Frerotte, Bubby Brister and Jake Plummer) and not see a huge difference in either their performance or the performance of the team with them at the helm. (Well, Jake Plummer did have one good year when the Broncos went 13-3 and lost in the AFC title game to eventual Super Bowl champions the Pittsburgh Steelers, led by a rookie QB named Ben Roethlesberger).
Anyway, I have always considered Cutler to be something of a pampered, hyped up, petulant under-achiever. It's sort of interesting to see that more and more of the NFL and the Denver Broncos fan base is starting to see him the same way I do. My only advice to Jay Cutler right now is to start acting like an adult, quit whining about how his ego has been punctured and get back on the field and prove (for once) that he's remotely as good as the hype which has surrounded him for years.
Lots of news out of Dove Valley this week. For those who don't know, "Dove Valley" is the practice field and general operations center for the Denver Broncos. It's a facility located in the suburbs of the Denver Metro area distinguished by a large white dome enclosing the Broncos regular daily practice field. I used to drive past it every day to get to work.
There are two substantive stories and one "human interest" story from the Broncos. The first story is perhaps the most impactful and that is the arrest in Florida yesterday of Broncos standout wide receiver Brandon Marshall. The arrest was for a fairly minor disturbing the peace incident involving a fight in a bar in the early morning hours of Sunday morning, but the impact is potentially hugely important to the Denver Broncos for a couple of reasons. Marshall had already been arrested three times in the past two years, and his last arrest in 2008 led to a one game suspension (which was reduced through extensive lobbying from Mike Shanahan and Pat Bowlen from the original three games that the NFL handed down). It is unlikely that any amount of lobbying can reduce the upcoming suspension which could be for as much as a full season, but is likely to be eight games. That's effectively taking the Broncos best player off the field for at least half of the 2009 season, if not the whole season. Also, if I understand the new rules put in play last year, this arrest actually opens up the Broncos for a signifant fine by the NFL. All of this is happening as Marshall's agent is trying to negotiate a sweetheart long term new contract.
The other substantive story is about Denver's hyper-active free-agent work this weekend. They brought in several specific-purpose players, seemingly following the New England Patriots model of situational drafting. In general I think they did an excellent job of plugging some holes which Mike Shanahan had inexplicably ignored for years. I think the draft work will significantly upgrade the team.
The "human interest" story is all about Jay Cutler, whose panties are all in a wad because rumors surfaced over the weekend that the Broncos had discussed a possible three-way trade which would move Jay Cutler to Tampa Bay and bring Patriots "backup" quarterback Matt Cassel to Denver. The Broncos front office insists that any talks that MAY have happened would have been instigated by Tampa Bay and that they had no serious plans to trade Jay Cutler, but regardless Jay Cutler actually demanded to be traded over the weekend his feelings were so hurt by this possible trade.
Now, any time there is a story about Jay Cutler that treats the QB as an elite QB, whether it is a sports reporter, an NFL official, a Broncos team member or even Jay Cutler himself, I have to go and look at Cutlers statistics to see just how much Cutler deserves this sort of treatment.
So, when I look at the "official" ESPN quarterback ratings for the just finished 2008 season I see Jay Cutler dead in the middle of the pack, rated 16th of the 32 starting quarterbacks in the league. His overall QB rating is a pedestrian 86.0 which is actually a slight improvement over previous years. His win-loss ratio is was 8 -8, meaning he STILL has not presided over a winning season after three years as starter. He did throw for 4,500 yards, which is certainly something to be proud of, but overall his performance continues to put him squarely in the middle of the pack of NFL quarterbacks, significantly below such names as Kurt Warner, Chad Pennington, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub, Ben Roethlesberger, and, NFL QB leader, Phillip Rivers.
I know that Jay had a cozy relationship with Mike Shanahan, and Shanahan pretty much bet (and lost) his job on Jay Cutler emerging as an "elite" quarterback, but Josh McDaniels has no such investment in the over-hyped and under-performing Cutler. I would not be surprised at all if the new regime in Denver is looking much more at Cutler's ACTUAL performance than his much-heralded, yet never achieved "tremendous potential." If Cutler's going to start whining and crying like a prima donna, I would think the new regime here would find it very easy to justify trading him to some other team enamored of his "potential."
It is true that Cutler went to the pro bowl last year, but it is hard to believe he will be back in the pro bowl if he continues to preside over a team with a .500 record while prancing around like some sort of team savior.
Hey Jay, let me clue you in on something. You AREN'T the savior of the team if the TEAM IS NOT WINNING. I don't give a fig how many yards you throw for, if you can't lead this team into the playoffs AT LEAST, then you don't get to act like an elite QB.
See, elite QBs do one thing more than any other. They. Win. Games.
So yesterday I had two significant Qwest events in my life.
First, our internet service went down. Apparantly the 80286 PC they have in a box on the side of highway 285 which provides network connectivity for our rural mountain neighborhood had a floppy drive controller error or something, or maybe the 300 baud modem card installed in the box was shorted out by the high winds howling down the canyon. Apparently they had to search the local PC "U-pull-it" shops to find replacement parts because our internet was down all afternoon and evening. This is not unusual for Qwest, as readers of this blog should know by now. My estimate is that they have to go through this routine every 3-4 months or so, and every time it happens our internet is down at least 8 hours and usually for a full day or so. As I point out to the technical support people I talk to in India, it doesn't reflect well on a "world-class communications company" that they can't keep an internet connection up, or repair it when it fails in less than a day on average, less than 50 miles from their friggin' corporate headquarters. Not that the technical support folks care, most have never heard of Denver Colorado.
The other Qwest news is that Joseph Nacchio's nineteen convictions on insider trading charges were reinstated by a federal appeals court, and since it is unlikely that the Supreme Court will hear Nacchio's appeal, it looks like the scumbag who pretty much wrecked my retirement plans and cost me over $100,000 in savings by wrecking qwest's stock prices is going to a well deserved rest in a federal prison. Yay. Not that it returns a penny of my losses, but at least I can cheer the fact that he'll be moving from his 100+room mansion into a 12x12 cell. Yay again.
On the positive side, without my internet access I did get a couple hours of practice on my guitar last night. Yay me.
Not much to add to this, it pretty much speaks for itself...
Students: Change Boulder High name to Barack Obama High : Updates : The Rocky Mountain News
A Boulder High student group is pushing to rename the school after a hot new historic figure: Barack Obama.
"We initiate this campaign in order to honor the momentous achievement of his election as an African-American, inspire the community with his ideals of unity and hope, and reflect the progressive spirit that is shared by both Barack Obama and our school environment," the Student Worker Club said in a press release today.
When Obama said on the campaign trail he supported domestic oil drilling, he must not have meant drilling where the oil ACTUALLY IS.
In its first action to overturn Bush administration policies on energy, the Obama administration on Wednesday said it will cancel oil drilling leases on more than 130,000 acres near two national parks and other protected areas in Utah.
To clarify this situation, Obama's administration supports oil drilling so long as it has zero impact on the evironment, or has zero reaction from cherished "green" voters.
Any decent, reasonable reporter would have asked Mr. Salazar (an ex-Colorado Senator, btw) exactly WHERE we can drill for oil if we can't drill in a literal desert populated by little other than imposing rock towers, cactus and scrawny coyotes. Obama and Salazar need to provide this country with a map of acceptable locations. Such a map would be very revealing, believe me.
I'm a big fan of Canyonlands and other national parks. But believe me, I've DRIVEN through these areas, and any oil drilling operation would be lost amid the MILLIONS of square miles of terrain that looks EXACTLY THE SAME as the "precious" land that would be drilled upon.
Seriously, if Obama opposes drilling in the least populated, least utilized, and most abundant terrain in the country, there is NOWHERE that would satisfy them. You would be hard pressed to find a location for drilling on this country that would have less environmental impact than drilling in the harsh, inaccessible, ABUNDANT rocky terrain of Utah. If you can't drill there, you can't drill ANYWHERE.
One wonders what the Obama team would do if instead of evil oil wells, the proposal was to cover tens of thousands of acres of THIS SAME LAND with solar cells and/or windmills. Either of which would have a vastly more significant impact on the land, its use and its ecology. I'm guessing they'd say "go for it."
OK, so I didn't do a status last week, I was just not up to it. Although the fact that Dallas collapsed in the fourth quarter to a Pittsburgh team they had owned the first three quarters didn't help...
Last week Denver looked awesome. Cutler threw three touchdowns and went over 300 yards. He looked great and the Denver O looked unstoppable. Dallas looked good for three quarters, but fell apart in the fourth quarter. The end result was both teams stood at 8 - 5, but Denver looked to be a playoff lock, and Dallas was on the outside looking in.
This week Denver (and Cutler) regressed again, losing 30 - 10 to a Carolina team that looked sharper than usual in their passing game. Denver looked bad on both sides of the football, Cutler threw one interception but had two other easy interceptions dropped by the defensive back. Even so all Denver could muster was 10 points, while their defensive secondary was shredded by Jake Delhomme. Denver's game strategy to commit 8 men against the run was ill-conceived at best. They made Jake beat them, and Jake was quite happy to exploit an overmatched Denver secondary.
Dallas looked great against the defending super bowl champs. I really thought they had no chance to win this game, but they won pretty convincingly, sacking Eli Manning 8 times while Tony Romo threw two touchdowns and had no interceptions. Even with some key players (like Marion Barber) still clearly not fully healed, Dallas ran the ball effectively and passed the ball well. If Dallas plays like they did yesterday for their remaining games, they can beat anyone.
As of now Romo is still in the top three QB rankings and Cutler is still outside of the top ten.
And you know what? I've not heard a lot on ESPN lately about how Jay Cutler is the "best young QB." And more and more grudgingly I am hearing Romo get credit for Dallas's wins. Yesterday Romo was sacked early and was clearly not himself the rest of the game, but even with limited mobility he made the plays he needed to when he needed to.
Maybe, just maybe Romo is starting to get some respect.
But as I have said for two years, I don't think he will get any real respect until he wins a few playoff games.
Denver still has the edge in playoff opportunity over Dallas. Denver only has to win one of their two remaining games to be in, while Dallas has to win both. And Dallas clearly has by far the more difficult teams to face. But if they can beat Baltimore, and Philly is out of the race by the last weekend, we might just see Dallas as the final NFC wild card.
At least both are still in the hunt in mid-December. That's better than a lot of the last decade.
Our local traffic copter person (named Amelia Earhart, if you can believe it) was giving a warning yesterday about today's freezing drizzle, but got tongue tied and it came out "frizzling dreezle" which was sort of funny...
But the drive in to work this morning wasn't funny. Frizzling dreezle indeed. The dreezle was frizzling on my car windshield as I drove, and you could see ice frizzling on the road.
I managed to get in to work OK, but maybe I should have stayed home today.
So, it's a bit past midway of the season. How are Tony Romo and Jay Cutler doing?
Both teams are 6-4. Denver is in first place in the woeful AFC West, Dallas is tied with Washington for second place behind the Super Bowl champion New York Giants in the always tough NFC East. At this point it would seem that Denver is in a much better place to reach the playoffs than the Dallas is, but that says more about their respective divisions than their actual teams.
Tony missed three games after breaking his pinkie finger in one game. He played yesterday with a splint on his pinkie and with a new throwing motion and ball-holding technique. Dallas is 5 - 2 with Romo, Denver is 6 - 4 with Cutler. Here's a breakdown of their stats:
In quarterback rating (supposedly the most important stat for quarterbacks, maybe aside from wins) Romo is currently in third place with a rating of 99. Cutler is in tenth place with a rating of 90. Because of the disparity in games the most comparable stats are averages over those games so that's what I'll focus on.
Romo's yards per attempt average is 8.31 yards, which is second in the league to Phillip Rivers. This is considered by many quarterback experts as one the best stats to truly measure how successful a quarterback is at moving the ball downfield. Cutler's 7.68 ypa is a respectable seventh place.
Romo throws a touchdown on 6.6% of his passes. That again puts him second behind Phillip Rivers. This is considered a great stat for determining how good a QB is at getting into the end zone as opposed to settling for field goals. Cutler's 5.1% is, again, a respectable 5th place.
Romo's completion percentage has taken a beating since he broke his pinkie (as has his interception count) but his 64.8% completion rate is still in the top ten (ninth) while Cutler's completion rate of 62.3 puts him right at the middle of the pack of NFL starters at #15.
Romo's 7 interceptions account for 3% of his passes. Cutler's 11 interceptions account for 3% if his as well, so on this stat, they are almost exactly even. I will note though that three of Tony's interceptions came with a broken pinkie finger.
So the result of analyzing these stats seems to indicate that Tony Romo continues to be a top three quarterback in the NFL, while Cutler is just barely a top ten contender. Which is pretty much exactly what my pre-season analysis of their career numbers showed.
In other words, both of them are performing in 2008 after ten games more or less exactly as their stats from the past three years would predict.
And yet I still see Cutler praised as the young QB of the future. He gets credit for Denver's 6-4 record leading the AFC West while Romo gets blame for his 6-4 record being a wild-card hopeful in the NFC East.
I don't suppose anything is going to change here, no matter what their stats end up being this year. It certainly hasn't mattered so far. The narrative has been defined and the stories have already been written. Cutler, the first round draft choice of the mastermind coach vs. Romo, the three year backup who nearly had to walk on to make the team...
In the meantime those stats just seem to keep on saying the same thing....
We'll see how things stand at the end of the year. From what I've seen so far, I expect they'll tell a very similar story.
So, taking out the Cosmic Pooch this morning, I felt that hard, cold bite of winter for the first time. My hands hurt by the time I got back in. Time to start putting on gloves...
Nothing like a 13 hour drive to rattle your brains...
But I'm home.
Had a great time in Phoenix, thanks to Dadman. The Cosmic Daughter had a good time too. Depending on the results I'll post on the reason for the trip sometime..
Man, I still feel like I'm in the car....