Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL wrap-up, week 15

By CosmicConservative
OK, so I didn't do a status last week, I was just not up to it. Although the fact that Dallas collapsed in the fourth quarter to a Pittsburgh team they had owned the first three quarters didn't help... Last week Denver looked awesome. Cutler threw three touchdowns and went over 300 yards. He looked great and the Denver O looked unstoppable. Dallas looked good for three quarters, but fell apart in the fourth quarter. The end result was both teams stood at 8 - 5, but Denver looked to be a playoff lock, and Dallas was on the outside looking in. This week Denver (and Cutler) regressed again, losing 30 - 10 to a Carolina team that looked sharper than usual in their passing game. Denver looked bad on both sides of the football, Cutler threw one interception but had two other easy interceptions dropped by the defensive back. Even so all Denver could muster was 10 points, while their defensive secondary was shredded by Jake Delhomme. Denver's game strategy to commit 8 men against the run was ill-conceived at best. They made Jake beat them, and Jake was quite happy to exploit an overmatched Denver secondary. Dallas looked great against the defending super bowl champs. I really thought they had no chance to win this game, but they won pretty convincingly, sacking Eli Manning 8 times while Tony Romo threw two touchdowns and had no interceptions. Even with some key players (like Marion Barber) still clearly not fully healed, Dallas ran the ball effectively and passed the ball well. If Dallas plays like they did yesterday for their remaining games, they can beat anyone. As of now Romo is still in the top three QB rankings and Cutler is still outside of the top ten. And you know what? I've not heard a lot on ESPN lately about how Jay Cutler is the "best young QB." And more and more grudgingly I am hearing Romo get credit for Dallas's wins. Yesterday Romo was sacked early and was clearly not himself the rest of the game, but even with limited mobility he made the plays he needed to when he needed to. Maybe, just maybe Romo is starting to get some respect. But as I have said for two years, I don't think he will get any real respect until he wins a few playoff games. Denver still has the edge in playoff opportunity over Dallas. Denver only has to win one of their two remaining games to be in, while Dallas has to win both. And Dallas clearly has by far the more difficult teams to face. But if they can beat Baltimore, and Philly is out of the race by the last weekend, we might just see Dallas as the final NFC wild card. At least both are still in the hunt in mid-December. That's better than a lot of the last decade.

Comments (10)

Andy
Yea Cosmic...this is getting fun finally. I almost never stay up past 9 pm, but I did last night to watch my 'Boys finally get a big win. When Romo got sacked in the end zone I thought, "Oh great...here we go again!" But the Boys sucked it up and played like champs. Romo made me proud to be a fan. He wasn't at his best...and really hasn't been all season...but the team seemed to rally around him. Poor Eli. I can honestly say that I've never felt sorry for a Manning until last night. King Eli hasn't been crowned like that since the Ole Miss days...the poor guy may as well have been out there by himself. Carolina has at least one thing going for them...one tough coonass at QB! It's a shame that a team with the Cowboy's talent is just hoping against hope to make the playoffs. But the "W"s & "L"s are what count.
CosmicConservative
Andy: A little over a decade ago a Cowboy's team had just lost a big game and was being written off by the national media, and I said to myself, "well... all they have to do is win every remaining game and they'll win the Super Bowl." And that's exactly what they did. So I'll say the same thing again. All Dallas has to do is win every single game they play until the end of the season. It's just that simple. And if they play like they did yesterday, it's not even that much of a stretch. I'd love to see Dallas do to New York what New York did to Dallas last year.... That would be fun. Especially on my big-screen High Definition TV.... One can always hope.
Andy
Well Cosmic, I remember some idiot saying "All the Rockies have to do is win 17 straight, and they'll win the pennant." (paraphrasing) It was something like that... You are right. If the 'Boys bring that game every week, well... I'll keep the faith.
Boyd
I have hope, but I'm not sure about faith. ...I don’t think he will get any real respect until he wins a few playoff games. Well, he's not going to get much respect from me until he's won at least one playoff game. While I don't engage in such silliness as blaming him for his trip to Mexico with his cute-but-empty-headed-honey on his off week, the bulk of the responsibility for the Cowboys' playoff losses lies on his head.
CosmicConservative
I do hold Tony Romo accountable for some of the responsibility of the Cowboy's last two years losses in the playoffs, but with a couple of caveats... Two years ago as I recall Terrell Owens dropped two certain touchdown passes that would have put the Cowboys well ahead of the Seahawks and would have made the last second field goal try unnecessary. I didn't hear too many people blaming T.O. for the loss. Also the Cowboys coaching staff had more than half a season to find a field goal holder replacement for their starting quarterback. There's a reason you don't see starting quarterbacks in the role of holding for field goals, and for the coaches to have just left Tony in that role for the full season is borderline incompetence. Last year they lost to a team that got super-hot and defeated what looked to be the strongest team in NFL history to win the Super Bowl. I'm not sure you can really put losing to the Giants all on Romo's head.
Old Goat
Last season just goes to show that any decent team can just catch fire. The Giants probably weren't the better team in the Superbowl, but they just seemed to have everything going their way. Can't say as I am complaining, I can't stand the Patriots so any team beating them last year was great. Romo did well, but there are still some throws that look pretty poor. I wonder if that pinkie finger is still affecting him.
CosmicConservative
What I've seen with Romo since his return is not so much that his throws are off, but that his timing is a bit off. When his timing is on, he makes near-perfect throws, but when it's off he can make some pretty poor-looking throws. But he's thrown long, short and across his body with oomph and accuracy since his return, so I think his pinkie is fine. FWIW, with the exception of the Pittsburgh game, his QB rating since his return has been slightly higher than before the injury. So he seems to be doing OK.
Boyd
I seem to recall one of those TO drops you mentioned was actually by...Crayton, I think. But I can barely remember yesterday, let alone a playoff game a few years ago. But as my brother says when we're discussing the Longhorns (paraphrasing), "This ain't about rationality. This is about bein' a fan!"
CosmicConservative
Boyd, you are probably right, I know TO dropped a huge one, and that he led the NFL in dropped passes that year due to a finger injury of his own. But he makes some incredible plays too, so on balance he's a benefit to the team. As is Tony, imho.
CosmicConservative
So Jay Cutler (13th ranked in NFL, 8-6 record) is voted to the Pro Bowl. Tony Romo (2nd ranked in NFL, 8-3 record) is not. Yeah, the bias is still there.