Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jay Cutler and the Denver Broncos

By CosmicConservative
Lots of news out of Dove Valley this week. For those who don't know, "Dove Valley" is the practice field and general operations center for the Denver Broncos. It's a facility located in the suburbs of the Denver Metro area distinguished by a large white dome enclosing the Broncos regular daily practice field. I used to drive past it every day to get to work. There are two substantive stories and one "human interest" story from the Broncos. The first story is perhaps the most impactful and that is the arrest in Florida yesterday of Broncos standout wide receiver Brandon Marshall. The arrest was for a fairly minor disturbing the peace incident involving a fight in a bar in the early morning hours of Sunday morning, but the impact is potentially hugely important to the Denver Broncos for a couple of reasons. Marshall had already been arrested three times in the past two years, and his last arrest in 2008 led to a one game suspension (which was reduced through extensive lobbying from Mike Shanahan and Pat Bowlen from the original three games that the NFL handed down). It is unlikely that any amount of lobbying can reduce the upcoming suspension which could be for as much as a full season, but is likely to be eight games. That's effectively taking the Broncos best player off the field for at least half of the 2009 season, if not the whole season. Also, if I understand the new rules put in play last year, this arrest actually opens up the Broncos for a signifant fine by the NFL. All of this is happening as Marshall's agent is trying to negotiate a sweetheart long term new contract. The other substantive story is about Denver's hyper-active free-agent work this weekend. They brought in several specific-purpose players, seemingly following the New England Patriots model of situational drafting. In general I think they did an excellent job of plugging some holes which Mike Shanahan had inexplicably ignored for years. I think the draft work will significantly upgrade the team. The "human interest" story is all about Jay Cutler, whose panties are all in a wad because rumors surfaced over the weekend that the Broncos had discussed a possible three-way trade which would move Jay Cutler to Tampa Bay and bring Patriots "backup" quarterback Matt Cassel to Denver. The Broncos front office insists that any talks that MAY have happened would have been instigated by Tampa Bay and that they had no serious plans to trade Jay Cutler, but regardless Jay Cutler actually demanded to be traded over the weekend his feelings were so hurt by this possible trade. Now, any time there is a story about Jay Cutler that treats the QB as an elite QB, whether it is a sports reporter, an NFL official, a Broncos team member or even Jay Cutler himself, I have to go and look at Cutlers statistics to see just how much Cutler deserves this sort of treatment. So, when I look at the "official" ESPN quarterback ratings for the just finished 2008 season I see Jay Cutler dead in the middle of the pack, rated 16th of the 32 starting quarterbacks in the league. His overall QB rating is a pedestrian 86.0 which is actually a slight improvement over previous years. His win-loss ratio is was 8 -8, meaning he STILL has not presided over a winning season after three years as starter. He did throw for 4,500 yards, which is certainly something to be proud of, but overall his performance continues to put him squarely in the middle of the pack of NFL quarterbacks, significantly below such names as Kurt Warner, Chad Pennington, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub, Ben Roethlesberger, and, NFL QB leader, Phillip Rivers. I know that Jay had a cozy relationship with Mike Shanahan, and Shanahan pretty much bet (and lost) his job on Jay Cutler emerging as an "elite" quarterback, but Josh McDaniels has no such investment in the over-hyped and under-performing Cutler. I would not be surprised at all if the new regime in Denver is looking much more at Cutler's ACTUAL performance than his much-heralded, yet never achieved "tremendous potential." If Cutler's going to start whining and crying like a prima donna, I would think the new regime here would find it very easy to justify trading him to some other team enamored of his "potential." It is true that Cutler went to the pro bowl last year, but it is hard to believe he will be back in the pro bowl if he continues to preside over a team with a .500 record while prancing around like some sort of team savior. Hey Jay, let me clue you in on something. You AREN'T the savior of the team if the TEAM IS NOT WINNING. I don't give a fig how many yards you throw for, if you can't lead this team into the playoffs AT LEAST, then you don't get to act like an elite QB. See, elite QBs do one thing more than any other. They. Win. Games.

Comments (4)

Andy
Yeah Cosmic...it's kinda like the year that O.J. broke 2,000. What did the Bills win...maybe 2 games? Same thing with Dan Fouts and all the 4 million yard passing games he lost.
CosmicConservative
You're funny Andy.. Are you seriously comparing Jay Cutler to O.J. or Fouts? I suppose if Cutler ends up with six or eight 4,000 yard seasons in a row, even with a losing season I might have to agree that he's in the "elite" category. But I don't think we're there yet... And as I recall, the Bills and the Chargers did make the playoffs during O.J.'s and Fouts tenure... At least I think they did. Also on Cutler, I would tend to be far more of a Cutler fan if so many of the Broncos losses in the past three years were not directly the result of some crazy Cutler desperation heave across the field into heavy traffic when he should have just thrown the ball away.
Andy
No Cosmic, I wasn't putting Cutler in that class...just trying to make the point that what really matters is wins. Yeah, Fouts made the playoffs some...but lesser "stat" guys like Bradshaw & Aikman have rings. I had to go back and look. The Bills did end up 9-5 in O.J.'s 2,000 yard season. But they didn't make the playoffs. (those were the good old days...imagine, a 9-5 team!) But for most of his seasons they were 1-13, 3-11, etc. I'm just saying...wins get counted.
CosmicConservative
Well, in the end there is nothing but wins that keeps a coach employed. And coaches make the decisions about who plays and who doesn't. Of course the new Broncos front office says all the expected things about Jay Cutler, but I feel pretty confident that behind closed doors they are looking harder at film of Cutler than Shanahan ever did. Plus I think they are reviewing game plans that were built around Cutler and asking themselves if those plans win games or not. And they may conclude that Shanahan was right and keep on the same offensive scheme that has Cutler throwing for 4,500 yards a season. Maybe they'll decide that all the problems were on the defensive side of the ball. But they did acquire two new running backs in the free agent market. And some other offensive talent. My guess is that you'll see a more conservative Broncos in 2009, with more emphasis on running the ball and grinding out wins, and less empahsis on passing schemes that show off Cutler's brilliant, if sometimes erratic, arm. Just my $.02.