Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Romo vs. Cutler, chapter 4

By CosmicConservative
So, it's a bit past midway of the season. How are Tony Romo and Jay Cutler doing? Both teams are 6-4. Denver is in first place in the woeful AFC West, Dallas is tied with Washington for second place behind the Super Bowl champion New York Giants in the always tough NFC East. At this point it would seem that Denver is in a much better place to reach the playoffs than the Dallas is, but that says more about their respective divisions than their actual teams. Tony missed three games after breaking his pinkie finger in one game. He played yesterday with a splint on his pinkie and with a new throwing motion and ball-holding technique. Dallas is 5 - 2 with Romo, Denver is 6 - 4 with Cutler. Here's a breakdown of their stats: In quarterback rating (supposedly the most important stat for quarterbacks, maybe aside from wins) Romo is currently in third place with a rating of 99. Cutler is in tenth place with a rating of 90. Because of the disparity in games the most comparable stats are averages over those games so that's what I'll focus on. Romo's yards per attempt average is 8.31 yards, which is second in the league to Phillip Rivers. This is considered by many quarterback experts as one the best stats to truly measure how successful a quarterback is at moving the ball downfield. Cutler's 7.68 ypa is a respectable seventh place. Romo throws a touchdown on 6.6% of his passes. That again puts him second behind Phillip Rivers. This is considered a great stat for determining how good a QB is at getting into the end zone as opposed to settling for field goals. Cutler's 5.1% is, again, a respectable 5th place. Romo's completion percentage has taken a beating since he broke his pinkie (as has his interception count) but his 64.8% completion rate is still in the top ten (ninth) while Cutler's completion rate of 62.3 puts him right at the middle of the pack of NFL starters at #15. Romo's 7 interceptions account for 3% of his passes. Cutler's 11 interceptions account for 3% if his as well, so on this stat, they are almost exactly even. I will note though that three of Tony's interceptions came with a broken pinkie finger. So the result of analyzing these stats seems to indicate that Tony Romo continues to be a top three quarterback in the NFL, while Cutler is just barely a top ten contender. Which is pretty much exactly what my pre-season analysis of their career numbers showed. In other words, both of them are performing in 2008 after ten games more or less exactly as their stats from the past three years would predict. And yet I still see Cutler praised as the young QB of the future. He gets credit for Denver's 6-4 record leading the AFC West while Romo gets blame for his 6-4 record being a wild-card hopeful in the NFC East. I don't suppose anything is going to change here, no matter what their stats end up being this year. It certainly hasn't mattered so far. The narrative has been defined and the stories have already been written. Cutler, the first round draft choice of the mastermind coach vs. Romo, the three year backup who nearly had to walk on to make the team... In the meantime those stats just seem to keep on saying the same thing.... We'll see how things stand at the end of the year. From what I've seen so far, I expect they'll tell a very similar story.

Comments (8)

Andy
Cosmic: I probably asked you this before, but I don't remember for sure. Are we talking equal weapons here? I mean, is this a "gun vs. gun" deal here, or "knives vs. a kick to the groin" Butch? I don't get to watch the Broncos play. So, I'm wondering if Cutler's weapons are comparable to Romo's. T.O. (love him, or hate him) CAN go get it...and this season he has occupied more than his share two-on-ones, freeing up other receivers. Witten is as steady as a fence post. And Romo has an explosive back in Barber...that always holds the linebackers for half a step...a great running back can sure make an average quarterback a lot better. I get from your post that Denver is in a weak Division. And no doubt, the 'Boys have to deal with playing the Giants, 'Skins, and Eagles twice...nothing fun about that for sure. I'm a Romo fan. I think the guy has great potential. I like the "almost had to walk on from Eastern Illinois" story. But I wonder whether Cutler's stats would be better than Romo's if he wore the star. Just askin', 'cause I don't know.
CosmicConservative
Andy: In several of my debates with the unfortunately no longer posting "Drax" I attempted as best I could to deal with this very question. Short answer, "yes" I think the Cowboys of 2006 and the Broncos of 2006 were very comparable teams, even though at that time the Broncos were both considered better and had the better statistics (I think the Broncos went 13-3 in 2004, won their division and lost to Pittsburgh in the playoffs) When Romo and Cutler started their run the Broncos, if anything, had the better "guns". They had Javon Walker and Brandon Marshall as receivers (Marshall is frequently cited as glowingly as Cutler is) and had the acknowledged best offensive line in football. In gaining Champ Bailey they acquired the acknowledged best defensive back by trading away megastar running back, Clinton Portis. Yeah, they had the tools. Since then both teams have morphed somewhat. Denver traded away Portis, lost O-line anchor Matt Lepsis and traded away Javon Walker, but they still have one of the best O-lines, Champ Bailey, Brandon Marshall and at least as much weaponry as Dallas. The one thing they lack right now is a standout running back, but frankly, based on statistics and results, I wouldn't say Dallas has a stellar running back themselves. Marion Barber is solid, but neither Dallas nor Denver have an Adrian Peterson or Clinton Portis. Marion Barber is currently the tenth-ranked back in the league in yardage. In pure team terms Dallas and Denver are separated by about 80 yards in the rushing department, and both are middle of the pack rushing teams. In fact Denver is much higher rated as a passing team than Dallas is, but I think that's mostly because of three games with Romo out and one with him playing with a broken pinkie. I think the comparison is fair, the teams have lots of similarities, and Brandon Marshall, if anything, is a better receiver today than Terrell Owens. Marshall is the real deal in my opinion, if he can only stay out of the courtroom...
CosmicConservative
Again, my point in this comparison is not to try to brag on Romo, but to continue to describe my total befuddlement with why the sports media is so infatuated with Jay Cutler... I don't mean anything nasty by it, I like Cutler and hope he does well. I simply can't understand the discrepancy in the reporting, the expectations and the seeming complete disregard for the one thing on this earth that actually quantifies their respective performances, which is their actual statistics.
Old Goat
I think Romo is the better QB by a long margin. Cutler doesn't seem to read the plays as well. I think Romo gets under appreciated because of the team he is on, Cutler gets over rated. As far as TO, he is seeing a lot less, but what he does get will be higher impact. He gets covered pretty well, which opens other doors. As others step it up more, the opportunities for TO will increase as well.
Andy
Cosmic: Thanks for the insights. I don't know the Bronco players, so I have learned something. I agree with you that Cutler does seem to be the new Darling of the sports media. You know how they are...pick a horse and beat it to death! And just like you, I wish Cutler well. But as a life-long 'Boys fan, I only wish him well until he comes up against us. ;) Heh, speaking of Drax...did he win some big class-action suit and retire to one of those lovely places with no internet service or something? I miss his comments.
Boyd
As a life-long (meaning, starting with their first year in 1960) Cowboys fan, I've learned to be humble when it comes to America's Team. Some of that comes from the Tom Landry approach to coaching, some of it comes from my own coaches telling me to just do my job on the football field, and other similar sources. Even in the heyday years, I've learned to not get too cocky about my 'Boys, since they have this awful knack of turning around at the end of the game and not bringing it home (as supporting evidence, see: all their recent playoff appearances). Of course, they also have this knack of putting on their big boy pants in the 4th quarter and running their opponents into the ground. Those are the guys I hope to see every Sunday.
CosmicConservative
I am a Cowboys fan, and have been since the late sixties. I remember Tony Dorsett's rookie year. When I moved to Colorado I tried hard to become a Broncos fan and forget about the Cowboys, but the first time the 'Boys played the Broncos I started rooting for Elway and ended up rooting for Aikman.. And I've been back on the 'Boys bus ever since. As a Cowboys fan I've seen the glory and the groans. Although there has been a lot more glory than groan. The Cowboys have won more Super Bowls (5) and played in more Super bowls (8) than any other team. They are tied with San Francisco, Pittsburgh and New England for the most Super Bowl wins (I think) and last year I was really hoping to see them sitting alone with most Super Bowl wins and appearances. Dallas, I believe, is the most successful franchise in the NFL since 1960. It's been a while since I went and looked at the statistics, but a few years ago I did an analysis of NFL teams success as defined by playoff appearances, playoff victoryies, Super Bowl appearances, Super Bowl wins, Regular Season wins, Division titles and Conference championships and Dallas was the top team in virtually every one of those stats. The closest teams to them were San Francisco and Pittsburgh. Dallas has a realistic claim to be the most successful franchise in sports since 1960. As such it is hard to complain as a Dallas fan. It's been a storied, incredibly successful franchise so far. Still, I'm greedy, I want them to dominate every year.
Boyd
...I want them to dominate every year. Of course! Otherwise, you wouldn't be a fan!