Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos
By CosmicConservativeHeh... According to reports from Dove Valley, the ongoing soap opera of the relationship between Denver Broncos new head coach Josh McDaniels and Denver Broncos "All Pro" quarterback, Jay Cutler, continues to degenerate. The "official" word from Dove Valley is that Jay and the Broncos brain trust held a long-anticipated conference call yesterday and the parties resolved their differences. However, "unofficial" reports from people who were supposedly on the call directly contradict that version of events and instead say that Cutler is more angry than ever because the Broncos refused to promise him that he would not be traded, leaving the door open to a trade at least before draft day. According to THAT version of events, Cutler asked to be traded as soon as possible.
Regular readers of this blog know that I have been unconvinced of Jay Cutler's brilliance since he was drafted. What I HAVE been convinced of since Cutler was drafted is that he has been pampered and hyped more than any similar quarterback I can think of, and has performed well below the top level "young quarterbacks" that he is frequently considered to be the "best of". In particular his performance has been well below that of Phil Rivers, Ben Roethlesberger, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub and others. Which is not to even compare him to perennial QB superstars like Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees or (cough) Eli Manning.
In fact if you look at statistics over the past three years Cutler has been mediocre at best. Other than yards per game, he is decidedly in the middle of the pack for yards per attempt, % complete, touchdowns per attempt etc. In fact the only starting QB in the past three years who has thrown more interceptions than Jay Cutler has been Brett Favre. Which I find very interesting because while many (if not most) of the sports pundits like to compare Cutler to ex-Broncos Hall of Fame QB John Elway, I find his statistics and style are much more comparable to Brett Favre, particularly his tendency to throw the ball up for grabs and give up game-breaking interceptions.
It is probably fair to say that if Cutler is traded, I won't miss him. Denver's revolving door at quarterback the last twelve years has been entertaining in some ways, but frankly you could compare all of those quarterbacks (Brian Griese, Gus Frerotte, Bubby Brister and Jake Plummer) and not see a huge difference in either their performance or the performance of the team with them at the helm. (Well, Jake Plummer did have one good year when the Broncos went 13-3 and lost in the AFC title game to eventual Super Bowl champions the Pittsburgh Steelers, led by a rookie QB named Ben Roethlesberger).
Anyway, I have always considered Cutler to be something of a pampered, hyped up, petulant under-achiever. It's sort of interesting to see that more and more of the NFL and the Denver Broncos fan base is starting to see him the same way I do. My only advice to Jay Cutler right now is to start acting like an adult, quit whining about how his ego has been punctured and get back on the field and prove (for once) that he's remotely as good as the hype which has surrounded him for years.
Comments (14)