Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos

By CosmicConservative
Heh... According to reports from Dove Valley, the ongoing soap opera of the relationship between Denver Broncos new head coach Josh McDaniels and Denver Broncos "All Pro" quarterback, Jay Cutler, continues to degenerate. The "official" word from Dove Valley is that Jay and the Broncos brain trust held a long-anticipated conference call yesterday and the parties resolved their differences. However, "unofficial" reports from people who were supposedly on the call directly contradict that version of events and instead say that Cutler is more angry than ever because the Broncos refused to promise him that he would not be traded, leaving the door open to a trade at least before draft day. According to THAT version of events, Cutler asked to be traded as soon as possible. Regular readers of this blog know that I have been unconvinced of Jay Cutler's brilliance since he was drafted. What I HAVE been convinced of since Cutler was drafted is that he has been pampered and hyped more than any similar quarterback I can think of, and has performed well below the top level "young quarterbacks" that he is frequently considered to be the "best of". In particular his performance has been well below that of Phil Rivers, Ben Roethlesberger, Tony Romo, Matt Schaub and others. Which is not to even compare him to perennial QB superstars like Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees or (cough) Eli Manning. In fact if you look at statistics over the past three years Cutler has been mediocre at best. Other than yards per game, he is decidedly in the middle of the pack for yards per attempt, % complete, touchdowns per attempt etc. In fact the only starting QB in the past three years who has thrown more interceptions than Jay Cutler has been Brett Favre. Which I find very interesting because while many (if not most) of the sports pundits like to compare Cutler to ex-Broncos Hall of Fame QB John Elway, I find his statistics and style are much more comparable to Brett Favre, particularly his tendency to throw the ball up for grabs and give up game-breaking interceptions. It is probably fair to say that if Cutler is traded, I won't miss him. Denver's revolving door at quarterback the last twelve years has been entertaining in some ways, but frankly you could compare all of those quarterbacks (Brian Griese, Gus Frerotte, Bubby Brister and Jake Plummer) and not see a huge difference in either their performance or the performance of the team with them at the helm. (Well, Jake Plummer did have one good year when the Broncos went 13-3 and lost in the AFC title game to eventual Super Bowl champions the Pittsburgh Steelers, led by a rookie QB named Ben Roethlesberger). Anyway, I have always considered Cutler to be something of a pampered, hyped up, petulant under-achiever. It's sort of interesting to see that more and more of the NFL and the Denver Broncos fan base is starting to see him the same way I do. My only advice to Jay Cutler right now is to start acting like an adult, quit whining about how his ego has been punctured and get back on the field and prove (for once) that he's remotely as good as the hype which has surrounded him for years.

Comments (14)

buckblog
Woa now! Cutler has been in the league 3 years and has a huge upside. I seem to recall many of the same comments about John Elway early in his career. Compare the stats for the first 3 years. Across the board Cutler is ahead of Elway. In fact Elway did not become the Elway football fans remember until about his 10th year. Until then his touchdown to interception ratio was awful and his completion percentage not particularly good. There was a rumor flying around that the Broncos offered Cutler to Cleveland for Brady Quinn and Shaun Rogers. As a Browns fan I'd take that in a second, and that's considering that I think Quinn is going to be a pretty good quarterback and Shaun Rogers was the Browns best defensive player.
Old Goat
Hard to say how well Cutler will do over time. I think he has been over rated by the various talking heads and he is a bit immature about his role. Football is first and foremost a business, and Cutler is taking all this far too personally. He may have a good career over the long haul, but its still too early to say he will, the jury is still out.
CosmicConservative
Buck: The difference between Elway's statistics and Cutler's statistics in their first three (ten) years is that John Elway was in a system that was predominately a run-based scheme with very little passing. When they were behind in the fourth quarter and it was clear that the running game was not going to win it, Elway was only then given free rein to pass away. Cutler's offense has been essentially exactly the reverse. The scheme has been dominated by passing plays, particularly passes to wide receivers. Had Elway been in a pass-centric offense (say like the Chargers of that time) his numbers would have been much higher. You see Elway's numbers improving dramatically once Shanahan and his pass-centric offense arrived. However, back then I was a huge critic of John Elway too, for the same reasons. And quite frankly I don't think John Elway became the "John Elway the fans remember" until he grew up himself. Elway was absolutely a pampered, over-hyped prima donna himself. And it wasn't until Denver put together a full package including the best offensive line and best running back in the game that they won the Super Bowl. Terrell Davis had far more to do with Denver winning two Super Bowls than John Elway did. Hell, you could argue that Matt Lepsis and Jason Elam did. I stand by my criticisms of Cutler. Yes, maybe he will grow up too, and learn game management and ball control. As of now he has shown no indication that he is doing so. His current petulant temper tantrum is just a public affirmation of the behavior I have pointed out since he joined the club. I watch him on the sidelines during games, and it is no coincidence that he is typically alone on the bench. I am quite certain that my opinion is shared by many in the NFL. Including some on the Denver Broncos themselves. (Now, quite notably, including the head coach.) Oh, as far as the rumored trade with Cleveland? I'd be happy to see it. Denver needs good defensive players much more than they need an over-hyped baby behind center.
buckblog
I'll agree he needs to grow up and a thicker skin. The fact that Elway was in a run oriented offense his first 3 years actually makes his interception to touchdown ratio and his completion % even more dreadful and lends support to my contention that Cutler is actually ahead of Elway at this stage. As you say Elway grew up. Cutler probably will also. At least I hope so That's what makes football fun. Can have lots of good natured debates over something that in the long run is of no real importance. Good luck to the Broncos, except against Cleveland
CosmicConservative
Buck: One reason Elway's interception ratio was so high back then is because he was always trying to drive a fourth quarter comeback while racing against the clock, and it is to be expected that such circumstances will drive a higher interception ratio. Yes he won a lot of those games, but he lost a lot of them too.
buckblog
"Yes he won a lot of those games..." Against the Browns unfortunately
Andy
Does Cleveland still have an NFL franchise? I thought they moved to Detroit a couple of years ago.
buckblog
Mangini is bringing in a bunch of old Jet coaches and players. They are now called the Brets
CosmicConservative
This was all they talked about on the "Ride Home" radio program I listen to on.... the ride home... Public opinion, which was initially solidly behind Cutler and against the Broncos is turning against Jay as he continues to refuse to show up for meetings and is planning on boycotting their off season weight training program. More and more I hear Bronco fans calling Cutler a "crybaby" and a "prima donna" and similar things. At this point I'd say there's at least a 50/50 chance that Jay will be traded by the time the draft happens. And the chances are he's more likely to end up on a team like the Detroit Lions than like the New England Patriots... I wonder if he'll regret any of this if he ends up staring a 2-14 season in the face in Detroit...
Jury awards $1 to professor fired for 9/11-Nazi essay - CNN | Denver Blogs
[...] » Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos CosmicConservative: Rational … [...]
Game on? Western Regional Rugby Championships in Greeley delayed - Examiner.com | Denver Blogs
[...] » Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos CosmicConservative: Rational … [...]
Impeach Conyers before it's too late - The Detroit News | Denver Blogs
[...] » Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos CosmicConservative: Rational … [...]
Loss of Sacramento airport hotel ripples through economy - Sacramento Bee | Denver Blogs
[...] » Jay Cutler vs. the Denver Broncos CosmicConservative: Rational … [...]