Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Something truly random

By CosmicConservative
First, the story.
The researchers – Professor Ping Koy Lam, Dr Thomas Symul and Dr Syed Assad from the ANU ARC Centre of Excellence for Quantum Computation and Communication Technology – have tuned their very sensitive light detectors to listen to vacuum – a region of space that is empty. Professor Lam said vacuum was once thought to be completely empty, dark, and silent until the discovery of the modern quantum theory. Since then scientists have discovered that vacuum is an extent of space that has virtual sub-atomic particles spontaneously appearing and disappearing. It is the presence of these virtual particles that give rise to random noise. This ‘vacuum noise’ is omnipresent and may affect and ultimately pose a limit to the performances of fibre optic communication, radio broadcasts and computer operation. “While it has always been thought to be an annoyance that engineers and scientists would like to circumvent, we instead exploited this vacuum noise and used it to generate random numbers,” Professor Lam said. “Random number generation has many uses in information technology. Global climate prediction, air traffic control, electronic gaming, encryption, and various types of computer modelling all rely on the availability of unbiased, truly random numbers.
Now, the analysis... There is something profound going on here that I believe most scientists are totally missing. There has always been this presumption in science that "randomness" is the same thing as "noise." But there are seriously powerful distinctions between the two. As this story reveals, if you think about it. If you read this story, you should be struck by how casually the scientist quoted in the story treats the epistemological acceptance of quantum mechanics. There is a real sense of "faith" being expressed here that the scientific discipline of quantum mechanics is unchallenged and accepted. The appeal to quantum mechanics itself as "proof" of the randomness of the "zero-energy field" is quite striking, even if it is simultaneously completely ignored. There is an even deeper alethiological issue here too. Hmm... it occurs to me that I'm using some of my favorite sesquipedalian verbosity again. So I'll explain. "Epistemology" is the study of "knowledge." It attempts to address the idea not only of what we know but as much as we can, how we know it. Alethiology is a more obscure branch of science, and one that is frequently mistaken for epistemology. Alethiology is the study of "truth." What is the difference between "knowledge" and "truth?" Heh... yeah, that's an awesome question. Perhaps the best answer to that is a simple question: "Can you know something that isn't true?" This article is the best example I've seen in a long time of at least attempting to demonstrate the reliance on "knowledge" when "truth" is beyond our ken. At its core this boils down the a fundamental question of how can we possibly extract truly random numbers out of "nothing". This question becomes more important the deeper theoretical physicists dig into the concept of "information theory" which more and more attempts to describe the universe in terms of abstract concepts which have associated attributes of information, and that information is what determines the "nature" of the physical manifestation of the concept in question. Sigh... I really have a problem attempting to communicate some things... Let me try again... There is a growing branch of physics theory that attempts to explain the nature of the universe by breaking the universe itself down into information components. The usual analogy is to a computer generated "universe" where the actual universe itself is a sort of illusion that is based on a collection of information which is operated on by certain rules. So gravity isn't a "force" at all, its a "rule" that derives from how the particular bits of information in the "computer memory" are manipulated by "algorithms" which result in transforming that information into a new state. This entire line of thought comes from some of the most fundamental "problems" we have in understanding the universe. For example, how does a photon "know" that it's a photon? How does a proton "know" how to interact with an electron? The current "standard model" theory says that fundamental particles interact through the exchange of "virtual particles" which carry information from one to another which results in what we see as a "force." But how do the particles KNOW that they need to exchange these virtual particles? Suppose one particle sends a virtual particle, but the other does not respond? Well, the standard model says that can't happen. But how can they "know" not only what to exchange but more importantly when to exchange them? There is something deeply mysterious and perhaps even mystical going on here. One of the most famous arguments in the history of physics was between the proponents of "force at a distance" and the proponents of "force projection." Einstein HATED force at a distance. In fact it was his deep belief that there was no such thing as force at a distance that led to his creation of the general theory of relativity. In Einstein's mind, the "information" that each particle needs to "know" to react as expected is contained in the warp and weave of space-time itself. But that simply introduces a NEW problem that Einstein simply ignored. What is space-time made of? It is interesting to me how much we "know" about the universe (epistemology) while simultaneously having no "proof" that what we know is actually true (alethiology). Which brings me back to extracting random numbers from the "zero-energy noise". People mistakenly think that "random" means "no information." That is totally not true. I mean just look at the story. Random numbers are incredibly useful things to have. If you can use them then they have value. What value do they have? They are unpredictable. How valuable is that unpredictability? Well, you can see from the story above that random numbers are extremely valuable. Why are random numbers so valuable? This is where I get all mystical. Randomness is required for the universe to have free will. Where do we find true randomness in the universe, as far as we know? Most scientists will tell you that you can find randomness in one of two places. EITHER you get it from the quantum foam (meaning quantum mechanical random fluctuations exactly like the ones this story is about) OR you get it from chaotic phenomena. But the usual explanation for how chaotic behavior happens eventually boils down to quantum mechanical effects anyway. So, in essence, all randomness comes from the quantum foam from which these random numbers are being extracted. Or are they really random? How do we know that they are?

Comments (6)

Drax
Excellent explanation. But, if one accepts the premise of a "big bang" (or whatever iteration of that theory is in vogue today), then, since all matter in the universe came from a single mass of matter (no matter how large or compressed or over how long a time), then, why is there a question about how any of these bits of a larger piece of matter "know" how to interact or when - since, in the beginning, they "knew" what their virtual "roles" were? Of course, this all depends on how far back into the "big bang" one goes, but, it would seem that, once the matter took on the particular characteristics which they currently have (however long after the "big bang" (see above)) then, their "roles" (the "how" and "when" they interact) would have, at that point been set - thus requiring no current "knowledge" - simply "being."
CosmicConservative
Drax... you might be surprised by how well your comment there aligns with the conceptual foundation of the "inflation" revision of the "Big Bang" theory. Except for the "simply being" part anyway. You are starting to delve into some of the core concepts of the Big Bang itself when you mention "took on the particular characteristics which they currently have" for example. I don't know how much of an interest you might have in cosmological origin theories, but they all have some conceptual foundation in the "information boundary" which describes which parts of the current universe could ever "know" about other parts of the universe. Inflation theory, for example, was explicitly formulated to explain how the cosmic background radiation could possibly be so uniform without all of the parts of the universe we see today "knowing" about all the other parts we see. BUT, there is no way that the extreme edges we see today could "know" about the other edge because the universe is bigger than light could travel across it in the age of the universe. So to answer that question (without resorting to yoru "simply being" argument) cosmologists simply assert that the universe must have exponentially expanded much faster than the speed of light during the very early stages of its existence. So this whole concept of particles "knowing" about not only themselves, but of the universe around them is profoundly "baked in" to the current cosmological theories of universe formation (including even String Theory). And, as I probably say way too much, there seem to be very few physicists who understand the implications of their theories beyond their "hard science" aspect of "confirming" observation. This stuff is deeply metaphysical when you start to actually try to comprehend what things like Inflation Theory actually mean about the nature of the universe itself. Einstein was probably right. The universe probably is not merely stranger than we DO imagine, but is stranger than we CAN imagine.
Andy
Wellllll CRAAAAAAAAAPPPPPPPPPPP! I spent 20 minutes writing a comment, and The Wordpress ate it. Crud... Wordpress sucks more than Blogger.
CosmicConservative
Well, I tried to find it in my spam filter or pending file, but no luck. Sorry.
yellow
"How do we know that they are?" Well the scientist did say they can't be sure that the what they have is truly random. http://150.203.48.55/FAQ.php "Randomness is required for the universe to have free will." Right. But do we have free will?
CosmicConservative
Yellow, if you had read similar posts on my blog here, you'd know that I long ago made the purely arbitrary decision to believe that we do, in fact, have free will. So my comments about free will assume that we do. I fully acknowledge that we may not have free will. But such a universe is pointless and as such nothing I would say matters in such a universe, so I'd just as soon not address that possibility.