Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What would you do?

By Dadman
Dadman here. I know it's been a long while since I posted anything on this blog but I have a serious question to ask. Honestly, I really don't like asking for advice or guidance preferring to work things out on my own, but the decision I will soon have to make is a real doozy and I really could use a dispassionate perspective or two. Here's my situation: I may soon have to choose between accepting a new role in a company I've worked at for 19 years or taking a generous severance package and walking away. The company I presently work for is a great company, but nearly two decades of working in the high stress corporate cubicle farm has grown boring and monotonous, and just a little bit unhealthy for a variety of reasons. The new role will be more of the same. My heart, mind, and soul really desire to take a risk and try something new and different. The severence would provide a financial buffer of at least 6 months perhaps longer. If I were to just 'follow my heart' I would take the severance and run. But there's so much more to consider. I have a son in college and one in high school. If I walk I might lose my healthcare or will at the very least have to pay a lot more to keep it current through COBRA. My current income will be difficult to replace. It might take a lot longer than I realize to find a new job at any salary level. On the other hand it's not often a company offers to pay you big bucks to leave your job. This could be just the opporunity I've been praying for the make a break from my current routine. If I find a new job relatively quickly the severence would become an enormous financial windfall that could help my family realize some of our dreams. I recently saw the movie 'We Bought a Zoo' (an excellent movie by the way) and a line in the film really resonated with me. Matt Damon's character tells his son, "All you need is 20 seconds of insane courage and I promise you something great will come out of it'" I feel like it may be time for me to exercise some courage. It's been awhile. I've let fear rule the roost for far too long. The choice I may soon be forced to make is an insanely difficult one. The stakes are high. The path is not clear. What would you do?

Comments (21)

CosmicConservative
I think that we are at the age where these sorts of things become really soul-wrenching decisions, whether we have a six month severance package on the table or not. In all honesty, if I were in your situation right now, I would take the severance and pursue my heart's desire to be a writer until I ran out of money or had a start in that career, even if I had to take a salary hit to do it. I'd even move into a smaller house. I know many, many folks our age who took this sort of leap. My own father did so at age 47, dropping everything to pursue a law degree. He ended up with a 20 year law career that provided him with great satisfaction and financial rewards. Life is short and getting shorter every day. Pursue your dreams. That's what it's all about, really. I am likely to do the same thing you are contemplating without the severance package the way things are going. I am really sick of my job, in spite of its generous pay. It's not just the stress, it's the constant insistence by corporate ladder-climbers that their own personal career goals are worth putting my health and family needs aside on a weekly basis. I understand the need to provide value to the company, but I can also see the bigger picture and it is quite clear on occasion that the only reason the "leadership" of the company is beating the crap out of their underlings is so they can get massive bonuses tied to specific goals set in their personal performance plan, whether that's really best for the company or not. So follow your heart dude!
Dadman
Thanks for the feedback. I'd really like to work for myself in some capacity, preferably as a cartoonist or freelance illustrator. But those are very difficult career paths so I'd likely have to keep some kind of day job. The prospect excites me and terrifies me simultaneously. It's a strange sensation. ;)
Boyd
TL;DR: I agree with Cosmic. Beginning in September of 2008 and already in my 50s, I was unemployed for 12 months, underemployed for 18 months (worked retail), moved back to Texas and was unemployed here for 4 months, got back into software development but at 2/3 of my former rate, and now back at about 90% of what I was making 4 years ago. All of which is to say I have some familiarity with some of what you may face. I got to the point once where I wasn't sure if I was going to have enough cash to buy gas for my 60-mile (each way) commute to work last year, so I was down to absolutely nothing. All that being said, maybe it's just my Texan nature, but I'm a big believer in following your heart. Risk-taking is a lost art in America IMHO, and we're the worse for it. I don't know about anyone else, but I gotta LIVE!
Dadman
Thanks Boyd. I'm concerned I won't be able to LIVE! without a steady income. Two decades of steady employment has really made me soft. :) But seriously, I really appreciate your perspective...
CosmicConservative
Well, from what I read, there are people living in "pre-foreclosed" houses that have lived there for two years without making a payment. So it's not as dire as you might think to miss a payment or two... or at least apparently not. Save your money for art supplies.
Drax
Well, as one who has "made the jump" (without the parachute which is offered to you), I can say the following: There are times when it is great. There are other times when it is beyond horrible (especially at bill paying time). There is quite a lot to be said for a steady paycheck (and healthcare...). A lot. Really. Quite a lot. If you haven't ever worked for yourself without supervision, it is a very difficult thing to do. You must motivate yourself each and every day to work - without any feedback - generally one way or another (except, perhaps, what you earn.) You will have to learn that, frequently, effort doesn't translate into reward. In fact, sometimes the reverse is true and you are not only not rewarded for your effort, but are penalized (financially, at least). Going out on your own can have great rewards (I'm still looking for the "financial" ones...), but it is HARD. You work EVERY DAY. From can until can't. And, you might not get paid (at least initially) for that effort. So, my advice is simple. Look at your life. Ask yourself if you're a risk taker or someone who is normally risk adverse. (There is nothing inherently good or bad about either attitude - it's just that most people are one way or another - with the vast majority being risk adverse...) Then, decide.
Dadman
Thanks Drax. That's a very valid, pragmatic perspective and one that is frankly foremost in my mind. I feel like I'm more risk averse now than I was when I was younger. But, honestly, I have a little more wiggle room now to take a few risks than I did 10-15 years ago. I'm not sure what I'm going to do. It's going to be a very tough call...
Drax
I find myself becoming more risk adverse as I get older, simply because I have more to lose - and not just in a financial sense. Young and single taking risks with not much is one thing. Old, married, with a mortgage and a small child is another entirely. And, one other factor which must be taken heavily into consideration is how living a life fraught with risk will affect your home life. If money becomes tight, or worse, then what happens? Money, after all, may not buy happiness, but it turns much unhappiness away at the door. (I'm sure that this is foremost in your mind and any such decision wouldn't be taken without consultation, but, you must honestly examine what YOU
Drax
Dang it...hit a button which sent this unfinished... You must honestly examine what YOU believe your wife's emotional state of mind might be in the event that things don't work out (or worse ...) NOT what she (who likely will support you and intends to do so) TELLS you (and likely believes). Good luck to you. Whichever you decide, I'm sure that you will give it your level best!
Dadman
Yep. My kids are mostly grown which is the wiggle room I'm talking about. And I would likely continue to work for someone, somewhere. I would just attempt to arrange my employment situation in such a way - e.g. contract work, part time work, etc. - to allow me more time and energy to build up a freelance illustration/cartooning/design business on the side. I've learned over the long years I've been at Intel that once I've delivered the results Intel expects of me I have very little time/energy remaining for anything else.
CosmicConservative
Aarrrgghhh!! Risk "AVERSE" not "aDverse"!!! Sigh... I know, I need to relax. "Averse" having the same root as "aversion"meaning something one would prefer to avoid. So, you see one of my pet peeves... like "mute point"... I still say go for it.
Dadman
I believe I used the word properly. I'm a bit of a word nerd and try very hard not to get such things wrong...
Andy
Dadman, it's really hard for me to give you much help on this, for a couple of reason. You asked for a "dispassionate" perspective. That is not possible, because I really care about you. Even though we've never been bosom buddies, I've come to know you as a REAL grownup (somewhat), and it's very difficult to be objective, and unattached. But...I remember 5 years ago at our 30th High School Reunion. Crud...I'd better just e-mail you about that. Something you said has stuck in my rapidly failing mind that I need to remind you of, but I don't want to do it publicly. Dadman, I have lived through more job change junk than most (and only regret ONE job I have taken...it's a long story),and have been the classic under-achiever (at least that's what I tell myself...heck, I may have been all I could be, but am so big-headed that I thought I could do mo' better!). The good thing is that I know it, and have made peace with it. God has been good. Drax makes a very good point about how wimmens can hide their real feelings/fears/struggles/whatever from us men. THIS ONE, I KNOW ABOUT! IN SPADES! You really have to dig deep on that one. Your kids will not care one way or the other. Your beloved wife will. She may not blink an eye one way or the other. But, trust me...she DOES have a firm opinion, and MAY never make it know, being the supportive wife that she is. You may have to pry it out of her. But, whether she gives it up voluntarily, or you have to stick flaming toothpicks under her fingernails...you REALLY need to know her honest feelings before you can proceed. So...if I were you, I'd take the money and run. I'd follow my heart/passion/whatever. Heck, if we live to be OLD men, we've only got a blink of an eye left here in the big picture. The deal about losing health insurance is a bit troubling to me. Not enough details were given...I don't really know if you and your family are big time consumers of it but if not, I wouldn't worry too much about that. I never have, and in an odd way I believe that's why we've all been so healthy. Anyway...don't worry about health care... Obama got it all under control. ;) Dadman, I wish you the VERY best. Seriously. In the end, I know you'll make the best decision. Your family loves you. They ALL want you to be fulfilled as a human being, and enjoy your life. They may not tell you very often, but I know as a son of an aging Father, it gives me no more joy than to see my Dad doing what he loves...profitable or not...it makes me smile.
Dadman
Thanks Andy. Your words are wise. I wish I could remember what the heck I may have said to you 5 years that stuck, but I can't for the life of me...and your e-mail seems to have disappeared into the cyber-ether. ;)
Andy
Didn't disappear...just didn't get around to it. En route.
tomnnva
I've been a hi-tech recruiter for the past 25 years, sales and sales tech support for top end software companies. 6 months’ severance package will evaporate in no time, you will be shocked how quickly it goes away. I see it happen all the time. (6 month severance package, by the way is chump change compared to some I have negotiated) My advice, keep the job. Then drop all non-related job activities and make finding your self another job your primary non-work related activity. Buy yourself the latest copy of "What color is your Parachute" plus other job finding books, build a database of companies and individuals within your industry and begin contacting them. Make your self a minor pest. Most of my time is spent "cold calling", most of my open jobs come from this dreary task. Become a research expert on social media sites, especially "Linkedin". If you "diligently" work hard finding yourself a job, 4-5 hours per day 16 hours on weekends, I guarantee you will find a new opportunity. It would almost be impossible not to. Most people do not work this hard at finding new opportunities; you will be unusual in this regard, another reason for the new company to hire you. THE most important word in this process is; follow-up, follow-up follow-up. Get use to hearing, "no", you are only looking for 1 "let's talk". Going out to become a writer or start up a small company are noble aspirations, accept for very small percentages, thought, they always fail.
Dadman
UPDATE: Well, I got the word yesterday that I will be offered a new job in the new organization. I accepted it without hesitation. Here's why: 1) While it would be nice to get a break from the 8-5 grind of the corporate cubicle farm the reality is I would HAVE to find a new job at some point in the very near future. I figured I might as well take the one being offered to me now. 2) I realized what I disliked the most was not my work or job per se, but rather all the uncertainty surrounding my personal job security. Much, if not all, of that uncertainty will dissipate now that decisions have been made about who stays and who goes. At least for a while. :) 3) My Plan B if I were to leave Intel - to pursue freelance cartooning and illustration opportunities - is impractical and a notoriously difficult career path. It can take years to grow a viable freelance illustration business. I undoubtedly would have to find a second job so I might as well keep the one I have and commit myself to creating more art in my free time... 4)...which is something I've already started. I'm building a functional studio in my home, have begun purchasing necessary art supplies, and I'm building a blog that I will unveil soon dedicated to my current art projects. I'm going to try very hard to get beyond the pen and ink work I've done in the past and design some projects that will require mastery of other media, like acrylics and watercolor. I also have a cartoon strip idea that I want to develop which I'll also debut on the blog. 5) I'm less than 24 months away from my next sabbatical and being able to formally retire from Intel should I choose to. I'd really like to hit those milestones. There are other reasons, but these are the main ones. Intel is a great company to work for and I'm grateful they want to keep me around a while longer. If I perform well in my new job it might even lead to a promotion. I must admit I'm a little concerned I'm rationalizing away an opportunity to make a break from my current routine, take some risks, and wander down a few unknown paths. Am I letting fear win again? I've come to the conclusion that is not the case IF I follow-through on my commitment to develop my creative talents regardless of how busy life gets or how tired I might be. In the final analysis, I have important responsibilities to people other than myself. That's the way it's been for a very long time and nothing has changed...
CosmicConservative
Well, no doubt it was the wise choice. And congratulations on being in the position to make a choice.
Andy
Good news, indeed! Taking a risk is highly overrated. It's pretty thrilling at the time, but when you look back at it...well...I'll just leave it at "well." Man, I'm with Cosmic on congrats. And, on the "wisdom" involved. We're not getting any younger, and a bird in the hand and all... I know that I advised you to "jump!" You can still do that. It's gotta be good to know that you have a net. Really glad to hear (read) the upbeat tone in your post. Life is good. It is REALLY good!
Dadman
I'm reasonably confident I'm making the right decision, but I still have some serious concerns about how my current Intel business group has been managed over the past couple of years and the possibility that what I (and many others I work with) view as borderline cruel management practices will continue. I'm taking the calculated risk that it will not since our management structure is also being overhauled and the Director who oversaw this long, difficult process is taking a new assignment in just a few more weeks. If I could leave Intel and not worry about replacing my income and health insurance then I most certainly would. But since, like I said, I will have to find a new job relatively quickly I might as well take the one that is in hand. If the organizational churn settles down I anticipate my job might actually become enjoyable again. Bold risks, I think, are better suited for those who don't have others who depend on them. I do and I take that responsibility very seriously...