Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Yep, I did it again...

By CosmicConservative
Another classic example of my compulsive behavior has just been demonstrated. I blame the reality show "Top Shot." (FWIW, so does the Cosmic Wife) Two weeks ago I didn't even know I "needed" a new pellet gun. Now I have one. Because... well.... I need one. Really. I do. To be fair, I've been contemplating getting a pellet rifle for some time. Ever since I bought my pellet pistol last year. The reason is pest control. I bought the pistol to harass birds enough to deter them from pecking on our house. I also had a notion that it would work for varmints too. We have regular problems with skunks and ground squirrels on our property. For a while we had a fox in the yard which deterred other vermin and I sort of liked the fox, but it either left or died, and so now a skunk (or skunks) has moved back in. In contemplating killing the skunk I decided to look up the effectiveness of pellet guns against skunks, and that's when I learned that my nifty little Crosman 1377 pellet pistol is an awesome pellet pistol, but it would not humanely dispose of a skunk. In fact it might just piss a skunk off. And one thing you really want to avoid is a pissed-off skunk. So for a long time I sort of just forgot about it. But with the coming of Spring has come the return of the skunk problems. So while sort of randomly surfing the web on the subject of pellet pistols, after a short detour down the path of exploding pellets and other fascinating subjects, my mind drifted back to the skunk. That led to a desire to find the most reasonable purchase of a pellet gun that I could find which would be suitable for skunk-busting. Throw into the mix that I received a small cash award from work and I not only had a "need" for a pellet rifle, but I had the opportunity to purchase one more or less guilt-free. That's never a good thing. So for most of a week I spent an hour or two each night researching pellet guns. This is what I do. I can't help it. I can't just call up Bass Pro Shops and say "Hey, I've got a skunk problem and need a pellet gun for about $200, what do you recommend for skunk-killing?" Well, OK, I actually did do that. But I didn't like their answer. Because it didn't match my own research. In fact the answer I got sounded a whole lot like "We have pellet guns we like to sell. We recommend that you buy one of them. Come on in and I'll set you up!" Their "expert" couldn't even answer some of my basic questions (like which pellets were the best for which gun, what their accuracy ratings were at 10, 20 and 50 yards, and how many foot-pounds of force they delivered at impact). In the end I learned more about pellet guns than I ever really needed to know. But as is usual with me, the initial need to find a suitable pellet gun became a complete fascination with pellet gun history, technology and performance. And, in the end, I purchased the one I mentioned in a previous post. Was it the "right" one? Well, even now I am second-guessing that question. It was undeniably the best performing pellet rifle in the range that I could afford for the purpose I needed (killing skunks) according to multiple reviews and personal endorsements of acknowledged pellet gun "experts" on the web. But there's still a few things that sort of poke at my "buyer's remorse" button. See, the gun I bought is an example of what I call "mature technology". What that means is that the gun has a classic, well-proven design and is supposedly the gun with the highest quality control, the tightest tolerances and, not coincidentally, the best consistency of performance, including accuracy. But there are two things that nag at me. First, the gun is a .25 caliber pellet rifle. .25 caliber pellets are more expensive than .177 or .22 caliber pellets. They are roughly $9 for a box of 200. however, if you buy three boxes, you can get one free, so it's roughly $27 for 800 pellets if you buy them that way. (At least that's how "Pyramyd Air" sells them). That's 3.375 cents per pellet. That's more than twice what I can buy .177 pellets for. So my per-shot cost is 2-3 times what a .177 pellet would cost, and is significantly more than a .22 pellet. Since I have learned that shooting steel BBs through your pellet gun is a classic n00b mistake (which ruins the rifling on your gun) that means there will be no cheap pellet shooting. But then again, shooting 200 pellets is a pretty significant investment of time and energy into something I enjoy, so it's probably a much cheaper form of entertainment than, for example, golf. The other thing that nags at me is a technology and design thing. See... break barrel pellet rifles work by using the barrel as a lever to compress a steel spring. The spring holds all the energy and when you pull the trigger it causes a piston to compress a huge amount of air into the firing chamber, resulting in the pellet being blown down the barrel of the gun. So, back to the "mature technology" thing. This sort of mechanical engineering is ancient. There are no mysteries involved in the engineering of a device which compresses a spring, and uses the spring to drive a piston down a cylinder. This sort of technology has been around for two hundred years. Steel used in such springs has a lifetime measured in decades if treated properly. They are as reliable as, well, steel springs. In fact there isn't much that is as reliable as steel springs. The physical forces involved are known to the fifteenth decimal place. The same is true for pistons and cylinders. It's all about the tolerances of construction and the seals. Compressing air in spring-loaded cylinders has entire text books written about the subject. The end result is that the theory involved is as well understood as it is possible to be. So making a functioning mechanical device using the technology becomes an exercise in choosing materials, creating parts with extremely high tolerances and constructing them reliably and well. And that's what Hatsan is known for. Hatsan is like the Mercedes Benz of air guns. They are a Chinese company, but they use German steel parts in their guns. Their quality control practices are Demming-inspired. They make excellent air guns. But Crosman has recently developed a new technology to replace the steel spring in air rifles. They call it "Nitro piston" technology. Their new top of the line air gun models use a nitrogen gas filled piston instead of a spring. There are many inherent design advantages to using a nitrogen gas piston instead of a spring. The most obvious is that springs create shock waves when they uncoil, producing violent physical effects that are not restricted to the single dimension of the spring's travel. You get secondary and tertiary vibrations in all dimensions. This compromises accuracy when used in an air gun. Current technology guns attempt to control this by using dampeners and having high tolerances for the parts, but there is only so much you can do. But a nitrogen gas piston has virtually no secondary or tertiary decompression effects. Plus the nitrogen gas suffers no stress fatigue. You can keep a nitro-piston gun cocked for hours or days, something that would more or less ruin a steel-spring based gun. Gas pistons are also more predictable and smoother in their decompression than a steel spring. With all of that going for them, you'd think that nitro-piston guns would seriously out-perform steel spring guns. But that's not true because there are many other factors involved in gun accuracy. Plus the nitro-piston technology itself is still improving. So for now a well-built steel spring gun still outperforms a nitro-piston gun. But I predict that within five years steel springs will be relegated to the bargain bin pellet guns of the future. So, the NEXT gun I buy....

Comments (3)

CosmicConservative
Sigh... reading this original post from April 11 when I first ordered my Hatsan 125 break-barrel pellet gun is sort of like going back and reading some of my high school essays it's so naive and optimistic... So, after going through three Hatsans and returning them all, and then upping the ante by several hundred dollars, my new PCP Air Force Condor "Bounty Hunter" package was shipped from Pyramyd Air this morning. I probably will get it in about a week. Too late for July 4... but still less than three months from my first purchase attempt. LOL, yeah, I first ordered a pellet gun on April 11, and it's now June 29 and I STILL don't have a pellet gun! Sheeesh...
Greg
In essence a nitro piston is a single pump pneumatic. Air being 80% nitrogen I'm assuming the nitro nonsense is Dodge style hype and reliability (lack of). To suggest there is no stress like on a springer is nonsense. It's a compressed air chamber under considerable pressure. Like most pneumatics the air will eventually leak hence their lack of popularity. Sorry when I see top manufacturers like Weihrach and Diana sticking with springers I think I will to. A good springer will last a lifetime and are fairly easy to fix if something does break (never happened yet in 20 years of airgunning). Even if your O rings go it's fairly simple to improvise. Good luck trying that with a high pressure air chamber. So if you thinking survival think again. Springers have been around for years and are rock solid reliable. My Diana 34 is still going strong 20 yrs later and has taken more game than I care to mention. I just bought a new one!
CosmicConservative
Greg, I think I understand the innards of break-barrel guns, both steel spring and nitro pistons, so I feel pretty confident that I understand the benefits/drawbacks of each design. The reason I would not consider a nitro-piston a "single pump pneumatic" is because the nitrogen in the piston is already under considerable pressure before you cock the gun. It's only because it's already compressed that it can deliver the power needed to shoot the pellet. There isn't any practical means to develop enough air pressure to shoot a pellet with sufficient force to be deadly to varmints from a single pump from normal atmospheric pressure (forget that I live at 8,500 feet where the air is about 70% as thick as sea level). The major benefits of the nitro piston are twofold. First the nitrogen never suffers stress fatigue, so you can keep it cocked without fear of ruining the "spring." Second, it has far fewer (almost none) secondary vibration effects. The first makes the gun much easier to hunt with, the second makes it less sensitive to the hold, meaning it is easier for people like me to shoot accurately. The benefits of the steel spring are also twofold. First it is still just easier and cheaper to make more powerful springs than nitro pistons. Second the spring does not suffer from loss of pressure through leaky seals. Just don't leave it cocked for long periods of time. In the end I decided that a pure PCP was what made the most sense to me. And I am thrilled with my Condor. I am getting dime-sized groups at 35 yards pretty consistently. The gun is more accurate than I am. And it hits hard, even on the lowest power setting. I got 60 shots without any shift of POI, so I feel like that is more than adequate for any realistic hunting scenario. Right now I think the Condor is pretty close to the perfect pellet rifle for me.