Target shooting ruminations...
By CosmicConservativeAs I mentioned in the below couple of posts on pellet guns, I've been looking at dozens of Youtube video reviews of pellet guns. Pellet rifles mostly, but on occasion I've checked reviews of some interesting pellet pistols as well.
In general the reviews will do target shooting as part of the review. It is quite interesting to me how consistent the target shooting "standards" seem to be. In other words, regardless of the source of the review, the standard shooting distances seem to be the same.
The bulk of the reviews I have been watching are done by one of two air gun providers, or are done by independent reviewers on their behalf. Those are "Pyramyd Air" (where I bought my gun) or "Airgun something-or-other" (I forget their name). Besides those there are a couple of guys who do reviews just because they seem to be airgun devotees.
All of the reviewers I've been watching use almost exactly the same equipment. There's this thing called a "Chrony" which measures the speed of a projectile, and all of them have one. The Chrony is a small box with two sets of "antennae" that look like nothing more than old portable TV "rabbit ear" antennae. You shoot through them and it calculates the speed by how fast it passes each set of antennae. Or that's what it seems anyway.
They also have ammunition scales that measure things in 'grains'. Pellets for pellet guns seem to range from about 4 grains to well over 20 grains for the largest pellets.
They also use a webcam set up to align their sights so that you are looking through the gun's scope as it is shooting. Although sometimes the reviewer will instead set the webcam up to record the target as the pellets hit instead.
What surprised me was not that they all had the same equipment, nor that they all recorded results from the same distances. No, what surprised me were the ACTUAL DISTANCES that they all used.
Generally speaking these rifles were tested at 10 and 20 yards. Every now and then, if the reviewer was interested enough, they might do a 50 yard test. Once, and only once, I saw a review that covered 100 yards.
TEN YARDS!? Really? Using a scope on a bench-mounted RIFLE? Thirty FEET? I guess I can see testing a PISTOL at ten yards, but what's the point of doing a rifle test at 10 yards? Jeeze, if you are 10 yards from your target, using a rifle scope starts to introduce parallax effects. I sure as heck wouldn't sight my scope in at ten yards.
Twenty yards is at least somewhat reasonable. Sixty feet. Still seems like a crazy close distance for a scope. I would think a scope would become useful more at about fifty yards. And required at more like a hundred yards. But the testing is all done at 10 and 20 yards.
At that range these pellet rifles were generally putting groups together that were no more than a few inches, and the best rifles were putting groups the size of a dime. Considering that you can't just keep a pellet gun clamped in place on the bench (because of the cocking or pumping needed to fire another shot), that's still probably more impressive in terms of the reviewer being able to repeatedly sight the gun than how the gun itself might actually perform.
Virtually all of the pellet rifles I have been looking at are of a design called "break barrel." The term is derived from the pumping design which uses the barrel itself as the pumping/cocking mechanism. The barrel "breaks" just in front of the breech and is levered downwards to compress a powerful spring in the body of the gun.
This is a totally different mechanism than the old standard multi-pump mechanism, such as my Crosman 1377 pistol uses. Multi-pump designs use a compression valve to drive compressed air into a receptacle which holds the air until you fire the gun. Multiple pumps drive more and more air into the receptacle, up to a point where a release valve bleeds off any excess air you pump in. When you pull the trigger on a multi-pump, all that really happens is that the air is released from the receptacle and expands into the barrel behind the BB or pellet, pushing it out the barrel. So there is virtually no recoil. But multi-pump designs are self-limited by the amount of air you can force into the receptacle, as well as how much pressure those compression valves can withstand. The result is that most multi-pump pellet guns top out at about 750 feet per second for a standard .177 caliber pellet. Which is respectable, and more than adequate for target shooting, plinking and very small game (birds, rats, small snakes..) but they don't really work well for larger small game (rabbits, squirrels, large birds, possums, etc.)
A "break barrel" design is totally different. Instead of pumping air into a compression valve, break barrel designs work much more like the old Daisy Red Ryder BB gun. They compress a spring. When you pull the trigger, the spring releases and drives a piston forward at high speed and great force so that a single massive blast of compressed air is forced into the barrel, expelling the projectile.
This sort of design can drive much more powerful bursts of air into the barrel, and can do so with only one cock of the gun (although it's a pretty good pull, usually around thirty pounds to do the cocking).
But there are drawbacks to the break barrel design. The most immediate drawback is that the release of the spring is a violent physical act, which jars the entire gun. Some of these break barrel designs kick more than a .22 rifle. But because the projectile is moving much slower than a .22 bullet, the violent motion imparted from the spring is acting on the gun while the pellet is still in the barrel. That means the barrel is moving slightly as the pellet leaves the gun.
So, how can such a gun be accurate at all? You might ask.
Well, some of them aren't. If you get sloppy with your spring alignment and the tolerances of your internal moving parts aren't tight, you get all sorts of three dimensional chaotic movement, and the result is that it's quite literally impossible to produce a decent grouping since each pellet leaves the gun with random lateral or vertical momentum. So the best guns are the ones which have the tightest tolerances and the best damping of the internal forces.
But even then, there is still some movement of the barrel. So how can you shoot straight?
The answer is that the spring's impact on the gun may be violent and may be impossible to stop just by holding the gun tightly, but it is repeatable. in other words, the spring reacts the same way every time.
So if you hold the gun lightly and let it do its little dance as the pellet is traveling through the barrel, then the final result on the pellet itself is very close to identical. But you have to let the forces flow through the gun, you can't fight it.
Most rifle hunters have been taught to hold their rifle tightly to their shoulder and to prepare for and overcome the gun's recoil. Trying that with a break barrel pellet gun will do nothing but guarantee poor accuracy. To shoot one right requires what they call the "artillery hold." They call it that because the problem that the internal spring introduces for weapon stability during fire is very similar to the same problem that artillery pieces have always had (and still have today). In fact if you watch a slow-motion video of a 4" battleship gun firing, you'll see exactly what I'm talking about. Those guns actually move a few FEET when they fire. But they can be fired accurately because that movement of the barrel is understood and planned for in the firing of the gun. It's predictable, so it is just factored into the aiming of the gun.
So, the bottom line is that shooting a break barrel pellet gun means having to learn an entirely new means of shooting the weapon. The technique is usually taught as using one hand to balance the gun, usually right past the breech, letting it rest freely on your flat palm, then using the other hand to pull the trigger, without gripping the stock any more than you have to, and just letting the gun jerk when you pull the trigger.
It's going to be interesting to see if I can master the technique, since my whole life shooting rifles I've been taught to do it almost exactly the opposite.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.