Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Erasing the Holocaust

By Dadman
More intimidation, more insanity, more surrender in the U.K...
DAILY MAIL-Teachers drop the Holocaust to avoid offending Muslims Schools are dropping the Holocaust from history lessons to avoid offending Muslim pupils, a Government backed study has revealed. It found some teachers are reluctant to cover the atrocity for fear of upsetting students whose beliefs include Holocaust denial.
If you ask me teachers need to be challenging students whose beliefs include Holocaust denial, not appeasing them. What if they denied killing innocent people was wrong? I ask that somewhat tongue-in-cheek, but the sad truth is many if not most of these young Holocaust deniers - taught to deny no doubt by their parents and imams - are also being taught that killing 'infidels' is justified by Allah. It's a mindset that the public schools in Britain should proactively challenge, not ignore as if it doesn't exist. Stories like this should leave little doubt the ghost of Neville Chamberlain is alive and well, working its appeasement mischief in the hearts of every squishy liberal and obsequious bureaucrat in the Western world. Stay tuned for WWIII...

Comments (21)

pace
The Islamic community in the UK has become very powerful, very quickly. As my brother (who still resides there) observes; for the most part, the politicians are now too fearful to put a stop to the insanity. Or even to acknowledge that there is a problem. The more radical Islamic elements will go so far as to deny UK sovereignty over Britain, and view the island as their own to do with as they see fit - such as establishing their own theocratic rule of law. For the most part the pols apologize and appease, while those who do not are labelled as jingoists and racists. This ranks right up there with prohibiting citizens from flying the Union flag during the Queen's Jubilee celebrations, because it might offend their Muslim neighbors!
Drax
It's sad. Here, we fail to observe Pearl Harbor Day, VE Day, VJ Day for much the same reasons. What are kids taught as to why the Civil War was fought? "An Inconvenient Truth," is being taught in School. Professors who TEACH that the U.S. Government was behind 9-11. Active and passive revisionism as far as the eye can see...
pace
I think it goes far beyond sad. I think the UK is setting a very dangerous example.
Dadman
Pace: Do you think there is any hope that Europe can reverse this trend in any significant way? This kind of stuff frankly makes my sleep restless; I can more or less see where it's leading and it's not a good place for those who love freedom and liberty...
Drax
Of course it's more than sad. It's more than dangerous. It's earth-shaking, armageddon inducing myopia. It is government sponsored and/or sanctioned ignorance. It is society's "leaders" purposefully erasing history for every reason but the right one (if there is a right one): fear, appeasement, attempt to get or keep votes, whatever. We are attempting to, as a country, fight a war in Iraq and Afghanistan (and elsewhere under the radar), a war which is directed against these Islamic fundamentalists (and those who exploit them) without our leaders having the guts to say what is reality: this is a war between Islam and the rest of us. We try to assuage the feelings of the "mainstream Muslims" by studiously NOT saying this truth. But, what we say doesn't matter in the reality--THEY (the "radical Muslims") know EXACTLY what war they're fighting. It does matter here, though. How do you mobilize a country when the real reason they're fighting is constantly obscured behind cowardly "wiggle words" which are uttered out of (pick your poison of the many reasons....Political Correctness, fear, appeasement, Ignorance, whatever). It's gonna get a LOT worse before it gets better.
CosmicConservative
I've said it before, and I'll say it again. The world is in a desperate race between the forces of ignorance trying to take us back to a theocratic dark ages, and the forces of freedom which are leading us to a world we won't even recognize. There are a lot of people wondering if either side should win.
pace
Dadman: I haven't really thought too much about the issue within the context of mainland Europe, as I believe that the problem is most pronounced in the UK. They continue to maintain extremely soft borders and have historically suffered from immigration related problems. I think this is one reason why the British are really struggling to assert their national identity, which has in turn fostered this overt political correctness toward Muslims. In my humble opinion, the British have never fully come to terms with the decline of the Empire and the independence of the Commonwealth nations. Growing up in the UK, one perceives some shared sense of responsibility toward the people of any nations we occupied or otherwise 'meddled in', and that the problems they face can be partially laid at our feet. Just my 2c.
pace
Oh, and as for reversing trends.. I am generally an optimist, but I think the UK has a rough road ahead. I would not be surprised if we see large scale race riots in some of their major population centers within the next ten or fifteen years. But I love my homeland and I sincerely hope I'm wrong about that.
Dadman
Pace: Interesting insight. Thanks for sharing. It seems clear to me that Western civilization is currently afflicted with a severe case of self-loathing and guilt that may just prove to be terminal...
CosmicConservative
You could make a case that the atavistic urge that is being expressed through fundamentalism in Islam, fundamentalism in Christianity, nature worship in "environmentalism," and attacks on the "establishment" by all manner of anarchists are all part of a primal urge in humans to stop the inexorable advance of technology before we lose all sight of what it means to be human. There have been a lot of books and essays written on this subject, perhaps the most famous now being "The Singularity is Near" by Kurzweil. It is not surprising to me that philosophies and religions that are fundamentally opposed to progress are getting more and more desperate as that progress looks more and more like it is going to reach a point of no return. And I don't just mean technological progress. I am also referring to the progressive liberal tendencies in politics which tend to threaten the power systems of most of these atavistic mindsets. I have thrown my lot in with progress, even though I am pretty certain that society in 100 years will be virtually unrecognizable according to current standards. I prefer that to the stagnant options offered by the atavists which will mire humanity in a lifestyle that should have died out a thousand years ago. I love my homeland too, but whether it is because it will be absorbed by a worldwide Islamic state, or will eventually be absorbed into a "progressive" world state, the steady march of history is clear that human societies tend to merge together as they are forced to coexist, and the technological forces of communication and travel are creating a situation where every culture on earth is constantly rubbing shoulders with every other culture. So it's just a matter of time before all national boundaries are either erased, or become quaint, symbolic lines useful for celebrating "diversity" or providing a local flavor of food or dancing. I don't see how to stop that without becoming atavistic ourselves. My goal has always been to try to see that our values remain the dominant ones so that when the world order is established, it is more or less comparable to our own values. That's the Gene Roddenberry solution too. He was very clear that the Star Trek universe was based on a model of a world government that grew out of the Western political tradition. I think that's the best hope we've got. But then again, if society undergoes dramatic change due to AI, nanotechnology, vastly extended human lifetimes and all the other things that seem to be on the horizon, who the heck knows what it will look like?
ams182764
"It is not surprising to me that philosophies and religions that are fundamentally opposed to progress are getting more and more desperate as that progress looks more and more like it is going to reach a point of no return." I'm a futurist myself, though a more moderate one. I don't quite believe in these points of no return or lines of demarcation. While I believe we will advance technologically, and in our understanding of the world, I'm also somewhat cautious of people who seem to expect magic from technology. (See my nanotechnology article, for example). The pace of technology is somewhat constrained by the pace of people's understanding. Some futurists get a little manic in predicting technology outpacing all human understanding. While all technology may confound some people, some technology cannot confound all people (or it wouldn't exist in the first place!). That doesn't mean I don't think the pace of advancement will continue to accelerate, I just think boundaries are a little arbitrary. Technology is ultimately something that people build, use, and maintain. It will never be a fixture in the natural world. The most intricate computer processor can still be smashed by an atavists hammer. If people stop being technically competent, technology will go away. While atavists of many stripes may be desperate, there is also a possibility that they can win (don't be too cocky, we've been fuedal or stone age for thousands of years, modern for a mere 300-500). When you look at the world, how many societies are actively inventing and pushing technology and progress forward? How many are passively trading for it and "riding the wave" as it were? And how many are in active medieval rebellion against modernity? The former are somewhat smaller than the middle and latter, IMO. I think what the atavists are in rebellion against is not so much any line of demarcation or point of technological no return. I think it's against (searching for words), the idea that the world can be understood in objective, non-mythological, non-emotional terms. I'll have to elaborate later.
ams182764
"I’m also somewhat cautious of people who seem to expect magic from technology." Hmm, in further elaboration of this point: Restoring sight to the blind used to be thought of as something that could only be accomplished by divine miracle. It was magic. It couldn't happen by any artifice of mankind, and to even entertain the thought that it could was impudent and blasphemous. I recently blogged about a medical advance that some doctors at (was it University of California? I'll have to look it up again) were making. They had created a device that interfaced with a damaged retina and sent a visual signal to the brain from a camera. They are in the process of restoring sight to the blind. The only reason that this happened is that these doctors understood the eye, understood how neurons worked, understood their device and how to make extremely small, extremely detailed, biologically clean interfaces. The only reason this could happen was because to somebody, this WASN'T magic. I don't know quite where I'm going with this, but Clarke's phrase "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" sort of stuck in my craw. To the people and society that created it, it couldn't be thought of as magic, or it couldn't exist in the first place. It had to be understood, from the smallest component to the largest function, or it couldn't be made. People who expect the world to function magically, who expect desires and emotions, either their own, or that of some diety (an angry God, or an offended, "wounded" Mother Nature for the Greens) to give rise to the behaviors of the world, will not be the ones creating and inventing new technology. I suspect that people who expect magic from technology, who are out looking for magic bullets that will bend the world to their desires without effort or thought going into it are also going to be disappointed. Before you can satisfy that desire, you first have to figure out how to do it. You then have to figure out how to build something that can do it. Whether the means at your disposal are microscopic replecators (which I'm somewhat skeptical of the feasability...), or stone axes, ropes, and levers; the responsibility of understanding the world, understanding how you will accomplish your aim cannot be abdicated. It can't be abdicated to God, and abdicating it to technology is putting the cart before the horse.
CosmicConservative
ams: I have always been a devout skeptic. And that includes my view of technology. However, I have also been a student of history and am very keen on the idea of trends that can be plotted to "predict" the future. The trends that are driving the "point of no return" both technologically and socially are well documented. They include things like the rate of major scientific advances, or the rate of information growth. When you plot these things the results are quite interesting. For hundreds of years they have been progressing exponentially. It is hard to see how they will suddenly stop progressing on that curve just because human understanding is somehow limiting them. The main reason for that is that human understanding is no longer a limiting factor. Look at a modern computer chip, for example. Such things simply could not exist if we were restricted to any single human being's ability to understand, model and fabricate it. Designing and fabricating a modern CPU chip requires the joint effort of human minds and existing computer technology. And the contribution of the computer side of this is growing with every new design, at the expense of the human side. It is not difficult to predict that within 20 years computer chips will be designing themselves. There is really a single critical component for the "Singularity" to happen. And that is true Artificial Intelligence. That is perhaps the "article of faith" that drives both sides of the debate. Some believe that AI is a myth, that intelligence is only possible in a biological being (usually of the human variety). Others believe that intelligence is the result of information processing in the brain, and that information processing can be effectively replicated in electronic systems. If those who believe it can be replicated are right, then I think the "point of no return" is a completely defensible position to take. And we're probably going to find out in our lifetimes.
Drax
The problem with following trends is the one Asimov pointed out in his Foundation series....throw one major monkey wrench into the works and all bets are off. There are many monkeys out there throwing wrenches in the works just as hard and fast as they can. Time will tell which, if any, will gum up the works.
ams182764
Well, perhaps I'm being a stick in the mud. The attitude I was reacting to (and I do tend to do this a lot) wasn't entirely yours. "There is really a single critical component for the “Singularity” to happen. And that is true Artificial Intelligence. That is perhaps the “article of faith” that drives both sides of the debate. Some believe that AI is a myth, that intelligence is only possible in a biological being (usually of the human variety). Others believe that intelligence is the result of information processing in the brain, and that information processing can be effectively replicated in electronic systems." We're a ways away from human level AI IMO (if the most useful AI even ends up resembling human intelligence in terms of the motives it is designed around). Even so, I see progress as a continuous effort, to understand, build, and maintain, as well as to suppress the darker fuedal aspects of our nature. I don't want to see us allegorically stick a flag on the shore, only to retreat and rest on our laurels. Without continuing mental effort to understand, both all the accomplishments of our forbears, and the new problems presented to us, I don't see how we would avoid a dark age, or at least a regression. In some hypothetical future where we have AI, I don't want our grandkids taught that it isn't for them to understand the world around them, that it isn't for them to care how or under what conditions they are sustained, the things that take care of them understand themselves just fine. It's all just magic. It would be fuedalism all over again without the peasants, just an airheaded class of cared-fors who lash out randomly since they have no standards of consequence or accomplishment by which to measure their decisions. What would be the difference between themselves and the atavists? Both are incapable of creating or sustaining the conditions by which this hypothetical society survives.
ams182764
"And the contribution of the computer side of this is growing with every new design, at the expense of the human side. It is not difficult to predict that within 20 years computer chips will be designing themselves." Well, computers can run algorithms to optimize a given design problem. Someone still needs to give it the problem, give it the "world model" that the problem operates off of, and understand the algorithm, even if the result is incomprehensibly complex. For a computer chip to "design itself", not merely run successive iterations on a specific optimization problem, but to actually invent new ways to set up the problem in the first place (invent ways around the limitations in the fitness points of the current design problem), it would have to have a pretty good understanding of the world (at a level of understanding approaching the human level). It would need to know what it is trying to do on a level that current design tools don't. I suppose if you turn a crank on a genetic algorithm for enough iterations, it can find all sorts of ways of optimizing parameters. You have to give it the criteria that it's aiming for though. If you hit a point where, to advance, you have to give it better models of the world, or change the criteria, you have to make an intelligent input to the problem. It would require a human, or an AI of some sort. I suppose if you want the AI to be able to do that, it has to be able to take some sort of feedback from the real world (and making sense of the world is the trick then, isn't it?), and use it to update it's world model, adjusting lower level priorities of the criteria which defines "desirable" to continue to meet the highest level basic requirements of the problem.
CosmicConservative
Drax: So, the question is, are the forces of "progress" able to overcome the monkey wrenches? For a long time the answer was "no." For the last 500 years or so the answer has been "yes." Will it become "no" again? I wonder about that. I have very odd philosophies of life, the universe and everything. And one of the key elements of my philosopy is the concept of "thresholds." The idea of a threshold is that when you cross one, you are in a different place, with different rules and different expectations. I believe that Isaac Newton effectively pushed us across one such threshold with his Laws of Physics. I may be wrong about that, but I am fairly confident that there is no going back to the dark ages now. Not entirely. Barring some global calamity such as an asteroid wiping out virtually all of civilization in one fell swoop. So in the old room we were in standard monkey wrenches could "gum up the works" but in the new room we are in, it takes a monkey wrench so big, that there may not be a monkey big enough to throw it. We'll see. Man I am the world's worst allegorist.... ams: I think you should read Kurzweil's book. It might make you see things a little differently. Maybe not. What Kurzweil is saying, and why it probably resonates so much with me, is that we are on the verge of yet another threshold, and this one is one that we can't even see over, but we are being pushed upwards toward it on an exponential tide of technological, societal and biological trends. Very few people, even in Newton's time, could have predicted the massive life-altering changes that Newton's Laws led to. It is probably fair to say that a person who lived 1,000 years ago would consider modern life to be akin to the lifestyle of gods. It is Kurzweil's belief, and my strong suspicion, that in 100 years "people" will look back on our time and say something very similar. Your description of AI in your above comment is not what Kurzweil and I are calling AI. What we are saying is that it is supremely arrogant to believe that human consciousness is somehow unique and special and cannot be duplicated in an electronic medium. Until someone can point to something happening in the human brain that cannot be explained by chemistry and physics, then I am going to assume that those processes can be replicated in an electronic or bio-electronic medium. And the result will be an intelligence that at first will be our equal. But it will not have our biological limitations. And so it will soon leave us far behind. So it isn't a case of teaching our grandkids "it isn't for them to understand the world around them." It is more precisely a case of our grandkids simply not having the mental capacity to compete with AI. Period.
ams182764
I wonder how much of our genetic code is responsible for the development of our brains? How much information does it take to form the basis to grow one? While the brain itself develops incredible complexity while iterating and interacting with the world as it develops, there is the possibility that the seed-pattern that generates it is a lot less complex. Of course, our genome is pretty big, so it could end up being monstrously complex, even at the seed level.
CosmicConservative
Most AI researchers seem to be of the opinion that the brain is a self-organizing entity, and that the "seed" you refer to is actually pretty simple. Chaos theory tells us that monstrously complex systems can arise from very simple rules iterated enough times. Even if the seed has to be "monstrously complex" that is precisely what computers are good at helping us figure out. So the more complex it is, the longer it takes us to replicate it, but all of the paths are finite so long as the complexity itself is not infinite.
Dadman
How in the world did a post on Holocaust suppression in the U.K. transmogrify into a thread on AI? Well...at least it's an interesting thread...
CosmicConservative
All roads lead to the singularity...