Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Computer dilemma

By CosmicConservative
OK, I recently did some programming work on the side, and the deal was that my reward for the work would be a new computer, since my old computer is pretty much hanging on by a thread. So now I'm at the point of fulfilling that arrangement and so am looking for a computer to buy. Because of the circumstances of the arrangement, it is far more convenient for that computer to be purchased from Dell, than from any other source. By agreement the max amount I can look to purchase the computer for is $2,000. However, it's not really the cost that is the key factor in this situation. What I need is a modern .NET capable development environment. .NET is the Windows development environment for local or web-based aplications. I have the .NET development software, but it drags my seven-year-old computer down and kicks it all over the room when I try to do things like run the development environment, run SQL Enterprise Manager, run SQL Analyzer, run Firefox and/or Internet Explorer and run Excel, MS Word and/or Visio all at the same time. I mean, my old computer can DO that, but it ain't pretty. So, I am having two fundamental dilemmas to solve. #1. Should I look for a laptop or a desktop? In general desktops are far more powerful for the same cost than laptops, and allow you to do things like add memory or peripherals much more easily than a laptop. But laptops are so convenient. The question I have is whether the modern laptops using core duos are capable of handling such a heavy load. I must admit that I am leaning towards a desktop because of the nature of the work I tend to do on the computer. So this really boils down to convenience vs. power, and ONLY if the convenient option has the bare minimum power to handle the load without, as my current system does, sometimes making me wait up to ten seconds or more for the words I just typed into the keyboard to show up on the screen. #2. Core 2 duo vs. Xeon processors (I guess I should throw in the AMD option here too, except that Dell seems to be heavily skewed towards Intel as their CPU option for both laptop and desktop). The Xeon options all seem to be much more expensive than the Core 2 duo. But if there is a reason for that, and that reason would mean better performance in the above described situation, then perhaps the higher cost (which actually translates into less RAM, less hard disk memory, and reduced options for sound and video cards) is worth it. In general I have found that computers designed to operate as "game systems" have been the most powerful systems for any CPU and memory intensive processes, such as running a bunch of compilers and database programs. So I tend to look at game systems as a sort of "performance benchmark" to compare things to. The trade-off with a game system is usually that they have more invested in video and sound cards than pure processing and memory, so they tend to cost more since the minimum processor and memory configurations are still pretty high. So, any advice on this would be appreciated. I'm sort of stuck right now between trying to decide between one of the Dell home business models (the "Dimension" line, which oddly enough is what I have now, just a seven year old one) and beef it up, or take one of the Xeon workstations, with limited memory and peripherals, or one of their mid-level game machines. Or a laptop, of course. Thanks in advance.

Comments (8)

Dadman
You definitely want to stay away from the AMD systems...
ams182764
I had an AMD processor once (granted, it was 5 years ago, and their company has probably changed radically since) that needed a software patch for a hardware problem in fabrication.
CosmicConservative
That's it? That's the advice? "Don't buy AMD?" And from Dadman what else could I expect? ;) Sigh... I'm going to give them a call. It used to be on Dell's site that every model had a "configure" button that let you modify the components of the system, but now I can't find that on most of their offers. I don't know if that's because I'm doing something wrong or if there has been a policy change at Dell to push more cookie-cutter computers to save money.
Boyd
You should see a green Continue button (or Continue with Something) on most pages. This walks you through the process of configuring the computer. Okay, with that aside, I have a three year old Dell Latitude D800 laptop with a 1.7 GHz Pentium M processor which originally came with 1 GB of RAM, upgraded to 2 GB a year ago, and it works fine for me (I'm a software developer for a consulting company). Builds don't take an excessive amount of time, I can have a grunch of stuff (technical term) running at the same time, and nothing seems too slow. Regarding laptop vs desktop, if you want the convenience of a laptop, performance shouldn't be an issue. Like you, I like the ease of adding stuff to the desktop, but for my work, where I go from workplace to workplace frequently, I just have to have a laptop. A bigger consideration is which OS to get. With XP, you can run Visual Studio 2003 and 2005. Vista will only run 2005, so if you need to do any work for .NET Framework 1.1 or earlier, you have to use XP. Or, Windows Server 2003 would be an option, too, but I can't think of a situation where I'd want to do that.
Boyd
Oh, and I can't see why you'd want a Xeon. I don't think you need the power, and certainly not at the cost. And while I have no personal experience with AMD processors, I wouldn't avoid them. The trade rags I subscribe to put AMD and Intel on pretty much the same level, and in some cases, they put AMD ahead, but that race switches back and forth fairly frequently.
CosmicConservative
Boyd: What you describe is what I recall, but that's not what I see now. Now I see a green "config" button that just takes me to three options that don't have any configuration button of their own. SOME of the systems have the old configuration capability, and at least one of them had both the old and the new style, depending on which way you chose the system. But the ones I am looking at fundamentally don't allow me to modify CPU, Memory or other things. I had already planned on getting XP Pro so I can keep using .NET 2003. I haven't yet upgraded to 2005 and don't think I want to since the system I have been developing FOR is not upgrading and I don't want to deal with compatibility issues. As much as I am embarrassed to admit it, a large part of my "desktop vs. laptop" dilemma is driven by the question of "am I going to play games on this thing?" Now I rarely play games today. But in the past I have gotten into games pretty heavily. I bought my wife a laptop a few years ago, and it was pretty much state of the art. When I decided to start playing an online MMORPG, I was unable to play it on her computer, but with a simple video card upgrade I was able to play it on my much older desktop system. Also I was unable to plug my guitar into her laptop to record, but my sound card allowed me to record to my desktop.
Boyd
Well, Cosmic, I use a different computer to play World of Warcraft. :) Regarding the Dell web site, I agree that they've made it much less intuitive than it used to be. Or maybe I'm stuck in the old ways of doing things. I'd just say keep clicking on green buttons, and don't forget to look at the top of the page for the button. Here's the process I used: On their main page, I hover over the laptop and select Home & Home Office menu selection. On the next page, I click on the green Choose button under the XPS. Next page, click on the green More Details button under the XPS 1210. Next page, click on the green Continue button. Next page, click on the green Continue & Select Services button for one of the computers. Next page, click on the green Choose button for one of the options. Now you're in the configuration section. You keep or change the selection, then click on the green Go To Next Component button. Lather, rinse, repeat. When you finally work your way through all of their multitudinous selections, you'll end up on a page that lists everything you've selected, with an Edit link by each one to make changes. It's a lot more painful than it used to be.
Dadman
AMD chips are to computers what buffalo chips are to pastures... As an Intel employee, I know on which side my bread is buttered... heh...