Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Book of Killed Cartoons

By Dadman
There are some rumblings in the editorial cartoon world today. Conspicuously absent from a new book edited by David Wallis, "Killed Cartoons" , is a Doug Marlette cartoon rendered in 2002 entitled "What would Mohammed Drive?" At the time, the cartoon was pulled off a website and subsequently barred from print publication when the prospective publisher, the Tallahassee Democrat, received thousands of raging e-mails and death threats. Now, the cartoon is being killed again by the publishers of Wallis' book, Norton. You can see Marlette's controversial cartoon here. The subtitle of Wallis' book is: "Casualties of the War on Free Expression". Now, ironically, Norton Publishing is guilty of pulling the trigger and inflicting the wounds... Kathleen Parker has written a column on what is going on with this cartoon and she makes some great points...
... Many doubtless would agree with Norton's decision, figuring that the possibility of mortal threat is a pretty good reason not to publish a controversial cartoon. But, in fact, it is the very reason to publish. ... Instead, by capitulating to intimidation (even if we call it sensitivity), we embolden the forces that have no interest in freedom. We telegraph to Islamist totalitarians, whose ultimate goal is subjugation of the West, that death threats and riots will silence us into submission - the literal meaning of "Islam." In the country that helped midwife free speech into civilization, that may be the definition of irresponsible.
Couldn't have said it any better myself. Doug Marlette had this to say about his experience with murderous Muslim rage...
I was used to negative reactions from religious interest groups, but not the kind of sustained violent intensity of the Islamic threats. The nihilism and culture of death of a religion that sanctions suicide bombers and issues fatwas on people who draw funny pictures is certainly of a different order and fanatical magnitude than the protests of our home-grown religious true believers.
What I wonder is how successful will Islamist intimidation continue to be. So far they seem to have everyone shaking in their boots...except, perhaps, a few brave cartoonists.

Comments (6)

CosmicConservative
One has to wonder about the basic confidence and security of any religion that feels threatened by a cartoon. Much like the Soviet Union was, I think most of the Islamist swagger and bluster is bluff, not real threat. But that's always how bullies get their way. It is up to us to punch this particular bully in the nose, which is exactly what we are doing, and the rest of the world is simply saying "a fight, a fight, you shouldn't be fighting!!" Without regard to whether the fight is worth having.
Dadman
I think Harry Reid has already declared that winning in Iraq is not worth one more drop of American blood. We know liberals rarely think any fight is worth having. They rely on others to do the heavy lifting...
Drax
The problem is that some of those who threaten do kill, making the threats of those who "might not" kill as effective as a threat from one who does....especially when it becomes "news" and you never know who will decide to martyr himself by taking out you and your family. The protests and angry letters to the editor may come from "mainstream Muslims," but they KNOW that their words will reach the ears of someone who may very well strap a bomb onto himself and wait outside your front door.....and don't give one rat's behind that this is so.
Dadman
Drax: True. You have the Muslim radicals who are little more than blood-thirsty murderers, and you seem to have a billion sympathizers who turn a blind eye to the atrocities being committed in the name of their religion. In this world Muslim moderation is synonymous with faint praise for barbaric acts of wanton violence against innocents...
Drax
"In this world Muslim moderation is synonymous with faint praise for barbaric acts of wanton violence against innocents… " Well put.