Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Supreme Court rules that CO2 is pollution

By CosmicConservative
... and therefore can be regulated.
Split court rules against Bush on greenhouse gases - CNN.com WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court ordered the federal government on Monday to take a fresh look at regulating carbon dioxide emissions from cars, a rebuke to Bush administration policy on global warming. In a 5-4 decision, the court said the Clean Air Act gives the Environmental Protection Agency the authority to regulate the emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases from cars.
This is going to become a problem when suits are generated for CO2 being produced from things like farming or ranching. Or breathing.

Comments (5)

ams182764
Now when did the Supreme court get the authority to sanction agencies to regulate things? Isn't that a function of the executive branch?
Rick Larson
About time. The new economy will include carbon credits. This will be a solid financial foundation for renewable energy and the manufacture of devices that harvest these free clean energies..
CosmicConservative
Rick: It is always interesting to me when someone presents an opinion that I consider to be 180 degrees away from common sense. And you've done it twice here. First, what is the "new economy"? If it includes "carbon credits" what other fantasy products or services will it provide? Radiation offsets? If you pay enough money someone will absorb radioactive materials somewhere so you can sleep better nights in the, no doubt, erroneous belief that you are somehow "radiation neutral"? What other modern "indulgences" will the "new economy" include? Murder offsets? How do you suppose this fantasy economy made up of "products" and "services" that are nothing more than feel-good get-out-of-hell free cards is going to provide ANY financial foundation, much less a "solid" one? Are you aware of how "carbon offsets" work? Did you realize that the entire concept of "planting a tree to absorb CO2" is, at best, simply a way to "offset" your "carbon footprint" to your children when the tree inevitably dies or is burned in a fire? The CO2 ends up back in the air, all you've done is RENT some CO2 offsets. How is it possible that you, an obviously intelligent person, can fall for this fantasy, utopian bullhockey?
Rick Larson
No, it is you who have fallen into the trap of believing fossil fuels do not pollute and will supply the world with energy forever. And, carbon credits are not the new economy, but a means to an end. The new economy will be filled with manufacturers producing wind turbines, solar panels, electric/hydrogen cars, ect., and many, many installers and maintainers of the same. More important, as a slowing of the flow of capital being paid to those countries with which we import these fossil fuels. By the way, capital that is needed to ramp-up this new economy. One more even better consequence of the new economy: cheap clean energy as a legacy to our children.
CosmicConservative
Rick: Where have I said that fossil fuels do not pollute? Obviously they do. The question isn't whether or not they do, the question is what are the consequences of that pollution. On a planet where one volcano spews almost exactly the same sort of pollutants into the air in amounts equalling millions or billions of automobiles, I'm not convinced that pollution from cars is going to destroy the world. In my other response to you I pointed out the ignorance of using "electric cars" to reduce CO2 emissions so I'll deal with your other utopian idealism here. Solar panels are grossly inefficient means of producing energy, even at the individual home level. Attempting to use solar panels to run an energy economy can easily be calculated out to reveal that the U.S. would have to blanket an entire state the size of Utah with solar cells to equal what we get from coal and natural gas. While they are getting more efficient, there is a maximum energy capacity that is driven by the radiation density of the land devoted to them. People who think solar panels are the solution to our energy problem are woefully ignorant of how much energy our economy needs. The same can be said for wind turbines, geothermal energy and tidal energy. They are all finite sources of energy and if they were ever tapped to the point that they provided energy comparable to our current needs, the resultant drain of energy out of the environment could have dramatic weather or climate impacts of their own. There is this old concept of "TANSTAAFL" (There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch). Which is closely related to the Law of Unintended Consequences. Now, solar power becomes quite possible if you think of ways to maxmize the energy density, and there are ways to do that. One of the most compelling ways is to put massive solar collectors in space where they can BE the size of Utah and not cause any problems for anyone. Then you can microwave beam the energy to earth for use. I notice your list did not include nuclear energy, either fission or fusion. I find that interesting. By the way, if you think that carbon offsets are going to provide any measurable capital for research into new energy, much less enough energy to actually make a difference in this area, you are far more optimistic about both the generosity of human beings, and the altruism of organizations than I am. The vast majority of the money being paid for such things as carbon offsets is going to end up as swimming pools and mansions for the elites who set them up and profit from them. Altruism has always been a poor business model Rick. Did you know they are building the first fusion power plant in Europe that is expected to actually generate more power than it uses? I'm crossing my fingers on this, because if it works, we may be seeing exactly the beginning of the new economy you are talking about Rick. And it will be one based on Fusion, not on windmills.