I know I'm a pretty strange person. But how strange I am is sometimes only revealed even to me when my brain takes a hard, sharp turn out of normal life for no discernable reason...
That's what happened today. Or really, it started last night.
I just got fed up with my office/hobby room. Over time it had acquired so much junk that it was simply bursting at the seams. My compulsive pursuit of newborn interests tends to act like a giant junk magnet, and I just pull stuff into the room by the bucket load, but nothing ever goes out. This tends to continue until I start having visions of the TV crew from "Hoarders" showing up.
So for the past day I've been boxing up junk and hauling it out of my room, probably to end up in a storage unit as we start seriously trying to sell our house next spring. Here are the things I've been dragging out of my room...
Old computers. Old hardware. Old electronic equipment. I had two shoe boxes full of old floppy disks. I don't even have a SINGLE computer in the house anymore (and I've got something like a dozen computers here) that can read a floppy disk anymore. A dot matrix printer. My Apple Newton. My original Macintosh (OK, I correct myself, I DO have a single computer that can still read floppy disks, but it can ONLY read floppy disks...). Games by the dozens. Sometimes multiple copies of the same games. When and where did I get a Pokemon version of Monopoly? And why do I have two identical boxes of Scrabble?
I've got three huge boxes waiting to go into the garage now (I can't put them in the garage because the Cosmic Wife had a similar urge to clean out the garage, so I can't put anything in the garage, including the car, until we get the garage all cleaned out.) They are jam-packed full of stuff that I still think is too important to throw away or try to dump on some unsuspecting school or church. And my room is still full of crap!
Model airplanes, calendars, jigsaw puzzles, entire collections of magazines (Papier, the Origami magazine, Sky and Telescope, Outdoor Photography...) a veritable library of programming books (Linux, C#, HTML, XML, XSLT, Java, Java, Java, C, C++, hell I've even got a PASCAL programming book in here!) I have an entire shelf full of D&D gaming books going back to the old version 1 of the game. Not to mention four or five notebooks full of old campaign notes, maps and NPC sheets...
I've got three boxes of LEGOS! One is a huge box that I bought for a work team building exercise years ago. Radios, watches, iPods (yes IPodS, plural. An original 40G model that still has a hard drive, and two versions of Nanos), iPod accessories, photographs, cameras, telescopeS (again, yes, plural, I have three telescopes just in THIS ROOM, I have two more in the walk in bedroom closet..)
Paints, clay, foam poster board, foam sheets, bags of rocks (yes, I have three different bags of rocks in the room... two are for making terrain for my gaming, and one is a bunch of flint and obsidian that I have been using to make arrow and spear heads as well as one sweeeet piece of obsidian that I am determined one day to turn into a knife blade).
Oh, did I mention my guitars? Three of those in the room.... oops, no, I can't count. Four. I have another one downstairs.... And music books, amplifier RCA jacks and cords, music stand, guitar cases, tuners, metronomes...
Two entire shelfs full of cartoon books, Calvin & Hobbes (eight books, plus the still shrink-wrapped collectors full set of strips), Peanuts, BC, Pogo, Bloom County, Tumbleweeds, Doonesbury... heck I've got over a dozen Doonesbury books alone...
Then there's all the tools. Why I have an entire set of socket wrenches, two hammers, a rechargable drill, allen wrenches... At least I KNOW why I have the Dremmel tool, that's for working on my miniatures....
Oh, did I say miniatures? I'm not even going to bore you with the extent of my miniatures that are overflowing the room...
I've been at it all day and I'm still not seeing daylight. I just uncovered a bunch of old papers including a bunch of report cards going back to third grade, the entire set of paperwork for my Close-Up trip to Washington back in 1977, every article I ever got published, two games I created and tried to market, and the rules for three more I never did market, a box of old letters from ex-girlfriends...
This room is like some sort of bizarre archaeological dig of my life. It's downright frightening....
Oh well, I have to get back to it. I've got three boxes and a couple bags of old origami to figure out what to do with....
So... I admit it. I, with my 305 page first draft of a novel, which I have edited and rewritten and tweaked, yes, I thought my work was likely the most complete and most compelling of the writing that we would encounter in the novel writing workshop.
But the third sample arrived from another group member last night, and I just finished reading it.
It. Is. Awesome. It reads like a warped cyberpunk version of Kurt Vonnegut on acid. It is a wild ride through a world far more alien and bizarre than mine. It's sixteen pages that shock, amuse, alarm and engage you. I hesitate to say it, but it stinks of genius.
I am truly humbled.
MR: Red Lemonade allows people to view free of charge complete manuscripts of books you have for sale. You’ve mentioned that having access to the full text online will help readers make up their minds and commit to buying a hard copy. This view differs from a general reluctance of publishers to post complete works online.
RN: Exactly. With the vast majority of books, the problem that most people have is they don’t know whether it’s going to be worth their time to read it. There are a tiny handful of books, in the case of each person, where they can be sure they want to read them. The reality is that I don’t think, in fact, there are a huge number of people reading our books for free online that have made a decision about whether to buy it. I mean there is probably a small number that are doing it for that reason and that number may increase, but I believe the number is smaller than has occurred to people because publishers refuse to do it. But what we’ve very clearly demonstrated by putting it for free online is that reading the book online has absolutely no negative impact on sales. Why in fact would it?
I'm not sure if I have previously posted that I am taking an 8 week novel writing workshop. I'm too lazy to look back to see. We have just finished week 3.
Part of the workshop (the biggest part, apparently) is having each writer submit a 15 page sample of their work which the rest of the group then reads and comments upon. I volunteered to go first, so last night we had our first critique session and chapters 1-3 of "Warrior" were up for critique from a group of ten folks I barely know and have only interacted with in the workshop.
The rules of engagement for the critique session are that the writer is not allowed to respond to any comment or even to talk at all until all of the critiques are finished. So you have to sit there on the hot seat taking notes while the results of pouring your heart onto pages are examined and analyzed from ten different perspectives. Really an uncomfortable and exposed situation to be in. There's no place to hide and since you can't rebut, you have to just accept the criticism and move on to let the next person critique.
To summarize the results, here are the things that were identified as problems by more than one of the group:
1. Not enough detail in my descriptions of the environment. This led to readers not being sure they were picturing events accurately.
2. Colloquialism and casual sentence structure in dialog. Some felt this was too "modern" and detracted from the stone age pre-industrial culture.
3. Not enough detail in describing my characters, and too many characters being introduced too early and at once. This coupled with the unusual names left readers confused about roles and relationships.
4. Some minor technical criticisms about specific sentence structure habits that editors don't like.
5. Lack of clarity around the obvious conflict between the protagonist and his older brother, exascerbated by the lack of clarity on the age of the two.
On the positive side, everyone said they enjoyed the read and wanted to read more. I'm sure some were just being nice, but some seemed very sincere about that. I figure that's got to be good.
The class instructor/facilitator does not provide his feedback in class. He dissects your writing in an email and sends it to you privately. I received his late last night (which kept me up later than I should have). His critiques were very specific about structural things, points of view, voice and story.
I came away from the experience more positively motivated than I thought I would. Everyone had specific parts of the story that they really liked, and some of the comments were dowright embarrassing they were so complimentary. Almost every criticism and suggestion for improvement was already on my list of fixes for the rewrite, so that made me feel like I had a fairly good sense of my own work and its weaknesses. That's very encouraging to me since it gives me some confidence that I am somewhat effective at identifying weaknesses in my own work.
The one thing that surprised me were comments about the casual, colloquial nature of the dialog. Some found that to be too "modern" and felt that it broke the spell of the story. I did it deliberately though because I felt like the more stilted, older style of speech was like hitting a literary speed bump every time someone said "I can not do this." or "You will need to do that." Instead of "I can't do this" or "You'll need to do that." The characters don't speak English so I don't see any reason I should translate their fictional language into archaic speech in English. I want the dialog to flow and I want the reader to be engaged in the story and I still feel that the stilted, formal approach just jars the reader.
But I am going to think about it...
Bottom line is I've got a ton of rewriting to do. A ton. Probably as much rewriting as I've done writing so far.
Sigh... I've commented on the sorry state of modern particle physics before and how I thought they were a dog chasing their own tail...
Now some leading physicists seem to be agreeing with what I've been saying for almost 20 years now.
And, after spending TRILLIONS of dollars and squandering the greatest scientific minds of a generation in a fruitless search for validation of "String Theory" those physicists are calling it an "exciting time" for physics because of the potential for new directions to come out of the realization that they've been chasing their own tail for 20 years.
You can't make this stuff up, and if you could, people wouldn't believe it.
Scientists chasing a particle they believe may have played a vital role in creation of the universe indicated on Monday they were coming to accept it might not exist after all.
But they stressed that if the so-called Higgs boson turns out to have been a mirage, the way would be open for advances into territory dubbed "new physics" to try to answer one of the great mysteries of the cosmos.
The CERN research center, whose giant Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has been the focus of the search, said it had reported to a conference in Mumbai that possible signs of the Higgs noted last month were now seen as less significant.
OK, so let's assume that you master the basic rules of spelling and grammar, and you've even managed to work out the use of active voice in your story. Is it compelling yet?
Sadly, no.
Look at your story. Now look at mine. Now back to yours. Now back to mine. Sadly yours is not mine. But it could read like mine if you knew how to make it compelling...
Some "experts" will say that the way to make a story compelling is to ensure it has the following elements:
1. Great character development.
2. Relatable culture and social interaction.
3. A believable and interesting world.
4. Economic interaction and consequences
Others give similar if slightly different lists. And of course they are usually all right. Great compelling stories usually have all of these things. But lots of totally boring and uninteresting stories do too.
Like mine.
I know my story has all these elements because I worked hard to make them all. My main characters and a dozen or so supporting characters have been mapped out, given motivations, backstories, quirks, ambitions, physical appearance, etc. And they evolve over time due to the circumstances of the story. That's part of the whole point of telling or reading a story, is to see how the characters evolve. I've detailed out the setting to include countries, mountain ranges, rivers, seas, forests, towns.... I've got friggin' MAPS of the world. I can tell you exactly how far it is from point A to point B, and show you the path you'd have to take to get there.
I have done my best to create completely different cultures for different areas of the story and have done quite a bit of research to get a feel for those cultures. (Yes, I learned how to make stone arrowheads, spearheads and knives because it was important to my story for me to have a feel for the process.) My goal is to make the cultural elements of the story PALPABLE.
OK, I've got some work to go on the economies of the world. I should have given that more thought. I couldn't tell you right now what the main imports and exports of the largest city in the story are... I definitely should know that... But still....
But I still don't feel my story is "compelling."
One blog I visited said a story is "compelling" if the reader identified with the protagonist, the event which triggered the protagonist's difficulties in the story, and the way the protagonist dealt with and (hopefully) resolved those difficulties.
Again, yeah, a good, "compelling" story will have that. But having that doesn't MAKE your story compelling...
So I have fallen back on what I personally found compelling about my most favorite books. And I've concluded that the answer is different for each of the books.
My favorite things about Tolkien's writing are not the same as my favorite things about Steinbeck's or Salinger's.
The one thing I can say is that when I read those stories, I CARED about the people and the world the story was about. So my current take on "how do you make a story compelling" has evolved into "How do you make the reader CARE about the characters and the cultures?"
But I feel no closer to having the answer than I did when I started.
So all of the web research I've done on writing query letters and engaging a literary agent say that the way to get your book published is for it to be "compelling." What it shouldn't be is "boring" or "derivative" or "confusing"...
But when you try to dig down and determine what makes a story "compelling" the only answer is basically the old SCOTUS definition of pornography... "I can't define it, but I know it when I see it."
There are lots of mechanical things that have to be done to give a story a CHANCE to be compelling. For example, you have to do everything you possibly can to put the story in an active voice. That means using active verbs and sentence construction. Then you have to be sure your story is SHOWING not TELLING the story. This is a big thing. Long paragraphs of exposition describing what the characters are doing from a disembodied distance is "telling" the story. Short concise paragraphs filled with dialog and active voice is SHOWING the story.
Right now I'd say about half of my book is showing and half is telling. I've got a lot of work to do to rewrite the "telling" chapters into "showing" chapters. Why is there so much "telling" in the first place? Well, in my case it seems to be my natural style to take the disembodied distant view and describe it dispassionately. And when you are writing the first draft all the advice and expertise says "don't worry about ANYTHING except GETTING THE STORY DONE!" The assumption is that the hardest part about writing is the initial story construction and the work effort involved in slogging through 100,000 words in an effort to get the dang story out of your head and into the real world in the first place. The thought seems to be that you can always go back and do edits and rewrites once that "hard part" is done.
Well, in my case that doesn't seem to be the case. Churning out page after page of text is no problem for me at all, as most who read this blog probably already know. I'm a wordy bastard. I like words and I type fast and accurately, so words tend to flow directly from my consciousness and stream onto the monitor without me even thinking about the keyboard or typing in between.
But rewriting is hard. Editing isn't too bad, it's mostly cleaning stuff up and you can use some actual spelling and grammar tools to make that easier.
When I try to rewrite I get really bogged down in the conversion from passive to active voice and something like this:
The pale disk of the setting sun scintillated behind the veil of distant clouds hovering over the brooding mountains as Joe carefully adjusted the throttle on his speeding motorcycle, cognizant of the fog-slickened road and the many inattentive drivers whose momentary desire to change their music player's playlist could lead to a sudden and unwanted early grave for Joe and a difficult life for his children.
... becomes something like:
Twisting the throttle forward on his roaring Harley, Joe ignored the setting sun and cursed the line of cell-phone squawking commuters ahead, determined not to leave two fatherless and penniless children.
One consequence of the rewriting is that I tend to reduce the word count by something like 20%. But I also tend to find new things to write about, so I add content while reducing word count. Which means I tend to end up after a rewrite with roughly the same number of words, but might have added two new chapters... As I did this week in my initial rewrites... More to come later...
People who know me know that I rarely get excited about anything. Consider it a character flaw, or consider it a deeply ingrained cynicism based on my life experiences. Doesn't matter, the end result is just that I almost never get excited enough to grin and say "Oh boy oh boy oh boy!!!"
But I did this morning. And it's all about my book.
My experience with investigating the query letter and the need to do some rewrites to make the book more compelling had me contemplating the final chapters of the book (and some of the lead-up to that) and I realized that I had to come up with some way to end the book with a major victory for the protagonist, even though he HAS to suffer an ignominious defeat to advance the plot. I was wracking my brain over this and how to do it without derailing the carefully laid out three-book story line.
And on my way to work this morning, I got an idea. And the more I contemplated it, the better it got. In the end it provides exactly what I need to end the book with the protagonist being heroic and dramatic, and more than that.... it allows me to advance the most important part of the overall story line more effectively than I had been doing it, and it sets up the second book to be more powerful and exciting.
So... "Oh boy, oh boy, oh boy!!!
Now I just want to get home to sit in front of my computer and make the rewrites.
OK, so I've completed a first draft. I've even done a couple of significant rewrites and done several editing passes.
Just a few hours ago I was feeling pretty good about myself.
Then I decided to do some research about the next steps, and I am starting to wonder if writing the damn book is the easiest part of the whole process!
The main thing that has me concerned has been a series of articles and blog posts on the subject of a "query letter." A query letter is what an author sends to an agent to get the agent to decide whether to offer to read the book. That's all.
In reading the descriptions of what agents love and hate about query letters, I have started to realize that I've got a LOT of work left to do on this book. To stretch a horrible metaphor, all I have done so far is create a rough approximation of the final story, sort of like I've taken a blob of clay and have shaped it into a stick figure of a person before working at all on any of the detail and uniqueness of the piece.
The one single comment made over and over by agents in response to "what do you want to see in a query letter" was this: "Explain in a single paragraph or two why I would want to read your book."
Wow. You know, all this time I've been working on my book, my whole thought has been about why I want to WRITE the book.
But that's really not even the point.
Now I have to go back and look at the book from an entirely different perspective so I can answer the question of why anyone would want to read it.
"Because it's good." Ha.
"Because it's got great characters." Tell me about it.
"Because it's got great action scenes!" Right.
"Because it's about magic and exotic lands and places!" So is a travel guide.
Sigh...
Why would anyone want to read my book?
Gonna have to think on that one for a bit.
Reporting from Washington— For the next two months at Logan International Airport in Boston, passengers will be casually greeted by Transportation Security Administration officials. But the officers aren't there for a friendly "hello" — they're trying to deter and detect passengers who pose a risk to aviation security.
As part of the TSA's new behavior-detection pilot program that started this week, screeners are engaging each passenger in Terminal A in casual conversation in an effort to detect suspicious behavior. After passengers provide their boarding pass and ID, they have to answer a few questions from TSA officers who have received two weeks of training.
via TSA launching behavior-detection program at Boston airport - latimes.com.
Just one more in a litany of things the mindless deranged left would be howling in the streets while hanging and burning GW Bush in effigy if this had happened in his administration.
Man, I have pretty much lost all hope for the Left. I mean we've got Obama going to war in three nations, higher casualties in Afghanistan then ever in Bush's administration and the White House shutting down photos of returning body bags and not a single peep from the vacuous useful idiots the Democrats spin machine whipped into a frenzy of manufactured hatred.
Not a single peep.
It's way, way beyond anything you can call "hypocrisy."