Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The State of Physics illustrated

By CosmicConservative
I have periodically stated on this blog, and in postings on other blogs, that the state of physics is best described as "dysfunctional." Physics is the father of all sciences, but for the past few generations physics has been virtually worthless as a predictive or theoretical "science." In fact it is hard to call physics "science" anymore. This article is a good illustration of why.
"Accordingly, our own Universe may be the interior of a black hole existing in another universe." So concludes Nikodem Poplawski at Indiana University in a remarkable paper about the nature of space and the origin of time. The idea that new universes can be created inside black holes and that our own may have originated in this way has been the raw fodder of science fiction for many years. But a proper scientific derivation of the notion has never emerged. via Technology Review: Blogs: arXiv blog: Why Our Universe Must Have Been Born Inside a Black Hole.
The real action is in the comments. You can sense the frustration of the commentators who see, as I do, that physics has become a realm where virtually any bizarre "theory" gains instant credibility so long as it pays proper homage to the current physics shibboleths and criticisms of those "theories" are discounted as "crackpot" or worse if they do not pay proper homage to them. The first time I encountered the concept of black holes containing a "singularity" which is usually defined as "infinitely dense" I knew that physics was losing its way. That way has led to 50 years of mental masturbation known as "String Theory" and out of that has come all manner of speculation masquerading as "theory." Physics is in a world of hurt. I think it's going to take a literal revolution in the ranks, or a complete expulsion from those parts of science that still have some connection with reality to fix it. One of the commenters here says the problem goes all the way back to Einstein, but I don't think that's fair. Einstein himself pointed out that his theories were not comprehensive and that there were serious problems with "continuity" and with reconciling the smoothness of relativity with the chaos of quantum mechanics. Einstein knew we were merely on the cusp of understanding. It's not his fault if an "Einstein cult" has grown up which has taken physics in directions that Einstein himself would not approve of. I think perhaps the revolution in physics might just occur after the "Higgs Boson" search reaches its climax. When the result of that "experiment" ends up with inconclusive results which do nothing to "prove" any current physics theory and merely open the door to more speculation, there may well be an economic revolt due to the massive amounts of public money spent on a pursuit that has provided exactly zero results after trillions of dollars spent and entire generations of physicists devoting their lives to no effect. We will see.

Comments (21)

Drax
I know I don't know anything. About much of anything. But, whenever I read the new thoughts on physics, I always think to myself, "Here's yet another theory attempting to find a way to explain the holes in the Big Bang." They'll keep at it -- making up all kinds of strangeness -- in an attempt to force the universe to conform to their theories. "Hey, what's this green crap uniformly spread around the edges of the universe? That ain't supposed to be there!" Enter new theory. "Hey, we can't account for the intrinsic momentum of spin half particles" (whatever that is...) Enter new theory. Etc. Etc. Etc.
CosmicConservative
Well, the truth is that when you look at the extremes of the universe, the infinitesimally small, and the infinitely large, it gets very, very strange. My problem is that physics seems to have given up on true science and has become a sort of faith-based religion where you have to believe in string theory or you won't get tenure, won't get published and won't get grants. It's very sad, actually.
Drax
I've always viewed science that way -- consensus world-view. World round/flat? Earth center of universe? AIDS research. Global warming. Big Bang. Whatever. The punishment for varying from the norm has been somewhat variable through the ages, of course...
Foobarista
Yup, the gagillions spent on the Large Hadron Collider could have gotten the Euros to Mars, or at least a serious presence on the Moon. And they could have built an extremely cool mega-collider up there without worrying about eminent domain...
staylor
Physics has seemed to have devolved into self absorbed naval gazing this is focused on gigantic, crazy theories that are totally unproveable. I would prefer it if they concentrate on more practical applications of the science.
Andy
I'm the dufus of the blog. Obviously. But, I enjoyed the read, and the comments. Didn't understand much of it, but I'm pretty sure y'all are right. You sound right. ;)
CosmicConservative
One of the things I've been personally very frustrated with in the past 30 years is how much brain power in physics has been pissed away on these bizarre, untestable, and unprovable "theories" when that same brainpower, focused on making fusion a reality, could have literally transformed this world by now. By the way, the reason I keep putting "theory" in quotations is that there are actually scientific rules for a hypothesis to qualify for the designation as a "theory" and Physics has thrown that completely out the window for the past 30 years. Any hairbrained notion that captures the imagination of the "intelligentsia" of the field becomes a "theory." For example, "String Theory" itself is not a "theory" by the strict definition of the term because it is simply not testable. There is no test you can come up with that would disprove String Theory. In scientific terms that means it is "non-falsifiable" and that is not merely A condition to meet for a theory, being falsifiable is the most important condition to meet. And String Theory doesn't meet it.
ASEI
Hmmph - black holes always seemed to have more than a few things wrong with them, but not only at the singularity - at the event horizon too. People say there is nothing wrong with the geometry of spacetime at the horizon, but any asymptotically distant observer sees time frozen there, any observer crossing it has the whole history of the universe go by prior to crossing, and space has to be discontinouous over differentially small distances for any of that to happen - unless you use some weird nonphysical hyperbolic coordinate system. My hypothesis is that black holes are an inadmissible initial condition. What happens when extremely dense objects collapse is that time dialation slows the progression of their state, and an event horizon, much less a singularity, never forms.
ASEI
PS - I wouldn't say that all of physics is mathematical model chasing with no application to the real world. As far as I can tell reading some trade journals, they now have a pretty good explanation for superconductivity. Though I do share your frustration as well. At the dawn of the 20th century, our view of the universe changed radically, and forces inconceivable in the 19th century were not only discovered, but brought under mankind's control in a mere four decades. These days, it seems such progress has stopped, and engineering is just refining our control over the areas of physics we have already long understood.
Kevin in WI
" I think perhaps the revolution in physics might just occur after the “Higgs Boson” search reaches its climax. When the result of that “experiment” ends up with inconclusive results which do nothing to “prove” any current physics theory and merely open the door to more speculation, there may well be an economic revolt due to the massive amounts of public money spent on a pursuit that has provided exactly zero results after trillions of dollars spent and entire generations of physicists devoting their lives to no effect." That's exactly why the results won't be inconclusive. At the end of all of that hugely expensive technology is a stream of data being interpreted by a team of fallible human beings deeply invested In finding a certain result - for the sake of both their reputations and their livelihood.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, I mostly agree with you, but I would also say that Engineers have done a remarkable job of taking physical results that have no comprehensive falsifiable theory behind them and have simply put those verifiable results to good use in spite of the lack of a solid theory. Quantum Mechanics is routinely described as the "most tested theory in history" which is only true if you allow probabilistic models of experimental results to qualify as "theory." That's what we do today with quantum mechanics and the results are stunningly accurate, but at root there is no explanation whatsoever of WHY fundamental particles act like probability clouds. It's just observed that they DO and we base our engineering on that fact, and lo and behold, it works! Kevin, yes, I am quite concerned that Physics is falling into the same groupthink trap that climate "science" has fallen into. There is a definite possibility that a similar scenario could play out in physics. There are literally billions and billions of dollars at stake, and it is a sad fact of the human condition that the more money something has, the more corruption comes into play.
ASEI
Well, there is one explanation that appeals to me more and more these days about that, though it leads to some ridiculously extravagant consequences: Everett's hypothesis. The mainstream interpretation of quantum physics to date, the Copenhagen interpretation, has the particles behaving as probability clouds related to the density of a function over configuration space called the wavefunction. Every time a quantum system interacts with a macroscopic system, the wavefunction "collapses" to a single subspace related to the value of the observation and then continues to evolve from there. The problem is the collapse event (which is never well described mechanically) happens non-locally and "instantaneously", which throws relativity for a loop. There is no such thing as "instantaneous", and it leads to things being changed faster than light, backwards in time, ect - if you accept that that is what is going on. Everett's hypothesis proposes that the wavefunction is the actual state of the physical system/universe and that no collapse events actually occur. Instead, a macroscopic system is given a much more complicated wavefunction which, upon interaction with a quantum system in an information storing manner spreads the wavefunction along divergent paths in configuration space, and you end up with a composite wavefunction. It looks to us like a discrete event because we split along with the macroscopic system - result A correlates to quantum event A, result B correlates with quantum event B, and both happen in seperate subspaces. This is why it is called the many worlds hypothesis. The avantages are that quantum physics becomes governed by a set of deterministic differential equations without any recourse to mysterious and wild collapse events. The physics involved restores locality, causality, and reality (Bohr and the Copenhagen interpretation was never really serious about realism, which Bohr regarded as unneccessary, but I regard as essential to sanity. An empirical basis for anti-realism is a contradiciton in terms!) The disadvantage is that the configuration space of any macroscopic system, let alone the universe, is absurdly huge. Each and every degree of freedom is a dimension of variation. This is really how all quantum systems behave, prior to the mysterious interaction with a macroscopic system. It is how we simulate the behaviour of an electron shell or a nucleus. All Everett proposed is that nothing magic happens when we take a look - we are just extremely complicated quantum systems as well.
ASEI
Sorry, here is that post again without the word wrap (though that might not help much, it is a ramble): Well, there is one explanation that appeals to me more and more these days about that, though it leads to some ridiculously extravagant consequences: Everett's hypothesis. The mainstream interpretation of quantum physics to date, the Copenhagen interpretation, has the particles behaving as probability clouds related to the density of a function over configuration space called the wavefunction. Every time a quantum system interacts with a macroscopic system, the wavefunction "collapses" to a single subspace related to the value of the observation and then continues to evolve from there. The problem is the collapse event (which is never well described mechanically) happens non-locally and "instantaneously", which throws relativity for a loop. There is no such thing as "instantaneous", and it leads to things being changed faster than light, backwards in time, ect - if you accept that that is what is going on. Everett's hypothesis proposes that the wavefunction is the actual state of the physical system/universe and that no collapse events actually occur. Instead, a macroscopic system is given a much more complicated wavefunction which, upon interaction with a quantum system in an information storing manner spreads the wavefunction along divergent paths in configuration space, and you end up with a composite wavefunction. It looks to us like a discrete event because we split along with the macroscopic system - result A correlates to quantum event A, result B correlates with quantum event B, and both happen in seperate subspaces. This is why it is called the many worlds hypothesis. The avantages are that quantum physics becomes governed by a set of deterministic differential equations without any recourse to mysterious and wild collapse events. The physics involved restores locality, causality, and reality (Bohr and the Copenhagen interpretation was never really serious about realism, which Bohr regarded as unneccessary, but I regard as essential to sanity. An empirical basis for anti-realism is a contradiciton in terms!) The disadvantage is that the configuration space of any macroscopic system, let alone the universe, is absurdly huge. Each and every degree of freedom is a dimension of variation. This is really how all quantum systems behave, prior to the mysterious interaction with a macroscopic system. It is how we simulate the behaviour of an electron shell or a nucleus. All Everett proposed is that nothing magic happens when we take a look - we are just extremely complicated quantum systems as well.
ASEI
In summary: The many worlds hypothesis proposes that the wavefunction is the actual state of any system - there are no particles, only distributed functions over configuration space evolving according to Schrodinger's equations - the probability only comes into play in the entangled correlations of the quantum state with the state of a system with which it interacts, leading to propagation in divergent directions in configuration space. PS - I used to think there wasn't anything that could convince me of something as extravagant as many-worlds. However, on learning a bit of quantum physics, it seems a heck of a lot more natural than the other explanations, and there are some very good reasons for it. But that is just where I am at now, I may change my mind again as I learn more.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, the problem with the "many worlds" hypothesis, as I understand it, is that it too is non-falsifiable. There is no way to show that all the wave functions collapsed into their own local space-time. We only see the one. All the others are forever cut off from ours as soon as the event occurs. I don't see that as much of an improvement over the probabilistic model "theory." I'm not sure I'd call it an improvement at all. It seems strange to me that I'd consider a "singularity" as absurdly unrealistic and then I'd accept the notion that every quantum event leads to a near infinite creation of new universes. I will admit, however, that when I'm scratching off a lottery ticket, I deliberately attempt to will my "consciousness" into one of those infinite number of universes where CosmicConservative is a lottery winner. No luck so far...
ASEI
Well, it isn't "non-falsifiable" because there is something inherently unprovable about it. It's just that no one has come up with an experiment that can differentiate between the copenhagen and many worlds interpretations yet. If we are able to use quantum events to build a faster-than-light, backwards-in-time, anti-causal radio, then many worlds will be falsified, because it is a local reletavistic theory. If we are able to use quantum events to build a quantum computer, then it would be hard to dispense with many-worlds - where else is all the quibit state stored?
CosmicConservative
Well, I don't think "how else do you explain it?" is a very sound basis for a true scientific theory. But I also admit that my problems with the "many worlds" hypothesis are as much philosophical as they are scientific. There's something about the assertion that there are a near infinite number of worlds where CosmicConservative is a genocidal mass murderer that doesn't sit well with my own self-image.
Drax
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20727703.000-every-black-hole-may-hold-a-hidden-universe.html Every black hole might hold a rainbow drawn by a unicorn, or, so says a scientist at MIT (Morons in Tandem)...
CosmicConservative
Drax, I call that the "invisible purple dragons fly out my butt" principle. "How does gravity work?" "Invisible purple dragons fly out my butt and grab onto things." "That's crazy!" "Oh yeah? Prove they don't exist." This is a real problem with physics today. The vast majority of theoretical physics has gone over the event horizon from physics into meta-physics. Oh, and by the way the "we live inside a black hole" hypothesis is at least 40 years old. One of the first things that people thought about when black holes went mainstream is "huh, the Big Bang looks a whole lot like a black hole turned inside out.... I wonder...." There is one thing I like about this article, and that's the "torsion" explanation which stops the formation of a singularity. I think I've said here before that I don't believe in singularities.
Drax
Yet another example of: "We're just making stuff up as we go along" school of "scientific thought." Sigh. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/12/science/12tools.html?src=un&feedurl=http%3A%2F%2Fjson8.nytimes.com%2Fpages%2Fscience%2Findex.jsonp
» God Particle may be “mirage.” CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains
[...] be “mirage.” Posted in August 23rd, 2011 by CosmicConservative in Politics Sigh… I’ve commented on the sorry state of modern particle physics before and how I thought they were a dog chasing their own [...]