Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The value of criticism

By CosmicConservative
I'm not sure if I have previously posted that I am taking an 8 week novel writing workshop. I'm too lazy to look back to see. We have just finished week 3. Part of the workshop (the biggest part, apparently) is having each writer submit a 15 page sample of their work which the rest of the group then reads and comments upon. I volunteered to go first, so last night we had our first critique session and chapters 1-3 of "Warrior" were up for critique from a group of ten folks I barely know and have only interacted with in the workshop. The rules of engagement for the critique session are that the writer is not allowed to respond to any comment or even to talk at all until all of the critiques are finished. So you have to sit there on the hot seat taking notes while the results of pouring your heart onto pages are examined and analyzed from ten different perspectives. Really an uncomfortable and exposed situation to be in. There's no place to hide and since you can't rebut, you have to just accept the criticism and move on to let the next person critique. To summarize the results, here are the things that were identified as problems by more than one of the group: 1. Not enough detail in my descriptions of the environment. This led to readers not being sure they were picturing events accurately. 2. Colloquialism and casual sentence structure in dialog. Some felt this was too "modern" and detracted from the stone age pre-industrial culture. 3. Not enough detail in describing my characters, and too many characters being introduced too early and at once. This coupled with the unusual names left readers confused about roles and relationships. 4. Some minor technical criticisms about specific sentence structure habits that editors don't like. 5. Lack of clarity around the obvious conflict between the protagonist and his older brother, exascerbated by the lack of clarity on the age of the two. On the positive side, everyone said they enjoyed the read and wanted to read more. I'm sure some were just being nice, but some seemed very sincere about that. I figure that's got to be good. The class instructor/facilitator does not provide his feedback in class. He dissects your writing in an email and sends it to you privately. I received his late last night (which kept me up later than I should have). His critiques were very specific about structural things, points of view, voice and story. I came away from the experience more positively motivated than I thought I would. Everyone had specific parts of the story that they really liked, and some of the comments were dowright embarrassing they were so complimentary. Almost every criticism and suggestion for improvement was already on my list of fixes for the rewrite, so that made me feel like I had a fairly good sense of my own work and its weaknesses. That's very encouraging to me since it gives me some confidence that I am somewhat effective at identifying weaknesses in my own work. The one thing that surprised me were comments about the casual, colloquial nature of the dialog. Some found that to be too "modern" and felt that it broke the spell of the story. I did it deliberately though because I felt like the more stilted, older style of speech was like hitting a literary speed bump every time someone said "I can not do this." or "You will need to do that." Instead of "I can't do this" or "You'll need to do that." The characters don't speak English so I don't see any reason I should translate their fictional language into archaic speech in English. I want the dialog to flow and I want the reader to be engaged in the story and I still feel that the stilted, formal approach just jars the reader. But I am going to think about it... Bottom line is I've got a ton of rewriting to do. A ton. Probably as much rewriting as I've done writing so far.

Comments (7)

JSullins
I'm quite jealous, and wish I had an opportunity like this. What university/college/etc is this through?
CosmicConservative
It's at LighthouseWriters.org, a writers group located in downtown Denver. We meet every Wednesday. My instructor/facilitator last night implied that I should be in the "intermediate novel writing" class instead of the "beginning". I suspect he's right. But regardless I'm learning a lot.
CosmicConservative
Oh, it was $285 for the class after a $30 members fee. If you aren't a member it's $315. Funny how that works...
JSullins
Downtown Denver? Maybe I can visit sometime (you know to gawk), since I work down there. Here. Whatever.
CosmicConservative
OK, not exactly "downtown Denver" but you have to go down Colfax about seven miles from I-25 and it's just north on Race street. That's "downtown" to me, since I almost never go near downtown Denver... And I try to avoid Colfax like the plague...
CosmicDaughter
Congratulations on getting through the first hurdle!
wfbj
I know that workshop well. Teacher/facilitator has been a tremendous help to me over the years.