Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

So long Tebow...

By CosmicConservative
Well, I suspect he will end up in Jacksonville. I hope he does well there. I was never much of a John Elway fan before this, but this whole episode with Tebow has pretty much made me despise the bastard. I will say this... if the Denver Broncos make the playoffs and end up playing against a Tim Tebow QB'd team, I'll be rooting against the Broncos.

Comments (31)

Drax
Jacksonville would be a good home. Miami as well. Cleveland? Kansas City?
CosmicConservative
Regardless of where Tebow ends up, the prevailing NFL "wisdom" is that Tebow is not an NFL-caliber quarterback, and Denver will not get close to the value of a first round draft pick, meaning yet another blown draft pick for Denver as they try to build a team around a declining QB at the tail end of his career with no receivers, a crappy offensive line, no running game, no tight ends and a defense that just barely hung on enough to win some iffy games last year. 2012 might well end up being a major disappointment in this city.
CosmicConservative
... but as far as Tebow's future is concerned... Miami and Jacksonville are probably the most likely to want him, simply for his ability to sell tickets to his rabid home town fans. But wherever he goes, the controversy of him being a "running back playing quarterback" will follow him, most likely for the rest of his career. Which may not be long. Oh well, he's expressed an interest in politics. Maybe he can run for President one day.
JSullins
Well, at least he's made millions from all this, right? I mean, how bad can it be when you're a mulit-millionaire at his age. I'd be looking at the bright side in his shoes, you know. And hey... there's always Dancing With the Stars!
CosmicConservative
Heh... the "dancing QB" would be just about the right end to his career.... I know I shouldn't allow myself to get emotionally invested in a sports figure. I normally don't do that. The last time I remember feeling this way about a player was when Doug Flutie was kicked out of the NFL and ended up becoming the most amazing CFL football player in history.
Dadman
I think the last sports figure I had this type of emotional investment in was Dorothy Hamill. ;)
CosmicConservative
I'm trying to think of a female sports star I ever had an emotional investment in... I mean I thought Chris Evert was cute... I remember Dorothy Hamill as a big cultural event, but I never really got into her... My deal with both Flutie and Tebow is that it grates against my sense of decency and fairness. Both never did anything but win at every level they played at, but because they didn't fit some mold that all the "experts" agreed was the only way to judge talent, they both got screwed in spite of their success. Maybe Tebow can overcome it, but after this mess here in Denver, I doubt it. I suspect he'll be out of the NFL in a couple years.
Drax
Man, I'd feel a whole lot differently about the "experts" if they had a better track record on QB's than I would flipping a coin.
CosmicConservative
I remember when Kansas City went nuts about acquiring Joe Montana. There is a reason the Colts chose to go forward with Andrew Luck and let Manning go. If the Colts, who know Manning the best, don't think Manning is their five year go to guy, what makes Elway such a genius for going after him? I respect what Manning has done in his career, and I hope he does well for the remainder of his career, but the number of mid 30s HoF QBs who left their original team to lead a different team to the SB is exactly zero. And those who did make the move lasted no more than a year or two of declining skills before retiring. It would be an historic reversal of history if Manning can even return to his pre-surgery skill level, and even if he does, the Broncos lack the skill to play with him. As a Colorado sports fan I have to say that this whole thing reminds me of the Rockies experience in pursuing and obtaining Bret Saberhagen. I expect the end result will be similar. My suspicion is that all the "experts" crowing about how brilliant Elway and Fox are today will be the same "experts" calling this decision one of the biggest blunders in NFL history when Manning retires and Denver is rebuilding from scratch again in two years.
Drax
This whole thing is just a horrid reflection on both Elway and Fox as GM and head coach. Forget about all the stuff that led up to the acquisition of Manning. Just look at what's happening now. The GM is taking the direction of his QB as to which personnel he is going to sign and (almost certainly) draft. Already the talk is that his long-time center, Jeff Saturday will be signed. Probably Dallas Clark and Brandon Stokely. All to make it good for Manning. Then the offensive scheme is going to be handed over to the QB. He will install his own offensive scheme. So, Manning will make personnel decisions and will make the offensive scheme. GREAT JOB Elway and Fox! Really making your money!
CosmicConservative
The local media is giddy with joy over the "end of Tebow-mania".
Drax
I think they're going to be less happy when Oakland wins the division and Denver doesn't make the playoffs. Oakland should be a bear this year - if McFadden can stay healthy.
JSullins
The local media is well.... pissing me off today. Lots of talk on the radio that, "if you are unhappy about this you are not a Bronco's fan, just a Tebow fan and you don't matter." As if preferring one player in particular disqualifies you from having an opinion. Elitist snobs.
Dadman
Cosmic: I was suggesting you might have a man- crush on Tebow. ;)
Drax
I have no problem with management going after one of the best quarterbacks who has ever played the game in hopes of winning a Superbowl or two. In fact, I would have thought even less of them than I already do if they hadn't. It's a business. Management knows that. Players know that. For some reason, fans don't seem to and expect loyalty from players towards management and from management towards players - even though there is absolutely no evidence that there is any going either way. Ask Manning. Or Johnny U. Or Broadway Joe. Or Hines Ward. That's why I don't root for any team. What's to root for? I do root for particular players who, for whatever reason, strike a chord with me. (Tebow, Nash, Rose, Aaron) and against others who strike a discordant chord (Brady, Bonds, Rodriguez, Kobe). Frankly, if it weren't for fantasy football, I wouldn't have much reason to watch football any longer.
Drax
Tebow's going to the Jets. For a 4th round pick. The Jets. He won't even be a back-up. Maybe some "wildcat" packages and tight end stuff. In New York. I can't think of a single place which would have been a worse fit for Tebow. Elway wanted to put him in the best place he could for Tebow. Laughable. He intentionally put him in the worst place he could so that he didn't get a starting job and became nothing more than Elway thought he would be so he didn't show him up. Despicable.
CosmicConservative
Hard to disagree with that. However, on the bright side, I think Mark Sanchez may be the single most overrated QB in the history of the game. Although his coach and the front office continue to pamper him, the fans will be in open revolt if he performs this year as he did last year. Maybe Tebow learned enough that he can come out of training camp as the #2 Jets QB. If so, and if Sanchez continues to under-perform, I suspect there will be another Orton-Tebow situation in NYC.
CosmicConservative
Drax, according to ESPN, as nearly as I can make it out from the unclear writing, the trade was as follows: Denver gives up Tebow and a seventh round pick. New York gives up a fourth and a sixth round pick. That's probably actually better than any expert thought Denver would get for Tebow. I was hearing "fifth or sixth round pick at best" for Tebow, straight up.
Drax
Yeah. But, it's the first day after signing Manning. If that's the best they get after feeling out all the teams and get the bidding going, then, that's one thing. Jacksonville was interested. Maybe not to that level - now - but, once it's clear that someone else has interest, as long as you have two people involved, it can get into a bidding war. But, that's not what happened. I wonder, though. The Jets did sign Tony Sopprano as Offensive Coordinator and he brought the wildcat to the NFL in Miami. Are they going to use Tebow just as a package player - or, perhaps, will we start hearing that the Jets are shopping Sanchize? Dunno. Just pisses me off.
CosmicConservative
My guess is that the Jets hope to have Tebow run a situational "wildcat" style offense four or five times per game, and potentially bring him in as a potential dual-threat decoy at fullback to pull secondaries in to stop potential runs. But they are playing with fire. Sanchez was booed repeatedly by his own fans last year and ended the season with three of the worst performances in recent memory. Plus he was very publicly beaten by the Tebow-led Broncos last year. So if Sanchez starts slowly, I think the Jets will learn why Elway was so keen to dump Tebow.
Drax
Just heard on NFL channel that the Jaguars and St. Louis had offers on the table when the Jets made this offer and said that it was a final offer which would expire when they left the building. Elway accepted without even calling the other teams back. New York isn't Denver. Next year isn't last year - Tebow ain't new to anyone. The only way this trade makes any sense is if the Jets are going to start Tebow. I can't see how this trade, with Tebow on the bench except for special packages, otherwise, will do anything other than further fragment a locker room which is already in chaos - and not just about the quarterback situation. Ryan is a ground and pound coach. Tebow would fit in with this much better than Sanchize. Especially as it relates to turnovers. (Other than one game, Tebow had 3(?) interceptions all last year.) And, he gives the additional "option" of taking the ball himself. Further, Sanchize was one of the worst in the NFL in the red zone and Tebow can be an upgrade there maybe. And, if they make an offense which is a bit more imaginative than run on 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 3rd and 20, whatever, then maybe Tebow can actually take the Jets over the top. Meh. Wishful thinking.
CosmicConservative
LOL, now the Jets deal looks like it may be falling apart due to a "payback" in Tebow's contract that would require the Jets to pay the Broncos something like $5M. St. Louis is said to be the front runner if the Jets deal does fall through. Man, if that trade falls apart, how stupid will Elway and the Jets front offices look? Dunno even what to root for. The other reason I think the Jets may have wanted to get Tebow was to put some competitive pressure on Sanchez to get him to stop lazing around and mailing in games.
Drax
Yeah. Apparently, after the deal was made, Elway put language in the trade documents asking to be paid back $5mil of the guarantee paid to Tebow. That's not how it's done. No team would sign off on that. Predictably, the Jets said "What? We didn't agree to THAT!" Elway, again, showing his incompetence as GM.
CosmicConservative
Yep, and Tebow apparently had some say in the matter... go figure...
Drax
Tebow gave a teleconference interview (mostly to the NY media) in which he was directly asked what input he had on the trade and he answered that the Broncos had "all the power" (the closest thing to a negative remark he gave in the entire interview) and he had absolutely no say in where he went.
Drax
It's also being reported that Jacksonville offered more than did the Jets, including a bigger percentage of the guaranteed money (of which the Jets paid 1/2) the Broncos paid Tebow and a higher draft pick. Unfortunately, it was reported by the same source who reported that Tebow was given the choice as to where to go and he chose the Jets. Since I heard Tebow specifically deny that and I have absolutely no evidence that he would outright lie about something like that (or anything else, for that matter) - I have to distrust the source and the story at this point.
Drax
Elway flat out says that Tebow was offered a choice. Pending further statements by the parties, it's a choice of believing "You're my starter, Tim!" John Elway or Tim Tebow.
CosmicConservative
As far as I am concerned, Elway lost all credibility for me when he clearly tried to make Tebow look bad and was obviously unhappy when Tebow succeeded in spite of him. Since then his public pronouncements on Tim Tebow have been the most disingenuous, prevaricating bullcrap I've ever seen from a supposed "manager" of anything. Between Tebow and Elway, I don't think it's hard to figure out who I would believe.
Drax
I listened carefully to what Elway said. It's being interpreted as Tebow was given the choice as to where to go, but what was said was that Tebow was kept "informed." It is clearly IMPLIED that Tebow was allowed the choice, but it wasn't STATED that he was, and Tebow specifically DENIED that he was given the choice stating that Denver had "all the power" in the decision. I need more to decide what happened, and, unless Tebow somehow breaks with his past behavior regarding Denver, I doubt that he will directly call Elway a liar or put Elway in the position that he will be caught out as one. Hrumph.