Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why We Get Fat

By CosmicConservative
So, last year when I began my attempt to reverse a potential descent into type 2 diebetes, several people recommended that I read a book called "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes. Having long considered dietary literature to be essentially as credible and scientific as paranormal literature, I politely declined offers to loan the book to me and responded with variations of "dieting is simple. You eat less and exercise more. Thermodynamics takes care of the rest." And I went on my way, dropped to a 1,200 calorie per day diet, made sure to exercise at least 45 minutes per day and sure enough, the pounds melted away. But having now been exposed to the book, and a previous book by the same author, "Good Calories, Bad Calories", I started seeing recommendations for the book everywhere, including on some sites (such as "Instapundit" which relentlessly promotes the books) that I hold in high regard. So, although I have not regressed badly in my dietary habits and have managed to keep off the weight I lost last year, when my weight started creeping back up and I decided to reinstate my "draconian dietary restrictions", on a whim, I purchased the books off of Amazon.com. And I promptly put them in a pile of "books to read" that I have not gotten to (that pile includes "The Hunger Games" by the way). Well, this weekend I decided to pick up "Why We Get Fat" and began reading it. My initial reaction was "huh, so 'calories in, calories out' doesn't work eh? What about me? It worked fine for me." But I found the book to be very interesting as it was a pretty decent high-level introduction to the biological basis for gaining weight. So I kept reading. And it was making sense. And the more I read, the more I realized that the book wasn't about "getting fat" it was about "Why we develop type 2 diabetes, heart disease and a host of other western diseases'." "Getting fat" was really more of a symptom of a deeper hormonal imbalance that was tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning. Not to go into any great detail but the fundamental concept presented in the book is that the modern carbohydrate based diet pushed by doctors, the government and even nutritionists for the past fifty years is basically a blueprint to wrecking your insulin balance, which leads directly to type 2 diabetes and all the health problems related to that. The more I read, the more I realized that my own dietary history was directly implicated. In fact I could have been the model for the book. The high-carbohydrate diet leading to insulin resistance causing pancreatic insulin over-production ending up with type 2 diabetes could have been taken directly from my medical charts. The litany of health problems associated with insulin imbalance included kidney problems, liver problems, gall bladder problems, gout, kidney stones.... GEEZ LOUISE!!! This was reading like a biography of ME. And the message of the book was clear, even if Taubes didn't put it into these words. The modern western diet is tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning. This isn't even about losing weight! Gaining weight might be the LEAST concerning health consequence of a high-carbohydrate diet. So I'm thinking hard now about my diet not from a "losing weight" perspective, but more from a "reversal of sugar poisoning" perspective. Blood sugar is downright toxic. Chronic blood sugar elevation is toxic to almost all of the cells in the body. It is particularly hard on internal organs such as the heart, liver and kidneys. The book did not really provide a road map for "eating right" because that book had already been written ("Good Calories, Bad Calories"). So now I'm starting to read that book. But the fundamental concept is clear. Sugar is not merely fattening. Sugar is addictive and is toxic. Carbohydrates from common sources like breads, potatoes, rice, pasta and desserts are converted to sugar almost instantly in the blood, so are not much different than sucking down spoonfuls of sugar. Fructose is, if anything, WORSE than table sugar. I am now embarking on a war against sugar. I'll let you know how it goes.

Comments (26)

ragnar
FWIW I read Taubes' "Why We Get Fat" just over 1 year ago, decided to try low carbing and was wildly successful, 45lbs in 6 months and sugar and cholesterol levels back to target norms in 3 months with minimal physical effort and no hunger/starvation issues (lots of behavior changes though!). One warning though, your family has to be on board or low carbing will be orders of magnitude more difficult. After reading Good Calories, Bad Calories you should also read Wheat Belly by William Davis - I haven't been able to figure out whether the alleged wheat/gluten issues are a subset of the whole carb/sugar thing or if the wheat/gluten thing is the killer and the carb/sugar issues follow from the wheat. My head hurts just thinking about it. Good luck with you battle!
CosmicConservative
Ragnar, I must admit that I have been as skeptical of "gluten-free" diets as I have been of any other diet that appeared to me to be a fad. Since I am embarking on a low carb diet, I will pretty much automatically be reducing my wheat intake. Eliminating wheat entirely will be quite a challenge. I'll read up on the whole dwarf wheat, gluten-free thing.
Dadman
So, how is this different from the Atkins Diet? I still tend to believe the issue is too many calories as opposed to the source of the calorie. But I also understand that our bodies respond biochemically differently to proteins and carbs, e.g. glycemic index, etc. Many years ago I read The Zone diet and still believe it's a very rational approach to healthful eating. Maybe I'll check out Taubes books...
CosmicConservative
"Why We Get Fat" and Taube's first book "Good Calories, Bad Calories" are different than the Atkins diet in that Taube is not presenting a diet plan. His books are an examination of the medical literature and history of diet and health which then presents his own conclusion about the causes of weight gain, the health impacts of insulin response and the long-term results of reducing carbohydrate caloric intake. He discusses the Atkins diet in his book as merely one of the latest examples of a long line of carb-free diets that can be traced back to the original "Banting" diet which was the first real "fad diet" publication and which is almost identical in it's dietary recommendations to the Atkins diet. Basically the medical literature appears to be full of dozens of reports that low-carb diets are by far the most effective ways to lose and keep off the pounds. Stanford University recently did a study of several "fad" diets and the Atkins diet nearly doubled the results of the next most successful diet. I guess the best way to describe the relationship between Taube's works and the Atkins diet is that Taube is essentially providing a scientific basis for why the Atkins diet works, both from a biological/endocrinological perspective and a historical one. I don't think I'm very gullible, in fact I think I am a hard-core skeptic, but I came away thinking that Taube's research and analysis is very, very compelling.
ragnar
I don't think of this stuff in terms of diet/weight loss at all - reading about blood sugar targets at Blood Sugar 101 (http://www.phlaunt.com/diabetes/16422495.php) and comparing with what my readings were, put the fear of ...something.. in me. I started doing post meal readings and even with the recommended portion controlled servings of starches and whole grains my post meal numbers were 12-13 which apparently is very bad for my health, minimal carb meals keep me below 7 - this seems like a good thing... might as well try for a couple of weeks and see what happens, can't hurt...can it? Continue for 2 weeks, the morning readings start trending down and the scales are 10# less and I've lost 1" from my waistline - BONUS! 3 months later I'm down 25#, a bunch of other issues I didn't think were sugar related have disappeared and my blood work shows cholesterol levels have not just dropped, but have crashed to acceptable levels - and all this with being able to eat bacon. Even for my skeptical nature, Taubes earlier article "What If Everything They Have Been Telling Us is Wrong?" startts to make a whole lot of sense.
CosmicConservative
In all honesty, I started reading the WWGF book with a real healthy dose of skepticism. The first few pages didn't do much to alleviate that. It wasn't until he started talking about the endocrinology that I began to start taking it seriously. My college background is in physics, but I did take biology and remember enough about the digestive processes to at least get a feel that this wasn't bullsh*t. There truly are biochemical processes that regulate our metabolism, and that does include the storing and burning of fat. When he started describing the way insulin affects that regulation, and began relating the process of insulin resistance leading to more insulin production, leading to more fat storage, and higher blood sugar.... that's when I started realizing that he was describing exactly what my doctor has been telling me for years. Perhaps I am not as skeptical as I should be. I made it a point to read all the negative reviews of the books I could find (which isn't all that easy since the positive reviews outnumber the negative ones by an order of magnitude), but the negative reviews were not as convincing as the positive ones. And, as I said, since he isn't promoting a diet, a website or any other obvious "agenda" (other than selling books of course) that also provides some level of credibility to his points. His research into the medical literature is impressive in its sheer volume and scope. His "Good Calories, Bad Calories" book has probably thirty pages of citations from scientific journals and case studies. Perhaps the most concerning thing about this whole situation is how aggressively and publicly the government health "experts" and academia have leaped to attack Taubes and Atkins and anyone else who suggests that a high carbohydrate diet is leading to obesity and diabetes. The most prominent "experts" in the field have called attempts to reduce carbohydrate intake "tantamount to mass murder" or "irresponsible flim-flammery" or words to that effect. It is singularly telling that I can find no scientific rebuttal of Taube's assertions. The things he says are long-accepted scientific truths appear to actually be long-accepted scientific truths. Nobody disputes insulin's role in regulating fat storage. Nobody disputes how carbohydrates cause insulin spiking in the blood. Nobody disputes that repeated insulin spiking produces insulin resistance in cells. Nobody disputes that study after study has shown no long-term benefit from reducing calories but maintaining a high carbohydrate to fat ratio in diet. Yet the "establishment" continues to call the low carb diet approach a dangerous fad that will lead to heart attack, stroke and diabetes. But all the actual research does indeed seem to contradict that conclusion directly. The more I look at this the more it reminds me of Global Warming. It's a "scientific consensus" that appears to be based more on the culture of scientists than on actual science. Weird.
ragnar
An interesting reaction came from our doctor - previously she had told us (my wife and I) that low carb was dangerous and we should stay far far away from Atkins and his devil diet, keep on with strict portion control, lots of whole grains and avoid fats on pain of seemingly immediate cardiac arrest. After our success, our family doctor, who also seems to have suspiciously lost a few pounds, congratulated us on our weight loss success but became very reserved and did not inquire much as to details or comment, good or bad on the means of our success. The immediate and cynical thought was that she was worried that we would blame her for the all previous years of bad and possibly unhealthy advice that she had provided. Which leads to a different disturbing thought - if, as seems both possible and likely, sugar, carbs and whole grains end up being (very) bad for us, while fat is necessary and healthy, how will the medical and dietary powers that be, explain that their recommendations over the last 40 years did not help, and may even have caused the North American epidemic of obesity and diabetes? ….and how long after before the lawyers start to circle and real lawsuits begin to fly?
CosmicConservative
Dadman, the "Zone diet" is a version of the low-carb diet. According to Wikipedia it was intentionally modeled after the Atkins diet but was deliberately named differently to distance itself from the anti-Low-Carb response of the nutrition establishment.
CosmicConservative
Ragnar, Taubes addresses exactly that question (why did the establish push a dangerous diet on the public for generations?) in both of his books. The answer he gives is a sort of combination of "rush to judgment" on the impact of fats on heart disease, coupled with "corporate influence" on the importance of pushing the low-fat message since that allowed corporations to push their "low fat" advertising as well as anti-fat drugs.
ragnar
I can easily understand how we got to where we are today, what I am having difficulty in predicting is how (and if) the medical, dietary and nutritional powers that be will be able to reverse their message.... "Oh, by the way, everything we have been harping on for a healthy lifestyle for the last 40 years is....wrong, its actually bad for you and is making you diabetic and fat.... so forget what we have told you and try this new regime instead! Trust us, we are professionals.". As if that's going to go over well. In any case everybody is different, not everyone seems to be suited to this type of blood sugar control plan - hopefully it will be as easy as it has been for me, YMMV and all that. Good luck and keep us posted on results.
GaryS
He may not be selling a diet, but he is selling books. The Japanese eat six times the rice, white rice, lots of fruits and vegetables, pasta, and sea food. Very little red meat and fat. They are a modern country with a large part of the work force in sedentary high stress jobs. They have the lowest obesity and highest life expectancy in the world. They have extremely low rates of heart disease and diabetes. They eat 25% less Calories then the typical American. Something to think about.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I was waiting for the "wait, Asians eat rice!" response. Here's the conclusion of a study on the insulin response reaction of Japanese to their diets by a researcher who looked into Japanese diets (not associated with the Atkins diet, just a research on diets in Japan)
Turning our attention back to the Japanese for a moment, does the evidence show that rice is as benign a food as some would have us believe? Well, rather predictably, the answer is no. Earlier this year saw the publication of a study in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition which looked at the relationship between GI and GL and body mass index (BMI) in Japanese women aged 18-20 [1]. The study found that higher GI and GL diets were associated with higher BMI. The differences in BMI were small (but statistically significant), but then again, young Japanese ladies do tend to be on the slim side. Further evidence for the not-so-benign nature of starch in the Japanese diets comes from a study which found the consumption of a high GI diet to be associated with adverse effects on risk markers for cardiovascular disease such as blood fat and insulin levels.
The study also showed how Japanese eat fewer calories than Americans. The reality is that while overall the Japanese people are slimmer than Americans, the ones who eat more rice than their peers have more fat in their bodies as a result.
GaryS
I am not claiming that white rice is good for you. But you’re claiming that white rice and other carbs are a poison causing obesity, heart disease and diabetes. I am just pointing out the Japanese with the lowest obesity and highest life expectancy in the world, who have the third or fourth lowest rates of heart disease and diabetes in the world. Typically eat rice or other carbs with every meal breakfast, lunch and diner, its not as a side dish, they live off the stuff. If rice was as bad as you say, they should have some heath issues you could point too. We do agree that they eat a lot less calories then Americans, and I believe this is a big part of why they are heather. IMHO Americans consume way to much of every thing including the corn syrup that is in soft drinks and other sugar filled treats. But I am not convinced that eating a lower cal diet that includes rice, bread and pasta is not healthy, people in other places do and not just Japan.
CosmicConservative
GaryS, I am not saying that carbohydrates are poison, although I can see how that could be interpreted from my comments. What I am saying is that high levels of BLOOD SUGAR are poison, and are known to be toxic to cells. High levels of blood sugar are known to cause heart disease, liver disease, kidney disease, gout and a host of other problems including, eventually, dementia. Carbohydrates trigger blood sugar spikes. The more carbohydrates you eat, the longer and higher that spike lasts. This leads to high production of insulin, which eventually overwhelms the pancreas and leads to insulin resistance and diabetes. In MY CASE, I'm already at the border of type 2 diabetes because I've pumped so much sugar into my blood for so long. So for my body carbohydrates are more damaging than they would be to someone who does not have insulin issues. So reducing my carbohydrate intake should improve my blood sugar levels, which should have positive impacts on lots of health issues, and not coincidentally, should improve my weight loss. For healthy people carbohydrates in moderation are fine. But eating the way the US Government recommends (more than 50% of your calories from carbohydrates) is a ticking time bomb for lots of people who are probably predisposed genetically towards cellular insulin resistance or pancreatic insulin limits. That's what I'm saying. What I am pointing out is that rice has the same effects, and studies of the Japanese confirm that Japanese people who eat higher proportions of rice in their diets have higher BMI and higher incidence of all of the diseases associated with insulin resistance.
Dadman
I tend to agree with GaryS. Like with anything else in life I believe moderation is the key when considering our carb consumption. My preferred approach is to avoid refined sugar, limit my carb consumption as much as possible to fresh fruits and vegetables, avoid fatty red meat, and watch my portion sizes. When I do these things with consistency I drop weight. My sister, btw, dropped a huge amount of weight by eliminating sugar and most complex carbs from her diet. She still eat carbs but only in the form of raw oatmeal, salads (greens), beans, etc., and only in moderation. I would guess that Taubes would approve of this kind of approach because it significantly limits high GL and GI foods. But again I tend to agree with the idea that Americans are fat because they eat too much of nearly everything. Of course, since we are all so different, I recognize it is entirely possible that carbs are indeed poison to one person and perhaps not so toxic to the next. Genetics no doubt play a significant role in the impact of certain foods on individual health...
Dadman
Didn't see your previous response. I agree with that too. Certainly those who are already in the diabetes zone need to be careful with carbs...and many others who are approaching the diabetes zone should do the same...
Dadman
I meant to mention that I just finished reading 'The Hunger Games' and really enjoyed it. Looking forward to the movie this weekend....
CosmicConservative
I better get to reading "Hunger Games" then, I promised the Cosmic Daughter I'd read it before the movie came out... I don't really see a conflict between what Gary is saying and I'm saying. Had I eaten carbohydrates in moderation throughout my life, I'm sure I wouldn't now be in the position of having to treat them as dangerous dietary items. However, I don't want to lose track of the fundamental point that our current "official government policy" is to push a diet that promotes carbohydrates as "good for you" and fats as "bad for you" when everything I am seeing about weight gain, diabetes, heart disease, etc. is that is almost certainly wrong. A high carb diet is almost certainly a root cause for our current obesity and diabetes "epidemic." The message that carbs are good for you and you should eat so much of them is a bad message.
Dadman
I agree...and our genius government is about to become the ultimate arbiter of our healthcare. I truly believe Obamacare, namely the rationing it will inevitably lead to, will be the end of me. BTW, Hunger Games is a very engaging, easy read. I finished it in a few hours...so you have plenty of time. :)
Andy
Dunno, Cosmic. My diet is almost all carbs, and I don't gain weight (much). Ate cornbread, purple hull peas, and scalloped 'taters for supper a few minutes ago. That's pretty well my normal evening meal. Actually, during the winter I gain about 10 pounds, but it drops back off in the Spring when I get more active. I honestly think it's a lot more about activity than the fuel source. But, that's just me. Every pile of humanity is put together differently...what works for one does not for others... Genetics, hormones, etc... I've given up trying to figure it out.
GaryS
I have been healthy as a horse my whole life, my weight has never been a problem, then about four month ago I found out I have high blood pressure and high cholesterol (I’m 50 years old). I lost weight by cutting back on red meat, pork, sweets, anything fried and eating more fish and chicken (white meat only) often with rice or potatoes, I am eating more greens too. Have lost about 20 pounds, currently at 6 foot & 180 pounds, but still on medication for the high blood pressure and cholesterol. I understand your problem is with blood sugar and I wish you luck on an Atkins type diet, my wife has lost significant weight using it several times, but she did not stay on it and gained the weight back quick. Not to beat a dead horse but your study implies that if the skinniest, healthiest people on the planet would just give up the food there diet is build around they be even heather and thinner? Maybe, but I would be happy to be as healthy as the Japanese are now. But I understand it may not be the diet for you given your issue with Blood sugar. I agree with Andy that genetics play a roll; high blood pressure runs in my family.
CosmicConservative
Gary, about 15 months ago I embarked on a fairly typical diet. I cut my caloric intake to 1,200 calories per day, increased my exercise to at least 45 minutes of "brisk" exercise per day and cut out sweets, "white stuff" (meaning anything white, white bread, potatoes, rice, pastries, etc.) And it worked. I lost 25 pounds fairly easily and quickly. I got my blood sugar under control. I improved my cholesterol levels. I had tipped the scales at 205 pounds at the time I got the "you are now diabetic" message from my doctor. After three months of draconian diet imposition I was at 180. I had briefly gotten down to about 176, but that didn't last long. Still, 180 was pretty good. And my doctor was pleased. And I felt better, both physically and just better about myself. I was down to a 32" waist (about what I had when I graduated college in 1984) and no longer had the bulging "love handles" lapping over my belt. So I went back to eating a more "normal" diet, but with a lot more attention to portion sizes and a lot more focus on getting my daily 45 minute walk in. That also "worked". For eight months or so my weight fluctuated between the high 170s and low 180s. Then the holiday season hit. by December I was back in the 180-185 range. But for some reason I found it far more difficult to lose that little bit of weight than it had been the year before. It seems like I've hit a wall right at about the 180 pound mark. And I have to keep at it every day or the weight starts to creep back up. A fairly typical situation is that I gain about four pounds over the weekend and then lose that weight again the following week. I got frustrated about that and announced here that I was going to re-impose the 1,200 calorie per day diet to get my weight back down to 170, or even 165. Which is another 15-20 pounds of weight to lose. Well, it's not really working. I can get down to 180 easily enough, but every time I try to push it down further, I end up losing all of my energy, I crave sweets or chips or other high-calorie carbohydrate snacks, and since our house is full of carbohydrates, I am losing the willpower battle too frequently. This morning I was at 181 pounds when I stepped on the scale. A few weeks ago my weight topped out at 187.5 pounds. That set alarm bells ringing. Since I had heard such great things about the Taubes books, I decided to buy them. So I did. Last weekend I decided to actually read them. They make sense. The arguments seem well constructed, quite logical and are supported by literally 30+ pages of scientific studies he cites. The fundamental idea that keeping your blood sugar low causes your body to break up triglycerides in your fat cell so your body can get its energy from fatty acids seems to be completely supported in the medical literature. So I thought I'd give it a try. I've been on an "Atkins-style" diet for about three days now, except I had a major lapse last night when the family voted to eat at "Schlotsky's" and I ended up eating half a sandwich. But I'm hoping that's not too much of a problem. I will keep you all posted. One of the main reasons I am intrigued by this approach is that on the 1200 calorie per day diet I am constantly fighting powerful hunger and craving urges. So far I have been nibbling on beef and turkey jerky to fight those urges. If the Taubes approach is correct, doing so should not cause me to gain as much weight as an equal amount of, say, Hershey bars. I'll find out soon enough and will report back here. At least so far I have not been as hungry and my cravings have seemed to be less intense.
JSullins
What does your book say about diet softdrinks?
CosmicConservative
It doesn't really say anything about them. But I have seen some indications online that diet soft drinks also spike insulin production. But there are also a ton of rebuttals saying that they do not. So since I mostly drink "Coke Zero", "Cherry Coke Zero" or "Sprite Zero", all of which have "Splenda" I searched the web for indications of what Splenda does for insulin. Again, there appears to be a lot of debate on whether Splenda has any impact on insulin or not. I am strongly, strongly considering just drinking water from now on, just in case.
GaryS
I understand your frustration, and I hope the Atkins diet works for you, my wife found that after a week or two, no matter how much protein or fat she ate she would start losing weight, she was also never hungry, but unfortunately she would still get cravings and the Atkins diet tolerates cheating poorly. And when she went off it she would quickly gain back the weight lost and then some. Personal I don’t believe I could stay on Atkins long term, and I believe that’s what it takes to make it work. But everyone is different you may be able to stick with it. My story is I spent six months in Iraq, left in January to redeploy to Afghanistan but needed to pass a flight physical, no problem I passed the last nine, but I failed, apparently I am a heart attack waiting to happen. very disappointing, for the first time in my life I felt old. I am stuck in Kuwait which limits how much I can change my diet, but when I get home I plan to experiment, like you I feel its important to be a bit underweight. Please keep us informed of your progress, sounds like you have been quite successful losing weight and improving your health so far.
CosmicConservative
Gary, I think you are correct about the intolerance of the Atkins diet. If what Taubes is saying is correct, even a little carbohydrate intake will reverse the direction of fat loss into fat storage again. You really do need to keep your blood sugar below a threshold. I dunno if I'm going to try to "stick with" the Atkins diet long-term. Right now my short-term goal is to crack 170 for the first time since the 80s. I am also reducing my overall caloric intake while moving to a more protien and fat based diet. The big difference in my current approach and my last year's diet is that I am truly pushing hard to stop eating carbs more than necessary but am allowing myself to "snack" on small beef or turkey jerky bits to satisfy any cravings. I will indeed keep you posted.