Why We Get Fat
By CosmicConservativeSo, last year when I began my attempt to reverse a potential descent into type 2 diebetes, several people recommended that I read a book called "Why We Get Fat" by Gary Taubes.
Having long considered dietary literature to be essentially as credible and scientific as paranormal literature, I politely declined offers to loan the book to me and responded with variations of "dieting is simple. You eat less and exercise more. Thermodynamics takes care of the rest." And I went on my way, dropped to a 1,200 calorie per day diet, made sure to exercise at least 45 minutes per day and sure enough, the pounds melted away.
But having now been exposed to the book, and a previous book by the same author, "Good Calories, Bad Calories", I started seeing recommendations for the book everywhere, including on some sites (such as "Instapundit" which relentlessly promotes the books) that I hold in high regard.
So, although I have not regressed badly in my dietary habits and have managed to keep off the weight I lost last year, when my weight started creeping back up and I decided to reinstate my "draconian dietary restrictions", on a whim, I purchased the books off of Amazon.com. And I promptly put them in a pile of "books to read" that I have not gotten to (that pile includes "The Hunger Games" by the way).
Well, this weekend I decided to pick up "Why We Get Fat" and began reading it.
My initial reaction was "huh, so 'calories in, calories out' doesn't work eh? What about me? It worked fine for me."
But I found the book to be very interesting as it was a pretty decent high-level introduction to the biological basis for gaining weight. So I kept reading.
And it was making sense. And the more I read, the more I realized that the book wasn't about "getting fat" it was about "Why we develop type 2 diabetes, heart disease and a host of other western diseases'." "Getting fat" was really more of a symptom of a deeper hormonal imbalance that was tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning.
Not to go into any great detail but the fundamental concept presented in the book is that the modern carbohydrate based diet pushed by doctors, the government and even nutritionists for the past fifty years is basically a blueprint to wrecking your insulin balance, which leads directly to type 2 diabetes and all the health problems related to that.
The more I read, the more I realized that my own dietary history was directly implicated. In fact I could have been the model for the book. The high-carbohydrate diet leading to insulin resistance causing pancreatic insulin over-production ending up with type 2 diabetes could have been taken directly from my medical charts. The litany of health problems associated with insulin imbalance included kidney problems, liver problems, gall bladder problems, gout, kidney stones.... GEEZ LOUISE!!! This was reading like a biography of ME.
And the message of the book was clear, even if Taubes didn't put it into these words.
The modern western diet is tantamount to self-inflicted sugar poisoning.
This isn't even about losing weight! Gaining weight might be the LEAST concerning health consequence of a high-carbohydrate diet.
So I'm thinking hard now about my diet not from a "losing weight" perspective, but more from a "reversal of sugar poisoning" perspective. Blood sugar is downright toxic. Chronic blood sugar elevation is toxic to almost all of the cells in the body. It is particularly hard on internal organs such as the heart, liver and kidneys.
The book did not really provide a road map for "eating right" because that book had already been written ("Good Calories, Bad Calories"). So now I'm starting to read that book.
But the fundamental concept is clear. Sugar is not merely fattening. Sugar is addictive and is toxic. Carbohydrates from common sources like breads, potatoes, rice, pasta and desserts are converted to sugar almost instantly in the blood, so are not much different than sucking down spoonfuls of sugar. Fructose is, if anything, WORSE than table sugar.
I am now embarking on a war against sugar. I'll let you know how it goes.
Comments (26)