Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Tebow's first start...

By CosmicConservative
Well, his QB rating was 100.5, 8/16 for 138 yards, one TD and no interceptions. And I saw at least three perfectly thrown balls dropped, one a sure touchdown. Without those drops he'd have been 11/16 for close to 200 yards and two touchdowns. Add in his 78 yards rushing (and one touchdown) and that's a pretty good day for Michael Vick. Considering that he spent the whole day with the Oakland front line in his face, I thought he did pretty darn well. Also it was a rainy day and the ball was slick enough that Oakland's QB, Jason Campbell, was having a tough time finding his own receivers. Based on his results in throwing the ball, I think the Denver game plan was seriously flawed by calling twice as many running plays as passing plays. Since the Raiders were teeing off on the running plays on first and second down, Tebow was in 3rd and long on most of his passing plays, with at least a couple Raiders in his backfield. Yet I didn't see him make a throw that I would call a bad throw. And after all the talk about his awkward throwing motion, I have to say he either improved it dramatically, or else people are just full of BS. He doesn't have the quickest release in the game, but he's at least as quick getting rid of the ball as Kyle Orton, who also isn't known as a quick-release QB, and yet was leading the league in passing until two games ago. I'd say it was a good start. It's not Tebow's fault that the Denver defense gives up 80 yard plays like candy to the opposition. For all the talk about Tebow vs. Orton, the real problem with these Broncos is a defense that is incapable of stopping the run, and gives up huge passing plays at least three or four times per game. It will be interesting to see who starts next week.

Comments (7)

Andy
I didn't watch it, but I'd say from the stats, and your description of what went down...not a bad first effort. Throughout Tebow's entire college career, I always heard, "Yeah, he's great, but he'll never make it in the pros." I never understood that thinking. He's gonna be just fine.
CosmicConservative
The local sports reporter on KOA is a Tebow-hater. He was beside himself when Tebow was drafted. He has habitually snarked on Tebow ever since. He is definitely one of those "Tebow will never be able to play QB in the NFL" people. He started his Momday morning sports report today with these words: "This just in. Tim Tebow is not the second coming of John Elway and did not save the franchise." His smugness just dripped out of my radio. He went on to snark on Tebow not throwing enough passes and implied as strongly as he could that the coaching staff clearly did not trust Tebow to throw. You could feel his glee through the radio. I think it will be very interesting to see who starts next week.
Andy
Well, it seems like Timbow might start. And, he'll likely get smacked around. Jeepers, did the KOA monor really say that he is not the second coming of Elway? Was this guy not around when Elway showed up at Mile High? Sigh...
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I felt like calling in and telling him that whatever else Tebow may have done, he didn't line up behind a guard.
Drax
I don't believe that Teebow will ever be an "elite" QB. He just doesn't have the skills. But, I believe that he can be a WINNING QB if the scheme is tailored to suit his skills and he has something resembling a decent team around him. I think that he can raise the level of play of those around him because he won't quit or accept less than full effort from those around him. We'll see. I want his to succeed. He's just an all around good guy from every account. And, as it stands right now, there isn't a single person in the league I root for...and, come Sundays, I wanna root for someone...
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure I agree that Tebow doesn't have the skills. I think he doesn't have the experience and he's a bit overwhelmed by the speed of the NFL game right now. He has to learn that his basic instinct from college, to run the ball, is the WRONG basic instinct in the NFL. In the NFL the basic instinct should be to move up in the pocket and look for a place to throw the ball. This is the lesson Michael Vick had to learn, and HAS learned. As far as his skills are concerned, his instincts for avoiding the rush look very good to me. His ability to throw the ball actually impressed me. He made some NFL quality throws, including a couple of touchdown throws, one of which was dropped. I hear a lot of commentators saying that he shouldn't have thrown the touchdown that Brandon Lloyd caught, but I disagree. That's a designed play where the ball is thrown to the corner and the receiver is supposed to use his size and strength advantage to either catch the ball, or to knock it away from the defenders. Lloyd fell down, or was knocked down. Yes it was lucky that he caught it, but Tebow's throw was exactly where it was supposed to be, when he threw it, Lloyd wasn't yet on the ground. He also displayed good touch on the ball on bubble screens and short passes. And when he had to uncork one, he easily showed the arm strength of a Jay Cutler. To me the question of whether Tebow has the "skills" will boil down to whether he can adjust to the speed of the NFL defenses. And that's always the challenge for a rookie QB. Everything I've seen so far from Tebow is consistent with the physical skills needed to be an elite QB. The mental skills are still in question, but mostly, imho, boil down to his adjusting to the speed of the NFL game. I was very impressed with his control of the huddle, his apparent ability to connect with his teammates and his ability to call the right play and execute the play he called. Right now I'd say that the outlook is much more positive for Tebow than negative. Just my $.02.