Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What is the funniest movie?

By CosmicConservative
Dean Esmay has a post on Monty Python and the Holy Grail, which makes me wonder what the funniest movie ever was. I have to admit that I find it hard to top MPATHG. The movie has both quantity and quality of humor. Even the background stuff is funny. Here are some examples of what I find funniest in the movie, and it's a pretty long list:
  1. The whole "She's a witch" skit is one of the funniest skits of all time.
  2. The argument between Arthur and the French knights in England who threaten to "taunt you a second time" is rib-hurting funny.
  3. For sheer surrealism, it is hard to top the "You've got two empty halves of coconuts and you're banging them together!" skit. That's the one with the whole discussion of sparrow speeds, laden and unladen.
  4. And that's not even mentioning the legendary "Black Knight" scene.
  5. Or the scene Dean linked to on the "Vorpal Bunny" which is probably the single scene that brings me to tears every time I watch it. "Look at the Bones, man!"
  6. And we still have the Lancelot rescue scene of the young prince, the Castle Anthrax, Knights of Nee, Bring out your dead, etc.
There are other movies that are incredibly funny. Some that come to mind are: It's a mad, mad, mad, mad world A couple of the Peter Seller's Pink Panther movies Dr. Strangelove Raising Arizona Jaws (maybe that's just me though) Young Frankenstein Animal House Ghostbusters Oh Brother, Where Art Thou The Jerk Airplane CaddyShack (one of the few that might challenge MP & Holy Grail) Now, this list is my list of laugh-out-loud movies, not just any old funny movies. Note that some comedies I like a lot, such as Bringing Up Baby, or The Odd Couple, or Sleepless In Seattle, did not make the list, because they are funny, but they do not engender helpless hilarity. It's a different kind of funny. Just about every one of the movies above has memorable lines that just crack me up hearing them. Here are some lines if you can link them to the movies they came from: "You put that steering wheel back on the right side and move this car." "What knockers!" "Next time someone asks if you are a god, SAY YES!" "He hates cans!" "It's a cross between Kentucky bluegrass, featherbed bent and California sensimilla" "I'm a zit!" "It's not my dog." "I'm barren!!" "They might harpoon us, but they dang sure ain't gonna spot us on no radar screen!" "I seem to be only one unaffiliated." I need to get all those movies on DVD...

Comments (11)

Drax
A guilty pleasure...."Dumb and Dumber." About the only movie that actually had me fall out of my chair at the theatre.... Raising Arizona. (Saw for the first time at a movie house/pizza parlor/pub...with beer and friends.....fun stuff.) Can't really put the Marx Brothers movies up there, but close. "Shakiest Gun in the West." Don Knotts at his best. "Cat Baloo" Jane Fonda at her sexiest (well, maybe Barbraella...) "Some Like it Hot." Ah Marilyn... "The Nutty Professor." These are just additions to your list....
Dean Esmay
Duck Soup is hilarious. My favorite Python movie has long been "The Life of Brian." Young Frankenstein probably gets my vote for funniest movie of all time. I saw Ghostbusters again recently and as influential as it was, I was surprised by how poorly it had aged. Some parts that seemed screamingly funny when it came out now seem a little dated. The phrase "he slimed me" for example.
Drax
How could I forget "Young Frankenstein?" We'll miss you Madelene...
CosmicConservative
Cat Ballou has some hilarious moments, but it also has some long boring sequences too (imho). I saw Life of Brian. I knew Life of Brian, and believe me, Life of Brian is no Holy Grail. Dumb and Dumber may be better than I give it credit. I'd have to see it again to judge.
CosmicConservative
Speaking of Don Knotts... "Shakiest Gun in the West" was indeed a funny movie, but so was "How to Frame a Figg" and "The Reluctant Astronaut". Don't forget "The Incredible Mr. Limpet" either. But now I am feeling pretty bad about missing "Support your Local Gunfighter" and "Support your Local Sheriff" two of the funniest westerns of all time. It doesn't get much funnier than Bruce Dern trying to explain to Walter Brennan that he wasn't able to escape from the jail with no bars because James Garner lied to him about whether his gun was loaded. "Support Your Local Gunfighter" wasn't as good, but it was funny too. One of the great lines in movie history was Harry Morgan explaining to James Garner why his daugher was such a hopeless scatterbrain. "Pooberty hit her pretty hard." Those are funny movies.
John
I'll second Dumb and Dumber. The only movie that made me laugh till I cried - THREE TIMES. -The scene with the hot peppers, ketchup, and mustard. -The scene where the 2 are sword fighting with their canes before the snow owl benefit. -The scene where Harry whales Lauren Holly with a snowball after she playfully hits him with one.
Martin L. Shoemaker
Monty Python: leaves me cold. It’s a mad, mad, mad, mad world: I loved it when I was a kid. Haven't seen it since, so I don't know how well it held up. Peter Seller’s Pink Panther movies: Zzzzzzzzz. Raising Arizona: Very wry, very funny. Young Frankenstein: One of the few Mel Brooks films I laugh at, Animal House: Zzzzzzzzz. Ghostbusters: If not the funniest movie ever, it's pretty close. Oh Brother, Where Art Thou: Zzzzzzz. The Jerk: Zzzzzzzz. I know, I know, it's lame; but I really only appreciate the modern, "sensitive" Steve Martin. All of Me was the first film of his I liked. Airplane; I liked a lot of the bits; but somehow, all strung together, it falls apart for me. CaddyShack: One of the few films where I found Chevy Chase funny. Cat Baloo: Funny, but some parts stretch too long. The Incredible Mr. Limpet: Cute, but I laughed a lot more at The Ghost and Mr. Chicken. Now I'll add some to the list... Casino Royale (the original feature film, not the original teleplay nor the upcoming remake). I sometimes wonder how anyone had the gall to make another Bond film after this film skewered all the cliches. Hudson Hawk. Either you understand why, or I can't possibly explain it to you. I'll watch it back to back, and laugh just as hard the second time. Who's Minding the Mint. Very rare film with Jim Hutton. It's a caper film, but all done as comedy. Start the Revolution Without Me. Another very rare one, a spoof of Dumas-like French nobility/revolution films. Gene Wilder and Donald Sutherland play two sets of twins accidentally jumbled at birth. One set of twins grows up to be peasants reluctantly drafted into the revolution. The other set grows up to be nobility and assassins, scheming to take the crown for themselves. And of course, the two sets get switched. The film opens with Orson Welles reading the story from a big book, as the narrator; but he doesn't get very far before he grumbles that it's not a very good movie, "because I am not in it." The royal ball scene is hilarious. "I thought it was a costume party." And the dead falcon makes me laugh my head off. Every trope of French intrigue is skewered; and the ending is so loopy, I'm laughing at it now. The Producers (the original). This is the only Brooks film that I really find to be as funny as his reputation led me to expect. I'm afraid to see the new version, for fear it will let me down.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, "The Ghost and Mr. Chicken" that's the Don Knotts movie I was trying to remember! Thanks. It's funny what differences in humor people have. The hot pepper scene in Dumb and Dumber was one of the parts of that movie where I tend to get up and go find something else to do. I don't typically find that sort of thing humorous, regardless of who does it. Hot sauce, hot peppers, tobasco sauce, whatever the source of the gag, and whether it's Bugs Bunny, Lucille Ball or Larry, Moe and Curly, I just don't find such things funny. And beyond that, I don't understand what's supposed to MAKE it funny. On the other hand, I did get a kick out of Harry firing a four-seam fastball at Mary after her playful little toss. I have not seen "The Producers" but have been told by many people that it is one of Brooks' best efforts. I wonder if there is some sort of "humor profile" that you can take to determine what sort of things you find funny.
Mary Janelle
Great list above. I really liked Animal House too.
Dadman
Some glaring gaps in the above lists: Ferris Bueller's Day Off. A classic comedy that is still very funny after multiple viewings. Sleeper. I haven't seen this Woody Allen film in years, but I laughed my arse off when I first saw it. Trains, Planes and Automobiles. Perhaps John Candy's best role. A hilarious film. And now a controversial selection... Home Alone (the first one). The bumbling antics of Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern are classic physical comedy performances in the tradition of the Three Stooges. The subsequent Home Alone films wore out the successful formula of the original, but the original is still a hoot. I also like many of the films listed above - The Holy Grail in particular - but I wanted to add something new to the thread.
CosmicConservative
How could I forget old Ferris? Sleeper has the manic insanity that it needs to be on the list too. Planes, Trains and Automobiles has to be disqualified due to the sappy ending ;) Home Alone actually was pretty good too, now that you mention it. But mentioning Joe Pesci reminds me of another that needs to be on the list, the inimitable "My Cousin Vinny." I notice there are no animated movies listed. Is that because animated movies aren't as funny?