Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN.com - Carter: Bush Israel's 'worst ally' in D.C.

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Carter: Bush Israel's 'worst ally' in D.C. - Aug 5, 2006
"In my opinion, maybe the worst ally Israel has had in Washington has been the George W. Bush administration, which hasn't worked to bring a permanent peace to Israel," Carter told the newspaper.
I wonder if Jimmy wouldn't mind asking Israel what they think of GW Bush as an ally? And when it comes to "bringing a permanent peace to Israel" being the job of a U.S. President, wasn't Jimmy Carter a U.S. President? If he wasn't able to bring a "permanent peace" to the middle east, why is he suggesting that's the measure of the Bush administration's success? I have tried to stop commenting on Jimmy Carter because I truly believe the man to have become senile. His comments in the past several years have become increasingly bizarre and divorced not only from reality, but seem to indicate that he does not even recall his own history. Jimmy Carter is the President on whose watch Islamic fascism become a factor in the world. It was his administration that saw the emergence of the Iranian mullah's who have been fomenting Jihad ever since. What sort of credibility does he think he has in this? And if the mainstream media were not a mouthpiece of the Democratic party, his utterances would never see the light of day.

Comments (12)

Thespis
Great Article! I wanted to ping back to your article from mine: Jimmy Carter Quacks Again! http://thespisjournal.blogspot.com/2006/08/jimmy-carter-quacks-again.html
Avery Davis
You are patently wrong and here's why. Jimmy Carter did indeed facilitate the peace accords between Israel and Egypt as well as the peace between Israel and Jordan. Both countries took part in the 1967 war and thanks to President Carter's diplomatic leadership both countries agreed to cease hostilities and formally acknowledged Israel's right to exist. I might add these are currently the ONLY lasting peace accords Israel has managed to reach since its inception, so yes I would think President Carter has a great deal of clout on this particular topic.
CosmicConservative
You are welcome to your opinion. Yes the Egypt/Israel accords have been successful, but led directly to Anwar Sadat's assassination and were in part a reason for the rise in Islamic fascism at that time. But whatever may have been accomplished between Israel and Egypt has been far overshadowed by the Iran debacle and the rise in Islamic terrorism that may not have begun with Carter, but became an international force under Carter. And whether Jordan or Egypt have been "officially at war" with Israel or not is not the issue here, neither is Lebanon, is it? The issue here is that we have terrorist attacks going on, and didn't I just see a story that the Egyptian wing of Islamic Jihad was joining Al Qada? What exactly did J.C. accomplish again?
Avery Davis
You are welcome to your opinion. President Carter's spearheading the Camp David Accords, and the Panama Canal Treaties is FACT not opinion - that is it actually happened, not something I just heard on talk radio. And yes it did lead to Sadat's assanination, but was that Carter's fault or the Muslim Brotherhood's? Isn't that a bit like blaming Bush for Hezbollah's current attacks on Israel? My comment was a response to - If [Carter] wasn’t able to bring a “permanent peace” to the middle east, why is he suggesting that’s the measure of the Bush administration’s success?. My point was Carter did work to bring a measure of “permanent peace” to the middle east whereas Bush seems totally disinterested in diplomacy. ... didn’t I just see a story that the Egyptian wing of Islamic Jihad was joining Al Qada? Could be ... didn't I the Iraqi PM offer amnesty to insurgants who attacked American soldiers? What does either have to do with Carter critisizing Bush? What exactly did J.C. accomplish again? Only the longest lasting peace Israel has managed to negotiate with any of its neighbors, set out a plan to eliminate America's dependance on foreign oil way back in 1978 (later dismantled by Regan), and won a Nobel Peace Prize for championing Human Rights around the world.
CosmicConservative
Avery:
And yes it did lead to Sadat’s assanination, but was that Carter’s fault or the Muslim Brotherhood’s? Isn’t that a bit like blaming Bush for Hezbollah’s current attacks on Israel?
Um... isn't that what this is all about? Didn't this whole thread start with the accusation from JC himself that Bush was at fault for the current Lebanon situation? So yes, it's exactly like that, that's the point. If Carter can blame Bush for Hezbollah in Lebanon, then I can blame Carter for Islamic Jihad in Egypt. It is exactly the same thing. Your definition of "peace" seems to be that Israel is not at war with Egypt or Jordan. OK, I'll accept that definition. Israel is not "at war" with Lebanon, Iran or Syria either. And has not been for as long as they have not been at war with Jordan or Egypt. So your whole argument is based on the fallacious statement that "peace" is equated with "no declared war with a nation-state". If "peace" is defined as "no hostilities from terrorists" then Israel has been at war with Egypt and Jordan just as they are with Lebanon. All of the Arab states support terrorism when it is aimed at Israel. Lebanon is the focus today, but Egyptian Islamic Jihad supports terrorism against Israel just as firmly as Hezbollah does. The difference is that Iran provides funds, arms and political cover for Hezbollah. But according to your logic, that's fine, so long as Iran is not "at war" with Israel. I repeat myself again. Carter is defining "peace" as "no fighting between terrorists and Israel" if he is saying that Bush is responsible for the lack of "peace" in the region. According to that definition Carter was just as miserable a failure as Bush, or Bush is just as wonderful a success as Carter. So until there is "War" declared between Israel and an Arab country, your argument says that Bush is a brilliant Middle East negotiator, since he has been just as successful in "stopping" war in the middle east as Jimmy Carter was.
Avery Davis
So your whole argument is based on the fallacious statement that “peace” is equated with “no declared war with a nation-state”. My definition of peace is that no one is dieing from deliberate acts of aggression. I would say Israel is at war with the PLO and Hezbollah (as opposed to any nation). Carter did NOT say Bush is responsible for the fighting, he critisized him for not doing anything to try and stop the fighting once it was clear it was going to escalate and thousands of people on both sides were going to die. Carter critisized Bush for his lack of diplomacy period. You asked 'What sort of credibility does [Carter] think he has in this?' and I told you. I repeat myself again. Carter is defining “peace” as “no fighting between terrorists and Israel” if he is saying that Bush is responsible for the lack of “peace” in the region. According to that definition Carter was just as miserable a failure as Bush, or Bush is just as wonderful a success as Carter. So until there is “War” declared between Israel and an Arab country, your argument says that Bush is a brilliant Middle East negotiator, since he has been just as successful in “stopping” war in the middle east as Jimmy Carter was. Your logic here is tortured to make an argument that is irrevelent. Carter never accused Bush of being responsible for the hostilities, he critisized his inaction and apparent nonchalance towards the massive killings and scorched earth policy inacted by Israel. In a time when we need all the allies we can get in the middle east it is irresponsible for the US President to sit back and watch Israel use American armaments to level entire blocks.
CosmicConservative
Avery, you can read and interpret Carter's comments how you like, and I will do the same. Obviously we do not agree on what Carter said and what he meant. Obviously I think I have it right and you have it wrong. I used to like Jimmy Carter as a person. However, I thought he was the most incompetent President of my lifetime and history has pretty much agreed with my analysis there. His Presidency was the low-mark in U.S. foreign policy of my lifetime. It was in Carter's reign that "Paper Tiger," "Malaise", "Stagflation" and "Oil shortages" become part of the American lexicon. You are free to adore Carter all you like. My opinion of him is that he single-handedly destroyed U.S. prestige in the world through inaction, incompetence and misjudging our enemies intentions and capabilities. You adore Carter, I'll adore Reagan. I'm pretty sure you don't share my respect and admiration for Reagan.
Avery Davis
I don't adore Carter, but I do think he's a good man even if a poor president. My point here has been that Carter's done more to secure peace in the middle east than Bush and as such he has credibility to call Bush out for his inaction. Not just in the recent conflict, but since he came to office. I almost agree with you - until Bush, Carter was the most ineffective president of my life time as well. You're free to adore Regan - free to ignore Iran-Contra where he sold arms to Iran (against the will of congress) to pay drug lords to overthrow the elected government in Nicaragua (again against the will of congress). I'll pick Clinton who was exonerated of any wrong doing in a 4 year investigation by a rabid independant counsel and impeached for lieing about an affair. Amazing, Clinton lies about having an affair and gets impeached ... Regan lies about selling weapons to a terrorist nation to fund the overthrow of a democratically elected government and all is forgiven.
CosmicConservative
Avery: Bill Clinton did not "lie about an affair". He obstructed an active investigation into his behavior in connection with a lawsuit brought against him by Paula Jones. His "lying about an affair" was not an attempt to protect his family, it was outright perjury in a court of law that was intended to undercut Paula Jones' case against him. His behavior with Monica Lewinsky was explicitly relevent to the case Paula Jones was making, which is why her team went after that testimony in the first place. If you don't understand why it is important that the top Law Enforcement Officer in the country obey they law and tell the truth when sworn to do so in order to settle a case in a court of law, then there isn't much point in arguing with you anyway. I don't give a fig if Clinton had an affair, but I do care greatly that a man sworn to defend and uphold the constitution perjured himself while under oath in an official court proceeding. That's why Clinton's lies mattered. Reagan's Iran-Contra affair is a serious blot on an otherwise magnificent legacy. I have never attempted to defend it or excuse it. But I look at the whole picture, just as I do with Clinton and Bush. Again, if Carter did so much to secure peace in the middle east, why isn't there peace in the middle east? Your whole argument falls apart. You can only say "Egypt and Jordan haven't gone to war against Israel since Carter." Well, as I have repeatedly pointed out, neither have Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia or any other Arab Nation. Instead they have turned to a strategy of supporting terrorism overtly and covertly. If you think that's a great triumph for Jimmy Carter, then I am just as unlikely to be able to explain why it is a failure as I am unable to explain to you why obstruction of justice and perjury committed by a sitting President is an issue of serious concern.
Avery Davis
Yes! Reagan’s Iran-Contra affair is a serious blot on an otherwise magnificent legacy. I knew I made the right choice lurking around this blog. You may be surprised how many conservatives outright deny Iran-Contra ever happened! I admire your honesty, but here are a few facts you've omitted or gotten wrong: The President isn't the top Law Enforcement Officer ... that's the Attorney General. And I DO understand the importance of the President to be honest with the American people, which is why like you I see the Lewinsky Affair as 'a serious blot on an otherwise magnificent legacy'. I also happen to think Iran-Contra is infinitly more egregious and dangerous than an affair with an intern or a trist with an Arkansas escort. Again, if Carter did so much to secure peace in the middle east, why isn’t there peace in the middle east? This is just silly. It's like saying if we put men on the moon, why aren't they still there today? Carter worked harder than ANY president to attempt to secure peace in the middle east. Did it succeed? For a time, yes. Was it worth the effort? In my opinion, yes. Does this give him credibility to criticize later presidents for not doing enough? I think it does. He also pressured Clinton into meeting with Arafat and Sharon to try and broker peace ... it failed. Does this mean we should give up on diplomacy? Absolutly not!
CosmicConservative
I don't think we have given up on diplomacy. I do think that GW Bush made a conscious effort to take a more direct approach in dealing with terrorism after 9/11. Frankly I think before 9/11 he had just as cavalier attitude about terrorism as Reagan, Bush 41 and Clinton. But 9/11 really shook him up and he decided to go after the roots of it. I can respect someone who thinks that Afghanistan was justifiable but that Iraq was not. I don't agree with that, but I can respect it. I do have a problem with people who don't understand that leaving Iraq now is worse than never having gone in in the first place though. I have never yet encountered a single President who doesn't have an ugly blot on their legacy, and I don't think Lewinsky is Clinton's ugliest blot. Frankly I think his dealings with China and North Korea are his ugliest blot by far. I also think that his choice in cabinet members was egregiously naive and was driven far more by focus groups than by actual competence, and that's what gave us Jocelyn Elders, Janet Reno and Henry Cisneros. But I admire Clinton in many ways. I used to live pretty close to Hope Arkansas, and I know what he grew up with and what he had to overcome to become President. To have accomplished that is a true American success story. So don't expect me to be one of those conservative Clinton bashers. I don't think Clinton was the incarnation of evil. I reserve that sort of evaluation for people like Osama Bin Laden. Bush has been no more and no less successful than other Presidents in the middle east. The main reason for that is that the power and influence of an American president in that region is greatly exaggerated in the U.S. press. The U.S. has been hated there for my entire lifetime, and as far as I can tell, it is no more or no less hated now than when Iran's revolutionary theocrats took 450+ of us hostage for four years. It is going to be a long hard journey to overcome Islamic fascist theocratic ideology. And we are just at the very beginning of that journey. One thing you and I probably agree on is that I don't think the ultimate solution to that conflict is going to be a military one. However, you and I probably will disagree on the justification for military action on a case by case basis. But that's what makes this country great, isn't it?
CosmicConservative
Avery: By the way, I truly appreciate your ability to discuss these things rationally. I consider that a breath of fresh air. Believe it or not, in spite of my having a blog and pontificating at will, I'm really not that sure I'm right about everything. I subscribe to what I call the anthro-cosmological principle, which is a fancy way of saying that people are pretty much the same, and there are so many people who are convinced they are right about things I know are wrong, I have to conclude that I must be wrong about some things I think are right. When I discover them, I try to adjust to them. But sometimes I don't quite get there.