Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Unforced error...

By CosmicConservative
My last post was on the Shirley Sherrod controversy where I took Breitbart to task for publishing a selectively edited video of Shirley Sherrod's speech at the NAACP. The whole imbroglio made the NAACP and Breitbart look bad and ripped the scab off the national racial lesion once again. Which may or may not be a bad thing. But one aspect of this controversy that deserves exploration is the reaction of the White House itself. Within hours of the video going public, White House spokespeople called for Shirley Sherrod to be fired, and she was fired from the USDA. For 24 hours after that the White House stood by its guns and refused to reconsier their call for Sherrod to be fired. Today that stance seems to be softening and the White House says it is "reconsidering" its position on the firing and my ask for her to be reinstated. This is remarkable on several levels. Most importantly it again demonstrates a White House operation that, after 18 months in power still seems to be completely incapable of basic competence. Drax and I have had many discussions about whether Obama is a zealous idealogue or if he is incompetent. In the end I more or less agree with Drax that Obama himself is not incompetent and that he has had significant successes in advancing his radical liberal agenda, successes that will either damage this country in perpetuity, or will be rolled back at great cost by Republicans in the future. But this and similar episodes (such as Hillary Clinton publicly calling out the Pakistani government as Bin Laden accomplices) demonstrate that whatever level of competence Obama himself may have, he demonstrably surrounds himself with incompetent aides, staffers and political appointees. So I've come to a conclusion about Obama that scares me even more than I'm already scared of the man. And that conclusion is that Obama is incapable of evaluating situations except through a partisan progressive filter. His measure of competence has nothing to do with how well someone can do a job, his only concern is if the person has the proper ideology. And since idealogues typically are not rewarded for competence, many of them are truly incompetent in their actual jobs. If I'm right that means that Obama is surrounded by incompetents, regardless of his own competence. And since the President of the United States necessarily has to delegate hundreds or thousands of important decisions to his staff every day, that means the government itself is riddled with incompetent idealogues who are making critically important decisions day after day through hyper-partisan liberal filters. Worse yet, when Obama himself has to get involved in one of those decisions, since the person involved is invariably a "right-thinking" like-minded hardcore progressive, Obama cannot recognize the incompetence and therefore does nothing to improve the situation. To exacerbate this situation, Obama seems to have a bunker mentality when his or his staff's decisions are challenged. Obama frequently doubles down on the incompetent decision that was made in the first place. This is a sort of institutionalized hubris that seems to show a belief in the White House that they can't reverse direction even when it's clear they are on the wrong side of an issue. Eventually this incompetence has to bring the Obama house of cards crashing down. It's just a question of time.

Comments (4)

Drax
Obama's house has already crashed down. If he didn't have 90+% approval by race-blinded blacks, he would now be in the mid-30's in approval, as bad as Bush ever was. I agree about the incompetence of his staff, in general. He has some Chicago political hacks who attempt to rule through thuggery and a slew of ideologues who view everything through their Marxist theology.
Andy
Cosmic, I have been reading your back and forth with Drax about how Breitbart handled all of this. I truly believe that he gacked it! Don't get me wrong...I am an admirer of Andrew. I believe that he is really one of the good guys. I heard him yesterday on Dennis Miller's radio program 'splaining that he received the vid he posted in the shape that he posted it...no editing on his part. And, I honestly believe that he posted it to show the great glee of the NAACP crowd when hearing that "Whitey" got the shaft for once. But, the entire point he was trying to make has been muddled, and he has been marginalized. A good looking into of the situation...a "set up" of what's coming... You know...like good speech writing. "Tell them what you're going to tell them. Tell them. And, then tell them what you told them" would have certainly been in order in this case. As the chips fell, Breitbart takes WAY too much heat from the right, and left. If he had only held fire for a few minutes...checked it out...dug deeper. Then the "moral of the story" he was trying to teach would not have been lost in all the controversy. Just my dos centavos, Amigo.
CosmicConservative
Andy, that's more or less my position on this. But since I can't stop myself, I'll analyze the situation a little deeper. Andrew Breitbart is not just another blogger. When he set up "BigGovernment.com" he did so with fanfare and announcement of his intentions to take on the liberal media establishment. He overtly and gleefully threw the gauntlet in the face of the existing media establishment. In effect he said "bring it on." To use a sports analogy, he promoted himself to the big leagues. And he found funding to back his play. He made the rounds as a budding conservative celebrity. And then he started fulfilling his promise. At first the media establishment most likely ignored him. But, much like Drudge before him, he began to gain traction by cleverly playing on the media's own tendencies. He was successful at this, and so his name grew in both the rightie blogosphere, and in the left. When he released the ACORN tapes, he did so in such a way that he stirred up a major national interest, and in the end forced the mainstream media to cover the story, and in fact he bloodied the nose of liberalism in a very public way. He humiliated a lot of powerful people. And that's when they began pushing back. Breitbart should have gotten the message when his film crew was arrested in Louisiana. He's no longer an annoyance to the Left. He's a threat. The gloves are off. They've been off for months. He's done an amazing thing to get as far as he's gotten, but he has changed the game for himself. He is now a target. Ann Coulter says that Breitbart was snookered himself into running the first edited videos. Perhaps he was. Whether he was or not, there are very powerful people with lots of resources at their disposal who are now fully committed to destroying Andrew Breitbart. This is no longer a game. Andrew is playing in the big leagues, and the rules are different now. Breitbart can no longer be slipshod and lazy in his efforts. He better dot every i and cross every t. Any mistake he makes will be turned into an attack. If possible his enemies will try to hit him with criminal charges. The people he is playing with now play for keeps. So if he wants to compete on that stage, he can't make foolish mistakes which open his right and left flanks for criticism. He is unlikely to gain knee-jerk support from powerful conservatives at this time, so he has to be sure to be right every time. In my opinion he has yet to demonstrate that he has learned that lesson. This episode reveals to me that he still thinks this is a game he can play without careful examination of every angle of possible attack. In a nutshell, Andrew is still playing checkers, but his opponents are playing chess. If he is not careful, he will find himself checkmated soon. But, he's shown an admirable amount of cleverness in the past, and it is quite possible that he might learn how to play the game. One way he could show me he is learning is to now pursue the firing and rehiring of Shirley Sherrod and make this into a story about White House racism and incompetence. Or perhaps better yet, turn this into an investigation of the lawsuit Shirley Sherrod won against the USDA. I've seen some indication that he might be moving in that direction. That would show a strategic sense of how to press an advantage and turn a lost battle into a winning campaign. I'm crossing my fingers for Breitbart, I really am. But he's got to realize that he's no longer in the minor leagues.
Andy
Cosmic, not to flatter here...but that is about as good an analysis of Andrew's rise, current situation, and pathway to the future (hopefully) as I've read. Post it. Heck, I'm just gonna copy it and post it as an unauthorized guest post. Don't take the trouble to delete it...it's already on the clipboard.