Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The tale of Shirley Sherrod

By CosmicConservative
So by now you've all probably heard about the Breitbart posting of a speech at the NAACP by the ex-Agriculture employee, where she made comments about how she once provided inferior service to a white farming couple who were looking for help with their mortgage. It turns out that the part published by Breitbart was taken out of context, and the full story she told was how she overcame her own prejudices and ended up learning a valuable lesson about race. Unfortunately she ended her story with an obligatory leftist screed against Fox News and the Tea Party, but otherwise her tale is quite heartwarming and American. So shame on Breitbart for using the same tactics to get this lady fired that were used to destroy Trent Lott. Now Breitbart is saying that he edited the video to show the reaction of the NAACP audience to Shirley's initial admission of anti-white bias, but although that's a real story and worth telling, it should and could have been done without trashing this woman. Now she's been fired from her job. I guess I've been one of those going around saying "it's time we used the Left's tactics against them!" and I mean that, to a point. Not to the point of destroying lives through selective editing of out of context comments. Let's fight hard, but let's not become the Left, OK? Here's a very good, thoughtful take on the situation from the Anchoress, one of my favorite blogs.

Comments (26)

Chasester
I agree. I also think Breitbart could have also done a second post showing how she and her husband were part of a discrimination lawsuit against the same department, and that the woman should have never been hired in the first place. the false cries of foul play would have still rang from the left - but it wouldn't have gained traction. Lost opportunity.
Andy
Cosmic, I agree. Actually when I watched the video the first time, I was disturbed by it...especially the reaction from the crowd. But, even in that video near the end you could tell where she was going with that. She said "I learned that it wasn't about black/white, rather rich/poor"...or something like that. That is one reason that I didn't make any mention of it. I had a feeling that this was going to turn around and bite somebody.
Cullen
I have always been opposed to the Left's tactics and find them reprehensible. However, the one thing they do that I wish Republicans would pick up on is that they protect their own. Dems are quick to stand up for their colleagues. When Lott was attacked in the press and by Dems, Republicans didn’t circle wagons, they ran away. Republicans almost never protect their fellow party members and when they do, they often pick the wrong fight. Wish we’d get better about that.
Drax
Um...you (and many others) completely miss Breitbart's point. The NAACP had earlier accused the Tea Party of being a collection of racists. Earlier, the NAACP accused tea party members of spitting at black Congress critters and calling them the "n-word." Breitbart said "prove it." After a long time with no proof forthcoming, but the NAACP continuing its libel of all tea party members, Breitbart said to the effect "if you don't stop this, you're going to be sorry as I have proof that the NAACP is racist." The NAACP took up a written resolution that the tea party was racist. Its president clearly stated that tea party members were racist. They continued to assert the false claim that tea party members spat upon and name-called black congress critters. So, Breitbart posted a tape -- not to show any particular speaker as being racist, but an AUDIENCE who listened to CLEARLY racist actions against whites and EXPRESSED THEIR APPROVAL. The "context" in this is MEANINGLESS, because the "context" which was intended (by the speaker) to turn the RACIST ACTIONS into a life lesson CAME LATER. AFTER the racist actions were related. AFTER the AUDIENCE (MEMBERS OF THE NAACP -- INCLUDING ITS PRESIDENT) heard those racist actions and EXPRESSED THEIR COLLECTIVE AND INDIVIDUAL APPROVAL. Breitbart was not attempting to show that Miss Shirley was racist -- he was showing that the NAACP was.
Drax
Missed Hannity last night. Breitbart was on it. He made clear what I stated above: http://gatewaypundit.firstthings.com/2010/07/breitbart-to-hannity-naacp-tarred-tea-party-movement-video/
CosmicConservative
Drax: I didn't miss any of that. I even mentioned the exposing of the racism rampant in the NAACP audience in my post. I also said that Breitbart claimed that he had edited the tape to show that racism. I got all that. What I am saying is that by editing the tape the way he did, without any clarifiction of the speaker's intent and context, he created an impression that the speaker herself was the demonstration of racism at the NAACP, instead of the audience reaction. That was unfair to Shirley Sherrod, who was fired as a result of the clip being exposed. I know that Breitbart was firing back at the NAACP after the NAACP drafted a resolution calling the Tea Party racist. My point here is that he did so in such a way that a person was vilified even though her actual speech, taken fully in context, was about fighting racism, even racism against poor whites. Sure there may be circumstances around Shirley Sherrod's initial hiring that should be investigated, but that's not the point. The point here is whether Breitbart erred in editing the video in such a way that a message was misconstrued and a woman was unfairly demonized. I think that is what happened. Whether Breitbart deliberately put Shirley Sherrod in the crosshairs or did so accidentally is certainly something that concerns me. In the first case Breitbart would be demonstrating a willingness to damage innocents in order to make his point, which is exactly what liberals have been doing for years. It's an "end justifies the means" argument, and I don't like those arguments whether I support the base contention or not. If it was an editorial mistake it is one that borders on editorial incompetence. Does Breitbart have anyone else do final edits on his own work? If not, he should. Whatever Breitbart's intentions here, the end result is that he has damaged his credibility, and that is a shame since he is currently one of the few voices on the right (another being Sarah Palin, who also missed an opportunity on this issue) who is willing to take on the Left head on. I stand by my original post and I don't think I missed a bit of the overall context, importance or overtones of the issue.
Drax
I'm unclear how Breitbart's editing was unfair. His point was EXCLUSIVELY to show the racism of the NAACP. His editing did that. The fact that a racist federal government worker was shown as being a racist federal government worker was IMMATERIAL to his point. (Beyond the snippet Breitbart posted, Miss Shirley claimed that all Republicans are racist and that opposition to Obamacare is, ultimately, due to racism.... Clearly, whatever "lesson" she claimed to learn from her earlier racist actions hasn't completely "took...") And, it's not as if those who reviewing his article and video weren't completely aware of what his point was. They were told REPEATEDLY why Breitbart was posting what he was posting. But, THEY decided to turn the narrative into the racism exhibited by the SPEAKER in the video rather than the AUDIENCE. What their motive in doing so is speculative, but...what are we talking about INSTEAD of the point Breitbart CONCLUSIVELY ESTABLISHED? That, in no way, is Breitbart's fault.
CosmicConservative
Drax, we will have to disagree. To go back to an earlier post here, Breitbart's strategic goal was obscured by his tactical approach. That's Breitbart's fault. However, due to the White House's unforced error on this situation, a larger strategic goal may yet be reached in this affair. If this ends up exposing Obama's willingness to settle a long-running lawsuit against the USDA to the tune of billions of dollars simply because the litigants were black... that could still gain some traction, especially if it turns out that Shirley Sherrod here can't explain where all that money went. There may still be another shoe to drop. But, regardless of that, to use a Sun Tzu analogy here, Breitbart chose the terrain here, and that terrain turned out to be unfavorable to his strategic goals. That's a mistake he shouldn't have made.
Drax
I get it. Because Breitbart chose a snippet of a speech in which the speaker expressed racist actions and thoughts which were immediately cheered by the audience as an example of the audience's racism, the fact that the speaker later mitigated her remarks somehow shows that Breitbart was in error to say that the audience acted in a racist manner in the snippet chosen. Yep. Makes perfect sense to me.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I don't know if you are deliberately avoiding my point, or if you actually don't see what I'm saying. I will let the results of Breitbart's actions demonstrate the tactical error he made. You can say that I'm missing the point and that everyone else is missing the point all you like. It was Breitbart's point to make, and the way he chose to do it did not work. That should be self-evident. Complaining that people misunderstood Breitbart completely overlooks that Breitbart chose the manner and method in which to make his point. Since Breitbart is playing in the major leagues now as an opinion shaper, he has to be judged by his results, not his intentions.
CosmicConservative
Tom, heh, I see DW is still as calm and rational as always...
Drax
Ah, so he had some OTHER manner to make his point and chose this one? Or wasn't video of a federal employee admitting to racist thoughts and actions to the detriment of a white client made to a cheering audience of NAACP members (including its president) good enough? He should make something up? Wait for video which might never present? Or go with what he had...something which EXACTLY and COMPLETELY makes the point he tried to make? Get real. You, like most commentators, have allowed the Progressive Media to control the narrative. Bretibart PRECISELY made his point. He CONCLUSIVELY demonstrated the hypocrisy of the NAACP. Yet, most commentators allow themselves to be controlled by the Progressive Media and concentrate where THEY want attention to be concentrated rather than where it should be concentrated -- where Breitbart shone the spotlight. Man, Trent Lott must be rolling over in his political grave, asking "Where was the 'context' THEN, man...where was it then...?" "Then" it was, like now, EXACTLY where the Progressive media wants it to be. So, no. I get your point. I understand your point. It's just the WRONG POINT.
CosmicConservative
Well, we'll have to disagree again Drax. Here's how I would have done it if I were Andrew and I were truly trying to nail the point of NAACP racism . Racism at NAACP Below I have posted a video of a speech given by an employee of the USDA to an audience of NAACP members. The speech isn't the important part of this, in fact the speaker is using this as a teaching moment to demonstrate how racism is insidious. However, as she relates her own actions before her epiphany about her own prejudice, the NAACP audience cheers and applauds as she describes her previous anti-white racist behavior. *Embed Video* That simple Drax.
Drax
Hindsight is 20/20. Few things, with hindsight, couldn't be made better. But, you don't get my point. It doesn't MATTER how it was "presented." It could have been presented perfectly, yet it would have been spun to mis-direct attention from where it should be. "Breitbart, yet again, attempts to smear the NAACP by presenting a video which contained inflammatory remarks by a black federal employee. Although Breitbart attempts to disguise his smear by minimizing the words of the speaker, it is clear that the selection of this video where a black employee exposes past racist actions and thoughts, was intended to inflame the base." Etc. Etc. It doesn't MATTER how something is "presented." It will be spun. What matters is whether or not we ALLOW the spin to control us.
CosmicConservative
I went back to Breitbart's original "BigGovernment.com" posting of the video. His only comment before presenting the video is "context is everything." And then he proceeds to present an out of context portion of the speech. But that's not all. In the long aftertext (so long I doubt a hundred people actually read it all) he goes on and on about how this refutes the NAACP racism accusations, but on the subject of Shirly Sherrod herself, he says this: "We are in possession of a video from in which Shirley Sherrod, USDA Georgia Director of Rural Development, speaks at the NAACP Freedom Fund dinner in Georgia. In her meandering speech to what appears to be an all-black audience, this federally appointed executive bureaucrat lays out in stark detail, that her federal duties are managed through the prism of race and class distinctions. In the first video, Sherrod describes how she racially discriminates against a white farmer. She describes how she is torn over how much she will choose to help him. And, she admits that she doesn’t do everything she can for him, because he is white. Eventually, her basic humanity informs that this white man is poor and needs help. But she decides that he should get help from “one of his own kind”. She refers him to a white lawyer. Sherrod’s racist tale is received by the NAACP audience with nodding approval and murmurs of recognition and agreement. Hardly the behavior of the group now holding itself up as the supreme judge of another groups’ racial tolerance." This is the very definition of taking things out of context. For example, the actions Shirley is describing took place 24 years prior to the speech, and she was working as a volunteer for a non-profit organization at the time, not as a federal worker as Breitbart implies repeatedly. Secondly, he clearly has seen the whole video which he describes as "meandering" but chooses only to publish this portion of it. He not only allows the out of context video to impugn Ms. Sherrod, he explicitly impugns her himself. This is a shameful moment for Breitbart. And the grief he is taking is self-inflicted. That's not to say I'm no longer a fan of Andrew, I am. I think he's one of the best and brightest things going for the right at the moment, but when he fouls up, I'll say he fouled up. And just as with the White House, this was an unforced error. He could easily have made his point without throwing Ms. Sherrod to the wolves.
CosmicConservative
Drax, our postings crossed. Let me put it this way Drax. Had Breitbart done what I suggested, he would not be taking flack from THIS commentator. Nor, I believe, would he be taking flack from the right at all. Of course he'll get attacked from the left, and they will attempt to deflect attention from his message, that's what they do. That's the battle for ideas in the marketplace of public opinion. Had he done what I suggested, he might very well be getting the same grief from the left, but the RIGHT would be supporting him and rebutting the left instead of shaking their heads and saying "Geez Andrew, that wasn't cool." Shirley Sherrod would not be a distraction and the discussion would be about the NAACP audience racism, which is what he claimed he wanted. Again, this was a very amateurish effort by Breitbart, and I sincerely hope he learns from it. ESPECIALLY if he's got other bombshells to lob.
Tom DeGisi
> Secondly, he clearly has seen the whole video which he describes as “meandering” but chooses only to publish this portion of it. No, that's not clear. It's not clear at all. You can describe only the portion given as meandering. Furthermore, he denies he had the whole video. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
OK, maybe it's not clear, but that sure is the impression I got.
Drax
Had he done it "your way" CC, it would have had the same result. Because the point (proven) was that the NAACP was filled with racists. (I do kind of chuckle that your notion of good journalism in this instance would be to show an entire video (for "context") then tell your readers to ignore everything after a certain point since...uh...it is immaterial to the story.) Context is everything. Of course it is. Everything is "context." Every act, every word is part of the greater whole, but, the greater whole is THE GREATER WHOLE. We can't take that part of the speech out of the whole speech. We can't take that speech out of her activities that year. We can't take that year out of her activities throughout her life. Context is EVERYTHING. Except when, you know...it isn't. It's important for Robert Byrd, but not for Rush Limbaugh. Important for Miss Shirley but not Trent Lott. I agree that Breitbart could have, and should have, handled it better. He didn't do his due diligence. If, as he asserts, that he did not have the whole video, his conclusions, drawn from the portions of the speech he had, were logical and easily assumed. But, he should have done that which he hammers the Progressive Media for failing to do -- confirm the source. Get the whole video. Make sure that the statements which are asserted as FACT are indeed FACT. So, I would smack him for his rush to print without properly checking his sources. But, I would not let that BE THE STORY -- which, of course, is where we are. It's like the ACORN investigation. The story became the investigators rather than that which they uncovered. Or, Linda Tripp, for that matter. Everything can be and most things are spun. So long as we don't push back against the spin and hold our side to a standard so much higher than that which the other side adheres to...we're going to keep losing this battle of ideas.
CosmicConservative
Again Drax, the difference between how Breitbart did it, and how I suggested that he should have done it is the difference between being attacked from right and left, and being attacked only from the left. I think that's a significant difference. This will become fodder in the future for any revelation Breitbart makes, the standard response will be "Breitbart, as we know, had his credibility challenged by staunch conservatives such as Jonah Goldberg and Charles Krautheimer..." This has diminished Breitbart more than he yet realizes. But, it hasn't marginalized him. If he repeats the error, he will be marginalized. I would hope that Breitbart understands this.
CosmicConservative
... Oh, and I didn't say he had to play the whole video. He could have played the exact video he originally played had he led into the video the way I recommended. That would have provided the context both for Shirley's speech, and for the audience reaction.
Drax
I'm with Dan Riehl on this one, for sure. http://www.riehlworldview.com/carnivorous_conservative/2010/07/my-human-events-op-ed-in-defense-of-andrew-breitbart.html
CosmicConservative
Drax, Riehl is making the same argument you are, so of course you are with him. I say again, in the marketplace of ideas when you set yourself up as a broker of ideas, you are only measured by your success, not your intentions. You and others can make all the excuses you want for Breitbart, the only thing that matters is results.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one more thing, on the ACORN investigation, in spite of all the charges thrown by the left against Breitbart, for the most part the right did not join in (I don't consider David Frum to be a member of the "right"). And in the end Breitbart's stature grew considerably as a result of the ACORN thing, so in that case he was successful. So much so that based on his posting of this video, he thoroughly embarrassed the White House enough so that they joined the immediate cacophany against Shirley Sherrod. In the long run that may be the most significant part of this entire episode. Breitbart forced the White House into such an egregious unforced error that the White House response itself became the lead story for the dinosaur media, which forced them to address the Breitbart story which had triggered the White House response. Had the White House ignored this story, it would have probably died on the vine, but they didn't ignore it, they ramped it up. That showed that much like Drudge got under Clinton's skin, apparently Breitbart is getting under Obama's skin. And that's significant. That means that Breitbart has leverage he can exploit, if he does so skillfully. In the end, just due to the White House's response, Breitbart's actual power may be increased from this affair. Sometimes it really is better to be lucky than good. And as they say, when your enemy is self-destructing, it is best to stand back and let them focus on it.