Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

He sure is generous with my money, isn't he?

By CosmicConservative
The candy man can...
LAS VEGAS (AP) - President Barack Obama is unveiling $1.5 billion in housing help, a boost timed to his appearance in the city with the worst foreclosure crisis in the nation. Obama's move, detailed by aides in advance of his town hall here Friday, is the latest by a White House determined to show it is helping families rebound from a deep recession. The downturn is taking an election-year toll on Obama's party as voter frustration builds. Obama was to announce that housing finance agencies in the five hardest-hit states in the housing crisis will receive $1.5 billion to help spur local solutions to the problem. Those five are Arizona, California, Florida, Michigan and Nevada.

Comments (19)

Old Goat
This is what I was talking about in the Vegas Mayor snubbing Obama article. Its probably why Obama was looking to have the meeting with the Mayor, to use that as his "see, I do care about Nevada" type spin.+ There are questions about this being something that can be constitutionally done because this money is coming from funds that were not specifically earmarked for this. I wonder how this can even work without all the other states chiming in and looking for their handout. Yet another signal of socialism from the one.
Drax
The money unspent from the "stimulus" and the money returned from TARP is one huge slush fund. Yeah. It's unconstitutional. It's not even arguable that it isn't.
Dadman
Since when did anyone in Washington care about the Constitution? So it's unconstitutional... now what? Obama is pathetic.
Old Goat
And they are now looking to push through the Healthcare takeover. Obama is set on a path of destroying the US to remake it in the image of the Soviet Union. When will he push things to the breaking point where there is massive revolt? Or will the American people just watch as these socialists remove all freedoms?
CosmicConservative
I'd say there's about an even chance that trying to force health care through the reconciliation process will end up being a suicide pact for the Democrat Party in 2010.
Old Goat
Trouble is, once passed its here to stay till the US is bankrupt and we have more problems to deal with. The real thing that needs to happen, aside from having a conservative majority, is that those elected who are conservative have to remain that way and not turn into another, though lighter, version of the liberals. That was my biggest thing against Bush, he seemed like he never saw a spending bill he didn't like. This can't keep happening.
CosmicConservative
Goat, that's the conventional wisdom, but I'm not so sure. To use reconciliation as a way to pass this bill is unprecedented. If Republicans take back the House, they could conceivably revoke the monstrosity.
esox67
"Or will the American people just watch as these socialists remove all freedoms" Sorry to say yes, there are plenty of morons out their who still kiss the feet the socialist/democrats walk on until the day the government comes for them....
kevin in WI
Cosmic, I agree that passing the healthcare bill by the "reconciliation" procedure will be a very bad thing, but it's not unprecedented. Bush's tax cuts in 2003 were passed the same way. In fact this little similarity is exactly why congress and both parties have such low approval ratings. One party wants to cut taxes, but keep spending and racking up debt. The other wants to continue taxing, but spend even more and continue racking up debt. This country has a center (where most people stand), but both parties have been ignoring it for a long long time.
Old Goat
Kevin, the problem isn't that the "conservative" side was ignoring things, its that we had Republicans who were acting like Democrats in their spending ways. Bush was far too easy with his pen signing off on every spending bill that came his way. Had the Republicans acted on reducing taxes and curbed their spending there would not have been the backlash against them that put the Democrats back in control. Their focus for far too long on social issues also hurt them. Those at best are state issues, not the Federal Government's to play with.
Chasester
The difference with Bush's Tax Cuts vs Health care is Reconciliation is intended for monetary only - Which Tax Cuts fall under that. Health care is a specific program.
CosmicConservative
Chasester made the point I was going to make. The Bush tax cuts are specifically covered under the provision where reconciliation is acknowledged as APPROPRIATE. It is the use of reconciliation for sweeping new programs that have nothing to do with monetary adjustments that is unprecedented. And I mean unprecedented. This is about as big of a power grab as is possible in modern day Washington. Make no mistake about it, there's a reason it's been called the "nuclear option." And there will be fallout.
Drax
The problem with attempting to "undo" any law Congress passes is that it takes a law to undo it, i.e., Obama can VETO the law repealing the healthcare reform. That's WHY he's trying to get everything done NOW. It's ALWAYS been the reason. He KNOWS that his window is short, but anything he gets through STAYS for at least 2 more years, and, if the economy picks up...then he'll likely get 4 more years unless we get someone really good to run against him or something really bad happens. He knows what he's doing.
CosmicConservative
Well, it may be a slim hope, but Obama's vetoes can be overridden. And frankly it is quite possible in my opinion that in another year Obama might be unpopular enough that enough Democrats might be fed up with him that a veto override could be possible.
kevin in WI
Look, I'm not defending what the democrats are trying to do here, but saying passing the 2003 tax cuts with that method was ok just because it was about money is wrong. Reconciliation is about crossing t's and dotting i's in order to put together two very similar house and senate budgets. It's not about making major changes to government funding, spending or regulation. Cosmic, you tend to be very objective on this type of thing instead of holding the parties to separate standards. Maybe it's my libertarian bent, but I'm not cool with either party using a loophole to get major legislation around standard senate vote count requirements.
CosmicConservative
Kevin, I'd have to look that whole thing up, but the only time a 60 vote count is needed is when there is a difficulty in getting the 60 votes needed for cloture. That's the case now on just bout everything, but in general that has not been the case historically. I don't recall Bush lacking the votes he needed, but maybe he did. If so, then I'd be opposed to it if Bush was pushing new legislation instead of making reasonable adjustments, I just don't remember the details.
CosmicConservative
Kevin: You are correct, the Bush reconciliation ended up passing with 58 votes, but that's still 2 short of 60. The process was not nearly as contentious as this, but it was protested by the Democrats and defended by Republicans. In fact that is now used as an example of Bush's reaching across the aisle since I think several Democrats voted for it, and a few Republicans voted against it. But at core, I'd have to say that it shouldn't have been done that way.
Drax
Cloture is to cut off debate. It is to deter filibusters. Adopted in 1917, it has been the Senate rule since that time on all issues EXCEPT matters of the purse. It used to be 2/3rds, but when the Demorats got enough votes to change Senate rules, they lowered the requirement (just as they are attempting to do now. If they had 39 seats, they'd be trying to raise the requirement to 2/3rd again...) There is argument that the money exception is due to Constitutional requirements, but I don't find any language there (or in Rule 22) which supports this. Maybe it's elsewhere, but I can't find the argument. Regardless, the Rule is the Rule, existing because, without it, we'd see filibusters breaking out all over the place...
kevin in WI
It may have been good planning or just plain serendipity, but the founding generation got the balance right. I get leery whenever any majority party (regardless of which one) tries to change congressional procedure.