Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama's death machines

By CosmicConservative
One of the things that I hear those on the right grudgingly give Obama credit for is his ramping up of the use of pilotless drone attack aircraft to target terrorists in Afghanistan and, reportedly, Pakistan. This practice, by the way, was denounced by Obama the candidate when he accused Bush of waging war by indiscriminately blasting at civilians. The howling anti-war left had this on its list of Bush-era hooliganism with charges that using techniques like this reduced war to a video game and thus made killing more, not less, likely. And just last week I saw a report of a misguided strike that killed 12 innocent civilians in Afghanistan, an event that would have made the left apoplectic had it happened under Bush, but which has received bare notice since it was Obama. Plus Obama has aggressively defended this use of drones and Joe Biden has gleefully exulted over the practice. But there's a reason that George W. Bush used it sparingly. It's not clear that it's legal. Seriously, Bush was using drones for targeting and went after a few "high quality" targets but did so following the rules of engagement that White House lawyers had laid out for him. The same people who call Bush a "war criminal" for the interrogation policies Bush put into place are now totally silent about Obama's death from the sky tactics. Bush and his team hired an army of lawyers to investigate the legality of interrogation, vetted those studies with both Congress and the Supreme Court and then documented everything they did to the nth degree. It appears that the Obama White House is pursuing these drone attacks without even the approval of his own White House counsel's office, much less the approval of Congress or the knowledge of the SCOTUS. The difference between the Bush interrogation and the Obama drone attacks is not merely that Bush did his very best to follow the law and Obama seems to be ignoring the law, a bigger difference is that no matter how much you may despise Bush, you can't claim that his interrogation policies were killing innocent civilians, and you actually CAN make that claim about Obama's death from the sky policies. It will be interesting to see what happens on this in the future. There are actual statutes on the books today that seem to make the Predator drone strikes illegal. But at the very least we should have the confidence that Obama and his legal team have vetted the practice and have a strong case to defend it if necessary, but the reality seems to be that they've simply ignored it.

Comments (2)

kevin in WI
You're right in that both the left and the right are being selective in their criticism (depending on who's in power). I think what we have here is the slippery slope in action, with the attacks increasing because they work and haven't been really challenged hard. These types of attacks (as effective as they may be at getting hard to hit non-state actors) are clearly illegal under international law. They were when Bush did it, and they are when Obama does it. This is something that might feel right now, but which we will regret later, when the world situation has changed (such as when China or Russia is doing it in some small country we don't think is so bad). War is hell.
CosmicConservative
Bush did this very sparingly, and in general he tried to use them in situations where he could plausibly claim he was conforming to the engagement rules. Obama is simply using them to execute targets. In practice there may not be much difference, but I do believe there is some difference in principle. And that difference, I believe, is that Obama has decided as policy that it's easier and less controversial to KILL these people (and whoever happens to be around, or whoever happens to be hit when an attack goes awry due to technical or human difficulties, or just poor intelligence) than it is to try to CAPTURE them and he then has to deal with his own careless rhetoric about how such captured targets should be interrogated and imprisoned. The result of that policy is that every one of these attacks that is successful is potentially depriving us of critical actionable intelligence, simply because Obama would rather kill them than interrogate them.