Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama foreign policy advisor revealed

By CosmicConservative
Now I see where Obama gets his ideas.
Miss Obama's peacenik T-shirt sends a message to G8 leaders | Mail Online Barack Obama's eldest daughter has a clear message for her father - it's time to get rid of the world's nuclear weapons. Just 48 hours after the U.S. President shook hands with Vladimir Putin over an agreement to reduce their stockpile of nuclear weapons, Malia spotted out wearing not one, but two anti-nuclear T-shirts.
I pretty much thought Obama's worldview was that of an 11 year old. Now we know why.

Comments (40)

Old Goat
Seems she has more fashion sense than dear ol' Mommy though. She also is working that MJ look.
Bongo
And what does this girl's T-shirt really have to do with anything? Cheap shots for the sake of it? Man, you conservatives.
CosmicConservative
LOL you talk about cheap shots after your moonbat ranting on the evil George W. Bush on a different thread. The complete inability of some people to recognize their own hypocrisy is one of the key indicators of ideological fanaticism. Thanks for demonstrating it so effectively.
Bongo
Oh, by the way, where did I say anything about 'evil George'? Nowhere. Putting words into my proverbial mouth there, friend. I said he left a mess which someone else has to now clean up. Deny it. Your site says "rational" conservativism. Well, let's hear something rational, or can you only dismiss my 'moonbat ranting'?
CosmicConservative
Bongo, if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck... I call it a duck. The reason this T-shirt is relevant is that it is comparable to Obama's views on the same subject. I call it the "platitude based community." It is all about people believing they can act as though the world is what they WISH it was, instead of what it ACTUALLY is. Obama's foreign policy, imho, is roughly comparable to the platitude based analysis of an eleven year old.
CosmicConservative
OH, also Bongo, the "rational" part of my conservatism is my insistence on dealing with REALITY instead of basing foreign and domestic policy on FANTASY.
Bongo
So you'd rather go with the flow than be a force of CHANGE? Everybody is going with the flow anyway, I wouldn't worry. I'd bet my life they've all got a 'gun under the table', these friendly nations. Still, it doesn't hurt to make 'nice' noises when dealing with another large beast. War is bad. No, seriously, it is. As a last resort, I'm fine with it, mind you. No qualms in defence of my nation, fight to the last man, etc. But I'm not for jumping in everywhere with the idea "offence is the best defence". In some cases it is, but not EVERY case.
CosmicConservative
Bongo, this is a testable hypothesis. Obama's efforts to "change" human nature are perhaps laudable in an academic or philosophical sense. In a geopolitical, economic and national security sense they are exactly what I called them. Naive and dangerous. The outcome of his efforts will be clear over time. It is my bet that he will be as successful as Jimmy Carter and Neville Chamberlain, two other "platitude based community" members who attempted the same thing.
Bongo
You can change human nature at home. For example - in how you raise your children: raise them well and they will be good people (most likely). Raise them badly, and there's a more than average chance they will turn out not to so well. Human nature is flexible, but like a child, it takes a long time to shape and a lot of effort needs to be put in. If you've got kids you'll know what I mean. I don't have any, because that would certainly be too much effort for me, but I understand how difficult a job it is. Difficult, but people manage it all the time, every day. Point made. Anyway, my view on nukes is that nobody can get rid of them now - it's too late, the arms race has begun and it can't go backwards. It never does. I'm sure we have plenty of nukes for attack and defence, and cutting a few for the sake of diplomacy won't be a big deal. The earth would be uninhabitable anyway if there was a huge nuclear barney and every nation pitched in with theirs too - so what would be the point of that. Nukes are bluffs, for posturing only really, since we know a nuclear war would suck for everyone. And you only need one or two in the right place to make all the difference. So I don't think it's a big deal if he cuts a few. There'll be many more left in the vault if they're needed, it's all for show. There's still the enormous threat of deterrence on both sides. What're you worrying about?
Dadman
Bongo: Human behavior and human nature are not the same things. Human behavior can, at times, be modified, but FUNDAMENTAL human nature has been quite constant since the dawn of time. The U.S. founding fathers understood this reality and it explains why they were so keen on creating a system of government with ample checks and balances. Human nature has no history. Think about it...
Bongo
I acknowledge that, Dadman. I'm just saying it can be improved. After all, society now has much more restraint and tolerance than it did in the middle ages, even if only on the face of it. Things HAVE changed somewhat. And I'm sure the Middle Ages were an improvement on the Pharaohs, and those on cavemen. So while the tendency of humans to be fearful and violent are still here, and we still love a good fight (undeniably) we at least have come to realise what we are. The very fact there is a United Nations is such a big deal in this respect. The fact we have democracy. The fact women get to vote. The fact people aren't left to die on the street. This is normal to us now because we've been born into a society that believes in it. Perhaps the future can believe in better things if we push for better things. If we don't push for anything, there won't be any change at all. Cosmic calls himself a realist, and seems to think I'm completely deluded, but I'm not - I am a realist also. But I know the value of action and what it does as much as he does. War isn't the only way to get things done.
CosmicConservative
Bongo, you call yourself a "realist" and claim to be "discussing issues" and then you end your comment with "War isn't the only way to get things done." As if ANYONE ANYWHERE ever argued that it was. It is this tendency of yours to argue against caricatures and ludicrous strawmen that I find so disingenuous. Then there's the whole invoking Hitler thing. If you want to have an actual discussion, you are going to have to put aside the liberal dogma you continue to spout like a water fountain.
Drax
Bongo: Those who rise to power over the bodies of their enemies see overtures of "peace" as opportunities to exploit -- given to them by people who are exhibiting weakness. They don't seek peace; they seek expansion of their power. Dealing with them as if they do seek "peace" is foolish at best.
Dadman
Improvements in society over time are not indicative of fundamental changes in human nature. I would argue one of the reasons U.S. society has been so successful is because we have constitutionally based rule of law which recognizes and leverages the immutable realities of human nature - namely that we are self-interested and will ALWAYS be so. Laws and associated punishments attempt to counteract the impulses of our nature. Capitalism and free markets work because they leverage self-interest on both sides of the equation, e.g. people want/need better products and the best product at the right price will make you rich. Liberals tend to believe that the right policies, laws, regulations, etc. will somehow revise human nature and move us close to some kind of social utopia. Liberals seem to think they can literally legislate the kind of world they wet dream about. In that sense, they are indeed deluded beyond hope... ...and more than a little scary...imho...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, that's what I mean by the "platitude based community." "War is not the answer." Well, I guess it depends on the question. "Can't we all just get along?" In a nutshell... No. "Give peace a chance." We did. "Imagine..." Pretty much the definition of fantasy. What really cracks me up is that these people have the unmitigated GALL to call themselves the "reality based community."
Bongo
Hmm. Well Dadman, someone dreamed of a world where black Americans weren't slaves, someone dreamed of one where the American colonists didn't have to answer to the British, someone dreamed someday women would be able to vote, someone dreamed of a healthcare system that would be available for all to use, someone thought about trial by jury and not by lynch mob, someone dreamed sending children to mills to work or up chimneys as during the Industrial Revolution was not something we should endorse... all of these things happened because someone 'dreamed' about them and about making them happen in a time when they simply were not a reality. People were ready to die to achieve some of these things, and some people here are so willing to dismiss the struggles that had to happen for the world that they now comfortably live in to be by saying that human nature simply 'is'. These things never were on their own, they had to be fought for and they had to be pushed and struggled for. Otherwise we wouldn't have them, because we could simply settle back into the 'realist' routine of not bothering, because at heart we're all just savages, right? Some things can happen if you make them happen. I say SOME things. Some things will never be, such as a "perfect world". There is, and never will be a social utopia. But there can certainly be improvements on the world as it is now, that's for sure.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: I believe you are confusing cultural tendencies with human nature. It should be obvious to any reasonable person that human CIVILIZATION has evolved over time, and IN GENERAL the evolution has been to a more egalitarian and more tolerant society. However, there are still many, many places where that positive tendency has stalled or even backslid. There have been periods where civilization AS A WHOLE has backslid, such as with the collapse of the Roman Empire. In the main the improvements we have seen have been associated with TWO CRITICAL THINGS. 1. A more egalitarian society which takes the lead in bringing other societies forward. 2. A MILITARY SUPERIORITY in the hands of that more egalitarian society. This was true with Greece, Rome, Chinese and Indian cultures, Brittanica and the United States. Might may not MAKE right, but when Might and Right are aligned, things get much better much more quickly. Ghandi is frequently held up as an example of how passive civil disobedience can "change the world." The UNSPOKEN and generally UNACKNOWLEDGED truth behind Ghandi is that Ghandi would not have been successful in MOST cultures. He was successful because the British Empire was BY AND LARGE a decent and egalitarian one. Had Ghandi attempted the same thing in the Ottoman Empire, the Soviet Union or MOST other cultures throughout human history, he would simply have been dragged off to be either executed or imprisoned until he died. The problem with Obama's attitude that a Ghandi-like effort is morally superior to negotiating through strength is that it IGNORES THIS FUNDAMENTAL TRUTH. Iran is not interested in freedom, liberty or tolerance. Ghandi would simply have been a casualty in Iran. The same is true by and large in Russia. In case you haven't noticed, Putin's challengers have a strange way of becoming dead or missing. Obama's naivetee is in thinking that everyone is like him. They aren't. And that is the fundamental problem.
Dadman
Bongo: Again, laudable advances in a society are not evidence of an evolving human nature. I would argue that the advances you cite were achieved IN SPITE of human nature and could be lost with great speed because human nature remains in effect. We must be ever vigilant and watchful of our own, and our competitors, baser instincts. By the way, realism is not laissez faire; it recognizes the reality that those we are dealing with are first and foremost self-interested and advocates policies that take this fact into account, e.g. peace through strength, etc. Liberals seem to think apologies and kind words will get the job done... ...while our enemies plot our demise.
Bongo
I agree absolutely Dadman, it is in spite of human nature. All these things can be taken away at any moment, given the right situation - society itself could generate in a day to caveman-like life given the right prompts and environment. I think it's an excellent survival strategy for human beings to retain this nature, yes. But that doesn't mean that the quality of life of extant people can't be improved by having pushed for that - that's the fruit of all that struggle. Quality of life.
CosmicConservative
Bongo, you concede the point without realizing the implication. Obama is attempting to deal with cultures which are not egalitarian, tolerant and reasonable as if they are. That's the problem. You seem to think that simply approaching people and saying "Let's agree to get along" is all that is needed. Obama is more and more being regarded and treated on the world geopolitical scene as exactly what he is. A naive beginner who has no real concept of how the world actually works. He is getting rolled time and again. He got rolled by North Korea. He got rolled by Iran. He is getting rolled by Venezuela. He is getting rolled by Russia. His world tour so far has been a nonstop diminishment of the United States as a world power and as an effective change-agent. His desire to become the world's puppy-dog is producing exactly that. The world's puppy-dog. While he bats his eyes and bows before other world leaders, they take advantage of his appeasement and apologies to demand concessions from us. Concessions he seems all too willing to grant so he can, in true Sally Field tradition, stand at a podium holding some sort of meaningless award and crow "You LIKE me! You REALLY LIKE me!" to the world. I have not been this disgusted with our President and our foreign policy since Jimmy Carter meandered around the Rose Garden emoting viciously while Iran made us look like fools to the world.
Dadman
Heh. Herein lies the problem. Liberals seem to think they are the final arbiters on what constitutes a 'quality life' and are never shy about using the force of government to literally MANDATE their vision of quality. Liberals are now moving to control the vehicles we drive, the food we eat, the energy we use (and how much it costs), the quality of our healthcare (which will become LESS available to most Americans and POORER in quality), etc. In the coming Liberal Utopia there will be no need for liberty and few resources to pursue our individual happiness... ...and with abortion on demand and healthcare rationing less life as well.
Drax
Hmmm...gonna post it again, can't find this post and spent too much time to let it lie fallow... Bongo: 1.) "[S]omeone dreamed of a world where black Americans weren’t slaves" NORTHERN Americans could AFFORD to "dream" that way since they were INDUSTRIALIZED. SOUTHERN Americans were economically tied to slavery. But, that came later...all the colonies (indeed, almost all the colonies of all the Kingdoms (Canada, Cuba, Brazil...) originated with slave labor. There were slaves in the north but, since the north wasn't as agarian as the South at the time of the Civil War, there were far fewer slaves in the North as in the south. By the time of the Civil war, most Northern states had emancipated their few slaves. (The exception was New Jersey which continued to allow slavery up to the beginning of the war. See,e.g., http://www.slavenorth.com/) Of course, the North wasn't SO offended by slavery that they didn't pass the Fugitive Slave act, criminalizing the shelter of run-away slaves in the North (or anywhere). (See, e.g., http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/USASfugitive.htm) Further, the North was quite willing for slavery to continue in the south. After the Louisiana Purchase, they dealt with the matter (slave state/free state) by making sure that the numbers of new states remained equal in the newly acquired territory. (See, e.g., http://www.laughtergenealogy.com/bin/histprof/misc/mocompromise.html) Finally, the issue of slavery was not why the Southern states seceded from the union -- it was over the issue of "nullification," i.e., whether the several sovereign states had to accept federal law. Slavery BECAME a "rallying cry" for the North (a recruitment tool) but wasn't any impetus for either secession or for the North to invade the South to force "union." 2.) "Someone dreamed of one where the American colonists didn’t have to answer to the British" I'll give you that one. (However, it must be said that it was the gentrified who, originally only concerned with being afforded their rights as ENGLISHMEN ("no taxation without representation") who, when they were DENIED their rights as Englishmen, rebelled. See, e.g., http://www.usconstitution.net/intol.html) 3.) "[S]omeone dreamed someday women would be able to vote. I'll give you that one. However, I'll repeat CC's admonition that such only happened in a country which was ALREADY an "egalitarian" society. Don't see so much of that in barbaric societies.... 4.) "Someone dreamed of a healthcare system that would be available for all to use." Not sure what you mean by this. Was there ever a time where people didn't want their wounds/illnesses to be treated? Was there ever a time when some people didn't attempt to fill that desire, whether tribal witch-doctor or metropolitan hospital? 5.) "[S]omeone thought about trial by jury and not by lynch mob." The history on the origin of jury trials is murky at best. Some think it was an outgrowth of the Inquest Juries where twelve knights sat as witnesses in a tax trial. Others think it is Saxon only or Norman only. Others differently. None that I can think of, however, think that it is the result of anyone "dreaming" of a more perfect judicial system -- rather an evolution of various forms of deciding cases which, at least in the beginning, had less to do with "justice" than with expediency. (See, e.g., http://www.constitution.org/cmt/wf/htj.htm) 6.) "[S]omeone dreamed [that] sending children to mills to work or up chimneys as during the Industrial Revolution was not something we should endorse" Again. These laws were enacted by those who no longer NEEDED child labor, exempting those areas (farms, for example) where it REMAINED needful. As always, it is easy to become outraged at the exploitation of children once it is no longer necessary for YOU to exploit them. 7.) "All of these things happened because someone ‘dreamed’ about them and about making them happen in a time when they simply were not a reality. People were ready to die to achieve some of these things, and some people here are so willing to dismiss the struggles that had to happen for the world that they now comfortably live in to be by saying that human nature simply ‘is’. These things never were on their own, they had to be fought for and they had to be pushed and struggled for. Otherwise we wouldn’t have them, because we could simply settle back into the ‘realist’ routine of not bothering, because at heart we’re all just savages, right?" A "realist's" view of history would be one which actually takes history into account. History shows us that, almost without exception, changes such as those you list, are only effected once THOSE WITH POWER no longer NEED the "old ways" and can FORCE those who do to accept the "new ways." In some cases, in egalitarian societies, that very enlightenment allows for FURTHER changes which grant to OTHERS the rights that THEY enjoy -- but almost NEVER at any cost to themselves.
Drax
Well, I give up. Posted twice. Can't find either. Probably links messing with things... CC, if you can find it, could you authorize one and delete the other? Thanks
CosmicConservative
Drax: I don't see them. They must have gotten lost in transmission somewhere. Sorry. I dunno why it would have lost yours.
Drax
CC: Heh. It gives me "duplicate comment detected" when I post the identical comment. Then, when I change it a bit, it appears to take it, but doesn't. I'll try it by changing the links to "non-links." Maybe that'll work.
CosmicConservative
OH... if you have links, it probably got nailed by the spam filter. Let me go check.
Drax
Bongo: 1.) "[S]omeone dreamed of a world where black Americans weren’t slaves" NORTHERN Americans could AFFORD to "dream" that way since they were INDUSTRIALIZED. SOUTHERN Americans were economically tied to slavery. But, that came later...all the colonies (indeed, almost all the colonies of all the Kingdoms (Canada, Cuba, Brazil...) originated with slave labor. There were slaves in the north but, since the north wasn't as agarian as the South at the time of the Civil War, there were far fewer slaves in the North as in the south. By the time of the Civil war, most Northern states had emancipated their few slaves. (The exception was New Jersey which continued to allow slavery up to the beginning of the war. Of course, the North wasn't SO offended by slavery that they didn't pass the Fugitive Slave act, criminalizing the shelter of run-away slaves in the North (or anywhere). (See, e.g., http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/USASfugitive.htm) Further, the North was quite willing for slavery to continue in the south. After the Louisiana Purchase, they dealt with the matter (slave state/free state) by making sure that the numbers of new states remained equal in the newly acquired territory. (See, e.g., http://www.laughtergenealogy.com/bin/histprof/misc/mocompromise.html) Finally, the issue of slavery was not why the Southern states seceded from the union -- it was over the issue of "nullification," i.e., whether the several sovereign states had to accept federal law. Slavery BECAME a "rallying cry" for the North (a recruitment tool) but wasn't any impetus for either secession or for the North to invade the South to force "union." 2.) "Someone dreamed of one where the American colonists didn’t have to answer to the British" I'll give you that one. (However, it must be said that it was the gentrified who, originally only concerned with being afforded their rights as ENGLISHMEN ("no taxation without representation") who, when they were DENIED their rights as Englishmen, rebelled. See, e.g., http://www.usconstitution.net/intol.html) 3.) "[S]omeone dreamed someday women would be able to vote. I'll give you that one. However, I'll repeat CC's admonition that such only happened in a country which was ALREADY an "egalitarian" society. Don't see so much of that in barbaric societies.... 4.) "Someone dreamed of a healthcare system that would be available for all to use." Not sure what you mean by this. Was there ever a time where people didn't want their wounds/illnesses to be treated? Was there ever a time when some people didn't attempt to fill that desire, whether tribal witch-doctor or metropolitan hospital? 5.) "[S]omeone thought about trial by jury and not by lynch mob." The history on the origin of jury trials is murky at best. Some think it was an outgrowth of the Inquest Juries where twelve knights sat as witnesses in a tax trial. Others think it is Saxon only or Norman only. Others differently. None that I can think of, however, think that it is the result of anyone "dreaming" of a more perfect judicial system -- rather an evolution of various forms of deciding cases which, at least in the beginning, had less to do with "justice" than with expediency. (See, e.g., http://www.constitution.org/cmt/wf/htj.htm) 6.) "[S]omeone dreamed [that] sending children to mills to work or up chimneys as during the Industrial Revolution was not something we should endorse" Again. These laws were enacted by those who no longer NEEDED child labor, exempting those areas (farms, for example) where it REMAINED needful. As always, it is easy to become outraged at the exploitation of children once it is no longer necessary for YOU to exploit them. 7.) "All of these things happened because someone ‘dreamed’ about them and about making them happen in a time when they simply were not a reality. People were ready to die to achieve some of these things, and some people here are so willing to dismiss the struggles that had to happen for the world that they now comfortably live in to be by saying that human nature simply ‘is’. These things never were on their own, they had to be fought for and they had to be pushed and struggled for. Otherwise we wouldn’t have them, because we could simply settle back into the ‘realist’ routine of not bothering, because at heart we’re all just savages, right?" A "realist's" view of history would be one which actually takes history into account. History shows us that, almost without exception, changes such as those you list, are only effected once THOSE WITH POWER no longer NEED the "old ways" and can FORCE those who do to accept the "new ways." In some cases, in egalitarian societies, that very enlightenment allows for FURTHER changes which grant to OTHERS the rights that THEY enjoy -- but almost NEVER at any cost to themselves.
Drax
Apparently, it was the first link... Inserted after "(The exception was New Jersey which continued to allow slavery up to the beginning of the war. See,e.g., http://www.slavenorth.com/)
CosmicConservative
No, I freed it up. Anything with more than four or five links will get triggered as spam.
Drax
Ah, the number of links, not the specific links. Got it...thanks.
CosmicConservative
By the way Drax, that was an excellent rebuttal of Bongo's rose-colored-glasses view of history. Bongo, Drax pretty much nailed the difference between your assertions and actual reality.
Bongo
I don't think there is anything rosy in my view of history - I do agree that these things were only allowed when they could afford to be allowed. And yet, someone still had to push for them, and hard, because they wouldn't have happened otherwise. No force of change for the good happens without a cost it seems. My point isn't invalid, just because we still need nukes doesn't mean we still need 6000, nor that we need to continue to act like those further back in history did with them. Do you not agree that progress has been made with the formation of organisations such as the U.N. and therefore that we don't need to view nukes in quite the same way as we did when the race to be the first to make one was on? We can afford to sit back a little, as you say, now. No - I'm not being unrealistic - getting rid of nuclear weapons totally IS a stupid idea, being that other nations will be opportunistic and nobody can really be trusted. I'm not stupid - I wouldn't give up my nukes either if I were in charge. But I would gain a little face with other countries to make allies of them (if there's likely to be looming oil conflicts in future particularly) - by a little show for the public, perhaps... It's true that those who have enough are usually the ones to criticse others who use less savoury methods to get things done. The West is a huge and practiced hypocrite of that type right now. We point fingers at China for their human rights record for example, while elsewhere in the world our companies buy diamonds from African mines, or other multinationals screw third-world farmers over to the glory tune of capitalism. Sure, that's how it all works in the realist's world, "they have to be poor so I can be rich", but we don't have to keep it that way because we are in that 'better position' to KNOW BETTER now. In terms of the argument of pushing for better quality of life - we have it. It's reality. We can also give it to others because we can afford to, hypocritical as that may be in the case of aid donations and charities bound for places of the world where we're still exploiting. I'm not disagreeing with you, if that hasn't been made obvious. I am simply saying, we are in a good position to gain some face in the world, rather than go stomping in with our hob nail boots. Either way might do good things - after all, if we start a few wars, the environmentalists should be happy with the population curbs...
CosmicConservative
Bongo: You continue to say "we" when you talk about the USA, are you an expatriate living in Britain (no pun intended)? Let's examine this "hobnail boot" and "screw third-world farmers" accusation you have placed. The USA in 1945 essentially owned the world. We had the only operational nuclear capability and the most dominant military in the history of the world. Had the USA wanted to "hobnail boot" march over the world in imperialist fashion, the whole world would be speaking English by now. So spare me your accusations of US hegemony. The USA has a long history of LEAVING after fighting a war and WINNING it. When we say we want to advance Democracy, we put our money and our blood where our mouth is. As Colin Powell once famously said to the PM of France, "We came here to fight and die for your freedom, and all the land we asked for was enough to bury our dead." If the USA was truly interested in empire, we would BE an empire. Now, let's talk about third world economic "screwing." Since China is the big thing now, I'll just discuss that. Leftists love to single out Walmart as some sort of evil corporate empire keeping the poor slave labor forces hammering in their dungeons. Nothing could be further from the truth. What Walmart and other corporations have been doing for years is exactly what Leftists CLAIM to want, which is to spread the economic wealth around the globe to the poorest nations. China's economic living standards have been steadily improving ever since we have been trading with them. This is not by accident. Among the original arguments for opening trade with China (and India and other places) was that providing that opportunity for the workers in those countries would do the same thing there that it did HERE and in EUROPE, which is to create a VIABLE MIDDLE CLASS. And that is exactly what has been happening. It's more obvious in India because India is more open, but it is happening in China too. The ability for Chinese and Indian labor to enter the same market as US labor has created a boom for the lower classes in both of those nations. The reality is exactly the OPPOSITE of what you claim, instead of "screwing" those poor bastards, the worldwide market for goods and services has ELEVATED their standard of living SIGNIFICANTLY and continues to do so today. Sure there are always pockets of exploitation, but the BIGGER PICTURE is one of Indian and Chinese progress into an economy that is BASED on the middle class, just like western economies. As this happens it has the unavoidable consequence of costing Americans well-paying jobs. But since I thought Leftists were all about redistributing wealth, I would think they would be all over this. Well, except for this one unfortunate alliance that Leftists have with Labor unions who find this to be unacceptable. So spare me your lectures.
Drax
Bongo: Of course each listed item was something which someone wanted, so was "advocated for" by someone. It would seem highly unlikely that anyone would be advocating for things which they did NOT want. As to the nukes issue.... You do realize that the number, variety, and location of our nukes SHOULD bear some relationship to the ability to deliver a successful SECOND strike, don't you? You see, the fewer we have, the easier it is to deliver a FIRST STRIKE and render us incapable of delivering a SECOND STRIKE. And, if we face an enemy who is WILLING to deliver a first strike who believes that he can deliver one which renders us INCAPABLE of delivering a strike in return, it INVITES the FIRST strike. When dealing with a rational, but implacable, foe, you MUST have the ability to destroy him even as he destroys you. You must NOT open a window through which he can potentially destroy YOU while surviving himself. This is the fundament of Mutually Assured Destruction. Every missile we destroy brings us closer to the "destruction" part without the "mutually assured" part. This is elementary. As to the other parts of your post which, like Obama, tends to point fingers at the U.S. for our past and present "mis-deeds," all I can say is the following: No country is without a past. The atrocities committed by France, Spain, England, (any surviving African nation), Greece, Turkey, pick your poison...would take a digital library to fully list. In comparison to the atrocities of ANY COUNTRY ON THE PLANET which has had the CAPABILITY of visiting harm on other countries without provocation, the U.S. is without moral peer. As to your notion of "gaining face..." Dealing with any country with adverse interests from any position other than a position of strength is destined to result in dealing with them from a position of weakness. If we seek "face" which has no value in the dealings between nations, then we give up something OF value to obtain it. This means that we give up something of VALUE in exchange for something of NO value. (You see, no rational leader of a nation will care one way or another as to whether or not they LIKE us, just whether or not we CAN and are WILLING to do anything which adversely AFFECTS them. If they believe that either of these two conditions are unlikely, then it doesn't matter WHAT their feelings about us are, they WILL advance THEIR NATION'S INTERESTS -- often to the detriment of ours. That's what those leaders get paid to do, and, in the case of the dictators of this world, it is their innermost desire...)
Drax
Oh...almost forgot... On the nuke issue .... The reason why Russia doesn't want us to have a missile shield is because it would render US invulnerable to a SECOND strike, not because it would protect us against their FIRST strike. In THEIR view, our potential invulnerability to a second strike makes it more likely that we'll deliver a first strike. This is the view they MUST have. It is the view I would have if THEY got a missile defense shield.
CosmicConservative
Drax: That is right. That's exactly the argument made in the early 80s when Reagan first proposed a missile shield. Those Leftists not laughing at him (Doonesbury called him "Ronnie Ray-gun") and sneering at it by dubbing it "Star Wars" argued that it would destabilize the MAD arrangement in exactly the way you describe. That's ALWAYS been the "nuanced" argument against it from the Left. And that's a major reason they opposed it. This sort of "logic" drives me crazy. "Let's not protect ourselves because it may make our enemies realize we can protect ourselves." I mean your average fifteen year old knows better. But not your average eleven year old I guess. My favorite episode from that period is when Reagan argued "Well, let the USSR build their OWN shield then." Which logically would have maintained the "balance of power" but Reagan knew that the effort would accelerate the bankruptcy of the USSR, which was happening anyway as they tried to keep up with our general military expansion. Reagan knew how to roll the Russians. And he rolled them good. Obama is the anti-Reagan and the predictable result is that the Russians would roll him. And so they are.
CosmicConservative
By the way Drax, I think the cold war terminology you are looking for is "primary strike" vs. "retaliatory strike." The "retaliatory strike" isn't really a "second strike" because it's the FIRST strike made by the country that received the "primary strike." I think that's the old terminology.
Drax
Not sure about "primary" (I believe that the non-scholarly (and politicos) used "first strike") but agree as to "retaliatory strike." Either way...thanks!
Old and getting older Goat
Just thought with all this I would point out that in the history of the world the country with the most powerful armed forces are on top. That hasn't changed throughout history. Yet the liberals think that being nice and talking peace and looking to reduce our arms and dismantle our weapons will be good for country. Peace is best preserved by having the means and the will to use overwhelming power. Words only mean something when it can be backed up.