Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama in a(nother) nutshell

By CosmicConservative
Obama, in Russia: "The future does not belong to those who gather armies on a field of battle or bury missiles in the ground." Obama no doubt believes this. Of course 10,000 years of recorded history demonstrate EXACTLY the opposite, but that's only REALITY. Obama, and his progressive ilk, don't live in the real world. They live in a world where the future DOESN'T belong to those who gather armies in the field or bury missiles in the ground. The only problem is that isn't THIS world and never has been. This demonstrates clearly the MOST FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCE between "liberals" and "conservatives." I'm a conservative. I look at history and I say "Hmm.... who runs the world? Oh, it's the people with the biggest armies and the most missiles, and has been since day one. Maybe SOME DAY that will change, but since that's the way it has clearly ALWAYS BEEN, I better act as if that's STILL THE WAY IT WORKS." Obama, and many liberals apparently, look at history and say "Hmmm.. who ran the world? Well, it was always those dirty bastards who had the largest armies and the most missiles, but THAT SUCKS! The world SHOULDN'T be that way! I'm not going to be party to that!" I really can't imagine a clearer demonstration of how Obama and his peers think that what they think SHOULD BE actually IS, when it demonstrably, and dangerously, IS NOT.

Comments (21)

Boyd
Well, aren't you just the Hope'N'Change curmudgeon!
Andy
Cosmic, I can't remember who said it, but it was a US Army General (I think). "Whoever said 'the pen is mightier than the sword' never faced machine gun fire." Obama and his crowd are either (a)terribly naive, or (b) know exactly what they are doing. (b) disturbs me much more than (a).
Bongo
Just because it always WAS that way doesn't mean it HAS to be. Are we dumb chimps with clubs or do we just WANT TO CONTINUE TO BE dumb chimps with clubs when WE KNOW there is an alternative? Diplomacy, for example? Tact? Constructive relations? Communication? Fostering allegiances instead of enemies? Indeed, being ABLE to defend yourself is as necessary as tact, diplomcay and constructive relations. But it's not THE BEST or ONLY way. Especially if you think you ought to be better than a dumb chimp with a stick. CAUTION and PREPARATION should be behind tact and diplomacy so that if your policies fall through sure, you can defend yourself properly. The US can do so, more than adequately, so stop whining.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: Thank you again for so clearly demonstrating why legislating by platitude is such a dangerous policy. Mark Twain had the clearest description of diplomacy I can ever recall. He said "Diplomacy is the art of saying 'nice doggie' until you can find a rock." The US can currently defend itself. Obama's agreement with Russia on nuclear weapons drawdowns is a huge win for Russia. It means the US will dispose of functional nuclear weapons and Russia will decommission some old rusting behemoths that likely would have failed anyway. The net result is more parity in our nuclear arsenals, instead of a US advantage. Couple that with his promise to "mull over" a reduction in missile defense and I can guarantee you that Putin is laughing up his sleeve at the rube who just sold his nation down the river (just as Carter did). As long as we have to live in a world where chimps with clubs have power, I'm not putting my club down. You can do what you want, but I don't want my leaders putting our clubs down either. YOU may think the world isn't ruled by armies and missiles, but it's not my fault you live in a fantasy world.
Bongo
Excuse me, I do not live in a fantasy. I am well aware of how the world works. But you know something - one of the perks of being human is that you don't have to be stupid by default! Fancy that! We CAN learn things. We CAN do better than cavemen - that's why we're where we are now, writing to each other on computers. However, we've a long way to go to escape the caveman ethic fully, as you agreed yourself. I wouldn't put my club down either, but I don't want to think of myself as another thick chimp in a world run by more of them. But evidently we still are. It is better to have friends than enemies though. And, I would always have a backup in case my diplomacy failed, in case my friends decided to stab me in the back, yes. But let's get real - you don't need 6000 warheads to finish anybody off. Hell, you probably wouldn't need 3, as we already know. So don't fret. I'm sure there'll still be a few thou of them knocking around (and a few more unofficially) in the U.S. arsenal. Going around threatening everybody these days though, it's just rather lame, in a era when the human race has supposedly matured a little (post WW2). I suppose you're advocating Hitler's tactics here, to secure living in the dominant nation? Well, look what happened to him. ;)
CosmicConservative
Bongo: Here are just a few of the reasons you live in a fantasy world. 1. Other nations choose their allies and enemies based on their own analysis of their national self-interest. The idea that the personality of the leader of a nation would trump the actual national security, economic security and political alliances that a nation has is infantile. 2. Nations which make foreign policy decisions based on a desire to BE LIKED by other nations are nations which will be suckered repeatedly until they learn the lesson that geopolitics is not a personality contest. Obama is (hopefully) learning that lesson now. At least I hope he is. 3. Part of the "backup" to our "friendship" with Russia is precisely the nuclear arsenal Obama just slashed, and more importantly the missile defense he just said he was open to dismantling. 4. You repeat Democrat talking points as if they were fact. Show me where Bush "went around threatening" Russia. Or France. Or even Iran (although I wish he HAD threatened Iran). The only nations you can say Bush threatened were Afghanistan and Iraq. And he followed up on those threats. In every other case Bush attempted the same "diplomacy" techniques Obama is attempting today. The liberal caricature of Bush as a knuckle-dragging, belligerent warmonger is just a caricature that has far less basis in fact than the conservative caricature of Obama as a socialist stooge. The fact that you treat it as fact tells me more about you than all your equivocating. 5. It is a well-known Internet rule that whoever first compares their opponent to Hitler automatically loses the debate. Congratulations. You lose.
Bongo
Hahah. Oh dear. You really are putting so much into my mouth than I have never said! You're assuming you know all about me, or even than I'm a democrat troll or somesuch. Assuming so much is, if you'll forgive another fact, foolish. My point on Hitler stands. Especially since you just skirted acknowledging it for some internet pop crap. We're supposed to be discussing here, aren't we? Not exchanging pop trash internet 'rules' like 15 year olds. Look, what exactly has been achieved by Iraq? Have we actually gotten anything at all out of the effort? Have we intimidated any terrorists? Don't you believe it. You can't 'kill' an ideology any more than they might think they can subdue the ethic of freedom Americans hold dear (well, except by killing every terrorist that ever was, or every American). Ok so we found out ol' Saddam wasn't hiding any nukes under his mattress. Turns out the guy didn't have two anthrax spores to rub together, really. So that's one thing - but aside from that it was rather pointless... not to mention illegal/hypocritical. Got a lot of our boys killed, as well. As will happen in Afghanistan when we realise that territory has never been successfully held in recent memory, and that it's going to be a major pain in the ass and a waste of time and resources doing what we're currently doing. Annnnnd what's next, Kim Jong Il maybe? Iran? Oh there's so many people to go give a ticking off... and so little time! But if it's going to yield the same results as Iraq, we might as well forget it. Without the support of the Iraqis themselves, it's a pointless venture, and they're pretty pissed, as I would be if I lived there right now. After all, think of it from the ordinary people's point of view: before they might have had a despot like Saddam in power, but at least their kids could walk to school without getting carbombed. And how long do you think this tenuous 'peace' and democratic government put in place will hold up in a nation inexorably ruled for centuries by warlords? So effectively we spent millions of dollars to pluck one man out of there only for his place to be taken by someone else. Routing out the Taliban is a waste of time right now, too. Are you telling me you think Iraq achieved something worthwhile? I'd love to hear what that is. These aren't democrat points but just points that ought to be made and acknowledged here. Sure, it's stupid to be a weak, fawning fool when you've got "the most powerful job in the world", but it's also stupid to whip the Middle East into a frenzy for no reason, or move out of turn. We should have learned that lesson by now, and you think we should invade Iran? Haha. Well maybe you're right on that one. I don't trust Iran's dude in power much, nor how he's handled his own election crisis. But still, invade everyone who doesn't do what we want with their nuclear material? Stomp all over anyone we suspect of anything underhanded? Pfft. That's practically half the globe we'd have to do it to. Shouldn't we have better things to do than worry about the INEVITABLE nuclear enrichment of developed nations and Middle Eastern countries? Unfortunately Team America World Police don't exist. We're going to have to learn to get along with them eventually, just as we did with what's now the U.N.. It's not a personality contest, no. Are you suggesting true diplomacy is? Actually, it's learning how to say something to another country without using machine gun fire. It comes in quite useful, actually. As useful as machine guns in a sense, I'd say, since it can remove the immediate need for them in the first place.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: I didn't "address" the Hitler comment because to do so would be to give it credibility it does not deserve. I stand by my statement that your invocation of Hitler is beyond the pale and essentially destroys any credibility you think you have. As far as the "discussion" you are simply repeating in more words the same caricatures of Bush that you've been stating all along. The fact that you BELIEVE something does not make it true. What have we gained from the war in Iraq? I'll make a SHORT list: 1. No more Saddam funding Palestinian suicide bombers. 2. No more threats of an empirical Iraq taking over neighboring countries. 3. No more secret deals by a corrupt UN to profit from Saddam's oil "restrictions." 4. An actual Muslim democracy in the middle east. This will either be a world changing thing or it won't. I put the odds right now at about 50/50 that it WILL be world changing. I think that's worth the risk we took. 5. No more rape rooms and woodchipper parties in Saddam's palace. 6. An Iraq which has roughly doubled its electrical generation and whose economy is going to double as well. 7. An ally from which we can better provide leverage against Iran, which is the true threat in the region. I could go on. The fact that you are not able to recognize these advantages isn't my problem. I can guarantee you that Obama does, whether he would publicly admit to them or not. I said when we went into Iraq that we would not know if it was a success for at least a decade. I think that's still about right. Now, just so you know, I OPPOSED the Iraq war. Why? Because I believed that it would squander any international political capital that we would need to go to war with Iran. Which is exactly what it did. HOWEVER, I am not going to squander the sacrifices of the Coalition and Iraqi people. Where we are now we need to press forward to make these improvements permanent. Your resurrection of the tired old liberal refrain about WMD also reveals more about you than your attempt to debate the issues. You conveniently forget, as has become the norm, that Bill Clinton planned to invade Iraq on the same basis and only decided not to because he was concerned that the Monica Lewinsky scandal would open him to charges of "wagging the dog." This is his own admission. Also every Democrat of note believed the same thing Bush did and in fact Bush was getting heat from Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, John Kerry and Al Gore for NOT GOING TO WAR FAST ENOUGH. So shut up Bongo. You can spew your revisionist history all you like to people who drink the same kool-aid you do. I'm sick of dealing with people who believe in a fantasy alternate version of reality. Really sick of it.
Bongo
I think I achieved something by getting you to think about what you believe and state it. Sometimes people can get very insular in their beliefs and not bother explain WHY they think and say what they do. I acknowledge these 'plus points' of Iraq, but you know what, I really don't think Iraq was OUR problem - or rather, it ought not to have been if we hadn't interefered over there in the first place and funded the guy (Saddam during Iran-Iraq). It isn't clear cut like you're suggesting it is, since part of what he became he did so because of us and our policies, our feeding him to keep him from allying himself with the Soviets. He became a problem because WE helped make him one! You could say the same for Bin Laden. Why are you getting stroppy with me? Aren't we just discussing things? I don't understand why people get so riled when they have to actually say something on a site they created to SAY things on. Isn't that the point of the site? Isn't it the point of having a mouth to speak or fingers to type? Or do you just dislike it when not everyone is firmly agreeing with you and putting little winks at the ends of their posts? Your insults and assumptions are pointless and I'm not assuming anything about you. I'm just getting you to extrapolate where you haven't done so adequately.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: If you think your comments here made me "think about what I believe" your naivetee is only exceeded by your ego. Why am I getting "stroppy" with you? Listen Bongo. When you decided to invoke Hitler, you not only forfeited ANY credibility you may otherwise have had, you also forfeited ANY OBLIGATION I might feel to treat you with decency and respect. In case you don't realize it, comparing someone to Hitler is a deadly sort of insult, and had you done it to my face, you would likely have had to deal with more than mere words.
Drax
Bongo: Bush recognized something which we all should recognize -- time doesn't stand still. We have a window in the long march of history where America is the lone superpower and able to unilaterally exert its power on other countries with essential impunity. (I'm not saying that we did, but that we could/can.) That window will soon close. It has closed with many countries -- countries who have WMD's and the ability to deliver them. That window appeared to be closing on Iraq -- as it has closed on North Korea and is closing on Iran. So, if you believed Saddam in his boasts of constructing a single Arab state under his control, then what do you do? Just let him do it? We KNOW that he tried to follow up on his boasts (ask Iran and Kuwait). We KNOW that he HAD WMD's and was willing to use them. (Ask the Kurds or Iran.) We KNOW that he had the ability to deliver these WMD's throughout the Middle East and parts of Europe. (Ask Israel.) We KNOW that he was building up his army such that it was the 4th largest on the planet. (Ask the NYTimes -- read their projected losses in the "war" (as opposed to the "occupation") part of the Iran War.) You say it was not our problem. I think that it was. Were we to wait until he again attempted to carry out his boasts? Maybe not even do something then? Wait until he had ICBM's with nuclear weapons? (How's that working out with North Korea?) I think that Bush did the right thing. I think that withdrawing the troops at this time is the wrong thing. We should stay there until Democracy TAKES -- as we did in Japan and in Germany. We need to stay there until the current generation of rulers DIES OUT, and TWO GENERATIONS are raised in a Democratic society. It takes TIME for such a radical change in culture to take hold. Obama threatens to waste this thin slice of time Bush bought us. The potential of a true Middle Eastern democracy is such a prize that the price in our blood and treasure was worth it. And, if we do NOT take action in Iran, then we will find out what the consequences of allowing countries with such ambition to obtain nuclear weapons costs us. You may be willing to "hope" that nothing bad will happen. I'm not. Unfortunately, we have a President who thinks that you can "negotiate" with "true believers." I don't know if that makes him naive or simply an idiot, but I do know that it makes him dangerous.
Dadman
BTW: I believe Bongo is a Brit based on his use of the term 'stroppy' and his spelling of 'defence' and 'offence'. Cheers!
Bongo
I compared Comsic to Hitler in the theoretical sense because he was suggesting 'take no prisoners' in his view of how America should operate. That's what Hitler did. And he didn't succeed. I don't see how it was a deadly insult since I didn't say "Cosmic, you are verily Hitler II!" I said that policy was similar to Hitler's, and look what happened to him. He bit off more than he could chew by trying to do so and being extremely offensive.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: There is no "theoretical sense" in comparing someone to Hitler. You either do it or you don't. You did it. You can try Obama-esque equivocation and historic revisionism all you like. I was there. I read it. Surely you could have come up with some other example of someone biting off more than they can chew. Obama perhaps? Also you assert that I promote a "take no prisoners" approach to geopolitics. That is untrue and is yet another example of your tendency to set up false straw men and caricatures and then to show how brilliant and reasonable you are by comparison. This cheap debate tactic is also one of Obama's favorites.
Bongo
If you can't discuss things without examples, you shouldn't be discussing them at all. Hitler is a very good example of what a nation's leader shouldn't do to promote its interests. Why shy away from it? It's been 63 years and can't we use the lesson we've learned? And once again, I did not compare you *personally* - in name - to Hitler, you're just insisting stubbornly and bone-headedly that I was. You believe it if you want, but I wasn't. I was saying that there's a line you shouldn't cross when trying to pre-empt or further your nation's cause or interests, and it's a VERY good example. Anger too many of the wrong people and that's what can happen - what happened to Germany.
CosmicConservative
Dadman: According to his IP address, you are correct, Bongo is a Brit.
CosmicConservative
Bongo: You are violating the first rule of holes, which is "stop digging." The more you try to defend your invocation of Hitler the more you prove that you are anything but a reasonable person who simply wishes to discuss issues. The points you claim to have been illustrating by invoking Hitler could have been made by invoking a thousand other examples that are not so offensive, including, say, John F. Kennedy in Vietnam. The fact you went immediately to Hitler as the "obvious" comparison reveals your true nature.
Bongo
What's so offensive about it? Can't you grow up? For the last time, it was an example of nationalism gone nuts, not a personal dig. You really can't discuss Hitler? I find him a fascinating subject personally. Sure, he was a crank and if you believe in Hell I hope he's rotting away down there. But still, his actions ought to be learned from, and discouraged from being emulated in future - not never discussed, never spoken of... and let's not empower him by giving him such a "He Who Must Not Be Named" kind of unholy aura. Your sensitivity overpowering your ability to discuss him reveals a lot about you, too. Not so rational.
CosmicConservative
Bongo, now you have entered the elitist realm of "what, you were offended by my statement? What's wrong with you!? All I did was compare you to Hitler! I mean grow up already." Such an argument doesn't even deserve a response it is so asinine. I am perfectly willing to discuss Hitler Bongo, but not as a proxy for ME get it? When I encounter such obtuseness in people I always wonder, are you ignorant of what you did? Are you simply disingenuous? Or are you so blinded by your own ego that you simply can't see that you were offensive? As far as discussing Hitler is concerned, let's start with his being a member of the National SOCIALIST Party, and his ascension to power being mostly fueled by his promises to nationalize the economy to fix a broken economy.