Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Do "Human Rights" exist?

By CosmicConservative
In the context of the discussion around the "right" of Iran to have nuclear power, the question of the actual existence of human rights has come up. Since that is a more abstract and fundamental question than the narrow context of nuclear power (and weapons), I decided to create a new post to discuss whether there is any such thing as "human rights." The concept of "human rights" is not a new thing. In most history books of Western Civilization, the first "official" mention of such rights is usually traced back to the "Magna Carta" in 1215. This document proclaimed that English subjects of the King had certain "rights" that the King himself could not LEGALLY override, primarily including the rights of habeus corpus and due process. The Magna Carta was a powerful influence on the early settlers of North America and inspired, among other documents, the Mayflower Compact, the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution. It was the Declaration of Independence itself which first and most forcefully proclaimed the "self-evidence" of "natural human rights." The "natural" in those quotations is important because Jefferson and most of the other founders of our country believed in "natural" rights as being rights granted by an all-powerful being (not necessarily the same thing as the modern concept of "God" by the way) to ALL men. The actual wording in the Declaration of Independence is: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." When the first completed draft of the US Constitution had no reference to Human Rights, Thomas Jefferson refused to support its adoption until the first ten amendments, now known as the "Bill of Rights" was added to the Constitution. Jefferson and Madison in particular wrote at length about the existence and providential source of natural human rights. It was this expression of natural human rights that led to the rejection of the feudal system of Kings, barons, dukes and lords. In fact it was the very expression of these "natural human rights" that led Jefferson and most other founders of this nation to proclaim independence from England. But all that means is that our founding fathers BELIEVED in human rights, it doesn't mean that there actually are any such rights outside of the imaginations of certain enlightened and libertarian minds. It is just as questionable whether any two people would agree upon the deliniation of any discrete and complete set of such rights. So it is a fair question to ask whether there is any existential reality behind "natural human rights" or if the concept is purely the product of human political and philosophical debate. Similar questions could be asked about the existential nature of such concepts as "justice" or "honor" or "liberty" or "freedom" or any other abstract concept which governs (or should govern) human affairs. I personally take the position that such concepts may be abstract, but they still exist. In some respects most, if not all, such rights can be traced back to the philosophical concept of "reciprocity" which is most commonly described as the "Golden Rule" or "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." In my mind this concept is so universally acknowledged in the world's religions and enlightened government systems that it is unlikely to have spontaneously arisen simply out of random chance. Reciprocity IS the fundamental expression of natural rights. It is the wellspring of the concepts of justice, fairness, honor and many, many other things that people think of as abstract concepts. But it is not an abstract concept in itself. In fact it is unlikely, in my mind, that ANY sufficiently advanced culture would not eventually recognize and adopt reciprocity as a core underpinning of any social system governing the actions of a group of individuals. In that sense I believe that human rights are "real" not simply abstract statements that have no basis in reality. To me reciprocity is as fundamental to the universe as gravity or electro-magnetism. It is not merely a concept, it is something which provides a fundamental force in societies towards fairness and justice. Yes, there are no doubt many societies which move against this tide because there are OTHER forces, such as selfishness, which oppose reciprocity. In fact the interplay of selfishness and reciprocity drive much of a society's fundamental conflict. Both are real. Both are forces which affect the real world and the real universe.

Comments (28)

Drax
I wrote a long post about what the Magna Carta was and how it was nothing more than the Barons forcing King John to recognize their traditional and customary rights as hammered out over the centuries and which upon which King John was trampling. I posited that the very existence of the Magna Carta, the necessity of the document spelling out what rights the King GRANTED those in his Kingdom (mostly nobility and churchmen) and the very fact that the King had those concessions forced from him proved my case, i.e., that the strong decide what rights he and others have. But, that's pretty obvious, so I suspect that we can agree that history (as evidenced by the Magna Carta) demonstrates conclusively that the strong define the rights of the weak. It's your notion of reciprocity which I find ... contrary to the long march of history. This notion, as a natural state of things, flies directly in the face of just about everything we know of history and of our own senses in contemporary times. If I were alone in the universe, I would be free to do whatever I chose. When someone else comes along, I can only do what the other allows me to do or what I can force the other to allow me to do. So, the very EXISTENCE of another person constrains my freedom. When there are many other people, we ALL have our freedoms constrained by the will of the governing body (or bodies), however defined and constituted. And ALL societies have rules which the members must obey or be punished. If reciprocity were the natural state, one might find ONE society (throughout history) which was governed by that rule, but cast about as you may, you'll not find a single one. Instead, you'll find what the Magna Carta stands for...groups with competing interests warring for power. The Founders recognized this fact, that the government will attempt to impose its will upon the governed, that being the natural state of affairs. Since the government is ... well ... PEOPLE ... this natural state of affairs is the natural state of affairs of PEOPLE. In other words, one cannot remark on the beauty of the Bill of Rights or the brilliance of the Constitutional Separation of Powers without recognizing the NECESSITY of them to prevent abuses of power...by PEOPLE in power. The long march of history informs us that the very opposite of the Golden Rule obtains and is the natural state of Man. Since governments are in control over what rights those it rules have, one can get a pretty good picture of human nature based on examining various governments with a view to seeing how much power is consolidated in the hands of one person and comparing that to how many rights those he rules has -- and then compare the result to see how well it comports with the "Golden Rule." One finds, pretty well without exception, that, to the extent that any "Golden Rule" obtains, it is when the power of the ruling class is diffuse, and the greatest when the power is most diffuse, and thus answerable to those governed. What this means is that when the governed have actual power themselves (by their ability to affect adversely those in power), those in power, as a matter of SELF-INTEREST, tend to employ something resembling the "Golden Rule" else they potentially LOSE their power and become one of the governed. On the other hand, the greater distance those in power have from those they govern (and, thus, the less ability the governed have to adversely affect those in power) the less those in power display anything resembling any "Golden Rule." (Compare the Judicial Rulings of the Supreme Court with the laws passed by Congress. SCOTUS doesn't answer to the people; Congress does. Therefore, SCOTUS makes rulings which are DIRECTLY against the "will of the people" while representatives tend not to. SCOTUS (and other Judges -- especially Federal Judges) can IMPOSE ITS WILL on those they govern without fear of consequence, SO IT DOES. They not only don't bow to the will of those it governs, they SUBSTITUTE their will for those it governs. Because it can. Where the "golden rule" fits in with the struggle of human "rights" isn't immediately apparent.
CosmicConservative
Let's take a longer view of history... 10,000 years ago humanity was just coming out of the last ice age. There were no cities. No countries. No "governments" as we know them today. Life in those days was, if our experience with recent stone-age cultures can be any guide, truly nasty, brutish and short. In large part this was due to the ability of those in power to simply beat into submission anyone who disagreed with them. But this was also due to the very real dangers those cultures encountered in their daily lives. Food was scarce. Competition was fierce. And yet even in THOSE societies, the fundamental concept of the "Golden Rule" existed. People understood basic fairness and people did not live in abject fear of their neighbors. Bowmakers traded bows for arrows made by flint knappers. Tribes interacted and traded with each other. People KNEW when they were being cheated, and they KNEW when someone was being bullied. Fast forward 5 or 6,000 years. Now you have the very beginnings of agrarian societies. These societies for the first time allowed human cultures to grow large enough that individuals could diversify into a large number of specialized roles, including the role of government. Even the earliest governments espoused the FUNDAMENTAL concept of reciprocity. In fact the EARLIEST official document that I know of is the Code of Hammurabi, and what does the Code of Hammurabi describe? Reciprocity. Pure and simple. Fairness. Justice. Then there are the Ten Commandments. Again, mostly reciprocity (with some "Worship only Me" thrown in). As you move closer and closer to the present you find this concept of reciprocity becoming more and more important and fundamental to the governing principles of the cultures involved. And it is in large part BECAUSE these governing principles are based on reciprocity that they gain the popular approval necessary for those in power to ACTUALLY GOVERN. Were it not for this fundamental human acknowledgement of the concept of reciprocity, most governments would not exist. It is through appealing to this fundamental concept that they gain power in the first place. Of course there are exceptions. But they are exceptions. Even the Constitution of the Soviet Union (yes they had one) bore homage to reciprocity. But basing a governmental system upon reciprocity in and of itself does not guarantee that the ACTUAL GOVERNMENT will be fair, just or even rational. This is because people ABUSE their power to act in their own self-interest. This is the OTHER side of the reciprocity coin, which I described in the initial post as the Yang of reciprocity's Yin. But that does not change these historical facts: 1. Governments have ALWAYS used the principle of reciprocity as a fundamental means of gaining the acceptance of the people governed. 2. Over time human civilization has been in large part a story of ever-advancing human rights. This is because the IDEALS of reciprocity are GOALS for the culture to achieve, and in the striving for them, progress is slowly, painfully, sometimes temporarily, made. To me the fact that governments based on the principle of reciprocity have overcome Hitler, Stalin, Pol Pot, King Henry the Eighth, Attila the Hun, et. al. is pretty convincing evidence that the human recognition of the RIGHTNESS of reciprocity is, in the end, more powerful than the human tendency to subjugate and terrorize their peers.
Drax
We clearly have a different view of history. There have always been "governments" as we know them. They have taken many forms, most of which, in one way or another in one place or another, exist today. From the earliest "chief" or village elders to a dictator...doesn't matter. What I said obtains: The more able those governed are able to adversely affect those governing, the greater degree the "golden rule" is adhered to. Let us look at the Code of Hammurabi (again...a document which merely codifies the existing state of affairs as to custom and tradition as the Magna Carta.) While there is "reciprocity" in the document, the notion that it proves the existence of some natural law resembling a "golden rule" cannot be established. In those rules where such exists, it exists as a constraint on the ABUSE OF POWER of others and the existence of the rules themselves establishes that they are the RESULT of former abuses of power sufficient so that LAWS had to be created to PREVENT IT. In other words, it is utterly unnecessary to pass a law preventing accusing another of a captial crime without cause ... unless some had been abusing that process. All those laws of "reprocity" are merely laws which prevent the abuse of process by another. As noted by Hammurabi: "When Marduk sent me to rule over men, to give the protection of right to the land, I did right and righteousness in . . . , and brought about the well-being of the oppressed." Again. There is no need to bring about the "well-being of the oppressed" if there are no "oppressed." Hammurabi thought himself to be ordained by his god to bring law to the land (his and the many he conquered...not really "doing unto them" as he would have done to himself, I don't think....). Several Kings and Emperors have thought of themselves as such. But, to extrapolate from the codification of law to the conclusion that the "golden rule" is somehow a natural law -- or that the laws so passed are an example of this natural law -- goes too far. More likely, the laws passed are ones which are either deemed necessary for the orderly running of the empire or are passed in response to pressure applied by other political powers. Let's look at the Code itself: First, of the 282 laws, how many deal with females and slaves as property? How does that comport with the "Golden Rule?" How many are simply rules of the road for steady commerce? How many laws are ones which say "If this...then that" followed by a law which says "If you lied in the previous law, you'll be put to death?" (Why the necessity for the second if not knowledge of the nature of Man to attempt to take advantage of his neighbor if he can do so without consequence?) Etc. Etc. Etc. Certainly, when someone decides to sit down and create laws and has as a goal "fairness" or "justice" then one can do so. But, to ignore the reality that such a set of laws is NECESSARY simply because people DO rape, steal, kill, and otherwise do to their neighbor as they will rather than as they ought, and concoct some sort of natural law which drives men to treat their neighbors as they would like to be treated when history teaches us that the opposite is true, just doesn't wash with me. One cannot have society on any level without rules. The fact that rules are necessary precludes the "Natural Law of the Golden Rule." If men lived by the Golden Rule, laws would be unnecessary.
CosmicConservative
Drax... heh, no doubt at all that we have a different view of history and of what history demonstrates about human beings, governments and the possible existence of transcendent concepts. When I look at the history of human self-government I see a steady increase in every principle related to reciprocity. I see an increase for the individual (a man today has far more liberty than a man 6,000 years ago) and I see an increase in the diversity (a woman today has far more liberty than a woman 6,000 years ago, and very nearly has the same liberty as a man). In other words the principles associated with reciprocity have increased both in scale and in quality. You continue to use examples of individuals abusing their power as some sort of proof that reciprocity is not a driving force of history. I don't dispute that individuals have abused their power, but I assert that in SPITE of those individuals the general direction of human civilization has been to consistently and substantially move in the direction that reciprocity takes us. You seem to think that because individuals succumb to selfish desires somehow invalidates the concept of reciprocity. Again, for the third time, I will say that there are (at least) TWO forces at play in human (and no doubt all intelligent species) culture. Reciprocity moves us in the direction of the acceptance and promotion of individual human rights, while selfishness moves us in the direction of trampling the rights of others and pursuing our own goals. These two forces are at play both in both the macro and the micro sense. Our cultures are just as conflicted over the competing desires of reciprocity vs. selfishness as each of us as individuals is. My contention is that reciprocity is the superior force, and although selfishness is powerful indeed, and has disastrous consequences at times, IN GENERAL the force of reciprocity wins out over the force of selfishness. Or to put it in simple human terms... every single day each of us has multiple opportunities to pursue selfishness, or to pursue "do unto others." In the great majority of cases, EVEN THE WORST OF US chooses the "do unto others" course. For example, I get up and go to work every day. I have a half dozen stop signs and an equal number of red lights that I encounter. For every individual who ignores the red light or stop sign and bulls on through for their own selfish purposes, a THOUSAND cars stop, look and proceed after giving the other drivers THEIR PROPER TURN. If the situation were reversed our society would fail spectacularly. If 999 out of a thousand grocery shoppers shoplifted their goods, grocery stores would go out of business. It is my contention that your use of examples of people being mean and selfish actually proves my point, because if that was the MAJORITY behavior of our culture, civilization would not only not be "civil" it would in fact be anarchic chaos. One final point. The very word "civilization" is rooted in the concept of reciprocity. And that's because it REQUIRES it.
Drax
We disagree, I think, on the fundamental nature of Man. You seem to think that I have singled out individuals who have abused power over the history of man as examples of the nature of man. In fact, I challenge you to find ANY totalitarian civilization which, except for the rare individual, ISN'T or WASN'T corrupt and rife with abuses of power at every level. And, in those where corruption and abuse of power wasn't the order of the day at the very top levels of government (ALL are rife at the lower levels) even those are so corrupt with the trappings and privileges of power that that "abuse" is inherent in the "job." (Compare for example how a thief of a royal's property is treated as compared to the thief of a commoner's in the Magna Carta or the Code of Hammurabi. Rank has its privileges. The more totalitarian a government, the greater those privileges are -- even to a benevolent king. I agree with your conclusion that the march of history has been one of ever-increasing individual rights and freedoms for a large part of the world, although I certainly wouldn't say this is the case for the entire world. There are still countries in which the citizens have no more rights today than they did a thousand years ago -- and in some cases -- less. But, overall, I agree with that conclusion. I just don't agree with the REASON, i.e. that it is an outgrowth of "natural law," or that the pertinent natural law is the "Golden Rule." If this "natural law" existed, then it has ALWAYS existed else it's not "natural." If it has ALWAYS existed, then it would have had force from the beginning, else it isn't much of a LAW. Since history tells a story of centuries upon centuries of Man (a story which continues yet -- ask anyone in Afghanistan or North Korea, for example) of the strong preying on the weak, of the strong exercising the power of life and death over entire populations, of ownership of one human by another, of women being little more than property. There has been a desperate fight (going on yet) to ESCAPE this paradigm, to find freedom and extract the ability to exercise it from the clutches of those who would deny it. This is a fight which would not be necessary if the natural state of things were for Man to apply the Golden Rule to his actions. As to your notion that the selfish nature of man would lead to chaos, I heartily disagree. Freedom is the handmaiden of anarchy, not order. Total order precludes anarchy. Order, especially of the lives of others, is imposed by selfish men who are more than happy to impose their wills upon others, restricting their freedoms, in their pursuit of power. Total Freedom, on the other hand, is the inability or unwillingness of anyone to impose his will upon another so that everyone can do whatever they desire whenever they desire to do it. Too much freedom is quite dangerous for a society. (Ask the growing majority of Russians who yearn for the Communist days. They are more than willing to give up their "freedom" for the certainty of the imposed order of that regime. There wasn't much of a Russia Mafia back then and everyone had a job. You could walk the streets at any time in any place without fear of robbery or rape. Not so much now.) One cannot HAVE "civilization" unless there are people who are willing to impose their will upon the populace, to make the rules of the road and to enforce them. There must be those who SEEK power and EXERCISE power or roads don't get built, borders aren't defended, children aren't taught, laws don't get passed or enforced. This seeking and exercise of power is innate. We ALL do it. We ALL seek to impose our wills upon others. Whether it's the Russian Premier staring down the U.S. President in October '63, the boss scheduling over-time without regard to the wants/needs/desires of his employees, the husband shouting at his wife for overspending, the mother slapping her child for not obeying, the child screaming because he wants his toy...doesn't matter. It's ALL an attempt to get others to do what WE want. This doesn't mean that we can't overcome that innate drive and act in a "civilized" manner, just that we must overcome our natural instincts to do so. Anyone who has raised a child knows that the natural instinct of a child is utterly selfish and he must be trained or broken of that innate selfishness. So, no. We disagree on the fundamental nature of Man. Of course, I can look to any point in history on any point on the map and provide examples of this...from Hitler...to his staff...to those who set the train schedules...to those who rounded up the Jews...to those who guarded them...to those who ultimately gassed them. From those who captured slaves...to those who purchased them for resale...to those who owned the boats who transported them..to those who purchased them for use...to those who protected that ownership through custom and law. It doesn't matter what point in history you look at. Whole societies corrupted. If we were ruled by the natural law of the Golden rule, such societies simply could not exist. Yet they did, and they do. Yet, my view of human nature predicts this type of society, ones ruled by ruthless men willing to do just about anything in pursuit of power and a populace so consumed with the selfish pursuit of self-preservation that they allow the rulers to do unimaginable evil with themselves as the instruments to carry out that evil.
CosmicConservative
So... Drax... If humans must overcome their innate drive to act in a "civlized" manner, and we both agree that by and large humans have been doing that to a greater and greater degree for centuries.... Isn't that proof that it is "natural" for humans to overcome their innate drives? Why do you seem to be having so much trouble understanding my FUNDAMENTAL argument that every human being has BOTH drives, the drive for selfishness and the innate comprehension and appreciation of the "golden rule"? You seem to be arguing that humans can only have one. I say they have both, and that the complex interplay of temptation vs. honor (for lack of better terms) leads to much of the complexity of human actions. ... BUT, for the most part, as history provides evidence, humans, and by extension their cultures, DO overcome their innate selfishness. And they do so because of their innate appreciation of, and adherence to, the natural rights which are founded upon the principle of reciprocity.
Drax
I'm not sure that I can agree that humans have an innate drive (or understanding) of reciprocity. I've not run across a child who knows this concept without being trained in it. On the other hand, every child I've met is intimately familiar with "MINE!" Civilization requires the appearance of reciprocity -- at least towards those who present a threat to the power of the "throne." Even Kim Jon-il must treat his generals with some degree of civility else they will ultimately do what disgruntled military leaders the world over have done -- turn their tanks on their soon-to-be former leader. I go back to my earliest point. If I were alone in the universe, I could do what I want when I want. When a second person shows up, I am constrained by his desires and can only do what he allows me to do or what I can force him to allow me to do. This is true of all people, even the greatest and most powerful ruler. If he doesn't appease those who have the ability to negatively affect him, then he will ultimately lose his power or a portion of it. It is a lesson repeatedly taught to those whose reach exceeded their grasps. (I return to King John and the Barons who forced him to accept the Magna Carta...) Even Pharaohs, gods in flesh, were subject to assassination if they displeased too much and too often those who had the power to negatively affect them. Kim Jong-il doesn't appease his generals because he has any innate drive towards reciprocity, but an innate drive of self-preservation. I see the selfish drive as the impetus in history's march towards "civilization" rather than some altruistic imperative. It was the Baron's selfish drive for power which allowed them to force the weakened King John into signing the Magna Carta. When Henry I introduced the King's Justice extending throughout the land, he wasn't trying to extend Justice but his power. He succeeded in both. It was the recognition of this selfish drive to power that informed the Founders, and it is the selfish drive for power by those we elect which, at least thus far, keeps this country relatively free. SCOTUS seeks to extend its power, the President his, Congress theirs. These competing interests prevent any from fully achieving its goal. Finally, this notion that there IS some fundamental "fairness" intrigues me. The notion of "fairness" is a fundamental underpinning of the Golden Rule for to do unto another as we would have him do to us really is of no worth if our respective notions of what is "fair" are widely divergent. As one who has represented hundreds of clients in divorces and many more hundreds of injury claims, AND one who has somehow been able to eat essentially haggling with others about the "fair" value of what they wanted to sell and what I wanted to buy, I must say that I have a difficult time agreeing that there is anything which even remotely resembles a consensus as to what is "fair."
CosmicConservative
I guess we're just going to have to disagree on this one. But I can never resist a parting shot... :) So... if children have to be "taught" reciprocity... Who taught the first child?
Drax
In simplistic terms, the child that taught the "first child" reciprocity is the second child. Once introduced to the obstacle to his desires, the first child is FORCED to consider the desires of the second child. When one can do what one wills without objection, unless one has an internal restraining force, one does what one wills. When one meets objection, one either gives up on one's desire or finds a way to obtain that desire. Force. Trickery. Cajoling. Persuasion. Theft. (Envision the many times you have told your children "no" only to find that they have found a way to stuff that cookie into their mouths anyway.) When the first child and the second child both want the "cookie," and neither is able to obtain his desire, then they must either both do without or they can decide to "share." Again, simplistic...since there is no "first child" any more than there is an "Adam and Eve." Many other factors come into play beyond the simple fact that no one person has absolute power and is forced to recognize the existence and the right to continued existence of others, even if those "others" only extends to the small sub-set of people who have the power to adversely affect him. Among these factors is the "us" and "them" reality. One treats members of his own society ("us") differently than one treats others ("them"). Compare the disparity in the Code and the Magna Carta. One treats, within the sub-set of "us" those who are more "us" better than those who are less "us." Again. Compare the treatment of slaves, women, and commoners to chiefs, warriors, and nobility in the Code and the Magna Carta. (I go back to those because they were mentioned by you and I have recently read them, but this disparity of treatment is echoed throughout history and continues today.) This is the extension of family. One learns very quickly by living in close proximity to others that other people have feelings, especially children. Those people have the power to adversely affect you, if only by making you feel miserable. You learn to respect those feelings simply you're forced to -- just as they are forced to respect yours. Seriously, simplified beyond words. A book wouldn't suffice to put into words the forces which drive us to accept the existence and continued existence of others. Just think of this. Whenever you're driving down the road and you honk your horn at someone, you're attempting to impose your will on that person. He is impeding you. On the other hand, if you're the other driver, you're almost certainly going to be annoyed that someone is honking his horn at you. So, you flip the horn blower off. Tempers flare. This is a microcosm of our debate. One doesn't learn to lose one's temper. One learns to CONTROL one's temper. If the "Golden Rule" were natural law, then the first instinct would be to patient with the other person just as we would like for those behind us to be patient with us. But, instead, our first instinct is a selfish one, irritation that someone delayed us resulting in a blown horn. I don't think that the Golden Rule can co-exist as natural law with an innate selfishness; they are very close to opposites, and I have seen no evidence that the Golden Rule obtains with untrained children while I have scads of evidence that they are innately selfish.
CosmicConservative
Drax: See, I fundamentally disagree with you. When I am driving and someone impedes me, my first reaction is to look for a way to get around them. I can't remember the last time I honked my horn at anyone. I don't believe I have ever flipped off another driver unless I have been seriously provoked. In fact I've probably given the one-finger salute to another driver less than five times in my life, regardless of provocation. I don't understand why you think selfishness and reciprocity can't co-exist as natural law. To me that's like saying positive and negative charges cannot both exist as natural law. You also have refered to reciprocity as "altruism" and I think that is a fundamental misunderstanding of what reciprocity is. Reciprocity is not altruism, it is a recognition that other beings exist and deserve respect. Reciprocity is "If you cut the cookie in half, I get to pick the half I want." I continue to be puzzled by my difficulty in communicating how reciprocity and selfishness are competing drives within human consciousness, and how human being react to both. I find this to be a statement of the blindingly obvious. When kids start to play a softball game the process of choosing sides AUTOMATICALLY becomes "I pick, then you pick, then I pick....." because it is universally recognized as the most fair way to distribute talent among two teams. If one team leader picks all the biggest players, the other "team" will simply refuse to play. I think this is where you see selfishness at play in both places. I don't see it as "selfish" to acknowledge that if you want to do something, you have to work with other people. I see that as "enlightened self interest". Recognizing that achieving your personal goals frequently requires helping others achieve their goals is not selfishness, it's an understanding that other people have goals too. This fundamental acknowledgement that OTHER PEOPLE MATTER is the most fundamental statement of reciprocity. Some of your argument strikes me as the sort of argument pure Epicureans sometimes make to try to "prove" that ALL philosophies are Epicurean because even pursuing an altruistic motive is done because it makes the person "feel good" and so is pursuing personal pleasure. This argument may appeal to other Epicureans, but it does not pass muster with followers of other philosophies who believe that there ARE transcendent realities, that all human behavior cannot be adequately described as the slavish pursuit of dopamine responses. I fall in the transcendent camp. I believe that people do the "right" thing because they "know" it's the right thing to do, not because it's a sideways, back-alley way to pursue their own selfish pleasures.
Drax
Yes, we disagree. You say: "Reciprocity is not altruism, it is a recognition that other beings exist and deserve respect." Why? How do you establish that as a fundamental aspect of the nature of Man in view of the history of Man. The ENTIRE history of Man is the exact opposite of the unreserved recognition of the right of other humans to existence and respect. Tribes conquered by other tribes. City-States vying for dominance over other city-states. Nations seeking dominance over others. Empires conquering everything that they are able to. The entire history of Man is one of Man seeking power over his fellows. It continues apace today. Wars, genocide, slavery. You practice it. I practice it. I COULD live in a smaller home, take the bus, eat rice and beans and give the rest of my money away to someone who lives in the street. So could you. We don't. The USA COULD forego building new roads, new warships, new schools and build those in Africa where they are needed more. But, we don't. We don't even do what we could when it causes us even the most minor of national inconveniences. We have 280+ warships. Why not give some of them to nations that have none and need them. We have more than enough nukes to protect ourselves. Why not give some of them to countries that can't protect themselves? Why doesn't Exxon, in the good times, give their money to nations or communities who need them? Or Microsoft? Or Bill Gates? Why don't Major League players give all but the first million of their bloated contracts to people in other countries (or here in our own), building roads, digging wells, constructing schools? The BILLIONS that could be funneled into ... say the homeless problem or the poor in Appalachia could solve many problems, make for a more "fair" life for those poor souls. But, they don't. No I continue to live in my big house while others sleep under bridges. Major leaguers continue to live in their mansions while the money they don't "need" could change the lives of entire cities if not entire countries. Where IS this Golden Rule practiced as a fundamental nature of Man? When Oprah funds a school in Africa, it makes national news. When Mutumbo takes a village under his wing to help them, it makes national news. When Pitt/Jolie adopt a child from a destitute village, it makes news. Why? Because it IS news. It is an abberation. Even though Pitt/Jolie could do MUCH more, even save the entire VILLAGE from which that child came with their untold millions, their saving that ONE child is news. Anyway, you call it "enlightened self-interest" and I call it "self-interest." I'll give you the "enlightened" part. It makes no difference as "self-interest" which isn't "enlightened" wouldn't work very well to achieve the desired end, i.e., to get what you want. I'm not saying that everything is defined by this drive towards self-interest, simply that such a drive explains much of Man's history while the supposed existence of a "Golden Rule" as natural law is utterly inconsistent with the history of Man.
Andy
Just a couple of things Drax & CC: I have truly enjoyed reading this back and forth. I have learned much...as I always do when you two "visit." The original question posed was "Do 'Human Rights' Exist?" I would say, Yes. But only those willing to sacrifice something (great or small) to walk in them. And Drax: You do divorces? I am going to need a LA attorney soon...not for me, but for a child of mine living out of state, yet will need the work done in LA. Can I get a break if I agree with you instead of CosmicCurmudgeon? ;) Just kidding about the break. I'll be in touch.
Andy
I meant, "Only those willing to sacrifice something (great or small) to walk in them will enjoy them."
Drax
Andy, I don't practice any longer. I simply got tired of liars and thiefs, and my clients weren't all that great either. However, if you wish to e-mail me (hl_golden@hotmail.com) I can provide some names of good attorneys, depending on the financial status of your child.
Drax
A final note CC: We're clearly not going to agree on the fundamental nature of Man or the existence, let alone the primacy, of individual drives, but as a final shot, let me simply say this: I could give a good account of explaining just about every behavior of Man throughout the ages through the prism of "self-interest." You cannot do the same with a natural law of reciprocity. I'm satisfied with that.
CosmicConservative
Wow, I am somewhat surprised by how completely we disagree on this subject. It's almost as if we are having a "half-full/half-empty" argument. Except that I keep saying that both views are correct and you keep saying that you can only call the glass half-empty. I also think I've made my points fairly well here, and yet they simply are not getting acknowledged or absorbed. I keep trying harder and harder to describe what I truly believe to be blindingly obvious. Let's try it this way. You mention one tribe going to war with another as an example of how humans are inherently selfish. I agree with that. But I assert that there would be no tribes in the first place without the reciprocity required for people to live together. You continually seem to miss or ignore that point. Plus AFTER the war, when the tribes have merged, the end result is MORE reciprocity as a new cultural equilibrium is achieved. Not always of course, and you will probably say "Oh no! SOMETIMES the victors ENSLAVE the losers!" Which is true, but that result may have been the norm 2,000 years ago, but is no longer the norm today, in yet another example of how the general direction of civilization is in the direction of recognizing the value of others instead of seeking always to exploit them. There is no doubt that the "us/them" issue is real, and that the more a group can call themselves "us" and call another group "them" the more they are willing to commit selfish acts on the "them." Even while demonstrating profound respect for the rest of the "us". My assertion is that throughout history the definition of "us" has been steadily growing more inclusive and the definition of "them" has been steadily growing more restricted. That is not to say that there are not still those who have ancient attitudes of "us/them." You continue to use what I consider to be the exceptions to "prove" their ubiquity. I continue to use the broad sweep of civilization's advance to "prove" they are exceptions. It almost feels as if you have a sort of all-or-nothing requirement in this argument. If I'm sleeping in a house while someone else sleeps in an alley, I am purely selfish in your view. I simply don't see it that way. I see a community of houses where people routinely demonstrate profound examples of reciprocity on a daily basis. You see a group of selfish people who flagrantly ignore the homeless man sleeping under the overpass. Both are true. Yet you ignore the existence of the community, and all the complex "golden rules" that allow the community to thrive because the community does not offer the homeless man a home. It's a strange argument to me. It's like saying "Yeah, you might be batting .400 and all, but you just struck out, so you suck at batting." It is not only POSSIBLE to exhibit reciprocity and selfishness simultaneously, it is REQUIRED to do so. Nobody could live their lives in constant need to consider everyone else's needs equal or superior to their own. To do so would be saintly indeed, and I frankly doubt even the saints abilities to do that. Ignoring the homeless man under the overpass does not negate the thousand other daily "golden rule" efforts that allow humans to live in some sort of harmony. People have to make practical choices about how to live their lives, and scouring the neighborhood for lost kittens and homeless people every night is not a practical way to live. By the way, one of the key diagnostic techniques to identify a particular sort of psychosis, the "sociopath" is the CLINICAL demonstration of a lack of reciprocity, which is considered NORMAL in most people. A psychologist or psychiatrist would consider the lack of reciprocity to be a DIAGNOSABLE MENTAL DISEASE. That's how universally recognized the principle of reciprocity is in the mental health community.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I already addressed the attempts by Epicureans to describe all human behavior as pursuit of self-interest. They still do so today. This is essentially the same thing as you saying that you can describe all human behavior in terms of self-interest. This has been debated for centuries, in fact it was a key debate between the Epicureans and the Stoics in ancient Greece. In that debate, by the way, Epicurus himself advanced the whole notion of reciprocity as a means of explaining why one feels good when one helps another, and advanced that as a basis for the Epicurean ethical system. Epicurus proposed that reciprocity was critical to self-interest BECAUSE he could not otherwise explain why people cared about other people and derived personal pleasure from helping them.
CosmicConservative
Oh... this point: "I could give a good account of explaining just about every behavior of Man throughout the ages through the prism of “self-interest.” You cannot do the same with a natural law of reciprocity. I’m satisfied with that." I am puzzled by why you seem to think that I have attempted to explain human behavior through reciprocity alone. I have repeatedly, at least four times now, described selfishness and reciprocity as competing forces. So if you can describe human behavior in terms of "self interest" so can I. "Self interest" or even "selfishness" is fully included in my view of the universe. Adding reciprocity only allows me to explain MORE behaviors than utilizing self-interest alone. Let's take one very specific behavior and analyze it through your prism and mine. A man finds a wallet in an empty street with $1,000 in cash in it. Let's say the wallet includes some photos of kids and a past-due mortgage payment notice of $750 with a threat of eviction for non-payment. And it contains a drivers license with a name and address. Let's examine some of the possible behaviors and see how we can explain them. 1. The man puts the money in his pocket and drops the wallet back in the street. 2. The man takes the wallet to a police station and turns it in. 3. The man walks to the nearest Post Office and mails the wallet with all its contents to the address on the drivers license anonymously. Ok, so I think both of us would agree that behavior #1 can be entirely and accurately described as being a purely selfish action. In Action #2 the prism of pure self-interest would indicate that the man wanted to feel the approbation of his peers for performing a "selfless" act, and that desire was stronger than his desire to pocket a quick and easy $1,000. The prism of a combination of self-interest and reciprocity would suggest that the man may have wanted some approbation for his actions, but also that he sincerely felt sympathy for another human being and did what he wished someone else would do if the situation were reversed. Action #3 is much more difficult to explain in the terms of pure self-interest. It CAN be done, but it requires some serious speculation about motives and somehow has to end up explaining how an anonymous act could produce more pleasure than either simply pocketing the cash or by publicly turning it in. Sure it can be done by sufficient rhetorical contortions, but it's not an easy sell. Action #3 is quite simple to explain from the prism of reciprocity competing with self interest. The man simply felt that he should do the "right thing" because he would wish the "right thing" would be done if the situation were reversed. His empathy for another human being simply overcame his selfish desire for his own gain. Perhaps I'm a pollyanna here, but I like the final description of action #3 much more than the pure self-inerest one.
Andy
Thanks Drax. I will leave you and CC to your visit...
Drax
I don't attempt to explain all human behavior through the prism of self-interest. I merely state that almost all human behavior CAN be explained by that innate drive. This debate began with the question whether "human rights" exist. You posited that they exist and exist due to a natural law you and others call "reciprocity" commonly known as the "Golden Rule." I posited that to the extent there are human rights, they were created (i.e., do not exist independently in "natural law") over the centuries as a result of the continual battles between individuals and groups as they pursued their self-interest. You seem to think that I've ignored what you've said. I haven't. I merely view it differently. Your acceptance of my example of one warring tribe against another as evidence of "self-interest" is one thing. Your argument that the very existence of a village (or several) is proof of reciprocity is another. Surely, you can accept that it is at least arguable that early humans banded together, initially, for protection? For sustenance? Division of labor? For other imperatives driven by their individual self-interests? So, I don't accept the existence of villages as "proof" of reciprocity any more than I accept your analogy of how one goes about picking a baseball team as such. (After all, why is it an issue who picks first if the underlying nature of Man is to do unto others as we would have them do to us? Wouldn't it be a contest to see who picked SECOND if that were the case? Indeed, if you chanced to pick first, wouldn't you give that pick to your opponent so that he picked 1st and 4th and you 2nd and 3rd, a much more "fair" order of picks -- if the goal is "fairness?" Nah. That ain't how it goes, is it?) I agree that reciprocity is critical to self-interest but have delimited it to exhibiting that reciprocity to those who are able to negatively affect us. When we sell a used car to our brother, we make sure that the price is fair (or better), all defects are clearly disclosed, and that he gets what he pays for. We're not so diligent in our dealings with strangers. Generals don't care about reciprocity in regard to their privates, but care much about such in regard to their staff to their colonels while sergeants care about reciprocity towards their corporals and corporals to their privates. Emperors pass laws which favor nobles. Nobles protect their knights. None care too much about "reciprocity" towards slaves, women, or serfs. I agree that the march of history has been one of ever-increasing circles of "us" and "them." When someone becomes one of "us," they have an increased likelihood of being in the circle that can adversely affect us, so are treated differently than they were than when they were "them." Many people believe that this is where the prohibition against incest came from. When you marry your daughter outside of your family, you create bonds with another family, increasing the number (and influence) of "us" as it relates to "them." That's why most marriages were arranged. (And still are in many parts of the world.) In that view, a female who marries into her own family is a wasted resource (more than that -- a negative resource as an additional mouth to feed without adding anything to the family "pot.") -- thus the prohibitions against incest. This worked quite well in the Middle Ages (ask, perhaps, the Plantagenents....) As the "us" grows, so, too, does the distance between the rulers of "us" and the rest of "us," resulting in some of "us" being treated closely akin to "them." A peasant in feudal Europe could no more adversely affect the King than could an individual barbarian at the door. So, the wants/needs of peasants were not tended to in the greatest part. They were simply used as a resource. However, the Barons had to be appeased as did the Bishops. They could hurt the King. Of course, those under the Barons could hurt them, so the Barons tended to them. And so on down the line. Self-Interest. Ah, well. I believe that "reciprocity" is a LEARNED concept rather than an innate one. I believe that it is used in pursuit of self-interest. I ALSO believe that it is often used as a result of OTHER imperatives a person experiences whether innate or learned which have NOTHING to do with self-interest and are often CONTRARY to self-interest. But, I believe that this is an INTELLECTUAL choice, rather than one driven by an innate drive. And, I guess that's where we depart company...
Drax
The last paragraph replies adequately to your last post, I think.
CosmicConservative
A pre-requisite for reciprocity is empathy, which is the ability to vicariously "feel" what another person is feeling. Do you consider empathy to be an "innate" trait or a "learned" one? This is a key question because it should be clear that empathy is what drives reciprocity.
Drax
Heh...we are SO far afield of the basic question "Do human rights exist?" that we may as well quit attempting to answer it. I'm glad you brought up empathy. I gave it a lot of thought while addressing these posts. I'm not sure I agree that empathy is what "drives reciprocity." Many time, if not most times, what the other person (or group) wants is clear, so "reciprocity" isn't a matter of empathy but intellect. North Korea wants nukes; we don't want them to have nukes. Not much necessary in the "empathy" department there. Two children fighting over a cookie -- again -- no great need for examination of the inner person to figure out where things stand. And, to treat another as we would like to be treated requires no knowledge of what the other is feeling...only what we are feeling. If we now re-define "reciprocity" as "treating another as THEY would like to be treated," rather than how WE would like to be treated, then, in those instances where circumstances don't clearly reveal what the other person wants empathy would certainly be a useful ability. But, empathy as "innate?" Dunno. Tend to think not. Don't know of many 2 year olds who inherently know and take action on what others want as they would do as a matter of course if empathy was innate. I'm not really sure that "empathy" exists, anyway, not inasmuch as it is an actual experiencing of the feelings of another. I'd go so far as to say that one can intellectually make a fairly accurate guess as to what another is likely feeling based upon the known circumstances. (I say this as, yet again, I have to call my 2 year-old off of my dog, again informing her that dogs don't LIKE to have their tails pulled.)
Drax
Very close. She says that she's "two and three quarters" when asked and will "be three soon." But, end of next month. Three. Gotta get used to saying "three" now instead of "two." Time ain't on my side, and I don't care who sings it is....
CosmicConservative
On empathy... Empathy is one of the least clearly defined attributes a human is said to possess, and that's looking at a lot of poorly defined attributes. There has been some very interesting research done lately on empathy that seems to demonstrate that it is deeply innate in human beings (and in other primates). Our ability to vicariously determine what another person is feeling seems to be based on a combination of scent and body language more than anything else. It does not seem to be "intellectualized" meaning that when we empathize it lights up the parts of our brains more associated with emotion than with higher thought. Because it is so closely tied to scent and body language, it is thought that our ability to emphathize with others is remarkable accurate. At least for those of us with the capacity to empathize. For those on the autism spectrum, for example, there is very little activity in this part of the brain when emotional signals are sent out, and inability to empathize is one of the symptomatic diagnostics for autism spectrum disorders. So empathy seems to be "real" from the research I've seen. In other words, human beings are pretty good at identifying how other people feel. Now, that's one thing. Reciprocity does not depend merely on an ability to accurately recognize CURRENT emotional states, it depends on the ability to PREDICT the emotional state that a particular event will engender. "If I don't share this cookie, Katie will be sad." That means that for the purpose of acting in a way to avoid causing emotional distress to another person DOES require higher thought. And since it requires higher thought, that means that the brain has to develop those higher thought processes which allow for predictability and recognition of patterns. That capability develops much more slowly than other brain functions, such as speech, coordination, empathy, etc. For that reason children are routinely regarded as "selfish" because it takes time for the brain to develop to the point that reciprocity is a reliable process. In that sense it is a "learned" behavior, but that doesn't mean that it has to be "taught." It is quite possible that as the higher cognitive functions develop, the ability to empathize with others and the ability to predict the outcome of events provides individuals with the tools they need to understand the importance of "reciprocity." This, of course, is very hard to empirically demonstrate, primarily because we human beings don't like turning our kids into experiment subjects, especially experiments that would of necessity require us to subject them to emotional distress. So the debate of whether individuals naturally develop the concept of reciprocity or not is not likely to be resolved anytime soon. It is MY contention that the concept of reciprocity is a natural result of combining the ability to empathize with cognitive functions and the close proximity of other humans. In other words, it would spontaneously develop if you raised kids in an insulated environment where all you did was provide food and shelter and let the kids work out a social system. Of course there are plenty who disagree. In fact it was pretty much exploring this question that led to the book "Lord of the Flies." And that brings us more or less full circle back to the fundamental question of human nature itself. My contention is that humans are inherently good and decent and naturally develop societal rules based on reciprocity. Your mileage may vary, I suppose.
Drax
I guess my contention is that people are inherently selfish and the rules of the road are determined by the competition between competing interests. And, again. I'm unconvinced of the existence of empathy as I (and many dictionaries) define it. Certainly, we can intellectually make a good guess at how someone does feel (or will feel) about something given the circumstances. I will concede the possibility of being able to unconsciously and imperfectly interpret non-verbal signals others give out. I tend to believe that in situations where body language and smell are of such degree as to register on the senses of someone untrained in detecting them, the degree of emotion felt would have to be somewhat extreme and obvious if merely described let alone observed. I'm torn on the "learned"/"taught" dichotomy. Certainly one can learn not to pull on a dog's tail as, eventually, the dog will "learn ya." I'm sure that, eventually, one will "learn" not to keep screaming and throwing tantrums for that cookie as, more likely than not, someone will "learn ya" to stop doing so. I don't know that there is really much to distinguish between "learned" and "taught" as a functional matter. Anyway. Good discussion. I don't have a clue as to why we so frequently find ourselves arguing about so many different things, when we have so much in common overall, lol.
CosmicConservative
"Debating" Drax. "Debating." It's good for the soul, when done respectfully on both sides. And hey... if it helps... .... I know how you feel. ;)