Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama: Iran has right to nuclear power

By CosmicConservative
LONDON -- President Barack Obama suggested that Iran may have some right to nuclear energy _ provided it proves by the end of the year that its aspirations are peaceful. In a BBC interview broadcast Tuesday, he also restated plans to pursue direct diplomacy with Tehran to encourage it set aside any ambitions for nuclear weapons it might harbor. Iran has insisted its nuclear program is aimed at generating electricity. But the U.S. and other Western governments accuse Tehran of seeking atomic weapons.
I believe I have said before on this blog that I don't understand where the USA or the UN gets the "right" to tell other countries whether they can or cannot have nuclear power, or even nuclear weapons. Sure the USA and the UN might have the POWER to control whether a country pursues either or both, but I don't see any "right" for either the UN or the USA to dictate what other countries do to pursue nuclear energy or nuclear weapons. Or space technology. Or whatever.

Comments (4)

Drax
Individuals and countries have no "rights." They either are allowed to do what they wish or others attempt to prevent them, by force and the threat of force, from doing what they wish. The U.S. has the "right" to attempt to force our will upon other countries simply because no one is able to force us not to. In this case, nuclear proliferation, most of the civilized nations have banded together and decided to attempt to force their will on non-nuclear countries in an effort to prevent the destruction of the human race through nuclear war. But, unless those countries are willing to FORCE their will upon nations not willing to agree to this decision, that decision has no effect and Iran is able to do what it wishes.
CosmicConservative
Drax. Hmm..... That's a lot more cynical than even I aspire to be, and I'm a pretty cynical dude. I do believe in human rights. National "rights" is another matter. I suppose we could have a stirring philosophical discussion about "rights" and "power" and whether "might makes right" or if there is some actual value in the concept of human "rights" as actual, existential things.
Drax
We can discuss human "rights" all day and night. I'll come to the same conclusion, the only one which is supported by history, i.e., that there ain't no such thing. Individuals are either allowed to do as they desire or others attempt to prevent them from doing so through force and threats of force. We can start at the top of the Bill of Rights and work our way down, if you choose.
» Obama: Iran has right to nuclear power CosmicConservative … | Iran Today
[...] the original post: » Obama: Iran has right to nuclear power CosmicConservative … Tags: announcement, compliance-with, either-or-both, have-the-power, obama, Technology [...]