Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is the NBA rigged?

By CosmicConservative
There is a lot of buzz going on right now about the disgraced NBA referee, Tim Donaghy, who was convicted of consorting with gamblers, gambling on games he officiated and supposedly changing the outcome of some NBA games with bad calls and non-calls. Remember he was convicted of these things, so it's not really a question of "did he do it?" anymore. Well, now that he's in the sentencing phase of his trial, he is telling everyone who will listen that his situation is just the tip of the iceberg. According to him, the NBA routinely pressured referees to influence games. As one specific example he claimed that the NBA referee team in the 2002 NBA conference finals specifically gave game six to the Lakers (who were down 3 - 2 at the time to the Sacramento Kings) to force a game seven, presumably to increase revenue to the NBA. The Lakers did win that game and went on to win it all that year. This would likely be seen as a desperate attempt by Donaghy to avoid prison time except for some troubling facts. Among those are the statements by the Kings team and coach that the officiating was the "worst they've ever seen" and the fact that the disparity of fouls called on the two teams in the decisive fourth quarter was something like 3 - 1 in favor of the Lakers. Exhibit A in that game was a foul called on the Kings when Kobe Bryant (of the Lakers) threw a flagrant elbow into the face of a Kings player. Shaquille O'Neil (then a Laker) also seemed to be the beneficiary of several calls and the Kings "big men" in the game were either in serious foul trouble (which greatly reduces the aggressiveness a player can play with) or had actually fouled out by then. There are many other examples of such disparities in the officiating that people point to, but that particular game is now under a microscope, as you can see in the story below where the FBI seems to be taking this very seriously.
ESPN - Report: Ex-ref Hollins says he was interviewed by feds - NBA The FBI has questioned an ex-NBA referee about Dick Bavetta, one of three officials to work Game 6 of the 2002 Western Conference finals, according to The New York Times. Hue Hollins, who retired in 2003, said the agents, who asked him about former NBA referee Tim Donaghy, also asked if he ever noticed that Bavetta "was making sure that the home team would win, and I told them I had no idea because I didn't work with him a lot," according to the Times.
There are, of course, two major reasons that we all hope this is not true. One is that we just like to think of our games as fair, not rigged. The second, more sinister, reason is that if it IS true, then the most likely motivation for this is money, and as much money that might come in from extending a six game series to seven games, everyone knows that the REAL money in pro sports comes from betting on the games. That raises the specter of the NBA being in bed with organized crime syndicates. That would be really, really bad. Now I have always believed that Major League Baseball referees and umpires have made unbelievably bad calls against the Rockies as a matter of course. But I have always believed that to be because pretty much all of MLB hated playing ball in the thin air at Denver and that they either consciously or unconsciously handicapped the Rockies because of the perception that Rockies offensive statistics were inflated from playing at Coors Field. I never really thought there might be something more sinister going on. And I sure hope there isn't.

Comments (11)

Andy
Cosmic: I have resigned myself to the idea that NBA Basketball is kinda like Pro Wrestling these days. More "show than go"...behemoth rappers jamming each other up, playing to the crowd, not to the purity of the game. And that's okay. It is what it is. The days of Jerry West, Hondo, Bill Russell, and The Pistol were a lot of fun to watch. But those days are gone. They are a bunch of thugs, driven by a love of the buck, not of the game. Now, I know that there are a few guys in the NBA that love the game. But I really do think that the NBA is more like "Championship Wrestling" than the NBA that I once enjoyed. Bird, Jordan, Johnson, McHale, Alcindor (sorry, Kareem), etc. I wouldn't be at all surprised if this ref really does have the skinny on things in the NBA. By the way...did you see this video? This might be a good idea for The Rockies to try...might dissuade some of the baseball bigotry by the umps...kinda like the Nolan Ryan approach to batters... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PH_2itdz-1E&feature=related
Drax
CC: Where's there's big money, there's corruption. Always. Andy: I used to moan and groan about "players who are in it for the money" transferring to another team for a bigger contract, holding out, etc. But, the bottom line is this: the players are commodities to the owners. I can hardly bame a player for treating basketball (or any other sport) as a business when he's essentially considered nothing other than "inventory."
Andy
Drax: I really don't blame the players either. I didn't mean to "moan and groan." If it sounded that way...well, it probably was deserved. ;) I just miss the "good old days" of the NBA when I really cared to watch the game. Even some of my favorites (Jordan topping the bunch) parlayed their love of the game into fabulous fortunes. Good for them! I just can't watch the game any more. Maybe I'm just too short, too slow, and too white.
CosmicConservative
I think that pitch you linked to bounced off the batter's helmet before hitting the umpire, so I don't see how it was supposedly planned by the pitcher and catcher...
Andy
Yea, yea, yea...what was the catcher doing by getting out of the way of a high fastball by bailing out like he did?
Andy
Cosmic: I was second guessing myself, so I went back and looked at it again. The batter's helmet didn't even try to move. The batter looked back, but his helmet stayed perfectly in place. Then he held his hand up toward third as if to signal "stay" to somebody. Any batter that gets hit with a pitch (even on the flap of his uniform) is going to sling the bat and start walking to first. I just don't see what you did. And I still think it might be a good strategy for The Rockies...
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... well, it sure looks like it took a sharp turn when it hit the batter's helmet to me. I've seen batters hit with a pitch react that way before. They can't take first until the ump tells them to anyway. Maybe it's an optical delusion though...
Drax
Andy: I stopped watching basketball (except for the playoffs and I've NEVER enjoyed watching amateur sports...they're too..amateurish...) long, long ago. I began my distaste when they began changing the rules to reign in Jabbar. (They did the same thing in college. He was insanely dominant.) This distaste grew with Jordan and the "Jordan rules." Unlike Jabbar and Russell where the game was changed to prevent their dominance, the NBA made it so that he was MORE dominant. Travelling? Palming? Pushing off? All meaningless "rules" now. Baseball lost its luster with batting armor, a strike zone which doesn't even remotely resemble that which is in the rules, and a love of the "long ball" where ballparks are designed to make it EASIER to score runs rather than harder. Football...still like football. But, when it comes to players playing "for the love of the game," we tend to disagree. Do you actually think that the star players in any sport need money? (Well, unless they gambled it away...) They play because they love the game. Favre? Manning? Bryant? Pujos? Rodriguez? Any star has millions stacked upon millions, so it ain't about the money. (In fact, they will sit out entire seasons sometimes due to a dispute over whether they're getting a 7 million a year contract or an 8 million a year contract. They say that it's about the "respect." Well, it sure ain't about the money....) So, I believe that most of the players play for the "love of the game."
CosmicConservative
OK, so let me see if I am understanding this... Players today make obscene amounts of money "playing" these games, and are more than willing to sit out an entire season in order to rake in MORE obscene amounts of money, and this is supposed to indicate how they really are playing for the "love of the game?" I think your logic got picked off on second base on that one Drax... You may be selling, but I ain't buying.
Andy
Cosmic: That's what I'm talking about. When a rookie drafted player will skip his first training camp because he's still "holding out" in negotiations with the team over the a difference in a $50 million contract as opposed to a $58 million contract... I ain't buying either!
Drax
CC: So, let me get this right. A player gives up on a 8 million a year contract, willing to sit out a season (and lose the 8 million and a year of playing time) in order to get a 10 million a year contract, which he would have to play for 4 more years (really more with the "time value of money" taken into consideration) in order to make up the 8 million... And, you think that he's doing it for the money? I'm not saying that players play ONLY for the "love of the game," although, at some point, that's all that keeps a Brett Favre or a Dan Marino...even a Barry Bonds playing long after they have stacks of millions and nothing to prove. Nor, do I believe, that you think that most of the players are playing SOLELY for the "love of money." Contractual disputes arise for different reasons. Sometimes you have a highly paid player certain to be HOF (Terrell Owens perhaps...) who isn't as highly paid as other receivers. He believes that he isn't getting his due "respect." He believes that he, the best in the game, should be PAID like the "best in the game." That has nothing to do with the actual money...just his "status" among other players. Sometimes you have someone who has played for a couple of years who has a "break-out season," but still has a couple of years to go on his contract. He knows that his football life is short, so he is willing to sacrifice a season (maybe) in order to get some "bank." This is especially true in football (where almost all of the contract disputes arise). My favorite example is Jamal Anderson. Jamal carried the ball more than any running back in the history of football one season and had a great season. He was still under contract, but vastly "underpaid" in comparison to other "elite" running backs. So, he threatened to sit out. He got the new contract, most importantly, he got a HUGE "signing bonus," which he KEPT when his career was ended at the beginning of the following season. Had he NOT "re-negotiated" that contract, he would likely be working at the Burger King right now. It's a mix of many things. But, so long as a football player can be cut for any reason or no reason and have his "contract" UNILATERALLY TERMINATED without "cause," then I'm on the side of all football players who are able to get their "value" from the owners while they still HAVE "value." I think Jamal would rather still be playing, though. These guys have been playing the game since they were little kids. How could they NOT "love the game?" The game is one thing....business, however, is business.