Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN "Science Reporting" strikes again

By CosmicConservative
I love these sort of "anthropomorphic interest" (as opposed to "human interest") stories that news organizations churn out.
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The official group that names objects in the solar system is calling all distant dwarf planets "plutoids" after the planet that was demoted to dwarf status. The International Astronomical Union has created a new category for objects that circle the sun and are too small to be considered planets, but are big enough to have their own gravity. Plutoids must also be farther from the sun than Neptune. The astronomical union, which is meeting in Oslo, Norway, raised a cosmic fuss two years ago when it demoted Pluto. There are only two plutoids: Pluto and Eris.
Just a few of the things in this story that tickle my funny bone: "cosmic fuss" - Um... So far as I know the only "fuss" over Pluto's new status was in a very tiny area of the science community on our tiny little planet Earth. From the story you would think that this story was making headlines in the Andromeda galaxy, and most of the galaxies in the Virgo Supercluster.... "demoted to dwarf status" - Again, it was "re-classified" not "demoted." To "demote" something means to reduce its area of influence. So far as I know our reclassification of Pluto had no impact on its gravitational field or any other physical manifestation of its area of influence. It may surprise this "reporter" to learn that Pluto actually DOESN'T CARE if it is called a "planet" or a "plutoid." "There are only two plutoids: Pluto and Eris" - Um.. no. Most experts believe there are dozens to hundreds (perhaps thousands?) of "plutoids" around the sun. We have only DISCOVERED two SO FAR. "Plutoids must also be farther from the sun than Neptune" OK this isn't about the story but about the actual "science". When are these bozos going to learn not to define THINGS based on where they ARE? There is absolutely nothing INTRINSIC about Pluto's or other "plutoids" being inside or outside an arbitrary line, especially one that just happens to be drawn by an orbiting planet. These sorts of "definitions" are doomed to failure when we learn more about the universe. Suppose we build a strong enough telescope and discover a large number of Pluto like objects orbiting Alpha Centauri, but some are closer to Uranus' orbit than Neptune's? Now what? Do we call some "plutoids" and some "dwarf planets" based on an arbitrary line? What if some of them have eccentric orbits that cross that line twice each year? Are they "plutoids" for part of their orbit and "dwarf planets" for other parts? These are supposed to be INTELLIGENT PEOPLE making these decisions, and yet they continue to create the same potential for dissension and confusion that they are (supposedly) trying to resolve. Idiots. Next time, just ask me, I'll set you all straight.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.