Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Did Obama "win" it , or did Hillary "lose" it?

By CosmicConservative
Or was it a little of both? I tend to want to give people credit when they do something well, and I do think that Obama ran a very good campaign, so although I think Hillary did a lot to "lose" the nomination, I think Obama did more to "win" it. I'd say that Obama's "winning" it was 70% to Hillary's "losing" it at 30%. So what did Obama do to win it then? Here's my list: 1. Obama crafted a better, more compelling narrative. His "Hope and Change" message is not as easy to make successful as people think it is. Yes people are always yearning for such a message, but Obama and his team picked the right moments to present the right rhetoric to capitalize on a nation (and particularly a Democrat party) that was fed up not only with GW Bush, but with virtually all of Washington, including some of Hillary Clinton's own record. Obama is a gifted speaker and has some good speech writers. He built an early buzz and reinforced it with carefully calculated events and speeches, going all the way back to 2004, really. Sure Hillary's narrative was flawed, and that helped Obama a lot, but Obama's narrative could have been flawed too, and it wasn't. (Not for Democrats anyway, it remains to be seen if his narrative is as compelling in a general election.) 2. Obama planned for a long, bitter and divisive primary campaign. He created a powerful money-raising system for his campaign. He built both a national and a state-by-state infrastructure and had plans for each state and resources to execute those plans. Even if Hillary had bothered to campaign in many of the states that she ignored, she would have found it quite difficult to compete with Obama's forces in many of those states. The fact that Hillary ignored many states was quickly exploited by Obama's national and local resources, true, but even if she had been there, in many, probably most, cases, Obama's superior organization would still have won the trench battles, and would have bled Hillary's inferior money-raising dry. 3. Obama understood the primary and caucus system and created a strategy that was specifically targeted towards gaining as many delegates as possible. Obama gambled that the superdelegates would follow the delegates when the rubber hit the road, and he was proven right. He aggressively exploited Hillary's weaknesses in uncontested states to build large margins of victory while he battled Hillary to a near-tie in virtually all of the states that Hillary "won." The best example of this is probably Texas, where Hillary's primary victory was hailed as a major milestone for her campaign while in reality Obama actually walked away from Texas with six more delegates than Hillary did. Obama's team recognized how to play the game to win, and they scrapped for every delegate they could get. 4. Obama courted the press. Hillary simply assumed that the press would always be her lap-dogs. Obama made it a point to court key members in the media (including Oprah) and to get favorable media treatment. Once he had that favorable treatment, he exploited it skillfully. While Hillary's team annoyed the press with thousands of emails and press releases of dubious veracity, Obama's team targeted key members of the press with far more personal and engaging emails and press releases designed to win the hearts and minds of the press, not just the daily news cycle. The best evidence of this is the number of reporters and editors who have publicly complained about how the Clinton campaign had been "spamming" them with junk emails. You never heard such complaints about Obama's campaign. 5. They played the race card by claiming that their opponents were playing the race card at every opportunity. I personally find this sort of thing reprehensible, but there is no denying the effectiveness of Obama's claims that every attack on him was race-based. Any misstep from the Hillary camp that could be found was viciously exploited. Obama and his team recognized that it was not enough for Obama to simply claim the black vote by virtue of his own racial heritage, they had to explicitly separate Hillary from the black vote by convincing people that Hillary (and more precisely BILL) was actually racist. This caused the tide of black votes for Obama to become a flood and delivered him huge margins of victory (and therefore huge leads in delegates) in several key southern states. Look for him to do the same in the general election, I am sure John McCain will be surprised by how many claims of "racist" will be hurled his way by the time the general election is over. Those are the top five ways that Obama WON the nomination as opposed to Hillary LOSING it.

Comments (8)

Drax
I'm not so easily swayed by this argument as others might be. I tend to look at other factors when I know that Hillary's campaign was being run by seasoned professionals and, most importantly, she was in serious trouble almost from the very start. As to your first point: "Obama crafted a better, more compelling narrative." I didn't really see that. They were both all "Change" in the beginning, but Hillary said "Change but with experience." Obama's "change" message was about nothing but change with little substance, at least Hillary was able to tout her "experience" which, although nothing like she professed it to be, certainly far exceeds that of Obama on the national stage. Of course, I saw the MSM, from the first, swoon at Obama's message and begin to hammer Hillary (to the extent the MSM "hammers" any liberal) for her, essentially, the same message. As to your second point: "Obama planned for a long, bitter and divisive primary campaign" Well, when you're not given much of a chance to win, either you go in with the notion that you're just going to "send a message a la Jessee Jackson, or you prepare to take the fight to the end. Obama gets no points for preparing for a fight that he knew was coming. Hillary was almost entirely blindsided by Obama's incredible surge. More importantly, she was blindsided by the huge amounts of MONEY which Obama got -- money from the same pockets that SHE would normally get money. It took her a while to recover (and she never fully did.) As to your third point: "Obama understood the primary and caucus system and created a strategy that was specifically targeted towards gaining as many delegates as possible." I really don't understand this. Hillary can't compete with the charismatic Obama in the smaller caucus polls. No one can. People SWOONED over him. Literally. Hillary won the BIG STATES; Obama won the caucus states. The disparity created by Obama's PRESENCE is most clearly shown in Texas where Hillary won the VOTES but Obama won the CAUCUS. How is Hillary to be faulted that Obama is more personable than she? As to your fourth point: "Obama courted the press" I'm not sure what this means. Hillary had been "courting" the press for close to two decades and was their darling. Do we "court" what we already possess? Is it her fault that she was JILTED by the same press who just yesterday professed their undying love for her? From the outset of this primary season, the press treated Obama with the gloves of a lover and the more Hillary complained about it, the more gentle the caress Obama received. Is it Hillary's fault that Obama's gaffs aren't even reported upon in the MSM while hers are replayed daily? (Of course, from my perspective, I get a kick out of seeing a Clinton squirm from "bad" press after all they and their surrogates have done to others through their (former) lackeys in the MSM.) Hillary "courted" them as best she could, but how to "court" a lover who has left you for another? As to your last point: "They played the race card by claiming that their opponents were playing the race card at every opportunity" I tend to agree. I also think that Hillary played the "race card" and, had she continued to play it, she might have won -- especially as the Wright matter hit. But that was too little, too late. The MSM "won" this election for Obama. They failed to do ANY investigative reporting on Obama. They FAILED at every turn to look into the contacts, the beliefs, and the character of the person who might be our next President. Worse than merely failing to do this, they built him up, magnifying his intellect, his charm, his persuasive ability, ignoring entirely his many gaffs, his incredible lack of knowledge of elemental politics, his ignorance of geo-politics. They were captured entirely by the notion of electing a black President because it shows how enlightened THEY are, so Obama got a "pass" on just about every bit of baggage he carries and hasn't received anything like a "vetting" by the Press. And, if McCain were left to his own devices, he would not receive on in the General Election either. Fortunately, other hands can stir that particular pot.
CosmicConservative
On the narrative thing, Obama's narrative was superior in part because it was vague. If Hillary actually had the experience she claimed, perhaps her narrative would have had more weight, but her "vague" claims of experience were far easier to investigate than Obama's vague claims of providing hope and change. I think this was not purely coincidence, I think Obama calculated that vagueness and that such things work with Democrats who tend to be touchy-feely instead of gritty. That same narrative would not have worked for a Republican, imho. And as I said, I'm not convinced its going to work for Obama in the general election. Still, my point is that these narratives are PRECISELY the point of the campaign effort, and Obama succeeded in creating the right one, while Hillary failed. I give him points for that. On the second point about the tactical planning of the Obama team, sure you can say "of course he had to plan that way" but you could say the same thing about Hillary but she didn't do it. In retrospect its easy to say that Obama's tactical plan was obvious, but I don't think it was obvious twelve months ago. I think Obama's team (and I don't fully credit Obama with this, I think he has better handlers too) did not just recognize a NEED to draft a battle plan of attrition, they SUCCESSFULLY crafted and IMPLEMENTED one. Every sports team in every professional league on earth KNOWS what they have to do going in, I still give those who ACCOMPLISH it the credit at the end of the season. Third, the whole "charisma" thing. Sure you can say "well, Obama just plays well in caucus situations" but they couldn't count on that, they had to plan for it, prepare him and then he had to actually PULL IT OFF. Charisma or no, he had to actually make it work, and he did. Just as I give an actor credit when their natural ability is successfully utilized to perform their craft, I'll do the same for a politician. Charisma is part of their game, he gets points for pulling it off. When I say Obama's team "courted the press" I mean they put a communication plan together that specifically was targeted to win the press to their side. You seem to be saying that it all "just happened" and that a large part of it is because "he is black." Well, that never worked for Al Sharpton or Jesse Jackson, so there must be SOMETHING else at work. And that something is a calculated effort at manipulating the media, not just reporters, but people like Oprah and influential bloggers like Arianna Huffington and the Daily KOS. That didn't happen by accident, it was planned and executed. Yes, Obama was given some unfair advantages, but so was Hillary. Hillary was so puffed up before January that even the press referred to her as "Her Inevitableness". Up until January I don't think that I saw a huge disparity in how the press treated Hillary compared to how they treated Obama. In fact I posted several examples of the press fawning all over Hillary (and Bill) several times in 2007. Yes, I agree that since January the tide turned heavily in Obama's favor, but that isn't entirely due to their "swooning" over Obama, a lot of it was the natural desire to report an "underdog wins" story, which is natural and helped George W. Bush in 2000. In my opinion the press coverage really turned against Hillary after Obama clobbered her in Iowa. At that time the "whimsical" campaign of Obama turned into a "man bites dog" story and the press loves that kind of story. Yes there are members of the press that are smitten with Obama, but there are still plenty smitten with Bill and Hillary too. I do agree that McCain is going to have to rely on other people to get down and dirty for him. And I think that's a mistake. But hopefully someone else CAN put the proper scrutiny on Obama before November. But even if they do, the nation is so fed up with Republicans right now that I think the Democrats could nominate Donald Duck and win.
Drax
We disagee on a few things, here, as is usually the case, heh. As to the "message." As between the two of them, there isn't a thin dime's worth of difference in SUBSTANCE. When they are fighting against each other, if they are attempting to get a "message" out that distinguishes one from the other, it can't be on substance, can it? So, it HAS to be "vague." There really ain't much else. (I'm reminded of all the agreement in their second(?) debate, just a bunch of agreement essentially on all issues of substance.) So, how can Hillary be faulted for "trumping" Obama's "change" message with "change plus experience" message? As to Obama "courting the media." Obama has been COURTED by the media since he was in LAW SCHOOL. When he "burst" on the national scene with his address at the 2000 Democratic convention (I think that was the year) the press SLAVERED over him. When he entered the race against Hillary, he didn't "court the press" any more than ANY politican does who isn't already firmly in office, but, more importantly, he didn't HAVE to. They had been swooning over him for at least a decade and some for two. And, you really can't compare the racially divisive Sharpton or Jackson who can't go a week without saying something which is offensive to someone to Obama who presented himself as the polar OPPOSITE of these "black leaders." He presented himself as one who would bring the people (races) together rather than having a decades long history of doing the opposite. It's simply inapposite. And, I disagree with you on McCain. I not only think he CAN win, I think he WILL win unless he does something extraordinarily stupid. Obama has very high negatives already and the general election has just begun. Most people aren't even paying attention to him, but they certainly will pay attention to ads of "Reverend" Wright's hatred, his wife's obvious racism, his connections to convicted felons (who knows what Resco(?) will say to stay out of jail), terrorists, and his own remarks in San Francisco. Most whites WANT a black leader who isn't a racist, who can help "bring us together." But, we don't want another white blaming, white hating, typical "black leader" and that's what Obama is for all his rhetoric to the contrary. (On a side note, while watching him speak, I've been bugged horribly until I figured out why. Watch how he holds himself, how he gestures. Does he remind you of anyone...say from WWII...say from Italy ... or Germany? His stance is studied, unnatural as is his cadence. Methinks he's been studying....)
CosmicConservative
How can Hillary be faulted for pursuing the wrong message? Because it failed, that's why. It doesn't matter if members of the press were infatuated with Obama or not. They CLEARLY were infatuated with Hillary when this all started. Obama's campaign set out to court the press and they succeeded. Whether the deck was stacked in their favor due to Obama's supposed "charisma" or not, they still had to deal and play the cards. And they played them well. When someone says Obama gained something or other because he was a black candidate for President, it is completely fair to contrast that with other black candidates for President. Your saying "well, it's DIFFERENT with Obama because he doesn't ACT like Sharpton or Jackson" is PRECISELY MY POINT! That was a KEY part of the narrative that his team built. Clearly at least THAT part of it worked, I think most of it worked. I would like to hope that you are right that McCain has a shot, and even is likely to win, but I'm afraid that I don't remotely agree with you. I think McCain will have to run a virtually flawless campaign and Obama will have to self-destruct. In my opinion Obama is at least as clear a front-runner for President now as Hillary was the front-runner for Democrat nominee a year ago. Sure McCain CAN win, but it would take something akin to a political miracle for him to do so in the current political landscape. Sure miracles happen, the race may not go to the swiftest, nor the match to the strongest, but that's usually the way to bet.
Andy
CC: You wrote: "In my opinion Obama is at least as clear a front-runner for President now as Hillary was the front-runner for Democrat nominee a year ago." I guess we see now how well that worked out for Hillary. :) I don't know. Maybe I am too optimistic for my own good, but I just do not believe that when the people that really go out and vote...not go to the rallies...not clickety-clack on the computer all day...not the young guys that get dragged to "experience" Obamamania by the girls they are honed in on currently...the REAL VOTERS...will actually put the leadership of the US in the hands of Obama. Like I say, maybe I am too optimistic. I remember my Father telling me what he went through when JFK was killed. Though not a very emotional man, Dad had a tear in his eye. It was really very touching. At the end of it all, he told me that he had voted for Nixon instead of JFK. Nixon was the first Republican my Dad ever voted for. Kennedy looked "too young" for my Dad to vote for, for President of the US. There is a huge difference for sure in JFK & Obama. Kennedy actually had some substance...WWII vet, tough-talker to our enemies, tax cutter...challenged Americans to pull their best from themselves (not look to the government for solutions to their problems)...he really was the "Reagan" of his generation. But Dad didn't vote for him because he seemed "too young." BarackO' may be our next President. McCain may shoot himself in the head with a terrible campaign. But I believe that McCain can shoot himself in the foot and still limp across the line ahead of this guy Obama. When I look at Obama, I think about those $1 paperback "romance novels" I see while checking out at the the grocery store. The picture on the front is alluring. But heh, they're selling it for a dollar... Maybe I'm in the minority of US voters. Though I don't care much for McCain, I have one son in the US Air Force, and one entering the US Navy in September. The idea of one of my sons having to salute BarackO' as their "Commander in Chief" makes me almost blow chunks. Maybe I am just "wishfully thinking." But I really hope that I still live in an America that has at least the tiniest bit of discernment. I guess we'll see...
Drax
If McCain is successful in the debates (however many and whatever form they take) in drawing a clear distinction between his position and Obama's, and his (supported or unsupported) "surrogates" bring to the fore all of Obama's baggage, I don't see how McCain can LOSE. Unless, like the blonde "conservative bimbo" too many "conservatives" would rather have a pro-abortion, pro cut-and-run, pro nationalized medicine, (even more)pro big government, most liberal President in the history of this nation rather than a lukewarm conservative. I never had much respect for Coulter, but her vow to vote for HILLARY instead of McCain drained me of every last shred of respect I did have.
CosmicConservative
Andy: Here's how I look at these things. Political campaigns are all about narrative and momentum, there is very little of substance about them. It's a myth that substance has EVER been the major part of American presidential campaigns. From the beginning they've been about narratives and momentum. Right now the Republican party is deflated, dejected and depressed. McCain may be a decorated war hero with a reputation as a "Maverick" but one thing he most assuredly does NOT do is energize his party. Obama, on the other hand, has energized the Democrat party in a big way. Yes right now there are a lot of disappointed Hillary supporters but I figure it's going to take no more than about three weeks for them to become energized Obama supporters. Those folks in the middle have the choice between a charismatic young black man and an old, temperamental white guy. That's all most of them will see and all most of them will vote on. It is my personal opinion that McCain is not merely heading for a loss, he's heading for the wrong end of a landslide. And I blame Bush. I really do. For years I have complained about Bush ignoring the future of his party and the future of his ideology. He squandered all of his political capital on losing causes like Social Security reform and what he did accomplish were mostly the sorts of things you'd expect from a Walter Mondale, not a Reagan conservative. Yes I have supported him on the war and on some key areas where he and I happen to agree, but in general I think GW Bush has been a severe disappointment, and one major reason is because he has dragged the Republican party down into the hole he has dug for himself. All Obama has to do is tag McCain with the "McBush" label, and he will win this election in a walk. And he's just about accomplished that already. The only real chance McCain has is to expose Obama as a racist, America hating super liberal. But I frankly just don't think he has the walnuts to do that. He wants to stay "above the fray." Perhaps other surrogates can do it, but Hillary tried and failed. So as much as I'd like to claim that this is going to be a competitive campaign, my personal opinion is, as I said, McCain will have to run a virtually flawless campaign (and I don't think he's up to it) AND Obama will have to commit multiple major gaffes for McCain to be competitive. That's just how I see it. But then again, I predicted an Al Gore victory eight years ago...
Andy
Cosmic: You could be right (sigh). Your rationale for your opinion is hard to disagree with. I agree that President Bush has had a great deal to do with the demise of the Republican Party. My own Congressman, Jim McCrery was the Chairman of the House subcommittee on Social Security when Bush came in to office. Jim looked me in the eye and told me "We're going to get Social Security reform done now. We're going to fix this mess. We finally have a President ready to tackle it." After one political "blip," Bush gave up. Jim finally did, too. Jim is not running for re-election this term. He's worn out from "crying in the wilderness." We may get a President Hussein. If we do, I guess it falls on us as a nation really. We get what we want, and we get what we deserve. It could well be that McCain gets "what the fly left on the pump handle" in November. It could be a landslide victory for Obama. My ever-expanding "gut" tells me that it is going to be a "landslide" (for one or the other).