The Iron Lady turns to Tin
By CosmicConservativeHillary has announced that she will concede the nomination to Obama on Saturday, ending three days of consternation among Democrats and political pundits who have been nonplussed by Hillary's unwillingness to concede on Tuesday when it was finally undeniable that Obama had amassed the necessary number of delegates to claim the nomination regardless of back room machinations and appeals to an increasingly misplaced sense of loyalty that Hillary (and Bill) felt was owed to them for favors granted during the Bill Clinton term.
Now we are finally seeing the post-mortems on Hillary's campaign. It is always fun to look at such post-mortems and compare them to my own sense of what was going on at the time.
Among the most frequently cited reasons for Hillary's fall from "inevitable" to "concession" are the following:
1. Hillary's sense of entitlement was so overwhelming that her campaign had not even planned for campaigning beyond February 5, the date of the Super Tuesday primaries. This is rather hard for me to believe, but I have seen this reported from so many sources that it appears to pass the smell test. I can't help but think that this single fact alone proves that Hillary had no business running for President and she would likely have been a miserable President if she surrounded herself with such incompetent people that they didn't even plan out the very campaign that Hillary was raising hundreds of millions of dollars to run. This is a rank issue of simple professionalism. How could she have had hundreds of people on her payroll and NONE of them said "Well, sure we're going to win, but let's plan for the FULL campaign anyway JUST IN CASE we don't have it sewed up on Super Tuesday." The fact that neither she, nor her campaign leadership, nor her rank and file campaign workers took this step demonstrates to me that Hillary simply does not know how to manage a large and complex operation.
2. Hillary's top leadership was totally wedded to the "Ready on Day One" message and even to the very end of her campaign they stuck to this message in spite of growing evidence that the message was actually BACKFIRING on Hillary. When Obama's message of "Hope" and "Change" was resonating with an electorate that was tired of "business as usual" Hillary's team continued to run as a Washington insider. Every time Hillary rolled out her spurious claim of 35 years of experience she thought she was saying "I'm ready" but what the Democrat party rank and file was hearing was "I'm part of the problem in Washington." The more she hammered on this point, the more the rank and file migrated to Obama.
3. Hillary badly misread the public mood about politics in Washington. This may be due to her being so tied into the day-to-day political culture in the Washington-New York corridor. But I think it is more due to her decades long obsession with Republicans being the "Vast Right Wing Conspiracy." She repeatedly stood in front of microphones on national TV and in interviews and bragged incessantly about how she was the "battle-hardened" veteran who could "take the fight to the Republicans." I'm a fairly partisan political person myself, but even I don't like to hear every political issue reduced to "we're the good guys, and they're the bad guys". While Hillary continually and shrilly bragged about the upcoming titanic battles she was looking forward to with those evil Republicans, Obama kept hammering a message of cooperation and a "new tone" in Washington. It may be hard to believe, but that was in large part the message that GW Bush used in 2000 to beat Al Gore. Hillary and her team obviously thought that all of America was absolutely salivating for more of the partisan warfare that had been "politics as usual" since the Clintons took Arkansas style politics and made it national politics. Most normal people don't like to see their political leaders demagogue every issue and hurl vicious accusations at one another. The politics of personal destruction may be effective, but it doesn't resonate on the campaign trail where most people would rather convince themselves that both parties can actually get along enough to effectively govern the country. Obama's message tapped into this deep desire for cooperation and reconciliation, while Hillary came to symbolize politics as an endless series of death match contests.
4. Hillary counted far too much on political loyalty that her husband believed he had earned being transferred to her without question. This was true overall in a general sense, but was very specifically true with the "power elite" in the Democrat Party. This was overwhelmingly obvious in the way that Hillary assumed that the party superdelegates would flock to her banner even in the face of Obama's growing lead in actual committed delegates. As much as Hillary and Bill publicly claimed that they were expecting superdelegates to support her because she was supposedly "more electable" behind the scenes this was purely about personal loyalty that they felt was owed to them by the superdelegates. Even with the devastating losses on Super Tuesday Hillary fully expected the superdelegates to stick with her and overcome any supposed lead that Obama may have gained in pledged delegates. This became more and more obvious as stories of Bill and Hillary calling superdelegates who had endorsed Obama and yelling at them and accusing them of betrayal became weekly events. The more pressure the Clintons put on the superdelegates to put loyalty to the Clintons above the will of the voters, the more the superdelegates came to view both Clintons as people undeserving of the very loyalty they demanded.
Obama not only ran a very good campaign in general, he quite clearly understood the issues above and used them to his advantage. His public statements and private actions were clearly designed to capitalize on each of the mistakes Hillary was making. Obama's campaign will one day be studied in political science classes as a model of David vs. Goliath campaign management. Obama's team outmaneuvered Hillary's team time after time.
I don't know what sort of President Obama will be (and I do believe he is by far the favorite at this time to become President) but he has proven to be a much more effective campaigner than Hillary turned out to be. Whether that bodes well for his administration or not remains to be seen. I personally think Obama will be a disaster as President, his ideology and track record is far more liberal than any President we've had since Jimmy Carter. I am fairly certain that if he governs according to the principles he has laid out in his campaign, we are looking at at least four years of misery index, stagflation and malaise. I hope I am wrong, but that's how I see it. But in spite of that I have to acknowledge that he has run a masterful campaign so far. If he rolls McCain like he rolled Hillary, it's going to be an ugly November for Republicans.
Comments (2)