Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Miley Cyrus in Vanity Fair

By CosmicConservative
OK so explain to me how a "famous photographer" like Annie Leibovitz can get away with taking half-clothed pictures of a fifteen year old girl, but if a high school volleyball coach does the same thing he or she finds themselves fingerprinted and mugshot and on a sex offenders list?
Exclusive: Miley Cyrus On Semi-Topless Pic: 'I Feel So Embarrassed'! Pop star and 15-year-old Disney sensation MILEY CYRUS tells ET she's "embarrassed" about an upcoming photograph of her appearing semi-topless in the new Vanity Fair magazine issue. "I took part in a photo shoot that was supposed to be 'artistic' and now, seeing the photographs and reading the story, I feel so embarrassed," she tells ET. "I never intended for any of this to happen and I apologize to my fans who I care so deeply about."
Oh, I guess they don't call it "art."

Comments (12)

Ed Minchau
If it is as bad as Cyrus implies, then by all means the photographer and the publishers of Vanity Fair should indeed find themselves fingerprinted and mugshots taken etc.
pace
She's 15. Why the heck weren't her parents supervising this photoshoot ? I guess with fame and fortune comes an abdication of parenting responsibilities.
Andy
Pace: The article I read about this said that Billy Ray was there at the photo session. And that everyone involved looked the photo in question over and thought that it was quite beautiful and appropriate. Unless that wasn't true, it seems to me that this might be either a "seller's remorse" attempt to head off possible bad PR. Or, a "seller's ploy" to stir up free advertising for Miley. I really hope that it is the former. I don't have teenage girls, and my sons are not in that age group that goes ape crazy over them. So I really don't understand the cultural phenomenon of Miley...but I have heard that you can't get a ticket to her concerts (there was one in my city a few months ago that sold out in about an hour), and she is making more money than Exxon. So I am assuming that Miley and her family are truly having second thoughts. I sure hope so.
CosmicConservative
Dadman knows that I have no problem putting myself virtually into a situation and making assumptions about what happened based on what I know and assume about the people involved. I think I get pretty close to reality when I do that, and this will be an example of that. Here's what I think happened: Miley is a huge star, and she's very pretty to boot. Of course these are not unrelated things, she is in part a huge star because she is very pretty. Plus she is the very picture of budding womanhood. Much like Brooke Shields was in the 1980s when she too was involved in a remarkably similar controversy. In fact I wonder if it was Annie Leibovitz who was involved in the Brooke Shields situation too? I can't recall. Whether she was or not, if I remember it, I know that Annie is well aware of it. I also know that Annie Leibovitz is a professional photographer who is trained and experienced in the impact that her photos will have. There is no doubt in my mind that Annie knew quite well that she was posing Miley in ways that would trigger a response from the general public that the photos were inappropriate. But I am also convinced that she has an ego large enough to think that such a reaction would simply distribute her photo more quickly and widely across the media outlets, and as such more people would see her photos. And since she is convinced that her photos are artistic whether they are provocative or not, she's only really interested in whether the photos will enhance her image as an artist and increase her potential client base. In fact I am convinced that her intention was to make them provocative, but in her mind that's OK because "it's art." We had this discussion a few days ago with the girl who did multiple inseminations and took abortificants as "art." This is rather tame compared to that. Then you have Billy Ray Cyrus who is in a really awkward position. I can't imagine the pressure on the guy to "let his little girl grow up" and to "see how beautiful she is" and to "keep the franchise growing" and whatever else. Yes it would be nice if Billy Ray could have completely kept his perspective in this, but it is quite easy for me to see him being convinced that the photo or photos in question are "tastefully intimate portraits" not "pornography" and in that moment, under those pressures, he lost the perspective of the average person seeing the photo published without context on salacious websites all over the internet, sites which have been clamoring for racy photos of Miley for months. Then there's Vanity Fair, a print magazine who is no doubt feeling the industry wide pressure of lost advertising, lost readership and lost influence, seeing an opportunity to "be relevant again." I am pretty sure that what happened is that Annie kept moving the boundaries for Miley back a little at a time, building an intimate relationship between Miley and Billy Ray, telling them how "this is art" and how many famous people she's photographed before. All the time Annie is thinking about how much free advertising she is going to get, how much attention her photo is going to get and how she is again "pushing the boundaries" of art. That's a big thing for artists like Annie. If she's not "pushing a boundary" or two, then all her art friends are going to tell her that she's lost relevancy. Over all of this is the crushing pressure of Vanity Fair to "get a story" and to "sell magazines." The end result is a photographer and a magazine representative going all Gollum on Billy Ray and Miley convincing them that the photos are "art" and are "beautiful representations of budding womanhood that will be treasured forever" or whatever nonsense they felt they had to say to get the Cyruses (Cyrii?) to lower their guard, all the while knowing that as soon as the photos hit the net, all hell would break loose, Miley would be slimed, Billy Ray would be cast as a bad parent, but Annie's "street cred" as a photographer would increase and Vanity Fair would be all 'relevant" again. That's how I think it went down.
Frank
I hope Cosmic is right, but I really believe Miley and/or Billy Rae knew what they were in to from this and are just backtracking now. <> I think this was the ultimate reason for the photo shoots. As it stands now for all the money she might make her fan base is limited to basically young, say 6-12 year old, girls (and the poor parents that have to come along). Whether or not it was to aimed mainly for the Maxim crowd to say "look I'm hot and not the good girl you think I am" or to the NYT crowd to say "look I'm a serious performer" I'm not sure. Probably a little of both I'm guessing.
Andy
Cosmic: I couldn't have said it better myself! Actually, I couldn't have said it at all...sigh. I really do think you have a good grasp of this deal. Even though I don't understand all the words you used, they are very convincing. I believe that the Cyrii have decided to get out in front of this thing because of true regret. As you outlined, it is easy to get sucked in and convinced of things "on the showroom floor." You end up buying something you didn't really want, and can't afford.
CosmicConservative
Heh... I sorta liked my "going all gollum on them" comment. They got gollumed. It sort of rolls off the tongue, or out of the throat anyway...
CosmicConservative
Here's a tidbit on the story:
For the record, only Cyrus' back and shoulders are bare in the most controversial shot by Annie Leibovitz, the renowned celebrity photographer. Many an Oscar-night gown would show as much skin. Cyrus herself told the magazine in an accompanying article that she found the photo, in which she gathers a sheet around her, "really artsy. It wasn't in a skanky way. And you can't say no to Annie."
Note that last comment "really artsy. And you can't say no to Annie." I think I nailed the situation, and this comment from Miley just proves it. I have no doubt who stressed how "artsy" the pose was.
mtnlurker
Isn't it interesting that the compromising cell phone photos came out just before the Vanity Fair issue. Makes me wonder.
CosmicConservative
Well, as far as I know the "cell phone photos" have never been proven to be of Miley. I saw them and they aren't that racy, if I saw the same ones everyone else is talking about. And it would have been very easy to Photoshop them.
Drax
I think she's a young girl who was flattered into making photographs which were ill-advised and "too old" for a 15 year old to make. Photographers, good ones, know how to get their subjects to pose in ways that they would never think of before going to the photo shoot.
CosmicConservative
Drax: That's more or less what I said, I just gave Annie Leibovitz and Vanity Fair some nefarious motivations to do it, and also suggested that they worked over Billy Ray a bit too.