Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Game Review: D&D 4e

By CosmicConservative
Well, I promised a review of the latest release of Dungeons and Dragons from Wizards of the Coast. Today I played in a four hour session that took us through three encounters with various NPCs. It's different. Very different. I knew from the hints and excerpts that had been released on the message boards that it was going to be different, and I had mentally prepared myself for it to be more or less an entirely new experience. My main goal in going to the "demo" game in the first place was to get some idea if I was going to enjoy it enough to keep moving forward with the game, or stick with the version I already knew and enjoyed. The game was started after six players gathered around the table and the Wizards-sanctioned GM (Game Master) sat at the table, complete with a "D&D 4E" hat on. After a short round of introductions, we listened while the GM gave us (and the crowd of about a dozen interested non-players who were watching the game) a description of some of the major differences between the existing game, and the new version. This took a fair amount of time because of the questions that were asked, many coming from the people standing around the table. The players, including me, were itching to get into the game. Next the GM handed out a sheet of 4e highlights which described in a short paragraph or two the basic game mechanics. I don't think I'm supposed to republish them here, so I'll just say that the attempts to simplify the game were apparent in many areas. This has been an ongoing trend with the game, every release attempts to simplify the basic mechanics more than the previous release, with varying degrees of success. Reading through the description it seemed that some of it would be quite clearly an improvement, while other aspects seemed to oversimplify things too much and another set were just strange and would need to be played to figure them out. Basically the game is still turn-based and each player's turn is broken down into three actions, each of which can only be taken once (with some caveats). Those are as follows: 1. Standard Action: This is basically the same as older versions of the game. This is where a player character does the basic activity of their turn, such as opening a chest, casting a spell, firing a weapon, or taking a swing at an opponent. This is the "highest level" of the three actions. 2. Move Action: This is also basically the same as the older versions of the game. As it sounds this action is basically an action where a character is repositioned according to the limitations they have in their ability to move. Movement is now square based but this is an area they have simplified to the extreme. On a square grid you can now move in any direction as many squares as your character can move in one move action, regardless of whether you are moving vertically, horizontally or diagonally. In the old rules diagonal moves cost more than vertical or horizontal moves, but apparently the math and geometry-challenged players or game designers felt that this was too complicated for today's game players to manage. My personal opinion is that if they wanted to make it this simple, they should have gone with a hexagonal grid instead of a square one. That way the movement is more or less realistic, where with the square based grids moving diagonally you move roughly 1.4 times as far as moving horizontally or diagonally. This sacrifice of common sense to the pursuit of simplicity just bugs me on so many levels that I can't even go into it. 3. Minor Action: In the old rules there were a variety of "minor actions" ranging from a free action to a swift action. Each had its own rules. I actually like this modification, because in the old rules it was sometimes difficult to determine what combinations of major and minor move actions could be legitimately attempted in one turn. Also a "standard action" can be replaced by either of the two "lower" actions, and a "move action" can be replaced by a "minor action." Which means that a character could do three minor actions if they preferred, and that would fill their turn, or two move actions and a minor action. Next the GM handed out a set of pre-created characters, and we worked out which character we would play. I ended up playing a "Ranger" which is intended to be a sort of outdoorsy combat specialist who favors ranged weapons over melee ones. The sheet was one page, front and back, and listed all of the possible actions the Ranger could take. It also listed the Ranger's attributes, most of which were either the same as, or comparable to older versions. For example, each character is still based around the venerable attribute scores of Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom and Charisma. A new twist on the character sheets was the breakdown of the character's abilities. Some abilities were "at will" meaning they could be used at any time by the character. Others were "per encounter" meaning they were limited to a finite number of uses during an encounter (all were "1 per encounter" uses). And each character had at least one "per day" ability, again, all of the characters were limited in their daily abilities to a "once per day" use. Basically an "encounter" is any set of activities that happens between "short rests" of at least five game minutes, and a "day" is any set of activities that happen between "long rests" of at least six hours. Short rests reset "per encounter" abilities and long rests reset "per day" abilities. Simple enough, but this was definitely new. With that we began to play the game. The GM explained that our group of adventurers was more or less on the outs with the local authorities, and had been hired to deliver a sealed scroll to a local merchant in the town. We were all cooling our heels in the local tavern waiting for the merchant to signal that it was safe for us to approach him, when he would give us the remaining half of our fee for delivering the scroll, and we could then be on our way. Of course that's not what happened. The merchant was suddenly approached by a group of men dressed as village guards and a man in robes carrying a staff. The GM announced that this group of men was demanding that the merchant (who had our fee still) surrender to them, then announced that we needed to "roll for initiative" which is the time-honored signal for the beginning of an "encounter." Our wizard won the initiative and his first action was to attempt to put the oncoming party of "guards" to sleep with his "once per day" ability. He was partially successful as four of the six dropped to the ground. The rest of our group, figuring that the guards would not appreciate having been the target of a spell, decided our best course of action was to hit them first and hard before they could attack us. D&D is described as a "role playing game" and in the early days, it was considered to be something of an insult to call someone a "roll player" meaning that they were more interested in the tactical aspects of the encounters and all the ways to roll dice to beat up their opponents. With each release of the game "roll playing" has been elevated until it was roughly equal to "role playing" in 3.5. In this release the attention to "roll playing" has been such that the "roll playing" now seems to be more central to the game than the "role playing." This was evident in our first battle as the game mechanics dictated virtually all of the actions. Now, that's not entirely a bad thing. In fact it may not be a bad thing at all. The increasing importance of "roll playing" in the game has always been to decrease the unpleasantness of having GMs and players argue about such things as whether a target is within range, has some sort of cover or is or is not vulnerable to a particular approach. For that reason it is imperative in today's gaming community that the game mechanics drive the action in a smooth, predictable and decisive manner. This, in fact, was one of the things that I was most interested in checking out by playing in the demo game. The first encounter was not smooth. But that was more due to the players' attempts to play the game as if it were still under the old rules, and our unfamiliarity with our own characters' abilities. In fact in that first encounter even the GM misunderstood a fairly basic rule around my (and our warlock's) basic use of our main minor action. But the encounter proceeded briskly even with those minor confusions. And soon we had defeated the "guards" and my character was tying up the leader for questioning. But at that moment the remaining sleeping "guard" awakened and began yelling for help from the real town guards. My character barely had time to snatch a curious dagger from the leader before we were forced to flee an oncoming phalanx of actual guards. Now this is important. In the older versions of D&D the rules around melee or ranged combat have always been fairly well done, well enough to satisfy millions of fans anyway. But one area that has always been "broken" has been such things as having a group of player characters attempt to flee from, or pursue a group of non-player characters. The new version addresses this situation directly with a set of rules for determining the success or failure of group actions such as hiding, running, obstructing or sneaking. Our group attempted all of those things. The rules for such a situation seem to be that the players' group needs to be successful in four attempts at such group actions before they fail at four attempts. Success means they achieve their objective (whether that is hiding, fleeing or obstructing, for example). Failure does not mean that they are captured, but it means something negative happens. We failed four times and succeeded three times. The GM ruled that the outcome of the activity was that we successfully evaded capture, but not before the guards had seen us well enough to identify us later. I have mixed feelings about this though. At one point our party was running through a corn field and we managed to set the corn ablaze behind us as we ran, forcing the pursuing guards to either rush through the flames, or rush around them, either of which should have given us enough of an advantage that we could have escaped or hidden. But the GM simply ignored the flames and continued the pursuit as if they had never been set. This sort of arbitrary ignoring of physical reality by a GM always bothers me, but I don't think that is a flaw in the new rules, I just think the GM was not being realistic and did not consider the likely actual reaction of a group of men in armor rushing headlong into a burning corn field. You see this sort of thing a lot in GMs actually, no matter what version of the game you are playing. After a short rest, we continued on into our second encounter which was against a group of undead skeletons, including one which was aflame, and one which could explode bone fragments from its body doing serious damage for a wide area. This encounter led to the most significant rules debate of the session when our warlock used his daily ability against the exploding skeleton. The description of the ability said that with a successful hit, besides doing direct damage to the target, the warlock could "slide" the creature three squares. The question raised was whether the "slide" allowed the warlock to move the creature in any direction, or if it only moved directly away from the warlock. My position in the discussion was that other actions which caused the target to move directly away from the player character described the reaction as "pushed back", and so "slide" was either a simple wording error, or else was intended to mean a specific sort of action. And in fact "slide" IS a specific action and a "slide" can go in any direction. The GM finally ruled as I had hoped, and our warlock was able to push the exploding skeleton off a cliff, disposing of the greatest threat to the party. We quickly mopped up the rest of the undead combatants. During that battle we almost lost two of our group. Our halfling paladin was set aflame and actully remained on fire for most of the encounter, leading to a lot of jokes at his expense. The halfling and our cleric both were brought to the brink of death multiple times, only to be brought back by other characters jeopardizing their own lives to save them. Until the warlock pushed the exploding one off the cliff, we were all convinced that we would be killed. The GM assured us that many other groups who played this demo did not survive this encounter. But we did, although it was a close thing. After that encounter the GM took pity on us and went around the table taking four of our group's character sheets and explaining in some detail how their abilities could be better utilized and made to work in synergy with the other characters' abilities. Unfortunately he had no suggestions for me since the Ranger seems to be a fairly simple character to play, and I had already used all of his abilities more or less as the GM would have suggested them to be used. Which sort of disappointed me because it implied that the Ranger was not as resourceful as the other characters. After that we took a full rest, recovered all of our abilities and hit points and went on our way where we had our final encounter, this one the GM said was the hardest of the three. Either our group is a fast learning group, or we got lucky in this encounter because it ended up being somewhat easier than the fight against the undead. Our opponents in this case were four human berserkers, an elf wizard and some sort of chain-weilding humanoid whose ability to attack multiple opponents was rechargable after use if the player (or GM in this case) rolled a six on a six-sided die. The GM rolled three sixes, recharging the ability three times. Even so the battle was relatively short and devoid of threats of total party destruction, and after we dispatched them all, we called it a day. So, my thoughts on the new game are: It's different. They have simplified some things that needed to be simplified, which makes the game better, but they also simplified some things that did NOT need to be simplified, which makes the game worse. I thought I would dislike the new mechanism of developing character abilities. Actually I sort of like the new mechanism. The daily, encounter and at will approach was surprisingly effective, both in terms of using them in battle, and in terms of keeping track of what your character can do. In the old rules it is not at all uncommon for the player of a spell-casting character to spend several minutes contemplating what to do before actually committing to a single action. From a game play dynamic, this is very bad because it slows down the game and causes other players to get bored. And bored people get up and walk around, which means when the slow player finally makes up their mind, someone has to go hunt down the next player so the game can continue. Such things sometimes take up a large fraction of an encounter. With the new approach that was not really a problem. In four hours we had three significant encounters and this was our group's FIRST TIME to use the new rules, so there was significant loss of time asking questions just due to our inexperience. My feeling is that the new rules move much quicker than the old rules, which is a very good thing in my mind. Other than the oversimplification of movement, distance and area of effect spells, the main concern I have with the new rules is one that may only be true of this demo, and that is the lack of "buffing". In the old rules a clever player can gain tremendous tactical advantages in an encounter through the judicious application of spells or effects which enhance certain attributes or abilities. I am a big fan of this because it makes the encounters more than a hack and slash exercise. I enjoy the contemplation of tactics and strategies that frequently can mean the difference between success and failure based on careful analysis of the situation and proper utilization of magic or effects. This is one of the main areas I feel that smarter, more experienced players have an advantage over dumber or less experienced ones. There was basically none of that in this session. I hope that is not true of the entire game. I'll find out when the new books come. The most important question of all, and the one I went to answer, was whether the new rules were worth the effort to move to them. Overall I was left with enough of a positive reaction that I am willing to give it a try. I can't say I am overly enthusiastic, but overall I was pleased with the results. The bottom line is that it was a fun session.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.