Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Yeah, but did the bastards water-board anyone?

By CosmicConservative
Because, if not, apparently that would be fine.
BAGHDAD, Iraq (CNN) -- The pain here is choking -- it's a dark, suffocating sorrow. "They took my husband away in front of me. I found his body in the morgue a few days later. He had multiple bullet wounds and his eyes had been gouged out," one woman tells me, forcefully twisting a tissue in her hands as if it somehow could ease her agony and erase the chilling memory. She didn't want her story told, too afraid that she would meet the same fate as the man she loved. Her husband's body bore the "signs of torture." How many times has that phrase been used? It's such a common phrase it's as if what really happened gets glossed over: skin scraped off their bodies, fingernails ripped out, horrifying screams of pain before death.
Just in case anyone is still wondering what the word "torture" actually means. Water-boarding was specifically developed as a HUMANE way to interrogate prisoners so that the victim was not permanently injured or disabled, and so that the interrogators could live with themselves afterwards. As Leftist demagogues continue to hammer the "water boarding is torture" meme home day after day, just try to remember that when it was developed, it was considered to be a humane thing. Much like spanking used to be considered "discipline" and is now considered "child abuse." I guess that's progress, right?

Comments (13)

Bryan Woody
Interesting perspective. If waterboarding is humane, do you agree that it should be used by police departments and the FBI to interrogate suspects?
CosmicConservative
Humane does not mean "pleasant" Bryan. Police? Probably not. FBI? If they had a suspect and knew he had planted a dirty bomb in a city? Sure. I guess you don't know or don't care that water-boarding is part of special services training. Are we torturing our own service personnel?
Bryan Woody
I understand that waterboarding is part of special services training. But I also understand that voluntary training undertaken by our best soldiers, in their best physical shape, for a few seconds is different than an interrogation in combination with other enhanced techniques where the procedure doesn't stop until the suspect is broken. But back to my question. If the procedure is humane (though unpleasant), why restrict its use to those suspected of planting dirty bombs? It would be useful to break up crime rings, find accomplices, even get confessions.
CosmicConservative
Bryan: It is difficult for me to believe that interrogation techniques are different than every other option on earth in that they have no gradations of application. Police already have a heirarchy of interrogation techniques beginning with "Hey, tell me what happened," and including good cop/bad cop techniques as well as psychological intimidation and threats (that's all plea bargaining is, is the defendant reacting to threats of jail time.) So no, I don't think it is appropriate to allow cops to immediately use water-boarding to get a 12 year old boy to admit to stealing a candy bar. Why would I allow the FBI to use the technique but not local police? Because the FBI gets more intensive training in interrogation techniques and has more stringent oversight. This is not a binary situation where water-boarding is either always applicable or never applicable. It is one of a set of interrogation techniques used on this planet ranging from the aforementioned "hey, what happened" to the flaying the skin off of a living human being. There are any number of "questionable" techniques on that broad spectrum of techniques. I simply don't believe that there is a hard black line that can be drawn and everything on one side of the line is OK for ANY use, while everything on the other side is EVIL for ANY use. I think there is a portion of that spectrum that is in the realm of "reasonable people can disagree" without calling each other "pansies" or "torturers". Water-boarding, to me, is in that portion of the spectrum. Which means, to me, that it is a technique that may be reserved for perhaps the most difficult and critical circumstances, under the appropriate observation and with every effort made to ensure the safety of the subject. As I am not an expert on interrogation, I assume there are other techniques that are also in that portion of the spectrum. I would draw the line at techniques which do permanent physical harm to the subject, and would not allow any threats or harm to innocents as part of the motivation to get them to talk. Breaking a finger, for instance, is more than I would allow as an approved interrogation technique. Even though even then you could argue that the pain and suffering is fairly minor (people break fingers all the time without collapsing into a puddle of emotional goo) and with proper medical attention the finger can be reset and repaired to be as good as new. Still I wouldn't allow it as a technique. But would I personally do it if I thought that would get a serial killer to tell me where my daughter was buried alive? In a heartbeat buddy.
CosmicConservative
Since you haven't addressed my other point yet Bryan... how about it? Is spanking child abuse or discipline?
Bryan Woody
I'm not a parent, so my opinions about spanking are worthless. However, when I was a child, I was spanked. I don't remember the spankings themselves, but two of my earliest memories relate to spanking. I remember asking if I was going to get spanked (and feeling terrified), and I remember beating the hell out of our dog. Without going into all the details, I believe that spanking was not done out of love but out of anger and frustration. It didn't teach me correct behavior, but taught me to fear and avoid adults. That's just me. I don't think slapping a teenager after a disrespectful remark or swatting a toddler on the butt is necessarily child abuse. I agree with your idea of a broad spectrum. However, the long term goal of child development should be the primary goal. It's easy to cross the line from helping the kid develop good behavior (and not kill himself) to causing the kid damage, even though the damage may not be physical or immediately apparent.
Andy
Bryan, you tipped your hand... "I’m not a parent, so my opinions about spanking are worthless. However, when I was a child, I was spanked." Every opinion on "spanking" is worthwhile. My worthless opinion is that "spanking" is discipline. I'll try to make this clear. "Spanking" is valuable to a child when done correctly. The child must know exactly WHY he is being spanked. Bryan makes a good point when he writes "I believe that spanking was not done out of love but out of anger and frustration." Guilty as charged! As a young Father, I got awfully angry and frustrated with the curtain climbers. To my shame, I once popped my eldest son on the head (he was a tough case) with my Granddaddys' sapphire birth-stone ring that I wore after he gave it to me on his death-bed. (Our birthdays were only 3 days apart). Mrs. Andy threatened to leave me if I didn't get that anger under control. Looking back, it's pretty funny. On his 18th birthday, I gave that ring to the son that I knocked in the head with it. His birthday is Sept. 8...the same day as my Granddaddy. I realized when threatened with the loss of Mrs. Andy that I really needed to "grow up" and learn about "disciplining children." I don't know if I succeeded yet, but the children that came behind have had a lot less spankings, and a lot more patience from Dad. Spanking is a valuable tool. Sometimes a kid will get so far out of line that they are really "begging for it." My third son once walked into my bedroom...He was probably 10 years old, and told me about some evil deed he had done...and laid face-front on the bed and said, "I need a whipping!" At that moment I realized that he had not ever really had a spanking...but was begging for one! (He came along after I had "learned better") I dutifully took my belt off, gave him a limp-wristed flog or two on the fattest part of his butt, and tried my best to act like I was upset with him. I used a belt, because I once heard a wise man say "Belts are for spanking...hands are for loving." That was after I had used my hand too often...wish I had heard that sooner. Bryan, do your best to forgive the anger and frustration of your folks when they spanked you. I don't know the story of your childhood, but I have lived it from both sides. It is not easy to know what the best thing is to do when disciplining a child...in fact it's impossible to know "the best." Anyway...waterboard the bastards!
Drax
All I know is this: If I had someone in my living room who had (or might have) information which had even the slightest potential to save the life of my fiancee or child, I would HOPE that I had the courage and the guts to do whatever was necessary to extract the information from him to potentially save their lives. As Commander in Chief, the President stands in for me because I don't have that terrorist in my living room...he has him in his jail. I want a President who has the guts to do the hard task of extracting the information which might save the lives of this country's sons and daughters.
Bryan Woody
Drax, let's say the police capture a guy who they think kidnapped your child. Your child is still missing. Should the police (or experts they bring in) waterboard the suspect to find your child? Do you think coercive interrogation such as waterboarding is acceptable any time a life might be saved?
CosmicConservative
Bryan: What would "non-coercive" interrogation be? "Hey, I'll give you a cookie if you tell me where the bomb is." Can't I respond with "Hey, you're trying to coerce me by withholding a cookie if I don't tell you where the bomb is!!!" Why don't you answer this question for us. Is there ever a time when you think it is necessary for the national security of this country to get information from a person who does not want to tell you that information? And if so, what techniques would YOU think are appropriate to find the location of that ticking dirty bomb?
Bryan Woody
I'm trying to understand where the line would be drawn. The argument goes far beyond ticking dirty bombs, doesn't it? Let's say I agree with using whatever means necessary to locate the ticking bomb, including waterboarding, breaking fingers, electric shock, drugs, whatever. Where do I stop? What if we don't know whether there is a bomb or not? What if the bomb isn't dirty, but just conventional? What if only a hundred people would die? Ten? What if the person has no information about the bomb, but might know about the organization, its finances, or members? If we are willing to use coercive techniques on anyone suspected as a terrorist, are we also willing to use these same techniques on others -- citizens -- who terrorize such as kidnappers and murderers? Drax said he would do anything for his child, and expects the Commander in Chief to stand in for him. I'm trying to understand where the line for the Commander in Chief should be drawn and how certain techniques, if effective, should be limited.
CosmicConservative
Bryan: Hmmm... aren't we all trying to do just exactly what you are saying you are trying to do? Nobody claims to be omniscient. Certainly nobody here does. What we do claim is to be willing to make judgment calls when necessary based on circumstances. In order to make judgment calls you have to have some options on the table. Having a "zero-tolerance for torture" policy allows people to define "torture" however they like and then accuse you of torture when they find you doing anything they can stretch the definition to cover. What my original post was all about was trying to demonstrate that in some areas of the world people actually KNOW what "torture" is, and when compared with sticking fathers feet-first into a wood chipper in front of their wife and kids, waterboarding is pretty tame stuff. And that other stuff really, actually happens in the world. But here in the U.S. instead of our politicians and self-appointed moral guardians in Hollywood (who are sparing time from being busted for drugs, shoplifting, moral terpitude and other headline-grabbing things) instead of them going after regimes who literally rip the skin off of their political enemies for fun they go on an ill-advised crusade against pouring water up someone's nose for 30 seconds in an attempt to discover when the next time someone wants to fly an airplane into a heavily populated skyscraper. Everyone is trying to figure out what the limits are. What I'm saying is that if waterboarding fifteen people would have stopped 9/11, and somebody decided not to do it because it was "torture" resulting in the loss of 3,000 innocent lives, that decision is a bad one. And Drax and I want the President to make a good one.
Drax
Bryan: First, you really shouldn't compare people who are engaged in ACTS OF WAR against the United States and those who are engaged in criminal activity. The two are not only different in kind; they are different in magnitude. But, to directly answer your question: I would WANT the officers to "put the screws" to the person who kidnapped MY daughter or allow me to do so. Remember, confessions obtained through such means aren't admissible because of the beating...but because they simply aren't deemed to be "reliable." (Read Miranda...which wasn't all that long ago...when we USED to do exactly that in these extreme cases...beat the offender until he told us what we wanted to know.) Of course there's a line. It's just a different line for just about everyone. That's why I defend McCain on his position on waterboarding; he's just drawn the line in a different place than I would, but his reasoning for his placement of that line is certainly as rational as is mine.