Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Doctors cleared in Ritter's death

By CosmicConservative
A jury has ruled that the doctors in the John Ritter aortic infraction (or whatever it was) case were not negligent and did not award the family (who had already been awarded $14,000,000 in other lawsuits about his death) any damages. I'm not an expert, but this feels about right to me. Not the $14,000,000, but the jury deciding that the doctors, when confronted with a man dying of a ruptured aorta and having minutes, if not seconds, to make crucial life-and-death decisions, were not required to be omniscient and omnipotent. Now who pays the doctor's attorney's fees? I'm sure they were not cheap.

Comments (10)

Boyd
Now who pays the doctor’s attorney’s fees? Their patients do.
Drax
No. Their insurer does. You know, the people who take your money then don't pay your claims? Yah. Those guys.
CosmicConservative
And since insurer's money comes from their customer's premiums, the end result is the same. It comes from the patients.
Drax
You know...it has become clear that you don't think anyone should sue anyone for anything, that doctors should be able to operate without the threat of libility, that drivers should be able to drive without consideration that they might run into people, that suing people or companies, in itself, is evil. If the Ritter family filed a frivolous lawsuit, they could be sued, their lawyer could be hit with sanctions, and both could end up paying, not only the costs of the lawsuit, but hefty fines as well. What cost to our society the "kill all the tort lawyers" mindset? We would not have products liability. We would not have medical malpractice (which kills more people every year than every automobile accident in the country does...). We would be at the mercy of those who do us injury. This mindset, that people who sue people who hurt them, are doing something "wrong" is troublesome. How do we know if they were unlawfully hurt? The jury tells us so. Are juries wrong? Sure, but it's the best indicator of what is "lawful" and what is not. It's like that lady who got burned by a cup of coffee in California who received a huge settlement. Everyone said: "Oh my gosh! That's crazy! Didn't she know the coffee was hot!?" As usual, the whole story wasn't told. The coffee wasn't "hot," it was SUPERHEATED. It was SO hot that, when it spilled, it caused 2nd and 3rd degree burns on the woman's genetalia. It was handed to the woman at a drive-through, and, predictably, was placed between her legs, and, predictably, it spilled. McDonald's had NO EXCUSE to "superheat" their coffee. It is MEANT to come into contact with the skin. It was utterly PREDICTABLE that someone would get burned badly, yet they continued to superheat their coffee. They don't now. That's part of the purpose of "torts," to punish the wrong-doers in the pocketbook so that they STOP doing things which PREDICTABLY hurt others. And, it WORKS. Whether you're talking about discrimination, medical malpractice, coal mining, or whatever...the threat of being sued causes people to change their behavior...and in a direction which makes it SAFER for those of us who are potentially injured by their failure to do so. In this case, all we know is that, regardless of your feelings about doctors being sued when they are faced with emergency circumstances....the BEAN COUNTERS at the insurance companies settled to the tune of fourteen million or so and left the remaining issues to the jury...and won. We have NO IDEA how a jury would have ruled on the issues which were SETTLED, just the knowledge that the insurance bean counters thought that it was a better financial decision to settle than to risk it in court. Doctors, "when confronted with a man dying of a ruptured aorta and having minutes, if not seconds, to make crucial life-and-death decisions" are not required to be "omniscient and omnipotent" in their decisions, but they are PAID to be COMPETENT and use GOOD MEDICAL JUDGEMENT when they make those decisions. That is what they DO. We have the right to EXPECT that they adhere to the standard of care of medical doctors who practice in the same area of medicine. If the Ritter family didn't have MEDICAL EXPERTS who supported their opinions that THIS WASN'T THE CASE, that the doctors who worked on Ritter DIDN'T adhere to that standard of care, the case would have been dismissed on Summary Judgment. And, contrary to popular opinion, getting doctors to say that another doctor committed malpractice is HARD. But, in order to win a medical malpractice case, you MUST have one or more who say that is the case. Faced with the "battle of the experts," the jury sided with the experts hired by the doctors rather than the experts hired by the Plaintiffs. How much the fact that there was an earlier settlement played into their decision is, of course, unknown. Tiresome, this constant attack on people who sue others because they get hurt by the actions of others...
CosmicConservative
It has become equally clear that you feel that people should sue other people for any redress, real or imagined. Well, if you can practice hyperbole and character attacks, so can I. ;) Look, the jury sided with me on this one. You can argue with the jury about why they decided the plaintiff's case was unproven. I think the final vote was 6 - 3 on this case, so three of the jurors agreed with you. I am not anti-lawyer, but I do recognize the very real cost to our society of the exponential increase in lawsuits over the past forty years. And yes, I do think that the whole idea of suing for damages and allowing the plaintiff (and their lawyers) to benefit fincancially from those damages is a fundamentally and potentially fatally flawed system. I have said before that if the concept of punitive damages is to penalize the defendent instead of enriching the plaintiff (and their attorneys) then take the punitive damages awarded and put them into a fund that is used to benefit people who have a need for legal aid. The way it is now not only encourages, it absolutely demands irresponsible behavior by attorneys and sets plaintiffs eyes ablaze with dollar signs that virtually guarantee inflated claims. It isn't just me who feels that our legal system is out of control, you know.
Drax
I know it's not just you. And, I, too, think that there is some really big issues with our legal system and "personal injury" and "mass tort" lawyers. But, by the same token, people are actually HURT by others individually and en mass by the negligence of other people and companies. What is the "compromise" here, then? Who gets to decide which cases are "frivolous" and not deserving of being heard by a jury? I mean, now, judges do that by means of "Summary Judgment," don't they? What would you have? Something like the Louisiana Malpractice Act where you have a three man panel (of...doctors) deciding whether the defendant (another ...doctor) has committed malpractice that the plaintiff must go through before he gets to go to trial? (In most cases ending up with three "independent doctors" saying "no malpractice" when the jury later determines there was...) And, no matter how badly the person was hurt or killed, the general damage award can't go over $500,000.00? Should we set up individual "boards" like this special one set up for doctors (everyone else gets sued for WHATEVER DAMAGE they do...not being "capped" because they have flooded the Legislature with money...) to have the cases "vetted" before they proceed to trial? No. What is needed is simply to enforce the laws and ethics regulations currently in force. Enforce "frivolous lawsuit" laws and knock the hell out of the LAWYERS who bring such lawsuits as it is meant to be. Have the JUDGES use "Summary Judgment" (and they do..they do..) to "vet" the cases. Then, as in the case of the "hot coffee at McDonald's" case, use the Appellate courts to oversee judgments of runaway juries. (The Appellate court in that case reduced the award to the hundreds of thousands from several million....as is one of their main functions.) But, how do we tell a lawsuit is "frivolous?" This reminds me of the "Bivens versus Six Unknown Agents of the FBI" (or something like that). This poor guy was hurt by FBI agents, but he didn't know which ones, so he sued as noted above. Now, at the time, there was no question that you simply COULDN'T sue "six unknown agents;" you actually had to name them. So, when it was at the trial court level, it certainly would appear to be a prime case for "frivolous." So, too, at the Appellate level. But....wait....the Supremes said that the case was properly filed and could proceed as styled. From "frivolous" to Supreme Court law. So, how can you TELL what is "frivolous?" Most of the cases which might fall into that category ARE "vetted" by the trial court, dismissed via "Summary Judgment" and upheld by the Appellate courts. The rest are decided by Jury. So, after the case has progressed through "Summary Judgment" (and vetted by the trial judge and possibly the Appellate court) and PASSED, who are we (who likely don't know the applicable case law and certainly don't know all the facts) to say that a case is "frivolous?" Let the Jury sort it out. As to the issue of giving the money to "deserving" people...the amount of the award (in the great, great, great majority of cases) is BASED on the INJURY to the person suing...both physical pain & suffering and, in the Ritter case (to have such a big award) FUTURE LOST WAGES. Your suggestion is to give that money, money which would have been EARNED by the DEAD GUY but for the fact that the defendant KILLED HIM...to someone else isn't a very good idea, in my humble opinion. Now, "punitive damages" (damages which have nothing to do with the extent of the injury but are EXPRESSLY given to "punish" the defendant and to deter like behavior by him and others in the future) might be distributed as you suggest....(of course, this allows those who didn't expend any time, money, or emotional investment in the case to "benefit" from the effort of others...but, what the hey....)
CosmicConservative
No, I specifically meant that the award for "punitive damages" go to a fund instead of to the plaintiff and their lawyers. Get rid of the incentive to ask for billions of dollars that is not actually in recompense for the loss of income, assets or pain and suffering. That would, imho, go a long, long way to reduce the frivolous lawsuits.
Drax
One thing you have to think about is the cost of bringing a mass tort lawsuit to court. It costs MILLIONS to bring some of these cases to court. If there wasn't some mechanism to make it worthwhile for the LAWYERS to bring them (since, as in the asbestos cases in which Cosmic's Aunt gets a pittance every now and again, the so-called "Plaintiffs" get almost nothing...). But, if the lawyers didn't bring the cases, we'd still be breathing Asbestos in our schools, our homes, etc. It's a tricky question, what is "frivolous" and what is not, who should get paid and who should not...