Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Huckabee, Obama win Iowa

By Dadman
But, of course most of you will already be aware of this. I am disappointed Romney placed second to Huckabee. I believe Romney's religion played a significant role in his defeat with a large percentage of Republican voters saying in exit polls that religion was a factor in their decision. I'm not hesitant to call it religious bigotry. I know many will disagree, but if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it must be a duck. Huckabee, in my view, will not be a viable candidate in the general election. Democrats are saying openly they hope Huckabee is the nominee so they can dust off their dancing shoes for the inaugural galas. That's the last thing I want to see. But I don't think Huckabee is going to be the Republican nominee. Romney still has a decent shot and McCain's chances have been bolstered. If the Huck-a-boom persists into the upcoming primaries good conservatives need to prepare themselves for the upcoming political dark ages. We'll soon be genuflecting in supplication for a new conservative savior in the similitude of Ronald Reagan... ...'cuz it sure ain't Huckabee.

Comments (29)

pace
I was pleased with how Obama and Edwards both faired relative to Hillary. I think Huckabee might be the last person whom I would vote for out of every one of the remaining candidates. I'd take Romney over him any day of the week.
Drax
If religion played a part, perhaps it was because there is a large evangelical contingent in Iowa. Is it somehow "bigotry" for people to vote for someone who has the same core values as do they as evidenced by their choice of religion...and not just choice...but a teacher of that religion? Is it bigotry to vote FOR someone who shares your religion as opposed to voting AGAINST someone who does not?
Dadman
Oh no, here we go again. Romney's shares the core values of evangelical voters and his conservative politcal credentials are probably better than Huckabee's (although some think otherwise). I would argue Romney's resume' is also superior to Huckabee's. So, the evangelicals of Iowa voted against Romney, it would appear, due primarily to perceived differences in religious doctrine between his faith and theirs. They simply would not vote for a Mormon simply because he is a Mormon. Yes, I call that bigotry...religious bigotry to be exact. Sorry you disagree. In my view, political leaders should not be selected based on questions of personal faith. It's stupid, but I know it's a part of the process. Romney and his supports will just have to suck it up...
Drax
Again. You state that the voters voted "against" Romney. Why could they not have voted "for" Huckabee?
Dadman
They could have, but in my view they did for the wrong reasons. This is a political race, not a theological one. I don't believe Huckabee is a viable national candidate. Anyone with a modicum of common sense can see that. Romney, in my view, has a better chance of beating the Dem nominee in November. I think he is a superior politcal candidate that just got beat because so many evangelicals simply REFUSE, on religious grounds alone, to vote for a Mormon... These religious right voters are cutting off their noses to spite the faces...in my humble opinion.
Drax
Further, even if some DID vote "against" Romney, why do you assume that it has anything to do with his religion when it could very well have been two other MAJOR factors which hit home with Iowa voters: 1.) Romney pumping all his millions into his campaign, including over TWENTY MILLION of his own fortune which, in the closest thing to "negative" campaigning that Huckabee engaged in was akin to "buying" the election. 2.) Romney going "negative" as Huckabee's numbers began to rise and Huck's refusal (and quite public) to retaliate. This resonated with the voters as well.
Dadman
Why were Huckabee's numbers going up in the first place? Look, I know you don't agree that religious bigotry had anything to do with Romney's defeat. I disagree. I think it played a significant part in the 9 percentage points that separated Huckabee and Romney. Sure, other factors played a part, but it's just a cold, hard fact that many Huckabee voters think like the guy who runs this site: http://www.godandculture.wordpress.com/?s=Mormon&searchbutton=go%21.
Drax
Sure. There are idiots out there. Some voted against Obama because he's black. Some voted against Hillary because she's a woman. Some voted against Huckabee because he's a former pastor. Some voted against Romney because he's a mormon. You would think that the evangelical leaders would have put their weight behind Huck (being a former pastor and all) rather than Romney, but, what the hey....
Dadman
Yes, they did, but for theological reasons, not practical political reasons. Last I heard, this was a political race for President of the United States, not Pastor of the United States. And, by the way, anyone who did not vote for Obama simply because he is black is a racial bigot, pure and simple...
Andy
Hey...Looking at it that way, the voters of Iowa voted AGAINST my guy, too (and by a larger margin by the way). Dadman, I love ya, but nobody voted against anybody. They voted FOR their guy. I wouldn't vote for Huckabee for anything. But I can't vote against him...it's just not possible man. Huckabee has had his big night...whoopidy crud! It's about over for him.
Dadman
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. I think Romney lost Iowa to a large extent simply because he is a Mormon. Huckabee won because he got the evangelical vote in Iowa and Romney didn't (because he is a Mormon). Sure, other reasons factored into the equation, but I think Iowa voters were casting votes based on theology and not practical politics. That's the way I (and many other political analysts) see it and you're not going to change my mind. ;)
Andy
Good man, Dadman! I wouldn't try to change your mind.We conservatives think for ourselves. My guy lost big-time because the voters of Iowa don't know their heads from a hole in the ground...had nothing to do with his religion. ;)
Dadman
The religion of your guy has not been made an issue in this campaign in any significant way. Just a couple months ago, Romney was way up in the polls in Iowa. What happened? Well, based on what I've seen, heard, and read, evangelicals (the bigoted variety) launched a campaign in Iowa via their pulpits, websites, radio programs, etc. to go out and vote against the Mormon cultist. Given that 60% of the voters who participated in the Republican caucus identified themselves as evangelicals it seemed like a good strategy and it apparently worked like a charm.
Drax
Dadman: To the extent that exit polls can be believed, apparently 6 in 10 of those who voted for Huck felt it important that their choice have the same religious beliefs as they. Choosing to vote "for" someone who shares your religious beliefs isn't the same thing as voting "against" someone who does not. It would be interesting to see how those 6 in 10 would have voted if they didn't have a former preacher to vote for. Since we don't, I'll simply choose NOT to ascribe to them any base motivation, rather choose to believe that the vast majority simply believed that Huck was the better choice...one who shared their beliefs and voted "for" him. You can choose to ascribe whatever motivations you desire to their choice.
Dadman
Drax: You are simply naive about the animosity many (not all) evangelicals feel towards Mormons simply because they are Mormons. If you compared the social values of Mormons and evangelicals you would find they are virtually identical, so the animosity is not a question of values, it is a question of doctrinal differences which, in my view, should not play a significant role in a political campaign. You also seem to be naive about what happened in Iowa and how significant the anti-Mormon evangelical vote was to the outcome. You are free to ascribe other motivations if you like, but the truth is out there to be learned with just a small amount of effort. It is gender bigotry when a person will not vote for another person simply because they are a woman. It is racial bigotry when a person will not vote for another person simply because they are black. And it's religious bigotry when a person will not vote for another person simply because they are a Jew or a Catholic or a Mormon. You can try to dress it up and disguise it anyway you like, but when the primary determining factor in a cast vote is gender, or race, or religion we are dealing with bigotry (which is admittedly a very common thing in political contests). I believe with great conviction that many of the votes cast for Huckabee in the Iowa caucus were also votes cast solely AGAINST Romney's faith. And I'm not the only one who thinks that...
Drax
Of course you're not the only one who believes that. One can interpret the data any way one chooses. (Do you have any actual DATA which definitively shows your conclusions? Of course not.) You call it "bigotry" to vote for someone who shares your religion. Can someone ONLY be "non bigoted" if they vote for someone who does NOT share their religion? Is that your litmus test for not being a bigot...to vote for someone who has a religion which you do not share? If we are talking about actual, practicing evangelical Christians...ones who take their religion seriously, why on this green earth do you assume (because you surely can't back up your conclusions with any actual data that can't be refuted) that it is "bigotry" to vote for someone who is not only a member of your chosen religion but a TEACHER of your chosen religion. I was under the impression that Huck was a govenor of an actual state. I was also under the impression that Mitt has had some serious issues with abortion....as does the Mormon church when viewed from the eyes of a evangelical Christian. I concede (again...again...again...) that there surely is some portion of the voters who are bigots of one stripe or another. (I actually suspect that Huck lost many votes because he is going bald. How many bald Presidents have we had since television?) I will NOT concede that the majority or even a significant percentage of the evangelical Christians are bigots and find such an assertion at least as bigoted as that which they are accused of.
Dadman
Talking past one another... I never said that the definition of bigotry is voting for someone who shares your religion. Please don't put words in my mouth to bolster your own argument. I said that it's bigotry when someone refuses to vote for a candidate simply because they DON'T share their faith. Just like when a white guy won't vote for a black guy simply because they don't share the same race. It's an important distinction, Drax, that I just know you grok... I'm a 'Mormon', Drax, and have been one for nearly 30 years. I joined the church by choice and was not born into it. I have experienced the irrational, anti-Mormon bigotry of some evangelicals first hand. I have read many of their books, pamphlets, websites, blogs, etc. I've seen many of their videos and video clips on YouTube. I have stood toe-to-toe with them as the shouted me down in the streets of Salt Lake City just outside Temple Square, condemning me and my family to hell (and worse). As a full-time missionary for the LDS church in Sweden I even attended their services from time to time (by invitation) where I was treated to breathless condemnations of my faith from their pulpits, by their preachers, and by their members. I have deconstructed their anti-Mormon literature brought to me by friends who couldn't believe what they were reading about their friend's Satanic cult faith. So, that is how 'on God's green earth' I know that some of these folks who voted in the Iowa caucus are bigots who would rather die than vote for a damn Mormon in a political contest. True, I can't tell you precisely how many, but I believe the numbers were significant enough to give Huckabee the victory. If evangelicals don't want to vote for Romney for other reasons pertinent to a presidential race, fine, I have absolutely no issue with that. My issue is with the religious bigots out there who have made Romney's faith the only pertinent issue in their small minds. When you equate real religious hatred and bigotry to a candidate going bald, you reinforce how utterly out-of-touch you are on this issue. You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about.
Drax
Choose to believe as you will. I will choose to believe that evangelical Christians are no more bigotted than Mormons.
Dadman
Sigh. I know some things, Drax, that you don't know and can't know become you are not a Mormon. I believe some things that neither of us can prove. When it comes to ecclesiastical matters, some evangelicals are without question more bigoted than Mormons. Mormons believe all people should be free to worship (or not) God according to the dictates of their own conscience. It is one of our formal articles of faith. As a result, Mormons have not created a cottage industry around denouncing other people's religions. You will not find books penned by Mormons criticizing Jews, or Jehovah Witnesses, or Baptists, or Catholics, or Evangelical Christians. Evangelicals (some of them) have not afforded the Mormons, and other major faiths, the same courtesy. George W. Bush, a self-proclaimed evangelical Christian, was supported in overwhelming numbers by Mormons everywhere. Utah has been one of the reddest states in the union the past two presidential elections - thanks to the Mormon vote. Mormons certainly have the capacity, like any human beings, to be bigoted, but not about religion in this presidential race. And that's what I am talking about specifically. Please understand I am not talking about all evangelicals - just some of the more rabid ones. Unfortunately, it is some of those more rabid ones that encourage their 'flocks' to go out and vote to ensure the Mormon doesn't win the election.
Drax
I'm conversant in the articles of faith Mormons subscribe to and am aware of their "tolerance" position just as I'm aware that Catholics aren't supposed to support abortion. We are at odds here and close to engaging in a conversation which goes far afield of that which is on the table before us, so I'll leave this alone save for some final thoughts. When Bush ran for office, were there any Mormons running for President at the time? Don't Mormons consider themselves to be Christians and, accordingly, find no mental dissonance voting for another Christian, albeit of another discipline? I haven't found a good break-down of the exit polls yet and don't know if I will, but I think that it would be illuminating. I did watch many people explain why they voted for whom and just don't recall a single person say they voted against Romney because he's a Mormon. But, hey... we know how closeted those bigots are, so we'll never know, will we?
Dadman
Come on, Drax, bigots never admit to their bigotry. I'm curious where you are tempted to take this conversation. I'm content to stay focused on the fact that many evangelical voters simply will not vote for a Mormon under any circumstances. But I think it is best to let this alone save for my final thought. You may be one of the only intelligent people left in American who doesn't believe anti-Mormon bigotry is working against Romney in a significant way. I'm amazed you have such an issue with me saying what so many other pundits and analysts are also saying on T.V and in the newspapers. Maybe they're not using the 'bigot' word like I am. Instead, they simply cite the polls that say that 30-40% of likely voters will simply not vote for a Mormon. I'm not sure if they've polled only the evangelical demographic, but I'm confident the numbers would be comparable. And my point was Mormons don't have an issue voting for an evangelical candidate while the reverse is often not true. I'm beginning to think you have an issue with Mormons yourself. Putting 'tolerance' in quotations and juxtapositioning it against Catholic's 'firm' stand against abortion was a nice touch. Oh, and I feel so much better you are conversant in the articles of faith I subscribe to. For a while there I thought I was dealing with someone who didn't have a clue.
pace
Drax noted that he watched many people explain why they voted for their guy. I also watched a few of these brief exit interviews, and I recall two or three of the self-proclaimed Huckabee supporters responding to the question that they like that he's a Christian, or words to that effect. Being as it was invariably the first thing out of their mouths, it is obviously of paramount consideration to them. Given the challenges that we face as a nation, it struck me as an exceptionally weak rationale for choosing a candidate to run for the POTUS. I also felt that within the context of this Republican caucus, it was a decidedly anti-Mormon sentiment. I would agree with Dadman insofar as I believe that there is a coordinated anti-Mormon movement within the Evangelical Republican base which has mobilized for this election. And although we'll never know whether it effected the outcome of the Iowa caucus, it is my belief that it has contributed in a significant capacity to Huckabee's status.
Drax
Dadman: Are you seriously under the impression that Mormons have cornered the market on knowledge of the tenents of the Mormon religion? Is everyone else under the sun incapable of reading and listening? I do get a kick out of your notion that bigots don't admit to their bigotry yet cite polls in which they do...
Dadman
Are you suggesting the polls don't exist, or that I'm making it up? Polls are not quite as personal as an on camera T.V. interview. Are you seriously under the impression that reading up a bit on Mormon doctrine on the internet (half of which is pure b.s.) enables you to understand the nuance of the Mormon faith? And what exactly are you listening to? I like the way you completely ignored pace's response. He certainly has no horse in this race, yet he is intellectually honest enough to see the reality of things. I wish you were the same...
Drax
Who the heck was talking about "nuance?" What is "nuanced" about the published and accepted doctrines of the Mormon faith as set forth by the Mormon church on their own sites? You have the Christian Bible (that which is recognized as accurate), your own Bible, and the pronouncements of your church leaders as set forth in their writings. Is there more? Is there some hidden and secret set of rules which Mormons adhere to which are not found in those texts? If so, please point them out for me so I can become more "nuanced" in my understanding of this religion. And, yes...polls exist. Some say that as many as 40% of all voters wouldn't vote for a Mormon and more than 50% of evangelical Christians. I guess Mitt was just lucky in finding a venue in Mass. where he didn't need the votes of 1/2 of the population (presumably even a greater percentage of Republicans as there are more Christians in the Republican party than the Democratic party) to be elected governor... Again (again...again...again) I concede that there are bigots who will not vote for Mormons...or Catholics...or Jews...or Baptist preachers...or women...or blacks...or whatever. What portion? Who knows? All we have are the exit polls which do NOT indicate that Mitt's religion played any significant part in the voters' decision. Again (again...again....again) you will believe what you will. You think I'm being intellectually dishonest. I think you're blinded by your own experiences. Maybe reality is somewhere in the middle.
Drax
It's all in the eye of the beholder. I would not, in any fashion, consider you unbiased on this subject. It would be difficult indeed to be unbiased on a subject which strikes so close to home. But, a mind game... If Mitt is the choice, do you REALLY think that over 50% of the Evangelical Christians (and over 40% of ALL Republicans as some polls suggest) will sit at home on election day to see Obama or Hillary elected? If not, then we can conclude that any poll which says such is full of crap, can't we?
Dadman
I'm not prepared to say anything is 'crap'. You've only posed a hypothetical that is not likely to be tested. I don't believe Mitt is going to get the nomination and when he doesn't I guess we can then begin debating the reasons. And, no, I am not unbiased. I have experienced FIRSTHAND the bigotry and intolerance of some evangelical Christians. I KNOW it is out there. I KNOW it is virulent. The only question is precisely how much it is impacting this political campaign.
Drax
I think Mitt can still pull it out. I don't think Rudy's tactics are going to work. But, it'll be interesting nonetheless.