Book Review: Children of Hurin
By CosmicConservativeOK, so this is billed as a book written by J.R.R. Tolkien, and "edited" by Christopher Tolkien, but if this was written by J.R.R., I'm an aardvark.
It's an interesting story, in a horrible Greek tragedy sort of way. Think Odysseus combined with Oedipus and you get some idea of the main protagonist of the story, the oldest "child of Hurin", his son Turin.
So, it is hard to imagine this book appealing to any but the most hardcore Tolkien fan, the sort who can recite obscure chapters of the Silmarillion, like the scene where Beren One Hand comes before the Elf-king without the Silmaril, and is about to be arrested by the king but instead Beren reminds the king that the command was that Beren come back and have the Silmaril in his hand, which at that moment it was, although both the hand and the Silmaril were in the belly of the wolf, Fenris (I think), which satisfied the letter of the king's command. That was a sort of amusing moment in the Silmarillion, in a morbid way.
Oh, yeah, so I guess maybe I'm one of those Tolkien geeks aren't I?
But, I didn't like this book much. It has all of the monotonous lugubriousness of the Silmarillion, with none of that books more clever or amusing moments. And the Silmarillion is not remotely a good read, it's thick, ponderous and reads more like a history tome than a novel.
But "Children of Hurin" reads more like an autopsy report than even a history tome. The characters are described very clinically and behave like one-dimensional automatons throughout the book. In many ways the only really interesting characters are the evil ones. Morgoth, once Melkor, and the Lord of Sauron, the evil Lord of the Rings, tempers his evilness with a sense of irony at least.
It is hard to talk about the book at all without spoilers, but since there isn't much of a story to spoil, I'll go ahead and cover it.
Basically the story begins by describing Hurin and his pals as they prepare for the coming onslaught of Morgoth after the Dark Lord unleashes the "Father of Dragons" Glaurung, and overruns the armies of elves and men after 480 years of being besieged by the elves in Angband, his own version of the Dark Tower of Mordor, but of course, vastly larger and more evil. Upon unleashing Glaurung and yet another horde of orcs (who seem to be able to breed and grow into the millions with no discernable source of food or water), Morgoth captures Hurin and imprisons him. He does this because he believes that Hurin has knowledge of the location of the secret elvish city of Gondolin, which Hurin once visited and dwelled there for a time. Hurin refuses to tell him where Gondolin is (and it's not clear if Hurin even knows since he reached Gondolin by eagleback) so Morgoth curses his family. Thus is the die cast for the Children of Hurin.
The rest of the story tells of how Hurin's first daughter dies in a plague set loose by Morgoth, and his son is sent to dwell with the elves to protect him from Morgoth. The son, Turin, grows up to be something of an ingrate and a selfish lout, and eventually gets himself into trouble with the elves after slaying one of them, although he was provoked into the act. The provocation was revealed after Turin left the elvish city believing himself in exile, and much of the rest of the book is the result of actions Turin took while living with outlaws.
Suffice it to say that Morgoth's curse is effective. Turin kills his best friend, alienates his foster-father, leads his band of men to disastrous orc-slaughter, escapes the slaughter to become a lord of Nargothrand, where he unwisely attracts the attention of Morgoth and Glaurung, who then sacks and despoils the city, resulting in yet another death of a friend, and possible romantic partner for Turin, etc. etc... Eventually Turin kills Glaurung, but not before Glaurung reveals that Turin had married his own sister, who kills herself upon learning this, and soon after Turin impales himself on his famous black sword, finally, and mercifully, ending the story of woe, tragedy, sorrow and disaster.
I can read books that are full of tragedy and woe. Some of them are great books, like The Grapes of Wrath for example. This book is simply not good enough to justify wading through the unrelenting passage from one disaster to another one. Eventually, after the fourth or fifth time Turin brings ruin down upon his friends and loved ones, it is hard not to start wondering why some merciful elf doesn't just sneak up on Turin and slit his throat before his curse spreads to their family and friends. But elves are too pure to do such a thing, so each disaster comes with the inexorable certainty of the incoming tide.
It wouldn't be so bad if Turin wasn't such an insufferable ass all the time. Even when he's been proven to be about as wise and intelligent as a stuffed mushroom, he continues to insist that things be done his way. Which is somewhat believable as a character trait, I've seen such people myself. But what isn't believable is that both elves and men FOLLOW him in his fey pursuits. What happened to the wisdom of the elves?
I really didn't want to write a negative review, but I have to say that after finishing this book I truly felt that the time would have been better spent rereading The Hobbit.
Comments (2)