Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Car fixing blues...

By CosmicConservative
So, I'm a jerk. I hate that I'm a jerk, but there it is. It's a factual statement. Why am I a jerk? Because I yell at customer service people. I know I shouldn't do it, I know it's bad, it's perhaps my most serious character flaw. (Although I may have worse that I'm hiding..) But I can't help myself. Latest incident described below: So, we bought this 2003 Audi A4. I really like the car, it's sweet. As I think I've said before. But, we needed to take it and have its 50,000 mile maintenance done. Plus we needed to get a second key since the dealer only had the one key when we bought it. And we had to fix a broken cup holder because of the poor design of the cup holder, which is a fragile thing that slides into and out of the dashboard in the way only an engineer who never actually USES cupholders could design. So off I went this morning to take it to the local Audi dealer. A sense of dread hung over me as I pulled out of the driveway, a dread that the rising sun itself could not fully penetrate. This was not the first time I had ridden off to do battle with the dreaded dragons of car dealerships. And as if to mock my sense of impending doom, as I drove down the highway towards the dealer, a light suddenly flashed on my dashboard. A light I did not recognize, a triangle with an enclosed exclamation mark, surrounded by a circular arrow. The portents of doom were escalating. But the trip to the dealer was otherwise uneventful, and as I pulled into the parking space, I shook my head to clear out the ominous sense of impending disaster and meekly went inside to deal with the dragons. But instead of dragons, I found a sweet young lady who listened intently as I described my needs. A maintenance check, a new key, and how much would it cost to fix the cupholder? She dutifully wrote it all down, handed me a copy, and off to work I went. Then, as I sat waiting for a meeting, the sense of doom erupted in the form of my cell phone ringing. The dread brought a clammy sweat to my forhead as I lifted the phone to my ear. "Mr. Cosmic?" (names have been changed to protect the guilty) "Yes?" "This is **** from Audi, we've checked your car for you." bright. pleasant. cheerful. "OK, what's the status?" "Well, the cupholder is $139 to fix, we have to replace the whole thing." "... OK, I sort of expected that. I guess I can live with that." "Then there's a problem with your brake light switch... the new key... and the maintenance.." "Uh.. what was that about a brake light switch?" "Your total will be $695 ... before tax." "....." "Mr. Cosmic?" "....." Mr. Cosmic, do you want us to start on these things?" "How did it get from $139 to $695?" "Well, the key was $195, the diagnostic was $50..." "Waitaminute. How much was the key?" "$195." "That's the simple, straight, no remote entry key?" "Yes sir." "$195?" "That's right." still cheerful and bright "Does that seem a bit excessive to you?" "Excuse me?" No longer so cheerful. "Does $195 for a car key seem excessive to you?" "I don't understand what you mean." "I think that's the problem." "That's what a key costs to replace." "I don't doubt that is what your price list says, I'm asking you if you think that is excessive for a replacement car key." "You don't have to be angry about it." "I have every right to be angry about it." "Well, I don't set the prices here." "I didn't say you did." "Well.... the diagnostic was $50 and the replacment of the brake switch was ..." "$50 for plugging my car into your computer?" "Yes, that's the fee." "Is that fee applied to the repair when you do a repair?" "No." now chilly, resentful. "Why not? Every other repair shop I deal with applies the cost of the diagnostic to the repair if a repair is needed." "We don't do that here." "Why not? You have to plug the computer in to fix it, so now you are charging me twice for plugging my car into your computer. Just charge me once." "I can't do that." "I'm not surprised." "You don't have to be angry, I'm trying to help you." "Let me tell you something lady, charging me $200 for a stupid key, and charging me twice for plugging my car into your computer is not 'helping me,' understand? "Please don't shout at me." "Tell you what, you don't insult my intelligence and I won't shout at you, deal?" "I'm just doing my job." "Which is significantly different in context and in application than 'helping me' don't you agree?" "I think you need to speak to my manager." "That is fine with me." etc... etc... etc.. Lather, rinse, repeat with the manager. End result.... $700 + for a brake light switch, a new cup holder and a new key. Plus I get the bonus of having the people at the Audi shop hate me forever. As I said, I'm a jerk.

Comments (4)

Dadman
I don't think you're a jerk. I think you're an angry, oppressed consumer. Like I am. In fact, my former (former as of last week) optometrist, otherwise know as Steve the Carnival Carney, just took me for a $500 dollar ride for a new pair of progressive lens glasses...one pair! Your car repair diliemma reminds me of a Seinfeld episode wherein Seinfeld takes his car to an unknown repairman...
Jerry: Hello? Yeah, this is Jerry Seinfeld. What? Twenty-eight hundred dollars?!! That's the estimate on my car?!! No, don't even do anything. I'm gonna think about it. Okay, bye. George: What's to think about? If Putty says it's what it is, it's what it is. He's not gonna cheat you. Jerry: Except that it's not Putty. George: What happened to Putty? Jerry: Eh, we had a little fight about the move. I took my car to this other place. I think they might be trying to screw me. George: Well, of course they're trying to screw you. What do you think? That's what they do. They can make up anything. Nobody knows. "By the way, you need a new Johnson rod in there." "Oh, a Johnson rod. Yeah, well, you better put one of those on."
I feel for ya man. Really...
Drax
I'm lucky as I have a good mechanic down the street who frequently doesn't even charge me for some minor stuff....and, I almost never take my car to the dealer....heaven forfend. I take out my frustrations on fast food service people. (To those who think that it's an easy job....you're right in the sense that it doesn't take a ton of intelligence to perform the duties required at McDonalds....but wrong in that it ain't "easy.") This week, I go to Wendy's and get me and my fiancee two large chilis and two medium chocolate frosties. I'm alone in my car. As is the case EVERY TIME I COME THERE, the person at the window begins handing to me the frostys...sans drink holder, just shoving them at my singular self. While I might be able to carry them home without a drink holder (or inside a bag) getting them inside the house is another matter. I would have to hold two drinks, a bag, all the while twiddling with the keys, opening the door, fending off the dog, etc. Which, of course, is why, when I ran fast food restaurants, I had a simple rule: If there are more drinks than there are people in the car, PUT THEM IN A BAG as the person who will be carrying the drinks will have one more drink (at least) than he has hands with which to carry it. So, as usual, I stop the guy and ask for him to put the frostys in a drink holder. He tells me he's out. (I don't ask how this could happen any more than I ask how they can run out of ketsup packages or whatever when there are 4 or 5 Wendys in town and at least two wholesale supply shops which carry everything a fast food restaurant could ask for.....) So, I ask that he put them in a bag. He tells me he can't. Nonplussed, I tell him: "Of course you can." "No I can't." "All you have to do is open the bag, put the drinks in, close the bag, and hand them to me." (I'm demonstrating with my hands, hoping to reach him....) "It's simple." He left the window and someone else came over and put my drinks in the bag and handed them to me. I guess I'm a jerk too. But, good gravy man....
CosmicConservative
So, when I picked up the car, I saw that they had only charged me $59 for the key after all. Which indicates to me that is what they actually cost the dealer, meaning that they were looking to make a 200% profit from me on the key. Which, of course, I knew the whole time. But at least they didn't charge me the full price.
Rick Larson
Well, write a best-selling book and you won't care so much about a 200 dollar key!