Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Government spending as % of GDP since 1940

By CosmicConservative
Here's another graph. This one is of actual U.S. Government spending as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product, again considered the best way to evaluate these things. receiptsoutlayspercentgdp.gif What is remarkable about this graph is how consistent spending has been. So why has the budget deficit fluctuated so much? Because our GDP is so huge that minor fluctuations in the percentage of revenue gained vs. amount spent equate into large swings of surpluses or deficits. But, as you can see from the graph, the Bush administration is spending roughly the same amount of GDP as Clinton was. And Bush I and Reagan and Carter and...... So the next time some Leftist with a chip on their shoulder tells you how Bush is spending us into bankruptcy, just show them this graph, and the one below.

Comments (7)

Rick Larson
How come Nixon closed the Gold window? And how come our currency has lost 98% of its value since 1913? How come the gap between the predators and the producers continues to widen? How come you equate anyone asking these questions as a leftist?
gjh
I don't think the war spending is included because it has never part of the budget. I might be wrong, but think the complaint was: by not including it in the budget it wasn't included in the deficit. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
CosmicConservative
Umm... gjh. Take a look at 1940 - 1945. Do ya think war spending is included?
CosmicConservative
Rick: In what way has our currency lost 98% of its value since 1913? How much did it cost in 1913 to buy a car that could travel 100mph, included air bags, seat belts, automatic transmission, air conditioner, radio, CD player, MP3 player, remote locking doors, fuel injection... etc... How much would a desktop computer operating at 3 gHz with 2 gB RAM and a tB of disk storage cost in 1913? You see Rick, it gets a little tricky when you try to compare the "value" of money across decades of technological progress. OK, so maybe food costs more now, but what percentage of your paycheck goes to food compared to your great-grandfolks in 1913? By that measure, which is a completely valid measure, by the way, the value of money has greatly increased. Comparing a dollar then to a dollar now is a fool's errand. If you want to compare "value of money" then you have to compare the earning potential of a typical wage earner with the spending that they do. That's the only relevent way to do it. In other words, compare time invested to purchasing power. How much bread does one hour of work buy today compared to 1913 Rick?
Rick Larson
In 1913 an ounce of Gold was valued at 20 FRNs, now it is well over 600. The point is worker's living standards are high now, as compared to 1913, is because of an expanded currency (borrowed money), and the currency being propped up by productivity gains through the use of oil. Take away the productivity gains and the value of our money collapses and living standards will plummet. We are living an illusion!
CosmicConservative
Rick: Well, no doubt SOME of us are living an illusion. Productivity gains have been skyrocketing since the 80s. In fact many economists consider the "Bill Clinton boom" period to be more accurately a "Bill Gates boom" period because of the well documented improvements in productivity that desktop computers have brought to the workplace. It's not oil that has doubled and redoubled productivity in our lifetimes Rick, it's silicon. And that shows no signs of slowing, by the way. Even if your analysis were remotely true, the only people talking about taking away the use of oil are Global Warming zealots. It would have been just as easy in 1913 to say the economy was artificially inflated since the introduction of coal-fired steam engines, or before that the introduction of the cotton gin, or the loom, or the wheel or fire. See, that's the nature of progress, it depends on technology and energy. Oil, coal, wood, whatever, all of it has "artificially inflated" the economy at some time or other.
ams182764
"The point is worker’s living standards are high now, as compared to 1913, is because of an expanded currency (borrowed money), and the currency being propped up by productivity gains through the use of oil. Take away the productivity gains and the value of our money collapses and living standards will plummet. We are living an illusion! " There is nothing magic about gold. It's just another, particularly hard form of currency. Gold itself is not wealth. However, you are correct to point out that our standard of living is propped up by the productivity we gain from industrial levels of energy (oil in modern times) and that it goes away when energy goes away. However, I don't quite see how having gold currency is supposed to fix the fact that our factories don't run.